1935 Hamilton, Ontario, municipal election

1935 Hamilton, Ontario municipal election

* * *

| <- 1934 | Monday, December 2, 1935 | 1936 ->

|
|

|  |  |  |

|
|
|

Candidate  | William Morrison | Septimus DuMoulin  | William Wardrope
Party  | Independent Conservative | Independent Conservative | Independent
Popular vote  | 12,910 | 9,069  | 7,883
Percentage  | 34.7% | 24.4%  | 21.2%

* * *

|  |
Candidate  | Edmund Goodfellow  | John Hunter
Party  | Independent | Communist
Popular vote  | 5,106  | 2,186
Percentage  | 13.7%  | 6%

* * *

| Mayor before election

Herbert Wilton
Independent Conservative

| Elected mayor

William Morrison
Independent Conservative

|

The 1935 Hamilton municipal election was held on December 2, 1935 to select one Mayor, four Controllers, and sixteen members of the Hamilton, Ontario, City Council, two from each of the city's eight wards. Voters also cast ballots for trustees for the public school board, and in three plebiscites that sought to restructure elections for both city council and the public school board.[1]

## Campaign

[edit]

The 1935 municipal campaign in Hamilton occurred at the height of the Great Depression, prompting municipal officials to consider cost-cutting measures in local government. In early November, 1935, Hamilton City Council began debating proposals to lengthen municipal campaigns and stagger elections so save on the cost of printing ballots and hiring polling workers.[2] James Berry, the city clerk, advised council members that increasing the length of a city council term could save taxpayers $9,000 a year in election-related costs.[3]

On Tuesday, November 5, council met to debate the matter. There was considerable confusion among members, who opted to submit a plebiscite question to the electorate asking if they were in favour of an increase in the term length for members of the Board of Control, city council, and school board from one year to two years. Almost immediately after passing the motion, the city's solicitor, A.J. Polson, informed Mayor Wilton that the motion was illegal, as it included wording regarding the Hamilton Board of Education. In passing this motion, it would have allowed supporters of Hamilton's Catholic School Board an opportunity to vote on the length of term of trustees for a school board other than the one they supported.[4] At a follow-up meeting, council determined it would be appropriate to split the plebiscite into three questions, asking voters if they wanted a two-year term, if they preferred a staggered election, and asking public school supporters if they wanted to bring trustee elections in line with council's two-year plan.

Despite having been elected to Parliament, outgoing mayor Herbert Wilton inserted himself into the municipal campaign, giving a speech in late November, 1935, railing against council members who found themselves unable to deal with the financial stresses placed upon the city by the economic crisis in the country. "You complain about high taxation," Wilton said, addressing Hamilton's electorate, "and then vote to elect men who have never been able to successfully manage their own financial affairs."[5] Wilton, a strong advocate for low taxes and classical liberal economic policy, implored voters to carefully manage municipal finances, which he referred to as a "$8,000,000 business concern."[5] Wilton also took aim at members of the Communist Party, who were seeking election in the city's working-class north-end. Wilton spoke passionately against the atheism of their members and the economic problems in the Soviet Union at the time. "They preach and teach the doctrine of hate, place their dead in graves without Christian burial, and deny the existence of God," he argued.[5]

The campaign was overtly partisan, with each political party's organization campaigning to elect candidates friendly to their platform. After the election, the Spectator declared that "Hamilton is still Tory Hamilton is the political affiliations of the new City Council may be taken as a criterion,"[6] Detailing the political affiliations of the members of council, the Spectator acknowledged that the mayor and 12 members of council were elected with the help of the local Conservative Party, five Liberals were returned, while Controller Nora-Frances Henderson and Ward 7 Alderman Donald Clark were members of the Reconstruction Party of Canada, with Ward 8 Alderman Agnes Sharpe serving as the only Cooperative Commonwealth Federation-affiliated member of council.[6]

In addition to the efforts of the organized federal parties, there was a clandestine 'ghost' slate supported by local teachers who advocated for the election of William Morrison, and Board of Control candidates Don McFarlane, Thomas Lewington, and Andy Frame. This was in response to the affiliated candidates promising to press the Hamilton Board of Education to reverse pay cuts imposed on teachers thanks to the city's worsening economic situation.[7]

