1910 Edinburgh South by-election

* * *

| <- 1910 | 29 April 1910 | 1910 ->

|
|

|  |  |

|
|

Candidate  | Lyell | Glyn
Party  | Liberal | Conservative
Popular vote  | 8,694 | 6,367
Percentage  | 57.7% | 42.3%

* * *

| MP before election

Arthur Dewar
Liberal

| Subsequent MP

Charles Henry Lyell
Liberal

|

The 1910 Edinburgh South by-election was a parliamentary by-election held for the UK House of Commons constituency of Edinburgh South in Scotland on 29 April 1910.

## Vacancy

[edit]

The by-election was caused by the appointment of the sitting Liberal MP, Arthur Dewar KC, who was the Solicitor General for Scotland, as a Senator of the College of Justice.

## Electoral history

[edit]

Dewar had first been elected as MP for Edinburgh South in a by-election in June 1899.[1] He lost the seat narrowly at the general election of 1900 but won it back in 1906, holding it in January 1910.[2]

General election January 1910: Edinburgh South[3] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

| Liberal | Arthur Dewar | 10,235  | 56.4  | −7.4
| Conservative | Harold B Cox  | 7,901  | 43.6  | +7.4
Majority  | 2,334  | 12.8  | −14.8
Turnout | 18,136  | 88.8  | +5.4
| Liberal hold | Swing | -7.4  |

## Candidates

[edit]

The Liberals first choice for the seat was Dr Edward Parrott. Parrott, a publisher and author, was chairman of the Edinburgh South Liberal Association and also of the Edinburgh United Liberal Committee.[4] At a meeting on 11 April, the local executive of the Liberal Association met to consider who the candidate should be, assuming Dewar was to be appointed to the College of Justice. Parrott asked for 48 hours to think the offer over[5] but turned it down and the committee instead turned to Charles Lyell a 34-year-old professional politician, as their preferred candidate.[6] Lyell had been MP for East Dorset from 1904 to January 1910. During that time he served as Parliamentary Private Secretary to Sir Edward Grey, the Foreign Secretary. He switched seats in January 1910, leaving the marginal East Dorset to Freddie Guest (Guest had family connections in the county) and taking on instead the usually Unionist seat of Edinburgh West, which he failed to gain.[7]

The Unionist candidate in the previous general election had been Harold Cox, an Edinburgh businessman but he ruled himself out as a possible candidate for the by-election on medical advice.[8] The Unionists then turned to 25-year-old Ralph Campbell Glyn, the only son of the Bishop of Peterborough whose mother was the sister of the Duke of Argyll.[9] Glyn had been the Liberal Unionist candidate in Elginshire and Nairnshire at the January 1910 election.[10]

## Campaign

[edit]

An early issue in the campaign was the question of House of Lords reform. This had been brought to a head by Lloyd George's People's Budget of 1909. Lloyd George's radical tax raising proposals and plans to finance social provisions such as old age pensions meant his budget was rejected by the landed majority in the House of Lords against the convention that the Lords would not reject financial bills. This sparked a constitutional crisis and provoked the January 1910 general election.[11] The issue was therefore still high on the political agenda and Glyn made it the centrepiece of his adoption meeting on 20 April. He said he was in favour of reforming the House of Lords but could not bring himself to attack its recent actions. He said the best party to reform the Lords was what he described as the Constitutional party i.e. the Conservatives. Constitutional reform should not be rushed and the Tories said Glyn were the best placed to consider this matter as they may have been slow but had always been sure.[12] This position was reinforced by the letter of support which Glyn received from the Conservative leader Arthur Balfour. In it, Balfour wrote that the present government desired a revolution, not he said against the House of Lords, but against the British people. In his letter Balfour contended that there were many evils associated with the reform of the Lords, including the postponement of the very social reforms which the Liberal government wished to implement. It is not in an atmosphere of revolutionary controversy, he wrote, that healthy legislation on such subjects can be secured.[13]

Asquith's letter of support to Lyell was less colourful simply referring to the great constitutional struggle which the country and the party was engaged in and anticipating another clear Liberal win in the constituency.

## Result

[edit]

Lyell held the seat for the Liberals with a majority of 2,327 votes over Glyn. This compared with an almost identical majority of 2,334 at the previous general election.

