Argument from love

Short description: Argument for the existence of God based on the existence of love

Part of a series on the

Philosophy of religion

Religious concepts

* Afterlife
* Apophatism
* Cataphatism
* Eschatology
* Enlightenment
* Intelligent design
* Miracle
* Mysticism
* Religious belief
* Reincarnation
* Religious faith
* Scripture (religious text)
* Soul
* Spirit
* Theological veto

Challenges

* Ethical egoism
* Euthyphro dilemma
* Logical positivism
* Religious language
* Verificationism
* eschatological

Problem of evil

* Theodicy
* Augustinian
* Irenaean
* Best of all possible worlds
* Inconsistent triad
* Natural evil

God

|  Conceptions

* Aristotelian
* Brahman
* Demiurge
* Divinely simple
* Form of the Good
* Holy Spirit
* Maltheist
* Pandeist
* Personal
* Process-theological
* Summum bonum
* Supreme Being
* Unmoved mover

Existence
|  Arguments for

* Beauty
* Christological
* Trilemma
* Resurrection
* Consciousness
* Cosmological
* kalām
* contingency
* metaphysical
* Degree
* Desire
* Experience
* Existential choice
* Fine-tuned universe
* Love
* Miracles
* Morality
* Mystical idealism
* Natural law
* Necessary existent
* Seddiqin
* Nyayakusumanjali
* Ontological
* Gödel
* Modal
* Anselm
* Mulla Sadra
* Spinoza
* Pascal's wager
* Reason
* Reformed
* Teleological
* Intelligent design
* Natural law
* Watchmaker
* Junkyard
* Trademark
* Transcendental

Arguments against

* 747 gambit
* Wager
* Creator of God
* Evil God
* Free will
* Hell
* Inconsistency
* Nonbelief
* Noncognitivism
* Omnipotence paradox
* Poor design
* Russell's teapot

By religion

* Abrahamic
* Bahá'í
* Christianity
* Islam
* Judaism
* Mormonism
* Buddhism
* Hinduism
* Jainism
* Sikhism
* Wicca

Theories of religion

* Acosmism
* Agnosticism
* Animism
* Antireligion
* Atheism
* Creationism
* Dharmism
* Deism
* Divine command theory
* Dualism
* Esotericism
* Exclusivism
* Existentialism
* agnostic
* atheist
* Christian
* Feminist
* Fundamentalism
* Gnosticism
* Henotheism
* Humanism
* Christian
* religious
* secular
* Inclusivism
* Monism
* Monotheism
* Mysticism
* Naturalism
* humanistic
* metaphysical
* religious
* New Age
* Nondualism
* Nontheism
* Pandeism
* Panentheism
* Pantheism
* Perennialism
* Polytheism
* Process
* Spiritualism
* Shamanism
* Taoic
* Theism
* Transcendentalism

Philosophers of religion

|  Atheist / agnostic

* Epicurus
* Hume
* Nietzsche
* Harris
* Critchley
* Singer
* Quine
* Dennett
* Camus
* Sartre
* de Beauvoir
* Russell
* Mill
* Marx
* Lucretius
* Heraclitus
* Rand
* Foucault
* Searle
* Goldstein
* Schopenhauer
* Drange
* Draper
* Kenny
* Hecht
* Michael Martin

Buddhist

* Nagarjuna
* Vasubandhu
* Buddhaghosa
* Dignāga
* Dharmakirti
* Jayatilleke
* Premasiri
* Ñāṇavīra
* Nakamura
* Nishitani
* Nishida
* Damien Keown
* David Loy
* Evan Thompson
* Smith
* Westerhoff
* Garfield

Christian

* Adams
* Alston
* Aquinas
* Augustine
* Bell
* Brümmer
* Burns
* Caird
* Craig
* Dalferth
* Eliade
* Evans
* Gamwell
* Heidegger
* Hick
* Kierkegaard
* Kretzmann
* Leftow
* McCabe
* McIntyre
* Merricks
* Miceli
* Moser
* Newman
* Otto
* Paley
* Schaeffer
* de Silva
* Smith
* Stewart
* Swinburne
* Taliaferro
* Tamer
* Thiselton
* Ward
* White
* Wiebe
* Wollaston
* Yandell

Islamic

* al-Amiri
* al-Attas
* Averroes
* Avicenna
* Badawi
* Brethren of Purity
* Damad
* al-Farabi
* al-Ghazali
* Ibn Arabi
* Ibn Bajjah
* Ibn Masarra
* Ibn Miskawayh
* M. Iqbal
* al-Kindi
* Nasr
* Ramadan
* al-Razi
* Sadra
* al-Shahrastani
* Shariati
* Suhrawardi
* Shaykh Tusi
* Waliullah

