1878 papal conclave

Papal conclave
February 1878

Dates and location
18–20 February 1878
Sistine Chapel, Apostolic Palace,
Rome
Key officials
Dean| Luigi Amat di San Filippo e Sorso
Sub-dean| Camillo di Pietro
Camerlengo| Gioacchino Pecci
Protopriest| Josef Friedrich von Schwarzenberg
Protodeacon| Prospero Caterini
Election
Candidates| Alessandro Franchi
Ballots| 3
Elected pope
Gioacchino Pecci
Name taken: Leo XIII

← 1846

1903 →

The papal conclave held from 18 to 20 February 1878 saw the election of Vincenzo Pecci, who took the name Leo XIII as pope. Held after the death of Pius IX, who had had the longest pontificate since Saint Peter, it was the first election of a pope who would not rule the Papal States. It was the first to meet in the Apostolic Palace in the Vatican because the venue used earlier in the 19th century, the Quirinal Palace, was now the palace of the king of Italy, Umberto I.

## Questions facing the cardinals

[edit]

When the cardinals assembled, they faced a dilemma. Should they choose a pope who would continue to espouse Pius IX's reactionary religious and political views, and would continue to refuse to accept Italy's Law of Guarantees guaranteeing the pope religious liberty in the Kingdom of Italy? Or should they turn away from the policies of Pius IX and choose a more liberal pope who could work for reconciliation with the king of Italy? Would choosing such a policy be seen as a betrayal of Pius IX, the self-proclaimed "prisoner in the Vatican"?

Other broader issues included Church-State relations in Italy, the Third French Republic, Ireland and the United States; the heresy Leo XIII later called Americanism; divisions in the Church caused by the proclamation of papal infallibility by the First Vatican Council; and the status of the First Vatican Council, which had been halted suddenly and never concluded. The length of Pius IX's reign suggested[how?] the cardinals give special consideration to the age and health of the man they elected.

## Conclave

[edit]

Pope Pius IX (1846–1878), whose reactionary policies the cardinals rejected in selecting the liberal Cardinal Pecci

Some 61 of 64 cardinals entered the conclave. Two others arrived too late from New York and Dublin to participate and one did not attend for health reasons. Three of the 61 had participated in the previous conclave in 1846: Luigi Amat di San Filippo e Sorso, Fabio Maria Asquini, and Domenico Carafa della Spina di Traetto.

With what many churchmen believed was the "unstable" and "anti-Catholic" situation in a Rome that was no longer controlled by the Church, some cardinals, notably Cardinal Manning, Archbishop of Westminster, urged that the conclave be moved outside Rome, perhaps even to Malta.[1] However the Camerlengo, Vincenzo Gioacchino Raffaele Luigi Pecci, advocated otherwise, and an initial vote among cardinals to move to Spain was overturned in a later vote. The conclave finally assembled in the Sistine Chapel in the Vatican on 18 February 1878.

Going into the conclave, Cardinal Pecci was the one candidate favored to be elected, in part because many of the cardinals who headed to Rome had already decided to elect him.[2] In addition to Pecci's competent administration as Camerlengo during the brief sede vacante period up to the conclave, Pecci was seen as the opposite of Pope Pius IX in terms of manner and temperament, and had also had a successful diplomatic career prior to being Archbishop-Bishop of Perugia.[2] Pecci's election was also facilitated in that Alessandro Franchi, the candidate favored by the conservatives, urged his supporters to switch their support to the Camerlengo.[2]

One account reported the voting tabulations without providing its source.[3]

### Ballot 1 (morning 19 February)

[edit]

On the first ballot, held on the morning of 19 February the votes were

* Vincenzo Gioacchino Raffaele Luigi Pecci 19 votes
* Luigi Bilio 6 votes
* Alessandro Franchi 4 votes

This ballot was ruled invalid because at least one cardinal did not mark his ballot properly.[4]

### Ballot 2 (afternoon 19 February)

[edit]

* Pecci 26
* Bilio 7
* Franchi 2

### Ballot 3 (morning 20 February)

[edit]

* Pecci 44 – elected

## Result, implications, and aftermath

[edit]

