1919 Croydon South by-election

By-election for the House of Commons

1919 Croydon South by-election

* * *

| <- 1918 | 14 November 1919 | 1922 ->

|
|

|  |  |

|
|

Candidate  | Smith | Houlder
Party  | Unionist | Liberal
Popular vote  | 11,777  | 9,573
Percentage  | 55.2  | 44.8

* * *

| MP before election

Malcolm
Unionist

| Subsequent MP

Smith
Unionist

|

The 1919 Croydon South by-election was a parliamentary by-election for the British House of Commons constituency of Croydon South on 14 November 1919.

## Vacancy[edit]

The by-election was caused by the resignation of the sitting Unionist MP, Sir Ian Malcolm on 28 October 1919. He had been the MP for Croydon since December 1910.

## Electoral history[edit]

Croydon was a traditionally strong area for the Unionists. The Croydon constituency was created in 1885 and won by the Unionists at every election. In 1918, it was divided into two seats, and its MP, Ian Malcolm, was elected for the new Croydon South seat. He was helped by the absence of a Liberal opponent and the official support of the Coalition government;

1918 general election [1] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

C | Unionist | Ian Malcolm | 17,813 | 71.8 |
| Labour | H. T. Muggeridge[2] | 7,006  | 28.2  |
Majority  | 10,807  | 43.6  |
Turnout | 24,819  | 55.0  |
| Unionist win
C indicates candidate endorsed by the coalition government.

## Candidates[edit]

* The Unionists selected 49-year-old Sir Allan Smith to defend the seat. He was a solicitor and Chairman of the Management Board of the Engineering and Allied Employers’ National Federation.[3]
* On 30 October, the Croydon Liberal and Radical Association unanimously adopted 60-year-old Alderman Howard Houlder to challenge for the seat.[4] He had not stood for parliament before but been elected to Croydon Council. He served as Mayor of Croydon from 1916 to 1919. He worked for the family shipping business.[5]
* The Labour Party did not run a candidate this time.

## Campaign[edit]

Polling Day was set for 14 November, just 17 days after the resignation of Malcolm. Close of Nominations occurred on 4 November to reveal a two cornered contest. Smith received official backing from the Coalition Government, while Houlder's candidacy was backed by the Liberal opposition.

## Result[edit]

There was a big drop in the Unionist majority.

1919 Croydon South by-election [6] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

C | Unionist | Allan Smith | 11,777 | 55.2 | -16.6
| Liberal | Howard Houlder  | 9,573  | 44.8  | New
Majority  | 2,204  | 10.4  | -33.2
Turnout | 21,359  | 45.5  | -9.5
| Unionist hold | Swing | N/A |
C indicates candidate endorsed by the coalition government.

Sir Allan Smith thought the result "was a victory for the forces of unity".[7]

## Aftermath[edit]

Smith retained the seat at the following election because the anti-Unionist vote was split when Muggeridge intervened. Houlder did not stand for parliament again. The result at the following General election;

1922 general election [8] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

| Unionist | Allan Smith | 15,356  | 47.3  |
| Labour | H.T. Muggeridge | 8,942  | 27.5  | New
| Liberal | Thomas Dobson | 8,183  | 25.2  |
Majority  | 6,414  | 19.8  |
Turnout | 32,481  | 66.4  |
| Unionist hold | Swing |  |

## References[edit]

1. ^ F W S Craig, British Parliamentary Election Results 1918–1949; Political Reference Publications, Glasgow 1949
2. ^ Debrett's House of Commons 1922
3. ^ ‘SMITH, Sir Allan (Macgregor)’, Who Was Who, A & C Black, an imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing plc, 1920–2007; online edn, Oxford University Press, Dec 2012 ; online edn, Oct 2012 accessed 16 Dec 2013
4. ^ Aberdeen Journal, 31 Oct 1919
5. ^ ‘HOULDER, Howard’, Who Was Who, A & C Black, an imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing plc, 1920–2007; online edn, Oxford University Press, Dec 2007 accessed 16 Dec 2013
6. ^ F W S Craig, British Parliamentary Election Results 1918-1949; Political Reference Publications, Glasgow 1949
7. ^ Hull Daily Mail, 27 Nov 1919
8. ^ F W S Craig, British Parliamentary Election Results 1918-1949; Political Reference Publications, Glasgow 1949

## See also[edit]

* List of United Kingdom by-elections
* United Kingdom by-election records

* v
* t
* e

« 30th Parliament « By-elections to the 31st Parliament of the United Kingdom » 32nd Parliament »

1919|

* February: Liverpool West Derby
* March: Leyton West
* North Londonderry
* Oxford University
* Hull Central
* April: Aberdeenshire and Kincardineshire Central
* May: East Antrim
* July: Swansea East
* Bothwell
* Dublin University
* August: Widnes
* September: Pontefract
* October: Manchester Rusholme
* November: Chester-le-Street
* Croydon South
* Isle of Thanet
* Plymouth Sutton
* December: St Albans
* Bromley
* Spen Valley

1920|

* January: Ashton-under-Lyne
* February: The Wrekin
* Paisley
* Horncastle
* March: Argyll
* Dartford
* Stockport
* Basingstoke
* Camberwell North West
* April: Northampton
* Edinburgh North
* Edinburgh South
* Sunderland
* June: Louth
* Nelson and Colne
* July: Ebbw Vale
* South Norfolk
* Woodbridge
* September: Ilford
* November: Hemel Hempstead
* The Wrekin
* Middleton and Prestwich
* December: Abertillery
* Rhondda West

1921|

* January: Hereford
* Dover
* February: Cardiganshire
* March: Woolwich East
* Dudley
* Birmingham Moseley
* Kirkcaldy Burghs
* Penistone
* Birmingham West
* April: Taunton
* Bristol West
* Glasgow Pollok
* East Dorset
* Bewdley
* Eddisbury
* Bedford
* Chichester
* May: Hastings
* Penrith and Cockermouth
* Abingdon
* Orkney and Shetland
* June: Belfast Duncairn
* Mid Armagh
* North Down
* West Down
* July: Mid Down
* Westminster St George's
* Heywood and Radcliffe
* Hertford
* August: Caerphilly
* Westminster Abbey
* South Londonderry
* September: Lewisham West
* Louth
* October: Westhoughton
* November: Hornsey
* December: Southwark South East

1922|

* January: Ludlow
* Tamworth
* South Londonderry
* February: West Down
* Manchester Clayton
* Camberwell North
* North Down
* Bodmin
* March: Wolverhampton West
* Liverpool Exchange
* Cambridge
* Inverness
* Chertsey
* Leicester East
* May: Clapham
* City of London
* June: North Londonderry
* Newbury
* Moray and Nairn
* Banbury
* Nottingham East
* July: Gower
* North Down
* Pontypridd
* August: Hackney South
* October: Newport

Lists of UK by-elections
1801–1806
1806–1818
1818–1832
1832–1847
1847–1857
1857–1868
1868–1885
1885–1900
1900–1918
1918–1931
1931–1950
1950–1979
1979–2010
2010–present
Northern Ireland
Hereditary peers
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template