1996 Charkhi Dadri mid-air collision

Fatal mid-air plane collision in India

Saudia Flight 763
Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907Accident

Date| 12 November 1996 (1996-11-12)
Summary| Mid-air collision
Site| Charkhi Dadri, Haryana, India
28°33′38″N 76°18′15″E﻿ / ﻿28.56056°N 76.30417°E﻿ / 28.56056; 76.30417
Total fatalities| 349
Total survivors| 0
First aircraft

HZ-AIH, the Boeing 747 involved, in 1986
Type| Boeing 747-168B
Operator| Saudi Arabian Airlines
IATA flight No.| SV763
ICAO flight No.| SVA763
Call sign| SAUDIA 763
Registration| HZ-AIH
Flight origin| Indira Gandhi International Airport, Delhi, India
Destination| Dhahran International Airport, Dhahran, Saudi Arabia
Occupants| 312
Passengers| 289
Crew| 23
Fatalities| 312
Survivors| 0
Second aircraft

UN-76435, the Ilyushin Il-76TD involved, in 1994
Type| Ilyushin Il-76TD
Operator| Kazakhstan Airlines
IATA flight No.| KZ1907
ICAO flight No.| KZA1907
Call sign| KAZAKH 1907
Registration| UN-76435
Flight origin| Chimkent Airport, Kazakhstan
Destination| Indira Gandhi International Airport, Delhi, India
Occupants| 37
Passengers| 27
Crew| 10
Fatalities| 37
Survivors| 0

On 12 November 1996, Saudia Flight 763, a Boeing 747 en route from Delhi, India, to Dhahran, Saudi Arabia, and Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907, an Ilyushin Il-76 en route from Chimkent, Kazakhstan, to Delhi, collided over the city of Charkhi Dadri, around 100 km (62 mi; 54 nmi) west of Delhi. The crash killed all 349 people on board both planes, making it the world's deadliest mid-air collision[1][2] and the deadliest aviation accident ever in India.[3][4] The final report from the investigation found that "[T]he root and approximate cause of the collision" was the failure of the Kazakh crew to maintain the correct altitude.[5] Contributing factors included the poor English language skills in the Kazakh cockpit resulting in inadequate interpretation of directions provided by air traffic control, and three specific incidents of failures in crew resource management (CRM) by the Kazakh crew.[6] The report also suggested technical enhancements (including ACAS and SSR) that would provide assistance in preventing a future crew's mistakes being allowed to go unchecked in real time.[7]

## Aircraft involved

[edit]

### Saudi Arabian Airlines Flight 763

[edit]

Saudi Arabian Airlines Flight 763 was a Boeing 747-168B, registration HZ-AIH, departing from Delhi as part of a scheduled international Delhi–Dhahran–Jeddah passenger service with 312 people on board.[8] The crew on this flight consisted of Captain Khalid al-Shubaily (aged 44), First Officer Nazir Khan (aged 37), and Flight Engineer Ahmed Edrees (aged 33). Al-Shubaily was a veteran pilot with 9,837 flying hours.[9]

There is some dispute as to the nationalities of the passengers of Flight 763. According to an article published on 14 November 1996, 215 Indians, many of whom worked in Saudi Arabia as blue-collar workers, boarded the flight, along with 40 Nepalis and three Americans.[10] However, according to a different article, the passenger manifest included 17 people of other nationalities, including nine Nepalis, three Pakistanis, two Americans, one Bangladeshi, one British, and one Saudi Arabian.[4] Twelve of the crew members, including five anti-terrorism officials, were Saudi Arabian citizens.[11]

### Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907

[edit]

Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907, an Ilyushin Il-76TD with registration UN-76435 was on a charter service from Chimkent Airport to Delhi. The crew consisted of Captain Alexander Robertovich Cherepanov (aged 44), First Officer Ermek Kozhahmetovich Dzhangirov (aged 37), Flight Engineer Alexander Alexanderovich Chuprov (aged 50), Navigator Zhahanbek Duisenovich Aripbaev (aged 51), and Radio Operator Egor Alekseevich Repp (aged 41).[12][9] Cherepanov was highly experienced, with 9,229 flight hours.[13]

A company from Kyrgyzstan chartered the flight, and the passenger manifest mostly included ethnic Russian Kyrgyz citizens planning to go shopping in India.[4][12][10] Thirteen Kyrgyz traders boarded the flight.[11]

