God, guns, and freedom U.S. Politics |
Starting arguments over Thanksgiving dinner |
Persons of interest |
“”You can't call yourself a think tank if all your ideas are stupid.
|
—Bill Maher on the Heritage Foundation[1] |
The Heritage Foundation is a neoconservative-turned-Trumpist "think tank" founded by Joseph Coors (of Coors Brewery), Paul Weyrich, Edwin Feulner, and Richard Mellon Scaife. As such, it formerly advocated economic deregulation[2] and an overtly interventionist foreign policy.[3] The think tank formerly published (until 2001)[4] the quarterly Policy Review, for many years considered the preeminent conservative publication in Washington, D.C.. Like many conservative think tanks, it is full of unbelievable amounts of hot air, as evidenced in this quote, which also serves as a window into the corrupt quixotic soul of the organization:
Liberation is at hand.... A paradigm-shattering revolution has just taken place... This revolution has been so sudden and sweeping that few in Washington have yet grasped its full meaning... the entire human outlook... will change... Once this shift takes place... we will be able to advance a true Hayekian agenda, including... radical spending cuts,[5] the end of the public school monopoly, a free market health-care system, and the elimination of the family-destroying welfare dole. Unlike 1944, history is now on the side of freedom.
- —former Republican Majority Leader Dick Armey, in a 1994 issue of Policy Review
Amazing! And is Jesus rising from the dead (again), too?
Since 2021, under the leadership of Heritage president Kevin D. Roberts, Heritage Foundation has completely abandoned neoconservatism in favor of a full-on embrace of Trumpism,[6] thus illegally supporting a political candidate as a tax-exempt non-profit organization. To this end, the foundation leads the Project 2025 initiative.[7] Roberts is closely associated with the far-right Catholic institution Opus Dei, an institute that had close ties to fascist Spain under Francisco Franco.[8]
The Heritage Foundation was founded with donations from the Coors and Mellon fortunes. It cut its teeth during the Reagan administration in the 1980s, when it lobbied Reagan to take a hard-line stance against the Soviet Union (they were responsible for getting Reagan to famously call the Soviet Union an "evil empire"), jeopardizing international relations in the process. It also contributed heavily to the ideals embodied in the Republicans' 1994 Contract With America. Later, the foundation became a major proponent of the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Its reputation has been only slightly tarnished by the fact that all of their predictions proved wrong.
In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, the Heritage Foundation sought to turn the reconstruction efforts in New Orleans into a test bed for all its harebrained conservative ideas: suspension of all government welfare, distribution of school vouchers, and the repealing of environmental and land use regulations in the New Orleans area.[9]
In 2022, it used the Ukraine crisis to bizarrely claim that Vladimir Putin planned to annexe Belarus as part of a scheme to restore the old Soviet Union/Russian Empire.[10]
As a think tank, Heritage Foundation conducts studies on socioeconomic issues. Suspiciously, their results always support whatever they are already lobbying for. In one classic example, a study they conducted found that poor people aren't actually poor.[11] They then lobbied to end welfare for the poor.
The foundation also pushed lackadaisical policies about Iraq, stating that only 40,000 troops would be needed to take over and maintain order in Iraq, that the war would be over in a couple of years at most,[12] and that the Iraqis would greet Americans with open arms (which proved true, but not in quite the way it was intended), and that the Iraqis wanted democracy.
Yes, they do pull these studies out of their ass.
A number of their studies on global warming also come from the PIDOOMA department. One study they cite supposedly demonstrates that global warming will have no effect on the US economy.[13] They also enjoy quote mining statements on climate research,[14] parroting denialist PRATTs,[15] and hosting other members of the denialist echo chamber, such as E. Calvin Beisner's Cornwall Alliance.[16]
They're also unrepentant treekillers; if you wind up on their mailing list, expect to be swamped by bizarre and paranoid mailings featuring names of various conservative figureheads like Ed Meese, push polls, fundraising letters from out of state candidates, and weird, pro-war criminal propaganda allegedly written by the parents of misbehaving members of the US military. It's… not pretty.
