1879 United States Senate election in Wisconsin

For related races, see 1878–79 United States Senate elections.

1879 United States Senate election in Wisconsin

* * *

| <- 1873 | January 22, 1879 | 1881 (special) ->

|
|

|  |  |  |

|
|
|

Nominee  | Matthew H. Carpenter | Edward G. Ryan | Gabriel Bouck
Party  | Republican | Democratic | Democratic
Legislative vote  | 84 | 28  | 13
Percentage  | 67.20% | 22.40%  | 10.40%

* * *

| U.S. senator before election

Timothy O. Howe
Republican

| Elected U.S. Senator

Matthew H. Carpenter
Republican

|

Elections in Wisconsin

Federal government

|  Presidential elections

* 1848
* 1852
* 1856
* 1860
* 1864
* 1868
* 1872
* 1876
* 1880
* 1884
* 1888
* 1892
* 1896
* 1900
* 1904
* 1908
* 1912
* 1916
* 1920
* 1924
* 1928
* 1932
* 1936
* 1940
* 1944
* 1948
* 1952
* 1956
* 1960
* 1964
* 1968
* 1972
* 1976
* 1980
* 1984
* 1988
* 1992
* 1996
* 2000
* 2004
* 2008
* 2012
* 2016
* 2020
* 2024

Presidential primaries

Democratic
2000
2004
2008
2016
2020
2024

Republican
2004
2008
2012
2016
2020
2024
U.S. Senate elections

Class 1

* 1848
* 1851
* 1857
* 1863
* 1869
* 1875
* 1881
* 1887
* 1893
* 1899
* 1905
* 1911
* 1916
* 1922
* 1925 sp
* 1928
* 1934
* 1940
* 1946
* 1952
* 1957 sp
* 1958
* 1964
* 1970
* 1976
* 1982
* 1988
* 1994
* 2000
* 2006
* 2012
* 2018
* 2024

Class 3

* 1848
* 1849
* 1855
* 1861
* 1867
* 1872
* 1879
* 1881 sp
* 1885
* 1890
* 1891
* 1897
* 1903
* 1907 sp
* 1909
* 1914
* 1918 sp
* 1920
* 1926
* 1932
* 1938
* 1944
* 1950
* 1956
* 1962
* 1968
* 1974
* 1980
* 1982
* 1986
* 1992
* 1998
* 2004
* 2010
* 2016
* 2022
* 2028

U.S. House of Representatives elections

* 1848
* 1850
* 1852
* 1854
* 1856
* 1858
* 1860
* 1862
* 1863
* 2nd sp
* 1864
* 1866
* 1868
* 1870
* 2nd sp
* 1872
* 1874
* 1876
* 1878
* 1880
* 1882
* 1884
* 1886
* 5th sp
* 1887
* 8th sp
* 1888
* 1890
* 1892
* 1893
* 4th sp
* 1894
* 7th sp
* 1896
* 1898
* 1900
* 1902
* 1904
* 1906
* 2nd sp
* 1908
* 1910
* 1912
* 1914
* 1916
* 1918
* 6th sp
* 11th sp
* 1920
* 1922
* 1924
* 1926
* 1928
* 1930
* 6th sp
* 1931
* 1st sp
* 1932
* 1934
* 1936
* 1938
* 1940
* 1941
* 1st sp
* 1942
* 1944
* 1946
* 1947
* 2nd sp
* 1948
* 1950
* 1952
* 1953
* 9th sp
* 1954
* 1956
* 1958
* 1960
* 1962
* 1964
* 1966
* 1968
* 1969
* 7th sp
* 1970
* 1972
* 1974
* 1976
* 1978
* 1979
* 6th sp
* 1980
* 1982
* 1984
* 4th sp
* 1986
* 1988
* 1990
* 1992
* 1993
* 1st sp
* 1994
* 1996
* 1998
* 2000
* 2002
* 2004
* 2006
* 2008
* 2010
* 2012
* 2014
* 2016
* 2018
* 2020
* 7th sp
* 2022
* 2024
* 8th sp
* 2026

