Moral intellectualism

Short description: View in meta-ethics

Part of a series on
Socrates
"I know that I know nothing"
"The unexamined life is not worth living"
gadfly * Trial of Socrates
Eponymous concepts
Socratic dialogue * Socratic intellectualism
Socratic irony * Socratic method
Socratic paradox * [[Socratic questioning]]
Socratic problem * Socratici viri
Disciples
Plato * Xenophon
Antisthenes * [[Biography:AristipAristippus * Aeschines of Sphettus|Aeschines]]
Related topics
Academic Skepticism * Megarians * Cynicism * Cyrenaics * Platonism * Aristotelianism * Stoicism * Virtue ethics * The Clouds
Category

* v
* t
* e

Moral intellectualism or ethical intellectualism is a view in meta-ethics according to which genuine moral knowledge must take the form of arriving at discursive moral judgements about what one should do.[1] One way of understanding this is that doing what is right is a reflection of what any being knows is right.[2] However, it can also be interpreted as the understanding that a rationally consistent worldview and theoretical way of life, as exemplified by Socrates, is superior to the life devoted to a moral (but merely practical) life.[3]

## Contents

* 1 Ancient moral intellectualism
* 2 Contemporary views
* 3 See also
* 4 References
* 5 Further reading
* 6 External links

## Ancient moral intellectualism

For Socrates (469–399 BC), intellectualism is the view that "one will do what is right or best just as soon as one truly understands what is right or best"; that virtue is a purely intellectual matter, since virtue and knowledge are cerebral relatives, which a person accrues and improves with dedication to reason.[4][5] So defined, Socratic intellectualism became a key philosophic doctrine of Stoicism.[6] The Stoics are well known for their teaching that the good is to be identified with virtue.[6]

The apparent, problematic consequences of this view are "Socratic paradoxes", such as the view that there is no weakness of will (that no one knowingly does, or knowingly seeks to do, what is morally wrong); that anyone who does, or seeks to do, moral wrong does so involuntarily; and that since virtue is knowledge, there cannot be many different virtues such as those defended by Aristotle, and instead, all virtues must be one. The following are among the so-called Socratic paradoxes:[7]

* No one desires evil.
* No one errs or does wrong willingly or knowingly.
* Virtue - all virtue - is knowledge.
* Virtue is sufficient for happiness.

However, it is clear in Meno that virtue is not knowledge, rather True Belief.

Typically, Stoic accounts of care for the self required specific ascetic exercises meant to ensure that not only was knowledge of truth memorized, but learned, and then integrated to the self, in the course of transforming oneself into a good person. Therefore, to understand truth meant "intellectual knowledge", requiring one's integration to the (universal) truth, and authentically living it in one's speech, heart, and conduct. Achieving that difficult task required continual care of the self, but also meant being someone who embodies truth, and so can readily practice the Classical-era rhetorical device of parrhesia: "to speak candidly, and to ask forgiveness for so speaking"; and, by extension, practice the moral obligation to speak the truth, even at personal risk.[8]

## Contemporary views

Contemporary philosophers dispute that Socrates's conceptions of knowing truth, and of ethical conduct, can be equated with modern, post-Cartesian conceptions of knowledge and of rational intellectualism.[9]

## See also

* Moral rationalism

## References

1. ↑ Adams, Zed (2014). "Against Moral Intellectualism" (in en). Philosophical Investigations 37 (1): 37–56. doi:10.1111/phin.12025. ISSN 1467-9205.
2. ↑ The Moral Intellectualism of Plato's Socrates The Case of the Hippias Minor
3. ↑ Silva, Brunno Alves (2023-09-29). "O belo na virtude da integridade em Aristóteles: réplica ao intelectualismo moralO belo na virtude da integridade em Aristóteles: réplica ao intelectualismo moral". Revista Enunciação: 54–76. doi:10.61378/enun.v7i2.145. ISSN 2526-110X. https://doi.org/10.61378/enun.v7i2.145.
4. ↑ "Ancient Ethical Theory". https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ethics-ancient/.
5. ↑ "FOLDOC". http://lgxserver.uniba.it/lei/foldop/foldoc.cgi?intellectualism. (Definition and note on Socrates)
6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Ancient Ethical Theory
7. ↑ p. 14, Terence Irwin, The Development of Ethics, vol. 1, Oxford University Press 2007; p. 147, Gerasimos Santas, "The Socratic Paradoxes", Philosophical Review 73 (1964), pp. 147–164.
8. ↑ Gros, Frederic (ed.) (2005) Michel Foucault: The Hermeneutics of the Subject, Lectures at the College de France 1981–1982. Picador: New York
9. ↑ Heda Segvic (2005). "No One Errs Willingly: The Meaning of Socratic Intellectualism". A Companion to Socrates. pp. 171–185. doi:10.1002/9780470996218.ch10. ISBN 978-0470996218.