Jewish

* Buber
* Heschel
* Maimonides
* Mendelssohn
* Schwarzschild
* Soloveitchik
* Spinoza

Hindu

* Adi Shankara
* Ramanuja
* Madhvacharya
* Udayana
* Kumārila Bhaṭṭa
* Vācaspati Miśra
* Jayanta Bhatta
* Abhinavagupta
* Raghunatha Siromani
* Sri Aurobindo
* Ramana Maharshi
* J. Krishnamurti
* Radhakrishnan
* BK Matilal
* KC Bhattacharya

Others

* Almaas
* Anderson
* Emmet
* Esaulov
* Ferré
* Forman
* Glogau
* Hartshorne
* Hatano
* Hatcher
* Klostermaier
* Kvanvig
* Martinich
* Meltzer
* Runzo
* Smart
* Vallicella
* Zank
* Zimmerman

Related topics

* Criticism of religion
* Ethics in religion
* Exegesis
* Faith and rationality
* History of religions
* Religion and science
* Religious philosophy
* Theology

Philosophy of religion article index

* v
* t
* e

The Argument from love is an argument for the existence of God.

## Contents

* 1 Arguments from love to the existence of God
* 2 Variants
* 2.1 Comparative rationality of belief in God and Love
* 2.2 Suggested compelling nature of God's Love
* 3 Notes and references

## Arguments from love to the existence of God

See also: omnibenevolence and Trinity § Trinity and love

Tom Wright suggests that materialist philosophy and scepticism has "paved our world with concrete, making people ashamed to admit that they have had profound and powerful 'religious' experiences".[1] The reality of Love in particular ("that mutual and fruitful knowing, trusting and loving which was the creator's intention" but which "we often find so difficult") and the whole area of human relationships in general, are another signpost pointing away from this philosophy to the central elements of the Christian story.[2] Wright contends both that the real existence of love is a compelling reason for the truth of theism and that the ambivalent experience of love, ("marriages apparently made in heaven sometimes end not far from hell") resonates particularly with the Christian account of fall and redemption.[3]

Paul Tillich suggested (in 1954) even Spinoza "elevates love out of the emotional into the ontological realm. And it is well known that from Empedocles and Plato to Augustine and Pico, to Hegel and Schelling, to Existentialism and depth psychology, love has played a central ontological role."[4] and that "love is being in actuality and love is the moving power of life"[5] and that an understanding of this should lead us to "turn from the naive nominalism in which the modern world lives".[6]

The theologian Michael Lloyd suggests that "In the end there are basically only two possible sets of views about the universe in which we live. It must, at heart, be either personal or impersonal... arbitrary and temporary[7] [or emerging] from relationship, creativity, delight, love".[8]

Catholic philosopher Peter Kreeft summarises the argument as "Love is the greatest of miracles. How could an evolved ape create the noble idea of self-giving love? Human love is a result of our being made to resemble God, who himself is love. If we are made in the image of King Kong rather than in the image of King God, where do the saints come from?"[9] Philosopher Alvin Plantinga expressed the argument in similar terms.[10]

According to Graham Ward, postmodern theology portrays how religious questions are opened up (not closed down or annihilated) by postmodern thought. The postmodern God is emphatically the God of love, and the economy of love is kenotic.[11]

## Variants

### Comparative rationality of belief in God and Love

A variant on the argument is a defence of the rationality of theism by comparing faith in God with love, and to suggest that if it isn't irrational to love someone then it shouldn't be seen as irrational to believe in God.[12] The philosopher Roger Scruton suggests: "Rational argument can get us just so far...It can help us to understand the real difference between a faith that commands us to forgive our enemies, and one that commands us to slaughter them. But the leap of faith itself — this placing of your life at God's service — is a leap over reason's edge. This does not make it irrational, any more than falling in love is irrational."[13]

### Suggested compelling nature of God's Love

Another variant of the argument is that the evidence for God's love is sufficiently compelling that people can reasonably believe in it, and hence a fortiori believe in God.[14] This approach is criticised by Richard Dawkins who suggests that it is an "Argument from emotional blackmail".[15]