The Heritage Foundation also promotes intelligent design. They have on several occations hosted lectures by people from the Discovery Institute such as Stephen Meyer[17][18] and John West.[19] They also hosted a press conference by the makers of the film Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed announcing their intention to use the film as a platform to pass "academic freedom" model legislation.[20]
“”☹️
|
—Heritage's thoughts on gay marriage[21] |
One thing all "conservative" groups have in common is an absolute hatred towards LGBTQ+ persons, and especially trans people (and in that subset, especially trans women). The Heritage Foundation is no exception to this rule. Through its subsidiary "The Daily Signal", which has become independent since June 2024, it has published articles spouting out misinformation concerning transgender athletes, dubbing the fight for trans rights the "transgender agenda".[22]
It has a long history of ties to Big Tobacco, arguing against tobacco taxes and regulations, including tax proposals in 2007 and 2009. It received donations from tobacco company Philip Morris in 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2016.[23]
The organization has links to various other right-wing parties and organizations around the world. Leading figures in the UK Conservative Party have spoken at its events, including Priti Patel in 2021 and chairman Oliver Dowden in 2022.[24][25]
“”And so I come full circle on this response and just want to encourage you with some substance that we are in the process of the second American Revolution, which will remain bloodless if the left allows it to be.
|
—Kevin Roberts, advocating a "vigorous executive" while simultaneously professing "love" for the Constitution[26] |
Since 2021, the Heritage Foundation has been led by Kevin D. Roberts. Unlike many past Heritage presidents, Roberts' background was not in business. Instead, Roberts previously served on the board of the Texas Public Policy Foundation (TPPF).[27] a Koch-funded right-wing think tank.[28] One of TPPF's primary concerns is advocating climate change denialism and shilling fossil fuels.[29] TPPF is also equally known for their advocacy of school vouchers, a favorite topic of Christian nationalists.[30] Roberts is an ally of Texas oil tycoon Tim Dunn, a Dominionist who believes that the nation is in the midst of a holy battle that pits culture war "Christians" like himself against everyone else.[31][32]
Roberts was also previously the president of Wyoming Catholic College, which notably declined Title IV federal funding over concerns that accepting federal funds would prevent the college from discriminating against homosexuals.[33][34]
Reflecting the evolution of the Republican party under Donald Trump, Roberts' hiring marked a notable shift from once standard paradigms of the Heritage Foundation, such as a hawkish foreign policy and strict adherence to free market economics. Instead, the Heritage Foundation shifted to embracing Trumpism. Indeed, Roberts stated in an interview that he believes that "institutionalizing Trumpism" is his primary role.[35][36] Instead of being unapologetic advocates of the free market, the new Heritage Foundation declared that free enterprise must be "orient(ed) in support of the common good". Instead of taking a hawkish stance against Vladimir Putin's 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, the new Heritage Foundation advocated isolationism.[35][36][37]
Under Roberts, members of the Heritage Foundation have praised the authoritarian government of Viktor Orbán[38]. As an example, after meeting with Orbán in November 2022, Roberts wrote the following fawning accolade on Twitter:
...One thing is clear from visiting Hungary and from being involved in current policy and cultural debates in America: the world needs a movement that fights for Truth, for tradition, for families, and for the average person.[39]
In March 2023, the Heritage Foundation signed a cooperation agreement with the Danube Institute,[40] a think tank / propaganda network funded entirely by the Hungarian government that seeks to provide the intellectual veneer to convert Western conservatives into adopting the Orbán model of "illiberal democracy".[41][42]
One of Roberts' core projects is Project 2025. Created in the run-up to the 2024 U.S. presidential election, the project outlines an administrative blueprint to enact should a Republican ever take over the presidency.[36] Contrary to past Heritage Foundation blueprints, Project 2025 is lighter on policy and heavier on retribution.[43] Using various bureaucratic schemes (most notably the utilization of the Schedule F appointment), the chief feature of the blueprint is a plan to attempt to take over much of the federal government agencies by firing large amounts of current federal employees (no matter how experienced the employee) and replace them with "conservative" "loyalists".[43] The document advocates ideological tests on federal government employees based on various bête noires of populist Republicans, such as critical race theory, woke, and climate change.[43] The blueprint deeply embraces Christian nationalism viewpoints. This includes staunch anti-abortion positions, to the point where the Heritage Foundation advocate nationally criminializing the abortion pill mifepristone, and also advocate setting up surveillance networks for "liberal states" that in their view had become "sanctuaries for abortion tourism". Discussions of potentially reviving the Comstock Act were even present in the document. Project 2025 also endorses anti-LGBTQ positions such as opposition of gay marriage. All of this comes on top of Heritage Foundation's usual wish list of corporate favoritism, such as favorable tax incentives for corporations and anti-environmentalism advocacy.[43][44][43][45][46] Critics called the plan a "far-right playbook for American authoritarianism" and "a threat to a multiracial, diverse democracy."[47]