## Further reading

* Virtue Is Knowledge: The Moral Foundations of Socratic Political Philosophy, Lorraine Smith Pangle, University Of Chicago Press, 2014

## External links

* Socrates' moral intellectualism
* The Ethics of Socrates
* Two Interpretations of Socratic Intellectualism

* v
* t
* e

Socrates

General|

* Trial of Socrates

Concepts
and
legacy|

* Socratic dialogue
* Socratic intellectualism
* Socratic irony
* Socratic method
* Socratic paradox
* Socratic problem
* Socratic questioning
* Socratici viri

Phrases|

* "I know that I know nothing"
* "The unexamined life is not worth living"

Related|

* Euthyphro dilemma
* Form of the Good
* Peritrope
* Religious skepticism
* Social gadfly

Family|

* Sophroniscus (father)
* Phaenarete (mother)
* Xanthippe (wife)
* Lamprocles (son)
* Menexenus (son)
* Myrto (wife)

Works
about
Socrates|

| Art|

* Double Herm of Socrates and Seneca (3rd century sculpture)
* The Death of Socrates (1787 painting)
* Socrates (1950 sculpture)

|

Stage|

* The Clouds (423 BC play)
* Der geduldige Socrates (1721 opera)
* Socrates (1759 play)
* Socrate (1919 oratorio)
* Socrates on Trial (2007 play)

Literature|

* De genio Socratis (1st century essay)
* On the Concept of Irony with Continual Reference to Socrates (1841 thesis)
* The Plot to Save Socrates (2006 novel)

Other|

* Barefoot in Athens (1966 film)
* Socrates (1971 film)

Dialogues|

| Plato|

* Apology
* Axiochus
* Charmides
* Clitophon
* Cratylus
* Critias
* Crito
* Demodocus
* Epinomis
* Eryxias
* Euthydemus
* Euthyphro
* First Alcibiades
* Gorgias
* Hipparchus
* Hippias Major
* Hippias Minor
* Ion
* Laches
* Laws
* Lysis
* Menexenus
* Meno
* Minos
* On Justice
* On Virtue
* Parmenides
* Phaedo
* Phaedrus
* Philebus
* Protagoras
* Republic
* Rival Lovers
* Second Alcibiades
* Sisyphus
* Sophist
* Statesman
* Symposium
* Theaetetus
* Theages
* Timaeus

|

Xenophon|

* Apology
* Memorabilia
* Oeconomicus
* Symposium

Other|

* Halcyon

Category

* v
* t
* e

Stoicism

Philosophers|

| Early|

* Zeno of Citium
* Persaeus
* Aristo
* Sphaerus
* Herillus
* Cleanthes
* Chrysippus
* Zeno of Tarsus
* Crates of Mallus
* Diogenes of Babylon
* Apollodorus
* Antipater of Tarsus

|

Middle|

* Panaetius
* Dardanus
* Mnesarchus
* Hecato
* Posidonius
* Diodotus
* Geminus
* Antipater of Tyre
* Athenodorus Cananites

Late|

* Seneca
* Cornutus
* Musonius Rufus
* Euphrates
* Cleomedes
* Epictetus
* Hierocles
* Junius Rusticus
* Marcus Aurelius

Philosophy|

* Stoicism
* categories
* logic
* passions
* physics
* Neostoicism
* Modern Stoicism

Concepts|

* Adiaphora
* Apatheia
* Ataraxia
* Ekpyrosis
* Eudaimonia
* Katalepsis
* Kathekon
* Logos
* Oikeiôsis
* Pneuma
* Prohairesis
* Sophos

Works|

| Epictetus|

* Discourses
* Enchiridion

|

Marcus
Aurelius|

* Meditations

Seneca|

* Letters to Lucilius
* Essays:
* Anger
* Benefits
* Clemency
* Constancy
* Happiness
* Leisure
* Providence
* Shortness of Life
* Tranquillity
* Consolations

Other|

* Lectures (Musonius Rufus)
* On Passions (Chrysippus)
* Republic (Zeno)

Related articles|

* Paradoxa Stoicorum
* Stoicorum Veterum Fragmenta
* Stoic Opposition

* https://philpapers.org/rec/ALVAEO-4

Aristóteles e o Problema do Intelectualismo Moral (Tese de Doutorado).

0.00

(0 votes)

Original source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral intellectualism. Read more

|

Retrieved from "https://handwiki.org/wiki/index.php?title=Philosophy:Moral_intellectualism&oldid=4240892"
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template