Pam Murray recall, Nashville, Tennessee, 2009

* Recall efforts
* Recall efforts by state
* Recall efforts by office
* Recall efforts by year
* Upcoming recall elections
* Local recalls
* City council recalls
* Mayoral recalls
* County commission recalls
* County official recalls
* School board recalls
* Sheriff recalls
* Special district recalls
* State and federal recalls
* State executive recalls
* State legislator recalls
* U.S. Congress recalls
* Laws governing recall
* States that have pre-petition signature requirements for recalls
* States that require grounds for recalls
* Analysis
* What are recalls?
* Recall terms
* Analysis (2010-present)
* 2025 year-end analysis
* 2025 mid-year analysis
* 2024 year-end analysis
* 2024 mid-year analysis
* 2023 year-end analysis
* 2023 mid-year analysis
* 2022 year-end analysis
* 2022 mid-year analysis
* 2021 year-end analysis
* 2021 mid-year analysis
* 2020 year-end analysis
* 2020 mid-year analysis
* 2019 year-end analysis
* 2019 mid-year analysis
* 2018 year-end analysis
* 2018 mid-year analysis
* 2017 year-end analysis
* 2017 mid-year analysis
* 2016 year-end analysis
* 2016 mid-year analysis

Nashville Metro Council recall

Officeholders
Pam Murray
Recall status
Recall approved
Recall election date
November 12, 2009
See also
Recall overview
Political recall efforts, 2009
Recalls in Tennessee
Tennessee recall laws
City council recalls
Recall reports

A vote about whether to recall Pam Murray from her seat as Metro Council District 5 representative to the Nashville, Tennessee City Council took place on November 12, 2009 in Davidson County for voters in the City of Nashville.[1]

According to unofficial results and the Davidson County Election Commission, the recall effort was approved.[2]

* Pam Murray (incumbent): 540 (49.91%)
* Jamie Hollin (challenger): 542 (50.09%)

## Contents

* 1 Background
* 2 Lawsuit
* 3 Signatures
* 4 Election costs
* 5 See also
* 6 External links
* 7 Footnotes

## Background[edit]

The recall petition filed with election authorities said that in the view of recall organizers, Murray had engaged in "dereliction of her duties and responsibilities to represent the citizens and residents" of the district.

Recall efforts began after Murray and Councilwoman Karen Bennett disputed a proposed bill that would have led to permitting mobile vendors on Cleveland Street. Residents became increasingly concerned after a NewsChannel 5 report in April 2009 that revealed that Murray works for a methadone clinic in Detroit, Michigan despite her legal residence being in Nashville.[3] According to Nashville law, elected officials must reside in the city or district they represent.

James Hollin, a recall supporter, said,"Her lack of responsiveness to the community and that's what made collecting getting the signatures easy." In response to the recall Murray said,"They can degrade me all they want. My true neighbors know I have done my job over there." Murray added that she once worked a private contractor in Detroit but most of the work was completed over email correspondence and she has never owned a home in Michigan.[4]

Murray was first elected to the District 5 council in 2003.

## Lawsuit[edit]

Murray filed a lawsuit against the Metro Election Commission in September 2009 following the verification of valid signatures. The lawsuit called for a judge to void the validated signatures and stop the recall election. However, on September 29, 2009 a judge denied the councilwoman's request. Murray's attorney, Mark Baugh argued in court,"They made an affirmative statement that she lived in Detroit, inducing people who were of the mind-set that a person should live in the county they represent to sign on that basis." But, according to the judge's ruling, the inconsistent petition language was not sufficient to throw out the signatures.[1]

## Signatures[edit]

In order for a recall election to take place supporters must first collect approximately 900 valid signatures or 15% of the registered voters in the district. Supporters had until September 14, 2009 to collect the necessary signatures. If approved, the recall election will take place within 60 days after the approval.[5]

On September 15, the Davidson County Election Commission said that the office verified 1,000 valid signatures before it stopped counting. Petitions were submitted September 14 and had a total of 1,253 signatures.[6]

## Election costs[edit]

If enough valid signatures are collected, a recall election is expected to cost about $12,000, said Election Administrator Ray Barrett.[7]

## See also[edit]

* Political recall efforts
* Political recall efforts, 2009
* Pam Murray recall appears to be successful