Edinburgh South by-election, 1910[14] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

| Liberal | Charles Henry Lyell | 8,694  | 57.7  | +1.3
| Liberal Unionist | Ralph Glyn | 6,367  | 42.3  | −1.3
Majority  | 2,327  | 15.4  | +2.6
Turnout | 15,061  | 73.7  | −15.1
| Liberal hold | Swing | +1.3  |

While turnout was down between the general election and by-election, the share of the poll each party received was broadly the same. It seems issues the electorate felt were important enough to vote for in January had not changed by April and neither did the Liberals suffer from voter impatience at being asked to turn out for what may have seemed like an unnecessary election, as sometimes happens when sitting MPs stand down close to general elections.

## Aftermath

[edit]

The Liberal held the seat at the following General Election.

General election December 1910: Edinburgh South[15] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

| Liberal | Charles Henry Lyell | 9,576  | 54.5  | −1.9
| Conservative | Charles Murray | 7,986  | 45.5  | −1.9
Majority  | 1,590  | 9.0  | −3.8
Turnout | 17,562  | 84.2  | −4.6
| Liberal hold | Swing | -1.9  |

Glyn was elected MP for Clackmannan and Eastern Stirlingshire in 1918.

## See also

[edit]

* Lists of United Kingdom by-elections
* United Kingdom by-election records
* February 1886 Edinburgh South by-election
* 1899 Edinburgh South by-election
* 1917 Edinburgh South by-election
* 1957 Edinburgh South by-election

## References

[edit]

1. ^ The Times, 20 June 1899 p10
2. ^ F W S Craig, British Parliamentary Election Results, 1885–1918; Macmillan Press, 1974 pp499
3. ^ Debrett's House of Commons and the Judicial Bench, 1916
4. ^ Who was Who; OUP online, 2007
5. ^ The Times, 12 April 1910, p. 12
6. ^ The Times, 19 April 1910, p. 10
7. ^ F W S Craig, British Parliamentary Election Results, 1885–1918; Macmillan Press, 1974 pp263&500
8. ^ The Times, 19 April 1910 p10
9. ^ The Times, 20 April 1910 p8
10. ^ F W S Craig, British Parliamentary Election Results, 1885–1918; Macmillan Press, 1974 p538
11. ^ "www.liberalhistory.org.uk – 1909 People's Budget". Archived from the original on 30 September 2006. Retrieved 6 October 2006.
12. ^ The Times, 21 April 1910 p8
13. ^ The Times, 28 April 1910 p8
14. ^ Debrett's House of Commons and the Judicial Bench, 1916
15. ^ Debrett's House of Commons and the Judicial Bench, 1916

* v
* t
* e

« 28th Parliament « By-elections to the 29th Parliament of the United Kingdom » 30th Parliament »

1910|

* February: Swansea District
* March: Rotherham
* Tower Hamlets St George
* Barnstaple
* North East Cork
* Ilkeston
* Shipley
* Reading
* West Wicklow
* Mid Glamorgan
* April: Govan
* North Down
* Edinburgh South
* Crewe
* June: Dublin Harbour
* Lewes
* The Hartlepools
* East Dorset
* July: Liverpool Kirkdale
* October: South Shields
* November: Walthamstow

Lists of UK by-elections
1801–1806
1806–1818
1818–1832
1832–1847
1847–1857
1857–1868
1868–1885
1885–1900
1900–1918
1918–1931
1931–1950
1950–1979
1979–2010
2010–present
Northern Ireland
Hereditary peers

* v
* t
* e

« 1868–1899 « By-elections in Scotland to the House of Commons of the United Kingdom 1900–1949 » 1950–present »

1900s|

* May 1900: Edinburgh and St Andrews Universities
* September 1901: North East Lanarkshire
* November 1902: Orkney and Shetland
* February 1903: East Perthshire
* August 1903: Argyllshire
* September 1903: St Andrews Burghs
* January 1904: Ayr Burghs
* August 1904: North East Lanarkshire
* March 1905: Buteshire
* September 1905: Elgin Burghs
* February 1906: East Aberdeenshire
* February 1907: Aberdeen South
* Banffshire
* Perth
* April 1908: Kincardineshire
* May 1908: Dundee
* Stirling Burghs
* Montrose Burghs
* February 1909: Forfarshire
* March 1909: Glasgow Central
* Edinburgh South
* Hawick Burghs
* April 1909: Edinburgh East
* May 1909: Edinburgh West
* July 1909: Dumfries Burghs