## Notes and references

1. ↑ Tom Wright Simply Christian p 16
2. ↑ Tom Wright Simply Christian pp 25–33
3. ↑ Tom Wright Simply Christian p 33
4. ↑ Paul Tillich Love, Power and Justice Oxford University Press 1954 p4
5. ↑ Paul Tillich, Love, Power and Justice, Oxford University Press, 1954, p25
6. ↑ Paul Tillich, Love, Power and Justice, Oxford University Press, 1954, p19
7. ↑ Lloyd cites Quentin Smith
8. ↑ Michael Lloyd Cafe Theology (2005) ISBN 1-904074-76-6 p 14
9. ↑ Peter Kreeft, Your Questions, God's Answers, Ignatius Press, 1994, ISBN 0-89870-488-X, p. 105.
10. ↑ Alvin Plantinga (1986), “Two Dozen [or so] Theistic Arguments,” paper delivered at the 33rd Annual Philosophy Conference, Wheaton College, 23-25 Oct. and republished as an appendix to: Deane-Peter Baker (2007), Alvin Plantinga, Cambridge University Press, ISBN 0-521-85531-4.
11. ↑ The Modern Theologians 3rd ed p 335
12. ↑ This type of argument was made by Alvin Plantinga in God and Other Minds
13. ↑ Roger Scruton. Dawkins is wrong about God reproduced from The Spectator
14. ↑ See e.g. Michael Welker in The Work of Love p131 "in this love God's identity and power are made known" (italics in original). He cites e.g. John 17:26
15. ↑ The God Delusion p83

* v
* t
* e

Philosophy of religion

Concepts in religion|

* Afterlife
* Euthyphro dilemma
* Faith
* Intelligent design
* Miracle
* Problem of evil
* Religious belief
* Soul
* Spirit
* Theodicy
* Theological veto

Conceptions of God|

* Aristotelian view
* Brahman
* Demiurge
* Divine simplicity
* Egoism
* Holy Spirit
* Misotheism
* Pandeism
* Personal god
* Process theology
* Supreme Being
* Unmoved mover

God in|

* Abrahamic religions
* Buddhism
* Christianity
* Hinduism
* Islam
* Jainism
* Judaism
* Mormonism
* Sikhism
* Bahá'í Faith
* Wicca

Existence of God|

| For|

* Beauty
* Christological
* Consciousness
* Cosmological
* Kalam
* Contingency
* Degree
* Desire
* Experience
* Fine-tuning of the universe
* Love
* Miracles
* Morality
* Necessary existent
* Ontological
* Pascal's wager
* Proper basis
* Reason
* Teleological
* Natural law
* Watchmaker analogy
* Transcendental

|

Against|

* 747 gambit
* Atheist's Wager
* Evil
* Free will
* Hell
* Inconsistent revelations
* Nonbelief
* Noncognitivism
* Occam's razor
* Omnipotence
* Poor design
* Russell's teapot

Theology|

* Acosmism
* Agnosticism
* Animism
* Antireligion
* Atheism
* Creationism
* Dharmism
* Deism
* Demonology
* Divine command theory
* Dualism
* Esotericism
* Exclusivism
* Existentialism
* Christian
* Agnostic
* Atheistic
* Feminist theology
* Thealogy
* Womanist theology
* Fideism
* Fundamentalism
* Gnosticism
* Henotheism
* Humanism
* Religious
* Secular
* Christian
* Inclusivism
* Theories about religions
* Monism
* Monotheism
* Mysticism
* Naturalism
* Metaphysical
* Religious
* Humanistic
* New Age
* Nondualism
* Nontheism
* Pandeism
* Panentheism
* Pantheism
* Perennialism
* Polytheism
* Possibilianism
* Process theology
* Religious skepticism
* Spiritualism
* Shamanism
* Taoic
* Theism
* Transcendentalism
* more...

Religious language|

* Eschatological verification
* Language game
* Logical positivism
* Apophatic theology
* Verificationism

Problem of evil|

* Augustinian theodicy
* Best of all possible worlds
* Euthyphro dilemma
* Inconsistent triad
* Irenaean theodicy
* Natural evil
* Theodicy

Philosophers
of religion

(by date active)|

| Ancient and
medieval|

* Anselm of Canterbury
* Augustine of Hippo
* Avicenna
* Averroes
* Boethius
* Erasmus
* Gaunilo of Marmoutiers
* Pico della Mirandola
* Heraclitus
* King James VI and I
* Marcion of Sinope
* Thomas Aquinas
* Maimonides

|

Early modern|

* Augustin Calmet
* René Descartes
* Blaise Pascal
* Baruch Spinoza
* Nicolas Malebranche
* Gottfried W Leibniz
* William Wollaston
* Thomas Chubb
* David Hume
* Baron d'Holbach
* Immanuel Kant
* Johann G Herder