State government

|  General elections

* 1925
* 1995
* 2000
* 2008
* 2009
* 2010
* 2011
* 2012
* 2013
* 2014
* 2015
* 2016
* 2017
* 2018
* 2019
* 2020
* 2021
* 2022
* 2023
* 2024
* 2025
* 2026

Gubernatorial elections

* 1848
* 1849
* 1851
* 1853
* 1855
* 1857
* 1859
* 1861
* 1863
* 1865
* 1867
* 1869
* 1871
* 1873
* 1875
* 1877
* 1879
* 1881
* 1884
* 1886
* 1888
* 1890
* 1892
* 1894
* 1896
* 1898
* 1900
* 1902
* 1904
* 1906
* 1908
* 1910
* 1912
* 1914
* 1916
* 1918
* 1920
* 1922
* 1924
* 1926
* 1928
* 1930
* 1932
* 1934
* 1936
* 1938
* 1940
* 1942
* 1944
* 1946
* 1948
* 1950
* 1952
* 1954
* 1956
* 1958
* 1960
* 1962
* 1964
* 1966
* 1968
* 1970
* 1974
* 1978
* 1982
* 1986
* 1990
* 1994
* 1998
* 2002
* 2006
* 2010
* 2012 (recall)
* 2014
* 2018
* 2022
* 2026

Lieutenant Gubernatorial elections

* 1942
* 1968
* 2012 (recall)

Secretary of State elections

* 1978
* 2014
* 2018
* 2022
* 2026

Attorney General elections

* 2014
* 2018
* 2022

Treasurer elections

* 2014
* 2022

Superintendent elections

* 1925
* 2009
* 2013
* 2017
* 2021
* 2025

State Senate elections

* 1934
* 1996
* 2008
* 2010
* 2011 (recall)
* 2012 (recall)
* 2012
* 2014
* 2016
* 2018
* 2020
* 2022
* 2024
* 2026

State Assembly elections

* 2008
* 2010
* 2012
* 2014
* 2016
* 2018
* 2020
* 2022
* 2024
* 2026

Supreme Court elections

* 1852 (3)
* 1855
* 1859
* 1860 sp.
* 1861
* 1863
* 1865
* 1867
* 1868 sp. (2)
* 1869
* 1871
* 1873
* 1875
* 1877 (2)
* 1878
* 1879
* 1881 (2)
* 1883
* 1885
* 1887
* 1889
* 1891
* 1892 sp.
* 1893
* 1895
* 1897
* 1898 sp.
* 1899 (2)
* 1901
* 1903
* 1904
* 1905
* 1906
* 1907
* 1908 sp.
* 1909
* 1911
* 1913
* 1914
* 1915
* 1916
* 1917
* 1919
* 1921
* 1922 sp.
* 1923
* 1924
* 1925
* 1926
* 1927
* 1929
* 1930 sp.
* 1931
* 1933
* 1934
* 1935
* 1936
* 1937
* 1939
* 1941
* 1943
* 1944
* 1945
* 1946
* 1947
* 1949
* 1950 sp.
* 1951
* 1952 sp.
* 1953
* 1954
* 1955
* 1956
* 1957
* 1958
* 1959
* 1961
* 1963
* 1964
* 1965
* 1966
* 1967
* 1968
* 1969
* 1970
* 1973
* 1974
* 1975
* 1976
* 1977
* 1978
* 1979
* 1980
* 1983
* 1984
* 1985
* 1986
* 1987
* 1989
* 1990
* 1993
* 1994
* 1995
* 1996
* 1997
* 1999
* 2000
* 2001
* 2003
* 2005
* 2006
* 2007
* 2008
* 2009
* 2011
* 2013
* 2015
* 2016
* 2017
* 2018
* 2019
* 2020
* 2023
* 2025
* 2026
* 2027
* 2028
* 2029
* 2030
* 2033