## External links[edit]

* We the People of District 5

## Footnotes[edit]

1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 The Tennessean, "Councilwoman Pam Murray recall vote allowed to proceed," September 29, 2009
2. ↑ The Tennessean, "Jamie Hollin is apparent winner in council seat recall vote," November 13, 2009
3. ↑ The Tennessean, "East Nashville voters try to oust Councilwoman Pam Murray," August 15, 2009
4. ↑ MLive.com, "Nashville (or Detroit?) City Councilwoman Pam Murray faced recall; she says 'my true neighbors know I have done my job over there'," August 21, 2009
5. ↑ The City Paper, "Committee close to forcing Murray recall election," August 18, 2009
6. ↑ The Tennessan, "Recall referendum on Councilwoman Murray will proceed," September 15, 2009
7. ↑ The Tennessean, "East Nashvillians push effort to recall councilwoman," September 9, 2009

Political recall elections

Recalls
by year

Upcoming recalls • 2026 • 2025 • 2024 • 2023 • 2022 • 2021 • 2020 • 2019 • 2018 • 2017 • 2016 • 2015 • 2014 • 2013 • 2012 • Historical recalls • Recall statistics and analysis

Recalls
by office

Governors • State legislators • County officials • County commission • Sheriffs • Mayors • City officials • City council • School board • Special district

Recalls
by state

Alabama • Alaska • Arizona • Arkansas • California • Colorado • Connecticut • District of Columbia • Delaware • Florida • Georgia • Hawaii • Idaho • Illinois • Indiana • Iowa • Kansas • Kentucky • Louisiana • Maine • Maryland • Massachusetts • Michigan • Minnesota • Mississippi • Missouri • Montana • Nebraska • Nevada • New Hampshire • New Jersey • New Mexico • New York • North Carolina • North Dakota • Ohio • Oklahoma • Oregon • Pennsylvania • Rhode Island • South Carolina • South Dakota • Tennessee • Texas • Utah • Vermont • Virginia • Washington • West Virginia • Wisconsin • Wyoming

Recall
laws

Alabama • Alaska • Arizona • Arkansas • California • Colorado • Connecticut • District of Columbia • Florida • Georgia • Hawaii • Idaho • Illinois • Kansas • Louisiana • Maine • Maryland • Massachusetts • Michigan • Minnesota • Missouri • Montana • Nebraska • Nevada • New Hampshire • New Jersey • New Mexico • New York • North Carolina • North Dakota • Ohio • Oklahoma • Oregon • Rhode Island • South Dakota • Tennessee • Texas • Vermont • Virginia • Washington • West Virginia • Wisconsin • Wyoming • States that require grounds for recalls • States that have pre-petition signature requirements for recalls

v • e

2009 recall campaigns

Mayors|

Sam Adams • Martha Andrus • Dan Cort • Carty Finkbeiner • Mark Funkhouser • Steve Hunter • Eric Perrodin • Don Plusquellic • Eddie Price • Bernard Russell • Ernie Troiano • "Sal" Vega • Matt White • Don Williamson

* * *

City council|

Ashtabula City Council, Ohio • George Barich, California • Mike Cone, Wisconsin • Bill Davenport • Buena Vista, Colorado • Golden City Council, Colorado • Hondo City Council, Texas • Kent City Council, Ohio • Jerry Kern • Madison Nguyen • Jackie Poplar • San Fernando City Council, California

* * *

School board|

Alameda Unified School District, California • Big Oak Flat-Groveland Unified School District, California • Gladstone School Board, Michigan • Jesus Velazquez, Alisal Union • Westwood Heights School District, Michigan • Greg Wilkinson • Tehachapi, California

* * *

County officials|

Bill Postmus • Julia Moeller • Don Munsterman • Kevin Stufflebean • Monroe County Commissioners (Wisconsin) • Ann Samuelson

* * *

Sheriff|

Daryl Anderson • Wally Krenzke • Deborah Trout

* * *

Special district|

Evermore Community Improvement District, Georgia • Jim Schneider • Lyle Turner • Cowlitz County PUD Commissioners • Fraser Valley Rec Board, Colorado

* * *

State legislative|

Anthony Adams • Roy Ashburn • Jim Silva • Abel Maldonado • Jeff Miller

v • e

State of Tennessee
Nashville (capital)

|

Elections |

What's on my ballot? | Elections in 2026 | How to vote | How to run for office | Ballot measures

Government |

Who represents me? | U.S. President | U.S. Congress | Federal courts | State executives | State legislature | State and local courts | Counties | Cities | School districts | Public policy