## Mayor

[edit]

The mayoral race in 1935 was marked by incumbent mayor Herbert Wilton's election earlier that year to Parliament for the constituency of Hamilton West. Soon after his election, incumbent Controller Septimus DuMoulin and former Hamilton East MLA William Morrison, who had been unseated by Sam Lawrence a year earlier, both expressed an interest in contesting the mayoralty.[8]

The city's Cooperative Commonwealth Federation establishment, organized and energized by Sam Lawrence's election to the Ontario legislature, had originally entertained plans to run a candidate for mayor, though they opted to forego that strategy, instead aiming to put up at least one candidate for election to the Board of Control, city council, and the public school board.[9] The Liberal Party as well originally considered running local real estate agent F. Kent Hamilton for the office to challenge DuMoulin and Morrison, who were both heavily involved in local Conservative politics. They ultimately decided against this strategy.[10]

On nomination day, DuMoulin and Morrison were nominated, along with Communist Party candidate John Hunter, local baker Ed Goodfellow, and lawyer William H.W. Wardrope. In their nomination speeches, each candidate outlined core planks in their platform, with DuMoulin emphasizing his experience and a desire to see water-rates lowered, Goodfellow outlining a plan to reduce the city's debt, Wardrope advocating increasing taxes on the wealthy, Hunter proposing a graduated property tax with exemptions for those making less than $3,000 a year, and Morrison calling for a continuation of Wilton's program of keeping taxes and spending low.[11]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Mayoral Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| William Morrison | Independent Conservative | 12,910 | 34.7% |
| Septimus DuMoulin  | Independent Conservative | 9,069  | 24.4%  |
| William Wardrope  | Independent  | 7,883  | 21.2%  |
| Edmund Goodfellow  | Independent  | 5,106  | 13.7%  |
| John Hunter  | Communist | 2,186  | 6%  |
Total votes | 37,154  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Morrison is Swept into Mayor's Chair," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 5.

## Board of Control

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Board of Control Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Freeman Treleaven (incumbent) | Independent Liberal | 15,406 | 17.7% |
| Samuel Nelson | Independent Conservative | 14,939 | 17.2% |
| Nora-Frances Henderson (incumbent) | Independent Reconstructionist | 14,088 | 16.2% |
| Donald McFarlane | Independent Conservative | 12,747 | 14.65% |
| Andy Frame  | Independent | 11,628  | 13.37%  |
| John Mitchell  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 8,600  | 9.89%  |
| Thomas Lewington  | Independent | 11,628  | 9.4%  |
| Charles McCabe  | Independent | 7,197  | 8.78%  |
| George Jones  | Independent | 2,268  | 2.6%  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Controllers' Recapitulation," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.
"Conservative Majority in New City Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.

## Plebiscites

[edit]

Hamilton, Ontario Municipal Election
1935 Plebiscites

Question  |  Yes  | No
Votes | % | Votes | %
Are you in favour of electing members of Hamilton City Council to a term of two years? | 10,028 | 32.13% | 21,182 | 67.87%
Are you in favour of the Board of Control and aldermen being elected
so that one-half the number are elected for a term of two years, the mayor
to be elected for a term of two years? | 7,973 | 28.2% | 20,289 | 71.8%
Are you in favour of all the trustees of the Hamilton Board of Education being elected
for a term of two years? | 11,543 | 40.38% | 17,043 | 59.62%
Total votes |
Registered voters |
Sources: "Plan to Change Voting System Junked," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.

## Aldermen

[edit]

### Ward One

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Ward 1 Alderman Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| William McFarland (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 4,194 |  |
| Orville Walsh (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 2,951 |  |
| Charles Turner  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 996  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Recapitulation for the aldermen", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.
"Conservative Majority in New Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.