Ballot measures

2006
Referendum 1
2025
Question 1

Green Bay

|  Mayoral elections

* 1995
* 1999
* 2003
* 2007
* 2011
* 2015
* 2019
* 2023

Madison

|  Mayoral elections

* 1874
* 1875
* 1876
* 1973
* 1997 sp.
* 1999
* 2003
* 2007
* 2011
* 2015
* 2019
* 2023

Milwaukee

|  Mayoral elections

* 1898
* 1900
* 1902
* 1904
* 1906
* 1908
* 1910
* 1912
* 1996
* 2000
* 2004
* 2008
* 2012
* 2016
* 2020
* 2022 sp
* 2024

* v
* t
* e

The 1879 United States Senate election in Wisconsin was held in the 32nd Wisconsin Legislature on January 22, 1879. Incumbent Republican U.S. senator Timothy O. Howe ran for a fourth six-year term, but was defeated for renomination. Former U.S. senator Matthew H. Carpenter--who had been ousted by a split in the party four years earlier--was elected United States senator on the 1st ballot.[1]

At the start of the 1879 term, Republicans held large majorities in both chambers of the Wisconsin Legislature, so had more than enough votes to elect a Republican United States senator. The main drama of the election was in the Republican caucus, which dragged out for a week and went to 96 ballots as they failed to agree on a nominee. Republican party boss Elisha W. Keyes was seeking the U.S. Senate seat as a crowning achievement in his mastery of the Wisconsin Republican Party, but would require unseating his former ally, the incumbent U.S. senator Timothy Howe, who still had a large loyal following. Former U.S. senator Matt Carpenter, who had been ousted by a party rebellion in 1875 also had significant support in the caucus for his return to office.

After 96 failed votes, Keyes and Howe withdrew and endorsed Carpenter; Carpenter was then unanimously nominated less than an hour before the start of the joint session of the legislature. The Republican caucus was likely afraid of a repeat of the 1875 election, where a divided party had allowed the Democrats to effectively choose which Republican would become U.S. senator.

## Major candidates

[edit]

### Democratic

[edit]

* Gabriel Bouck, incumbent U.S. representative of Wisconsin's 6th congressional district.
* Edward George Ryan, incumbent chief justice of the Wisconsin Supreme Court.

### Republican

[edit]

* Matthew H. Carpenter, former U.S. senator.
* Timothy O. Howe, incumbent U.S. senator, former Wisconsin circuit court judge from Green Bay.
* Elisha W. Keyes, head of the "Madison Regency" political machine and de-facto head of the Republican Party of Wisconsin throughout this era, former mayor of Madison.

## Results

[edit]

### Republican nomination

[edit]

Prior to the Republican caucus, Republican Party boss Elisha Keyes made an extensive campaign for the nomination with the support of many allies, operatives, and loyal newspapers around the state; several papers reported that he was nearly guaranteed to secure the U.S. Senate seat, possibly with near-unanimous support. It was also suggested that Keyes had been preparing to win a special election for U.S. Senate two years earlier, when he believed the Republican incumbent senator, Timothy Howe, would be appointed to the U.S. Supreme Court.[2] Although Senator Howe was still seeking another term and Republicans generally did not object to him on policy or personal grounds, many described him as too old (at age 63), and having served long enough (about to complete his third six-year term).[3]