## Accident

[edit]

Saudia Flight 763 departed Delhi at 18:32 local time (13:02 UTC). Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907 was descending simultaneously, to land at Delhi.[8] Both flights were controlled by approach controller V.K. Dutta.[9] Immediately after take-off, the Saudia flight was cleared to an initial altitude of 10,000 feet (3,050 m). At 18:34, Dutta cleared the Kazakh plane to descend to 15,000 feet (4,550 m) when it was 74 nautical miles (137 km) from the beacon of the destination airport. Two minutes later, at 18:36, Dutta cleared the Saudia plane, travelling on the same airway but in the opposite direction, to climb to 14,000 feet (4,250 m). At 18:38, the SVA crew reported reaching 14,000 feet, and requested a higher level. Dutta told them to hold their altitude and standby, to which First Officer Khan replied, "Saudi 763 will maintain one four zero."[9]

At 18:39, the Kazakh flight reported having reached its assigned altitude of 15,000 feet, but it was actually higher, at 16,348 feet (5,000 m), and still descending.[14][9] At this time, Dutta advised the flight, "Identified traffic 12 O'Clock, reciprocal, Saudia Boeing 747 at ten miles, likely to cross in another five miles. Report, if in sight."[9] Radio Operator Repp requested clarification, to which Dutta replied, "Traffic...is at eight miles, level 140."[9] Repp acknowledged the update, and signed off with, "Now looking 1907."[9]

Less than a minute later, at 18:40, the crew of a United States Air Force cargo flight made a radio call saying they had seen "a big explosion" at their two o'clock position.[9] Dutta attempted to contact the Saudia and Kazakh flights, but received no response. The two aircraft had collided, with the left wing of the Kazakh flight slicing through the left wing of the Saudia 747 while the left horizontal stabilizer of the 747 sliced off the vertical stabilizer (including the horizontal stabilizer) of the Kazakh flight.[citation needed] The crippled Saudi Boeing immediately lost control and went into a rapidly descending spiral with fire trailing from the wing, and broke up mid-air before crashing to the ground at a nearly supersonic speed of 1,135 km/h (613 kn; 705 mph). With most of its left wing and vertical stabilizer gone, the Ilyushin went into a flat spin and crashed into a field at a flat attitude near the wreckage of the Saudia plane. All 312 people on board SVA763 and all 37 people on Flight 1907 were killed.[15]

The recorder of the Saudi Arabian plane revealed the pilots said the Islamic Istighfar (forgiveness prayer) and recited the Shahada before impact with the ground.[9]

The collision took place about 100 kilometres (60 mi) west of Delhi.[16] The wreckage of the Saudi Arabian aircraft landed near Dhani village, Bhiwani District, Haryana. The wreckage of the Kazakh aircraft hit the ground near Birohar village, Rohtak District, Haryana.[13]

## Investigation and final report

[edit]

The crash was investigated by the Lahoti Commission, headed by then-Delhi High Court judge Ramesh Chandra Lahoti. Depositions were taken from the Air Traffic Controllers Guild and the two airlines. The flight data recorders (FDR) were decoded by Kazakhstan Airlines and Saudia under the supervision of air crash investigators in Moscow and Farnborough, England, respectively.[17] The ultimate cause was held to be the failure of Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907's pilot to follow ATC instructions, whether due to cloud turbulence or due to communication problems.[9][18][19]

The commission determined that the accident had been the fault of the Kazakhstani Il-76 crew, who (according to FDR evidence) had descended from the assigned altitude of 15,000 to 14,500 feet (4,550 to 4,400 m) and subsequently 14,000 feet (4,250 m) and even lower. The report ascribed the cause of this serious breach in operating procedure to the lack of English language skills on the part of the Kazakhstan aircraft pilots; they were relying entirely on Radio Operator Repp for communications with the ATC. As part of this, the report suggested that First Officer Dzhangirov (and possibly Captain Cherepanov) might have misunderstood Dutta's final radio call, and assumed that the Saudi 747's altitude (14,000 feet) was their own assigned altitude.[9] Indian air controllers also complained that the Kazakhstani pilots sometimes confused their calculations because they are accustomed to using metre altitudes and kilometre distances, while most other countries use feet and nautical miles respectively for aerial navigation.[20] Although the crew in this particular collision did not appear to have made a computational error, Kazakhstan Airlines did not have enough foot-marked altimeters for all crewmembers. Repp did not have his own flight instrumentation and had to look over the pilots' shoulders for a reading, which likely limited his own situational awareness.[21]