The election of Cardinal Pecci, who took the name of Leo XIII, was a victory for the liberals. Pecci had been an effective bishop whose diocese had moved from the Papal States to the Kingdom of Italy successfully, without Church problems. He was seen as a diplomatic pragmatist with the tact and flexibility opponents of the previous pope believed Pius IX lacked. At 68 Leo was also young enough to do the job without hindrance of health problems, but old enough to offer the prospect of a relatively short reign of ten to fifteen years. Whereas Pius IX was seen as having isolated the Church from international opinion (his confining Jews in ghettos and his treatment of minorities had been condemned by world leaders such as Gladstone), Leo was seen as an "internationalist" who could earn back the Vatican some international respect.

Though always seemingly in poor health and delicate condition, Leo reigned for 25 years. He had the third longest reign of any pope until that time. Leo XIII was later surpassed by Pope John Paul II who reigned for 26 years and six months from his election in October 1978 to his death in April of 2005. When Leo XIII died on 20 July 1903 at the age of 93 he had lived to be older than any of his known predecessors.

## Participants

[edit]

Arrived too late to participate[5]

* Paul Cullen, Archbishop of Dublin (Primate of Ireland)
* John McCloskey, Archbishop of New York (United States)[a]

Unavailable through ill-health[5]

* Godefroy Brossais-Saint-Marc, Archbishop of Rennes (France)

PAPAL CONCLAVE, 1878 LENGTH OF CONCLAVE  | 2 days

|

NUMBER OF BALLOTS  | 3
ELECTORS  | 64
Absent  | 3
Present  | 61
Africa  | 0
Latin America  | 0
North America  | 0
Asia  | 0
Europe  | 61
Oceania  | 0
Mid-East  | 0
Italians  | 40
VETO USED?  | No
DECEASED POPE  | PIUS IX (1846–1878)
NEW POPE  | LEO XIII (1878–1903)

Black smoke during the conclave of 1878

Present[8]