1910s|

* April 1910: Govan
* Edinburgh South
* March 1911: North East Lanarkshire
* June 1911: Ross and Cromarty
* July 1911: Glasgow Tradeston
* September 1911: Kilmarnock Burghs
* December 1911: North Ayrshire
* Govan
* February 1912: Edinburgh East
* Glasgow St Rollox
* September 1912: Midlothian
* November 1913: Linlithgowshire
* December 1913: Wick Burghs
* South Lanarkshire
* February 1914: Leith Burghs
* April 1914: East Fife
* February 1915: Wigtownshire
* May 1915: Kilmarnock Burghs
* July 1916: Berwickshire
* October 1916: North Ayrshire
* December 1916: Edinburgh and St Andrews Universities
* January 1917: Inverness-shire
* February 1917: West Perthshire
* April 1917: Aberdeen South
* May 1917: Edinburgh South
* July 1917: Dundee
* August 1917: Edinburgh and St Andrews Universities
* May 1918: Elgin Burghs
* April 1919: Aberdeenshire and Kincardineshire Central

1920s|

* February 1920: Paisley
* March 1920: Argyll
* April 1920: Edinburgh North
* Edinburgh South
* March 1921: Kirkcaldy Burghs
* April 1921: Glasgow Pollok
* May 1921: Orkney and Shetland
* March 1922: Inverness
* June 1922: Moray and Nairn
* May 1924: Glasgow Kelvingrove
* December 1924: Dundee
* June 1925: Ayr Burghs
* November 1925: Galloway
* January 1926: Dunbartonshire
* East Renfrewshire
* March 1927: Leith
* April 1927: Combined Scottish Universities
* April 1928: Linlithgowshire
* August 1928: Aberdeen North
* January 1929: Midlothian and Peebles Northern
* September 1929: Kilmarnock

1930s|

* June 1930: Glasgow Shettleston
* November 1930: East Renfrewshire
* May 1931: Glasgow St Rollox
* Rutherglen
* March 1932: Dunbartonshire
* June 1932: Montrose Burghs
* February 1933: East Fife
* November 1933: Kilmarnock
* March 1934: Combined Scottish Universities
* April 1935: Perth
* May 1935: Edinburgh West
* Aberdeen South
* June 1935: Combined Scottish Universities
* September 1935: Dumfriesshire
* January 1936: Combined Scottish Universities
* February 1936: Ross and Cromarty
* March 1936: Dunbartonshire
* November 1937: Greenock
* June 1937: Glasgow Hillhead
* September 1937: Glasgow Springburn
* February 1938: Combined Scottish Universities
* December 1938: Kinross and Western Perthshire
* March 1939: Kincardineshire and Western Aberdeenshire
* April 1939: South Ayrshire
* October 1939: Clackmannanshire and East Stirlingshire

1940s|

* April 1940: Argyllshire
* Glasgow Pollok
* May 1940: East Renfrewshire
* July 1940: Montrose Burghs
* February 1941: Dunbartonshire
* July 1941: Greenock
* Edinburgh West
* December 1941: Edinburgh Central
* April 1942: Glasgow Cathcart
* January 1943: Hamilton
* February 1943: Midlothian and Peebles Northern
* February 1944: Kirkcaldy Burghs
* April 1945: Motherwell
* Combined Scottish Universities
* October 1945: Edinburgh East
* February 1946: South Ayrshire
* Glasgow Cathcart
* August 1946: Glasgow Bridgeton
* November 1946: Aberdeen South
* Combined Scottish Universities
* December 1946: Kilmarnock
* November 1947: Edinburgh East
* January 1948: Glasgow Camlachie
* February 1948: Paisley
* September 1948: Glasgow Gorbals
* October 1948: Stirling and Falkirk
* November 1948: Glasgow Hillhead

Lists of UK by-elections
1801–1806
1806–1818
1818–1832
1832–1847
1847–1857
1857–1868
1868–1885
1885–1900
1900–1918
1918–1931
1931–1950
1950–1979
1979–2010
2010–present
Northern Ireland
Hereditary peers
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template