Kazakh officials found such a misunderstanding implausible, because their records showed Dzhangirov sufficiently fluent to teach English to other Kazakh pilots at the time. Instead, they concluded - from the Kazakhstani plane's misleading flight data records - that the aircraft had descended while their pilots were battling turbulence inside a bank of cumulus clouds.[9][18] Meteorological reports,[21] the affidavits of a Lockheed C-141B Starlifter crew that observed the crash,[17][22] and conclusive analysis by the investigators - showing that the specific flight data record the Kazakh officials focused on proved only that the record was based on faulty recording equipment on the plane[23] - disproved the Kazakh theory that turbulence was to blame.

However, whether or not particular crewmembers fully understood the radio transmissions or were distracted by atmospheric conditions, the five-person crew was sufficiently large that it likely struggled to maintain common situational awareness and coordinate crew actions.

Just a few seconds before impact, Repp had realised that the pilots were flying below the required 15,000 feet and brought it to their attention. Cherepanov gave orders for full throttle, and the plane climbed, only to hit the oncoming Saudi Arabian plane. The tail of the Kazakhstani plane clipped the left wing of the Saudi Arabian jet, severing both parts from their respective planes.

Furthermore, the investigation noted that Indira Gandhi International Airport did not have secondary surveillance radar, which provides extra information, such as the aircraft's identity and altitude, by reading transponder signals; instead the airport had a primary radar, which produces readings of distance and bearing, but not altitude. In addition, departures and arrivals both shared a single corridor within the civilian airspace around New Delhi. While most areas have separate corridors: one for departures and another one for arrivals, the airspace of Delhi in 1996 had only one civilian corridor for both departures and arrivals, because much of the airspace was taken by the Indian Air Force.[17]

Due to the crash, the air-crash investigation report recommended changes to air-traffic procedures and infrastructure in New Delhi's air-space:[9]

* Separation of inbound and outbound aircraft through the creation of 'air corridors'
* Installation of a secondary air-traffic control radar for aircraft altitude data
* Mandatory collision avoidance equipment on commercial aircraft operating in Indian airspace
* Reduction of the airspace over New Delhi that was formerly under exclusive control of the Indian Air Force

## Aftermath

[edit]

The Directorate General of Civil Aviation subsequently made it mandatory for all aircraft flying in and out of India to be equipped with an airborne collision avoidance system. This set a worldwide precedent for mandatory use of traffic collision avoidance system.[24]

As of 2021[update], there is an ongoing effort by the Charkhi Dadri district administration to develop a memorial honoring the victims of the mid-air collision. The proposed memorial, which would consist of names and other information of the victims, would be located at a to-be built memorial-park in the district. However, the district administration is waiting to get an approval for the project from the Haryana government, and plans to include the participation of Ministry of Civil Aviation of India, Airport Authority of India, and embassies of Saudi Arabia and Kazakhstan in the development of the memorial.[25]

## Documentaries

[edit]

Miditech, a company based in Gurugram, Haryana, produced a documentary about the disaster called Head On!, which aired on the National Geographic Channel.[17]

The collision was also the subject of the 2009 episode "Sight Unseen", of the Canadian-made, internationally distributed documentary series Mayday.[23]

## See also

[edit]

* List of accidents and incidents involving airliners by airline

## References

[edit]

### Citations

[edit]