* Luigi Amat di San Filippo e Sorso, Dean of the College of Cardinals, cardinal-bishop of Ostia and Velletri
* Camillo di Pietro, cardinal-bishop of Porto e Santa Ruffina
* Carlo Sacconi, cardinal-bishop of Palestrina
* Filippo Maria Guidi, cardinal-bishop of Frascati
* Luigi Bilio, cardinal-bishop of Sabina
* Carlo Luigi Morichini, cardinal-bishop of Albano
* Friedrich Johannes Jacob Celestin von Schwarzenberg, Prince-Archbishop of Prague (Bohemia, part of Austria-Hungary)
* Fabio Maria Asquini, Prefect of the Sacred Congregation of Indulgences and Sacred Relics
* Domenico Carafa della Spina di Traetto, Archbishop of Benevento
* Ferdinand-François-Auguste Donnet, Bordeaux
* Vincenzo Gioacchino Raffaele Luigi Pecci, Camerlengo (Papal Chamberlain), Archbishop-Bishop of Perugia (Italy)
* Antonio Benedetto Antonucci, Ancona
* Antonio Maria Panebianco, Prefect of the Sacred Congregation for Indulgences and Sacred Relics
* Antonio Saverio De Luca, prefect of the Pontifical Congregation for Studies
* Jean Baptiste François Pitra, librarian of the Vatican Library
* Henri-Marie-Gaston Boisnormand de Bonnechose, Rouen
* Gustav Adolph von Hohenlohe, archpriest of Santa Maria Maggiore
* Lucien-Louis-Joseph-Napoleon Bonaparte, cardinal of Santa Pudenziana
* Innocenzo Ferrieri, Camerlengo of the Sacred College of Cardinals
* Giuseppe Berardi, Cardinal-Priest of Santi Marcellino e Pietro al Laterano
* Juan Ignacio Moreno y Maisanove, Toledo
* Raffaele Monaco La Valletta, Cardinal Vicar General of Rome
* Inácio do Nascimento de Morais Cardoso, Patriarch of Lisbon[b]
* René-François Régnier, Archbishop of Cambrai (France)
* Flavio Chigi, Grand Prior of Rome of the Sovereign Military Order of Malta
* Alessandro Franchi, Prefect of Propagande Fide
* Joseph-Hippolyte Guibert, Archbishop of Paris (France)
* Luigi Oreglia di Santo Stefano, Prefect of the Sacred Congregation of Indulgences and Relics
* János Simor, Esztergom
* Tommaso Martinelli, Prefect of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints
* Ruggero Luigi Emidio Antici Mattei
* Pietro Giannelli, cardinal-priest of Sant'Agnese fuori le mura
* Mieczyslaw Halka Ledóchowski, Archbishop of Gnesen and Posen, (Poland, part of the German Empire).
* Henry Edward Manning, Archbishop of Westminster (Head of the Catholic Church in England and Wales).
* Victor-Auguste-Isidor Deschamps, Archbishop of Mechelen (Belgium).
* Giovanni Simeoni, Secretary of State of the Holy See
* Domenico Bartolini, Cardinal-Priest of San Marco Evangelista al Campidoglio
* Bartolomeo d'Avanzo, Bishop of Calvi e Teano (Italy)
* Johann Baptist Franzelin, Jesuit theologian, Cardinal-Priest of Santi Bonifacio ed Alessio
* Francisco de Paula Benavides y Navarrete, Patriarch of the West Indies
* Francesco Saverio Apuzzo, Archbishop of Capua
* Emmanuele Garcia Gil, Zaragoza
* Edward Henry Howard, Protector of the English College at Rome
* Miguel Payá y Rico, Santiago de Compostella
* Louis-Marie Caverot, Lyon
* Luigi di Canossa, Verona
* Luigi Serafini, Viterbo
* Josip Mihalovic, Zagreb
* Johann Rudolf Kutschker, Archbishop of Vienna, Austria-Hungary
* Lucido Parocchi, Bologna
* Vincenzo Moretti, Ravenna
* Antonio Pellegrini, cardinal-deacon of Santa Maria in Aquiro
* Prospero Caterini, Protodeacon, Secretary of the Inquisition.
* Teodolfo Mertel, Prefect of the Apostolic Signatura; the last cardinal to not be ordained to the priesthood
* Domenico Consolini, Prefect of the Pontifical Roman Seminary of Sts. Peter and Paul for the Foreign Missions
* Edoardo Borromeo, President of the Fabric of Saint Peter
* Lorenzo Ilarione Randi, Vice-Camerlengo of the Apostolic Camera
* Bartolomeo Pacca il Giovane, Cardinal-Deacon of Santa Maria in Campitelli
* Lorenzo Nina, Prefect of the Congregation for Studies
* Enea Sbarretti, Cardinal-Deacon of Santa Maria dei Martiri (the Pantheon)
* Frédéric de Falloux du Coudray, Cardinal-Deacon of Sant'Agata de' Goti

## Notes

[edit]

1. ^ McCloskey sailed from New York on 9 February[6] and reached Rome on 23 February.[7]
2. ^ Cardinal Cardoso arrived late and only participated in the final ballot.[9]

## References

[edit]