Tellingly, in a New York Times interview, Roberts endorsed Trump's Big Lie, stating that he did not believe that Joe Biden won the 2020 U.S. presidential election. He also believed that Black Lives Matter "riots" were "far worse" than the 2021 U.S. coup attempt. He even offered praise for Joe McCarthy.[36]
In early July 2024, Roberts appeared on Steve Bannon's "War Room" show. On there, Roberts expressed the opinion that the country was in a "second revolution" which would be complete by 2050 and would coincide with a new "great awakening" that would bring America to God. Roberts argued for the need for a ""vigorous executive" and, in a roundabout manner, threatened violence against any resistance to this "revolution". He also insisted that "God's law can, in fact be a huge influence on the civil laws". He even invoked a bit of doublespeak in defining freedom — "Our definition of ‘freedom’ is not the freedom to do whatever the heck we want, but the freedom to do what we ought." These statements were seen by commentators as a sign that Heritage Foundation had embraced both fascism and especially Christian nationalism.[32][48][49] This is not the first time that Roberts has threatened violence: it has been alleged by his former university colleagues that Roberts told them he beat a neighbor's dog to death with a shovel in 2004.[50]
Roberts has used violent rhetoric, including calling for a political revolution to "overthrow today’s incarnation of the ruling class", and calling for the elimination of an assortment of institutions, presumably by dictatorial rule: Ivy League universities, the FBI, Fairfax County Virginia public schools and the Boy Scouts.[51] The rhetoric was so bad that it caused Paul Dans, co-editor of the Project 2025 book,[7] leading to Dans quitting or being fired from the foundation.[52][53][51]
Due to this significant policy shift under Roberts, multiple scholars departed the Heritage Foundation for other think-tanks.[38]
Roberts has gone even further than Project 2025's flirting with illegally endorsing a political candidate as a tax-exempt non-profit; he said in an interview that the role of The Heritage Foundation is "institutionalizing Trumpism".[54]
Shortly after Roberts' "War Room" appearance, the foundation held a "war game" conference in which they discussed far-fetched scenarios based on the conspiracy theory that Biden would seize power after losing the 2024 election,[55] something incidentally that their favored far-right Supreme Court basically enabled.[56] During the conference, Mike Howell, executive director of the foundation's Oversight Project claimed, "As things stand right now, there’s a zero percent chance of a free and fair election."[55] Howell was setting the stage for a repeat of Trumpist election denialism and of the 2021 coup attempt.[55]
In late May 2023 on Twitter, the Heritage Foundation, accompanied by a video from "reactionary feminist" Mary Harrington, declared that "conservatives have to lead the way in restoring sex to its true purpose", and advocated ending "recreational sex". To accomplish this goal, they also recommended ending the "senseless use of birth control pills.[57]
This anti-contraception viewpoint was echoed by Manhattan Institute fellow Christopher Rufo in February 2024 after the Alabama Supreme Court ruled that frozen embryos should be considered as living beings, severely impacting in vitro fertilisation in that state. Replying to a tweet from Michael Shermer declaring that birth control pills would be next in line, Rufo retorted (without evidence) "So what? The pill causes health problems for many women". He then declared that "'recreational sex' is a large part of the reason we have so many single-mother households, which drives poverty, crime, and dysfunction."[58] Such reflected a trend within conservative activists in the 2020s to demonize birth control pills; similar anti-contraception content were posted by Ben Shapiro, Tim Pool, Steve Bannon, Elon Musk, and others in 2023 and 2024.[58][59]
Long-running observers of Republican politics might note that the above combines common conservative pundit themes of the past — demonizing single mothers, often with strong whiffs of racist or misogynist dog whistles, was a key "conservative talking point" in the 1990s[60] — with opposition to birth control, once a fringe position held primarily by Catholic leadership (but not Catholics themselves), but increasingly a position held by hard-line evangelicals as well, due to the convergence of Catholic-evangelical politics since the Moral Majority formed in the late 1970s.[61][62][63]
In 2022, a poll from FiveThirtyEight/Ipsos found that 90% of Americans believe that birth control pills should be legal in "all" or "most" cases.[64] It is unclear how the Heritage Foundation and other conservative activists reconcile their opposition to "recreational sex" with Donald Trump's frequent extra-marital porn star fucking.[65]
In 2024, The Heritage Foundation was hacked by a group calling itself SiegedSec, who describe themselves as "gay furry hackers".[66] Mike Howell, the foundation's Executive Director of its Oversight Project,[67] actually threatened one of SiegedSec's members with anal rape, "Are you aware that you won’t be able to wear a furry tiger costume when you’re getting pounded in the ass in the federal prison I put you in next year?"[68]