### Ward Two

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Ward 2 Alderman Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Beamer Hopkins | Independent Conservative | 2,184 |  |
| William Ainslie (incumbent) | Independent Liberal | 1,271 |  |
| James Phin  | Independent | 1,182  |  |
| Hugh Lennox  | Independent | 1,018  |  |
| Lawrence Gatenby  | Independent | 741  |  |
| Richard Griffith  | Independent | 583  |  |
| William Shaw  | Independent | 232  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Recapitulation for the aldermen", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.
"Conservative Majority in New Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.

### Ward Three

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Ward 3 Alderman Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Robert Evans (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 2,219 |  |
| Herbert Smye | Independent Conservative | 2,110 |  |
| William Fick (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 1,740  |  |
| Austin MacAuley  | Independent | 1,633  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Recapitulation for the aldermen", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.
"Conservative Majority in New Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.

### Ward Four

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Ward 4 Alderman Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| John Marsh | Independent Liberal | 1,647 |  |
| Peter McCulloch | Independent Liberal | 1,536 |  |
| George Hancock (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 1,298  |  |
| John Rowley  | Independent | 821  |  |
| Charles Pollicott  | Independent Labour Party | 647  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Recapitulation for the aldermen", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.
"Conservative Majority in New Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.

### Ward Five

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Ward 5 Alderman Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Thomas White (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 2,246 |  |
| Alexander Nelligan | Independent Conservative | 1,163 |  |
| Charles Aitchison  | Independent | 1,114  |  |
| John Sherring  | Independent | 693  |  |
| William Ronald  | Independent | 479  |  |
| John Rae  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 430  |  |
| Michael Hutchison  | Communist Party | 330  |  |
| Herbert Savage  | Independent | 124  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Recapitulation for the aldermen", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.
"Conservative Majority in New Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.

### Ward Six

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Ward 6 Alderman Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| William Weir (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 2,774 |  |
| John Hodgson (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 2,369 |  |
| Archie Pollock  | Independent | 2,058  |  |
| Frank Thomson  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 915  |  |
| Bruce Smith  | Communist Party | 383  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Recapitulation for the aldermen", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.
"Conservative Majority in New Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.

### Ward Seven

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Ward 7 Alderman Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Donald Clark | Independent Reconstructionist | 1,776 |  |
| Archie Burton (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 1,305 |  |
| Sam Clarke  | Independent | 1,256  |  |
| James Morris  | Independent | 1,170  |  |
| John Watson  | Independent | 628  |  |
| John Doyle  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 462  |  |
| James Newell  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 358  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Recapitulation for the aldermen", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.
"Conservative Majority in New Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.

### Ward Eight

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton, Ontario Ward 8 Alderman Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Agnes Sharpe (incumbent) | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 2,191 |  |
| Robert Elliott | Independent Conservative | 1,871 |  |
| George Snyder  | Independent | 1,630  |  |
| Roy Aindow  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 1,166  |  |
| Thomas Ellis  | Independent | 708  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Recapitulation for the aldermen", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.
"Conservative Majority in New Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.

## Board of education

[edit]

### Ward One

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton Board of Education Ward 1 Trustee Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Russell William Treleaven (incumbent) | Independent | Acclaimed  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Five School Trustees Are Not Opposed", Hamilton Spectator, November 22, 1935, pp. 7,17.

### Ward Two

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton Board of Education Ward 2 Trustee Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| George Tweedle Inch (incumbent) | Independent | Acclaimed  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Five School Trustees Are Not Opposed", Hamilton Spectator, November 22, 1935, pp. 7,17.

### Ward Three

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton Board of Education Ward 3 Trustee Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| S.B. Russell (incumbent) | Independent | Acclaimed  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Five School Trustees Are Not Opposed", Hamilton Spectator, November 22, 1935, pp. 7,17.

### Ward Four

[edit]

Summary of the December 5, 1927 Hamilton Board of Education Ward 4 Trustee Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| George R. Allan (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | Acclaimed  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Five School Trustees Are Not Opposed", Hamilton Spectator, November 22, 1935, pp. 7,17.

### Ward Five

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton Board of Education Ward 5 Trustee Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Humphrey Mitchell | Independent Liberal-Labour | Acclaimed  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Five School Trustees Are Not Opposed", Hamilton Spectator, November 22, 1935, pp. 7,17.