1800
1850|

* Friedrich Schleiermacher
* Karl C F Krause
* Georg W F Hegel

* William Whewell
* Ludwig Feuerbach
* Søren Kierkegaard
* Karl Marx
* Albrecht Ritschl
* Afrikan Spir

1880
1900|

* Ernst Haeckel
* W K Clifford
* Friedrich Nietzsche
* Harald Høffding
* William James

* Vladimir Solovyov
* Ernst Troeltsch
* Rudolf Otto
* Lev Shestov
* Sergei Bulgakov
* Pavel Florensky
* Ernst Cassirer
* Joseph Maréchal

1920
postwar|

* George Santayana
* Bertrand Russell
* Martin Buber
* René Guénon
* Paul Tillich
* Karl Barth
* Emil Brunner
* Rudolf Bultmann
* Gabriel Marcel
* Reinhold Niebuhr

* Charles Hartshorne
* Mircea Eliade
* Frithjof Schuon
* J L Mackie
* Walter Kaufmann
* Martin Lings
* Peter Geach
* George I Mavrodes
* William Alston
* Antony Flew

1970
1990
2010|

* William L Rowe
* Dewi Z Phillips
* Alvin Plantinga
* Anthony Kenny
* Nicholas Wolterstorff
* Richard Swinburne
* Robert Merrihew Adams

* Peter van Inwagen
* Daniel Dennett
* Loyal Rue
* Jean-Luc Marion
* William Lane Craig
* Ali Akbar Rashad

* Alexander Pruss

Related topics|

* Criticism of religion
* Ethics in religion
* Exegesis
* History of religion
* Religion
* Religious language
* Religious philosophy
* Relationship between religion and science
* Political science of religion
* Faith and rationality
* more...

* Portal
* Category

* v
* t
* e

Theology

Conceptions of God

| Theism|

| Forms|

*   * Deism
* Dystheism
* Henotheism
* Hermeticism
* Kathenotheism
* Nontheism
* Monolatry
* Monotheism
* Mysticism
* Panentheism
* Pandeism
* Pantheism
* Polydeism
* Polytheism
* Spiritualism
* Theopanism

|

Concepts|

*   * Deity
* Divinity
* Gender of God and gods
* Male deity
* Goddess
* Numen

Singular god
theologies|

| By faith|

* Abrahamic religions
* Bahá'í Faith
* Judaism
* Christianity
* Catholic
* Islam
* Buddhism
* Hinduism
* Jainism
* Sikhism
* Zoroastrianism

|

Concepts|

* Absolute
* Brahman
* Emanationism
* Logos
* Supreme Being

God as|

* the Devil
* Sustainer
* Time

Trinitarianism|

* Athanasian Creed
* Comma Johanneum
* Consubstantiality
* Homoousian
* Homoiousian
* Hypostasis
* Perichoresis
* Shield of the Trinity
* Trinitarian formula
* Trinity
* Trinity of the Church Fathers
* Trinitarian universalism

Eschatology|

* Afterlife
* Apocalypticism
* Buddhist
* Christian
* Heaven
* Hell
* Hindu
* Islamic
* Jewish
* Taoist
* Zoroastrian

Feminist|

* Buddhism
* Christianity
* Hinduism
* Islam
* Judaism
* Mormonism
* Goddesses

Other concepts|

* The All
* Aristotelian view
* Attributes of God in Christianity / in Islam
* Binitarianism
* Demiurge
* Divine simplicity
* Divine presence
* Egotheism
* Exotheology
* Holocaust
* Godhead in Christianity
* Latter Day Saints
* Great Architect of the Universe
* Great Spirit
* Apophatic theology
* Olelbis
* Open theism
* Personal god
* Phenomenological definition
* Philo's view
* Process
* Tian
* Unmoved mover

Names of God in|

* Christianity
* Hinduism
* Islam
* Jainism
* Judaism

By Faith

| Christian|

* History
* Outline
* Biblical canon
* Glossary
* Christology
* Cosmology
* Ecclesiology
* Ethics
* Hamartiology
* Messianism
* Nestorianism
* Philosophy
* Practical
* Sophiology
* Soteriology

|

Hindu|

* Ayyavazhi theology
* Krishnology

Islamic|

* Oneness of God
* Prophets
* Holy Scriptures
* Angels
* Predestination
* Last Judgment

Jewish|

* Abrahamic prophecy
* Aggadah
* Denominations
* Kabbalah
* Philosophy

Theology portal

0.00

(0 votes)

Original source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument from love. Read more

|

Retrieved from "https://handwiki.org/wiki/index.php?title=Religion:Argument_from_love&oldid=869518"
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template