1. ^ Hittinger, Russell (2006). "Pope Leo XIII". In Witte, John; Alexander, Frank S. (eds.). The Teachings of Modern Christianity on Law, Politics, and Human Nature. Columbia University Press. pp. 42–2\. ISBN 9780231133586.42-2&rft.pub=Columbia+University+Press&rft.date=2006&rft.isbn=9780231133586&rft.aulast=Hittinger&rft.aufirst=Russell&rft_id=https://books.google.com/books?id=GvVVAa_-bsEC&pg;=PA41&rfr_id=info:sid/en.wikipedia.org:1878+papal+conclave" class="Z3988">
2. ^ a b c Pirie, Valérie (1935). "Leo XIII and His Successors". The Triple Crown: An Account of the Papal Conclaves. London: Sidgwick & Jackson.
3. ^ Jedin, Hubert; Dolan, John Patrick, eds. (1981). History of the Church: The Church in the Industrial age. London: Burns & Oates. p. 5\. ISBN 9780860120858. Retrieved 4 May 2018.
4. ^ Burkle-Young, Francis A. (2000). Papal Elections in the Age of Transition, 1878-1922. Lexington Books. p. 59\. ISBN 9780739101148. Retrieved 15 November 2017.
5. ^ a b Burkle-Young, Francis A. (2000). Papal Elections in the Age of Transition, 1878-1922. Lexington Books. p. 161\. ISBN 9780739101148. Retrieved 15 November 2017.
6. ^ "Departure of Cardinal M'Closkey" (PDF). The New York Times. 10 February 1878. Retrieved 15 November 2017.
7. ^ "Miscellaneous Foreign Notes" (PDF). The New York Times. 24 February 1878. Retrieved 15 November 2017.
8. ^ Burkle-Young, Francis A. (2000). Papal Elections in the Age of Transition, 1878-1922. Lexington Books. pp. 159–60\. ISBN 9780739101148. Retrieved 15 November 2017.159-60&rft.pub=Lexington+Books&rft.date=2000&rft.isbn=9780739101148&rft.aulast=Burkle-Young&rft.aufirst=Francis+A.&rft_id=https://books.google.com/books?id=t9QxJMdp6FMC&pg;=PA159&rfr_id=info:sid/en.wikipedia.org:1878+papal+conclave" class="Z3988">
9. ^ Henry Dodridge, Henry; et al. (1903). The Catholic Church Alone: The One True Church of Christ. New York: Catholic Educational Company. p. 407. Retrieved 4 May 2018.

## External links

[edit]

* L’Osservatore Romano article revealing ballots in 1878 conclave Archived 15 April 2017 at the Wayback Machine

* v
* t
* e

Papal elections and conclaves

* Papal selection before 1059
* Papal conclave (1274-1276, 1294-present)

Elections and
conclaves|

* 1061
* 1073
* 1086
* 1088
* 1099
* 1118
* 1119
* 1124
* 1130
* 1143
* 1144
* 1145
* 1153
* 1154
* 1159
* 1181
* 1185
* October 1187
* December 1187
* 1191
* 1198
* 1216
* 1227
* 1241
* 1243
* 1254
* 1261
* 1264–1265
* 1268–1271
* January 1276
* July 1276
* September 1276
* 1277
* 1280–1281
* 1285
* 1287–1288
* 1292–1294
* 1294
* 1303
* 1304–1305
* 1314–1316
* 1334
* 1342
* 1352
* 1362
* 1370
* 1378
* 1389
* 1404
* 1406
* 1417
* 1431
* 1447
* 1455
* 1458
* 1464
* 1471
* 1484
* 1492
* September 1503
* electors
* October 1503
* electors
* 1513
* 1521–1522
* 1523
* 1534
* 1549–1550
* April 1555
* May 1555
* 1559
* 1565–1566
* 1572
* 1585
* September 1590
* October–December 1590
* 1591
* 1592
* March–April 1605
* electors
* May 1605
* electors
* 1621
* 1623
* 1644
* 1655
* 1667
* 1669–1670
* 1676
* 1689
* 1691
* 1700
* 1721
* 1724
* 1730
* 1740
* 1758
* 1769
* 1774–1775
* 1799–1800
* 1823
* 1829
* 1830–1831
* 1846
* 1878
* 1903
* 1914
* electors
* 1922
* electors
* 1939
* electors
* 1958
* electors
* 1963
* electors
* August 1978
* electors
* October 1978
* electors
* 2005
* electors
* 2013
* electors

Governing
documents
(selected)|

* In nomine Domini (1059)
* Ubi periculum (1274)
* Aeterni Patris Filius (1621)
* Cum proxime (1922)
* Ingravescentem aetatem (1970)
* Romano Pontifici eligendo (1975)
* Universi Dominici gregis (1996)
* De aliquibus mutationibus in normis de electione Romani Pontificis (2007)
* Normas nonnullas (2013)

* Category

Portals:

* Catholicism
* Christianity
* Vatican City

1878 papal conclave at Wikipedia's sister projects:

* Definitions from Wiktionary
* Media from Commons
* News from Wikinews
* Quotations from Wikiquote
* Texts from Wikisource
* Textbooks from Wikibooks
* Resources from Wikiversity
* Data from Wikidata

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template