1. ^ Cooper, Kenneth J. (13 November 1996). "At Least 349 Are Killed in Collision". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 26 June 2013.
2. ^ Ashraf, Syed Firdaus. "Charkhi Dadri collision report expected this weekend". Rediff. New Delhi. Archived from the original on 10 April 2014.
3. ^ "India air safety profile". Aviation Safety Network. Retrieved 10 April 2014.
4. ^ a b c Burns, John F. (13 November 1996). "Two Airliners Collide in Midair, Killing All 351 Aboard in India". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 6 March 2014.
5. ^ Lahoti 1997, p. VII
6. ^ Lahoti 1997, p. VII
7. ^ Lahoti 1997, pp. VIII, XIII
8. ^ a b Kingsley-Jones, Max; Learmount, David (20 September 1996). "Collision raises doubts on ATC routeings". Flightglobal. Flight International. Archived from the original on 1 January 2015.
9. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n Lahoti 1997
10. ^ a b Burns, John F. (14 November 1996). "Indian Officials Gather Evidence on Midair Collision". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 3 January 2015.
11. ^ a b "Pilot error focus of India collision investigation". New Delhi: CNN. 14 November 1996. Archived from the original on 28 January 2000.
12. ^ a b Burns, John F. (5 May 1997). "One Jet in Crash Over India Ruled Off Course". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 3 March 2018.
13. ^ a b Civil aviation aircraft accident summary for the year 1996 (PDF) (Report). Directorate General of Civil Aviation. p. 8/18. Archived from the original (PDF) on 3 January 2015.
14. ^ Accident description for Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907 at the Aviation Safety Network
15. ^ Job, Macarthur (November–December 2006), "Mid-Air Disasters" (PDF), Flight Safety Australia, p. 42, archived from the original (PDF) on 30 October 2008, retrieved 10 September 2009
16. ^ Bellamy, Christopher (13 November 1996). "Human error is blamed for crash". The Independent. Archived from the original on 26 February 2014.
17. ^ a b c d Head On – AirCrash (TV documentary). Miditech. Archived from the original on 23 March 2007.
18. ^ a b "Kazakh aircraft held responsible for Charkhi Dadri mishap". rediff.com. 1997. Archived from the original on 23 May 2020.
19. ^ Morris, Hugh (12 July 2017). "The truth behind the 10 deadliest plane crashes of all time". The Daily Telegraph. London. Archived from the original on 23 May 2020.
20. ^ McGirk, Tim (14 November 1996). "THE INDIAN AIR CRASH: Tapes point blame at Kazakh pilot". The Independent. Archived from the original on 1 May 2019.
21. ^ a b "Communication gap caused Charkhi Dadri mishap". Rediff. 26 May 1997. Archived from the original on 7 October 1999. Retrieved 4 July 2006.
22. ^ "Charkhi Dadri collision occurred in "heavy clouds": US pilot". Rediff. Archived from the original on 11 October 1999. Retrieved 4 July 2006.
23. ^ a b "Sight Unseen". Mayday. Season 7. Episode 4. Montreal: Cineflix. 11 November 2009. Discovery Channel Canada et al.
24. ^ "History & future of airborne collision avoidance". Eurocontrol. 9 March 2012. Archived from the original on 4 February 2018. Retrieved 6 May 2019.
25. ^ "Haryana's Charkhi Dadri plans a memorial for 1996 mid-air collision victims". The Times of India. 4 March 2021. Archived from the original on 18 February 2024.

### Further reading

[edit]

* Lahoti, Ramesh Chandra (15 July 1997). Report of Court of Inquiry on Mid-Air Collision Between Saudi Arabian Boeing 747 and Kazakhstan IL-76 on 12th November, 1996 Near Delhi – India (Charkhi-Dadri, Haryana) (Report). Directorate General of Civil Aviation, Ministry of Civil Aviation. Archived from the original (PDF) on 25 May 2020. Retrieved 25 May 2020.
* Anas al-Qawz [ar]. A Pilot's Encounters [ar]. Obeikan, 2000. (in Arabic): Book by a Saudi pilot which discusses this incident
* Bhavya Dore. "Collision". Fifty Two. 9 October 2020.
* "Pilot error focus of India collision investigation" (Archive). CNN. 14 November 1996.

## External links

[edit]

External image

Pre-Crash photos of the two airliners at Airliners.net

* Directorate General of Civil Aviation OPERATIONS CIRCULAR NO.3 OF 1999 (Archived 24 February 2012 at the Wayback Machine)
* "Officials say hundreds feared killed in airline collision over India" (Archive). CNN. 12 November 1996.
* Burns, John F. "Indian and Kazak Officials Trade Accusations in Air Collision." The New York Times. 15 November 1996.
* Centre for Disaster Management (Haryana Institute of Public Administration) Case Study: Charkhi Dadri Mid Air Collision
* Victims, crash site of the mid-air collision from Associated Press Archive

Portals:

* Aviation
* India
* Saudi Arabia
* Asia
* 1990s

* v
* t
* e

Aviation accidents and incidents in India

1950s|

* BOAC Flight 783 (May 1953)
* Dan-Air Avro York crash (May 1958)

1960s|

* Alitalia Flight 771 (July 1962)
* United Arab Airlines Flight 869 (July 1963)
* Poonch IAF helicopter crash (November 1963)
* Gujarat Beechcraft incident (September 1965)
* Indian Air Force An-32 crash (February 1968)
* Garuda Indonesian Airways Flight 892 (May 1968)

1970s|

* Indian Airlines hijacking (January 1971)
* Japan Air Lines Flight 471 (June 1972)
* Japan Air Lines Flight 472 (September 1972)
* Indian Airlines Flight 440 (May 1973)
* 1973 Royal Nepal Airlines DHC-6 hijacking (June 1973)
* Indian Airlines Flight 171 (January 1976)
* Air India Flight 855 (January 1978)
* Indian Airlines Flight 403 (17 December 1978)
* Indian Airlines Flight 410 (20 December 1978)

1980s|

* Indian Airlines Flight 423 (September 1981)
* Air India Flight 403 (June 1982)
* Indian Airlines Flight 405 (July 1984)
* Indian Airlines Flight 421 (August 1984)
* Indian Air Force An-32 disappearance (March 1986)
* Pan Am Flight 73 (September 1986)
* Indian Airlines Flight 113 (October 1988)

1990s|

* Indian Airlines Flight 605 (February 1990)
* Indian Airlines Flight 257 (August 1991)
* Indian Airlines Flight 427 (April 1993)
* Indian Airlines Flight 491 (April 1993)
* Indira Gandhi Airport collision (March 1994)
* Charkhi Dadri mid-air collision (November 1996)
* Indian Airlines Flight 503 (July 1998)
* 1999 Pakistani Breguet 1150 Atlantic shootdown (August 1999)
* Indian Airlines Flight 814 (December 1999)

2000s|

* Alliance Air Flight 7412 (July 2000)
* Jalandhar MiG-21 crash (May 2002)
* Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister helicopter crash (September 2009)

2010s|

* Air India Express Flight 812 (May 2010)
* Pawan Hans Mi-17 crash (April 2011)
* 2015 Indian Border Security Force King Air crash (December 2015)
* Indian Air Force An-32 crash (July 2016)
* UY Aviation King Air C90 crash (June 2018)
* Indian Air Force An-32 crash (June 2019)

2020s|

* Air India Express Flight 1344 (August 2020)
* Indian Air Force Mil Mi-17 crash (December 2021)
* Chetak helicopter crash at INS Garuda (November 2023)

* v
* t
* e

Aviation accidents and incidents in 1996 (1996)

Jan 8

Air Africa crash

Feb 4

LAC Colombia Flight 028

Feb 6

Birgenair Flight 301

Feb 29

Faucett Perú Flight 251

Apr 3

USAF CT-43 crash

Apr 5

Formosa Airlines Flight 7613

May 11

ValuJet Flight 592

Jun 9

Eastwind Airlines Flight 517

Jun 13

Garuda Indonesia Flight 865

Jul 6

Delta Air Lines Flight 1288

Jul 15

Belgian Air Force Hercules crash

Jul 17

TWA Flight 800

Aug 16

Airstan incident

Aug 19

Spair Airlines Flight 3601

Aug 29

Vnukovo Airlines Flight 2801

Sep 3

Hemus Air Flight 7081

Sep 5

FedEx Express Flight 1406

Sep 25

Texel Douglas DC-3 crash

Oct 2

Aeroperú Flight 603

Oct 5

Westendorff UFO sighting

Oct 19

Delta Air Lines Flight 554

Oct 22

Millon Air Flight 406

Oct 31

TAM Transportes Aéreos Regionais Flight 402

Nov 7

ADC Airlines Flight 086

Nov 12

Charkhi Dadri mid-air collision

Nov 19

Quincy Airport disaster

Nov 23

Ethiopian Airlines Flight 961

Nov 27

Abakan Ilyushin Il-76 crash

Dec 9

Dirgantara Air Service Flight 5940

Dec 22

Airborne Express Flight 827

Dec 24

New Hampshire Learjet crash

1995  ◄ ► 1997
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template