### Ward Six

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton Board of Education Ward 6 Trustee Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| George Henry Wild (incumbent) | Independent Conservative | 2,920 |  |
| John McGregor  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 1,739  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Five School Trustees Are Not Opposed", Hamilton Spectator, November 22, 1935, pp. 7,17.
"Recapitulation for School Trustees", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.

### Ward Seven

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton Board of Education Ward 7 Trustee Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Henry Bickel (incumbent) | Independent | 1,981 |  |
| Issac Armes  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 1,531  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Five School Trustees Are Not Opposed", Hamilton Spectator, November 22, 1935, pp. 7,17.
"Recapitulation for School Trustees", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.

### Ward Eight

[edit]

Summary of the December 2, 1935 Hamilton Board of Education Ward 8 Trustee Election  Candidate  | Affiliation  | Popular vote  |  Elected?

|
|
|

Votes  | %
| Goldwin Henry (incumbent) | Independent | 2,050 |  |
| Sara Doyle  | Cooperative Commonwealth Federation | 1,552  |  |
Total votes |  |
Registered voters |  |  |
Note: Candidate campaign colours are used as a visual differentiation between candidates and to indicate affiliation.
Sources: "Five School Trustees Are Not Opposed", Hamilton Spectator, November 22, 1935, pp. 7,17.
"Recapitulation for School Trustees", Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 15.

## References

[edit]

1. ^ "Hamilton Voters Choose New Council on Monday", Hamilton Spectator, Saturday, November 30, 1935, pp. 7, 10.
2. ^ "Will Submit Question at Municipal Election," Hamilton Spectator, November 2, 1935, pp. 7.
3. ^ "Council Will Approve of Plebiscite," Hamilton Spectator, November 5, 1935, pp. 7.
4. ^ "Council Toiled in Vain; New Meeting Must Be Held," Hamilton Spectator, November 6, 1935, pp. 7.
5. ^ a b c "'Don't Sink Municipal Ship with Load of Politics'", Return Sound Men to Council, Mayor Wilton Urges Hamilton's Electors," Hamilton Spectator, November 23, 1935, pp. 7.
6. ^ a b "Conservative Majority in New City Council," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.
7. ^ "'Ghost' Slate Will Be Allowed To Fade Out," Hamilton Spectator, December 3, 1935, pp. 7.
8. ^ "Another Addition is Made To Contestants For Board," Hamilton Spectator, November 2, 1935, pp. 7.
9. ^ "DuMoulin May Yet Be Given Mayor's Chair," Hamilton Spectator, November 5, 1935, pp. 7.
10. ^ "F. Kent Hamilton May Be Candidate," Hamilton Spectator, November 13, 1935, pp. 7.
11. ^ "Candidates Submit Their Platforms to Electors To-day", Hamilton Spectator, November 22, 1935, pp. 7,22.

* v
* t
* e

Municipal Elections in Hamilton, Ontario

One-year Terms
1847
1848
1849
1850
1851
1852
1853
1854
1855
1856
1857
1858
1859
1860
1861
1862
1863
1864
1865
1866
1867
1868
1869
1870
1871
1872
1873
1874
1875
1876
1877
1878
1879
1880
1881
1882
1883
1884
1885
1886
1887
1888
1889
1890
1891
1892
1893
1894
1895
1896
1897
1898
1899
1900
1901
1902
1903
1904
1905
1906
1907
1908
1909
1910
1911
1912
1913
1914
1915
1916
1917
1918
1919
1920
1921
1922
1923
January 1924
December 1924
1925
1926
1927
1928
1929
1930
1931
1932
1933
1934
1935
1936
1937
1938
1939
1940
1941
1942
1943
1944
1945
1946
1947
1948
1949
1950
1951
1952
1953

Two-year terms
1954
1956
1958
1960
1962
1964
1966
1968
1970
1972

Special election upon creation of the Region of Hamilton-Wentworth
1973

Reversion to two-year terms
1976
1978
1980

Three-year terms
1982
1985
1988
1991
1994
1997
2000
2003

Four-year terms
2006
2010
2014
2018
2022
2026
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template