The Republican caucus met on January 16\. An initial informal ballot was taken, indicating roughly equal support for Keyes, Howe, and former U.S. senator Matt Carpenter, with a scattering of votes for other candidates. Over the course of the night, they took 21 ballots for the nomination with very little change in the outcome. They re-convened on January 17 and continued voting. After 49 ballots, the top three candidates remained roughly tied even as other minor candidates fell off.[4] They adjourned for the weekend and returned to caucus on January 20, where voting resumed. Numerous dark horse alternative candidates rose and fell, but none of them attained even 10% of the caucus vote. Voting continued on the 20th until 12:30 am, with the 79th formal ballot showing little change from the first. They reconvened at 11 am on January 21 to continued voting through the entire day.[5] During the course of the day on January 21, the legislators also had to cast their ballots in their respective chambers as an informal step before the joint session. That informal vote found Keyes receiving 29 votes, Democrat Edward G. Ryan receiving 29, Carpenter receiving 26, Howe receiving 24, Democrat Gabriel Bouck receiving 11, and 10 scattering.

Back in the Republican caucus, voting continued. The 96th ballot showed almost no change from the first day, with Keyes stuck at 25, Carpenter with 33, and Howe with 28. At about 9:12 pm, a motion was made for a 97th ballot, but no one seconded the motion. They instead narrowly voted to adjourn until 9 am the following day, an hour before the joint session was scheduled to begin.

On the morning of January 22, state senator George B. Burrows gave an impassioned speech extolling the virtues of his candidate, Keyes, before announcing Keyes's withdrawal from the race and calling for the unanimous nomination of Matt Carpenter. Assembly speaker David M. Kelly, a supporter of Howe, then spoke and seconded Burrows' motion. Carpenter was then declared the nominee by acclamation.[6]

### Official vote

[edit]

The 32nd Wisconsin Legislature met in joint session on January 22, 1879, to elect a U.S. senator. The voting was almost entirely along party lines, with one vacant seat, and seven members absent or not voting. Of the 125 present and voting, Matt Carpenter received the votes of every Republican legislator, winning the election.[1]

1st Vote of the 32nd Wisconsin Legislature, January 22, 1879[1] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %

|
|
|

| Republican | Matthew H. Carpenter | 84[a] | 67.20%
| Democratic | Edward George Ryan | 28[b] | 22.40%
| Democratic | Gabriel Bouck | 13[c] | 10.40%
|  | Absent or not voting | 7  |
|  | Vacant seats | 1[d] |
Majority  | 63  | 50.40%
Total votes  | 125  | 93.98%
| Republican hold

## Notes

[edit]

1. ^ Carpenter received the votes of all Republican members except for senators Gysbert Van Steenwyk Sr. and David E. Welch, and representatives Knud Adland, John Bradley, and Roger Williams (who were all absent).
2. ^ Ryan received the votes of all Democrats except senators Andrew Haben and George Howard Paul and representatives Philip Greening and Francis Steffen (who voted for Bouck), and senator John A. Rice and representative James D. Condit (who were absent).
3. ^ Bouck received the votes of all of the Greenbackers, along with Democratic senators Andrew Haben and George Howard Paul, and Democratic representatives Philip Greening and Francis Steffen.
4. ^ Republican senator Charles Phillips died before the start of the session.

## References

[edit]

1. ^ a b c "January 22, 1879". In Assembly Journal of Proceedings of the Wisconsin Legislature (Report). Wisconsin Legislature. 1879. pp. 72–73. Retrieved March 8, 2025 - via HathiTrust.
2. ^ "The Senatorial Question". Wisconsin State Journal. December 23, 1878. p. 1. Retrieved March 8, 2025 - via Newspapers.com.
3. ^ "U.S. Senatorship". Wisconsin State Journal. December 23, 1878. p. 1. Retrieved March 8, 2025 - via Newspapers.com.
4. ^ "A Dead Lock". Wisconsin State Journal. January 18, 1879. p. 1. Retrieved March 8, 2025 - via Newspapers.com.
5. ^ "Still Unbroken". Wisconsin State Journal. January 21, 1879. p. 1. Retrieved March 8, 2025 - via Newspapers.com.
6. ^ "The Chosen One". Wisconsin State Journal. January 22, 1879. p. 1. Retrieved March 8, 2025 - via Newspapers.com.

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template