2006 Blaenau Gwent by-elections

Two parliamentary by-elections in South Wales in 2006

Two by-elections were held for the constituency of Blaenau Gwent in Wales following the death of Member of Parliament and Assembly Member Peter Law on 25 April 2006. As Law was the MP and Assembly Member (AM), his death required by-elections in both the parliamentary seat and the equivalent Welsh Assembly constituency. The two elections polled on the same day, 29 June, as a by-election in Bromley and Chislehurst. A win by the Labour Party in the AM by-election would have restored their majority in the Welsh Assembly, which was lost when Law was expelled from the party.[1]

Law's successors won both seats: the independent Dai Davies, Law's former election agent, won the Westminster seat with a majority of about two and a half thousand. He was the first independent to hold a seat previously occupied by an independent since Sir Charles Vere Ferrers Townshend held The Wrekin in 1920. Meanwhile, Law's widow, Trish Law, was elected to her husband's former seat in the Welsh Assembly.

## Westminster by-election

[edit]

2006 Blaenau Gwent by-election

* * *

| <- 2005 | 29 June 2006 | 2010 ->

|
|

* * *

The Blaenau Gwent seat in the UK House of Commons.
Triggered by death of incumbent
Turnout| 50.5% (15.6%)
|  | First party  | Second party

|
|

Candidate  | Dai Davies | Owen Smith
Party  | Blaenau Gwent PV | Labour
Popular vote  | 12,543 | 10,055
Percentage  | 46.7 | 37.0
Swing  | 11.5%*  | 4.7%

* * *

| Third party  | Fourth party

Candidate  | Steffan Lewis | Amy Kitcher
Party  | Plaid Cymru | Liberal Democrats
Popular vote  | 1,755  | 1,477
Percentage  | 6.5  | 5.4
Swing  | 4.1%  | 1.1%

* * *

| MP before election

Peter Law
Independent

| Subsequent MP

Dai Davies
Independent

|

The writ for the UK Parliament by-election was moved on 6 June so that it would be held on the same date as the Assembly by-election, (29 June 2006).[2] Labour whips had reportedly pressed for the election to be held on 25 May. The movement of the writ was more complicated because Law sat as an Independent, and therefore the convention that the party of the former member moves the writ cannot apply.[3] According to the precedent (when Dennis Canavan resigned his Parliamentary seat at Westminster as an Independent), the whip of the governing party moves the writ.

### Candidates

[edit]

Maggie Jones, the Labour candidate who had been defeated by Law at the 2005 general election, was not able to stand, because she had been elevated to the House of Lords.[4] There had been speculation about an independent candidate running with the backing of the Conservatives, Liberal Democrats and Plaid Cymru, but all three parties decided to contest the election.[1]

It had been reported that prior to Law's death that the Labour Party had decided against selecting their candidate for the next general election with an all-women shortlist.[5] It was the use of such a shortlist for the 2005 general election that led to Law standing as an independent. Labour instead left the selection to the local party.[6] The Labour candidate, Owen Smith, was chosen on 8 May.[7][8] He was a former special adviser and BBC producer who worked for a pharmaceutical company.[9] After losing this by-election, Smith went on to become MP for Pontypridd at the 2010 general election, and in 2016 launched an unsuccessful campaign to lead the Labour party, remaining in Parliament until the 2019 general election.

The Liberal Democrat candidate was Amy Kitcher. The Conservatives stood Margrit Williams, who worked for Sir Malcolm Rifkind.[9] Dai Davies, Peter Law's former agent, stood as an independent with the support of the Blaenau Gwent People's Voice Group.[10]

Despite contesting both the previous Assembly and Parliamentary elections, the United Kingdom Independence Party decided not to stand a candidate, instead calling for a vote for the Blaenau Gwent People's Voice Group - even though the Group does not support withdrawal from the European Union, nor the abolition of the Welsh Assembly, key UKIP policies.[11]

The Conservative fifth place was their worst position in a UK mainland by-election since at least 1945.

### Result

[edit]

Blaenau Gwent by-election, 2006[12] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

| Blaenau Gwent PV | Dai Davies | 12,543  | 46.7  | −11.5
| Labour | Owen Smith | 10,055  | 37.0  | +4.7
| Plaid Cymru | Steffan Lewis | 1,755  | 6.5  | +4.1
| Liberal Democrats | Amy Kitcher  | 1,477  | 5.4  | +1.1
| Conservative | Margrit Williams  | 1,013  | 3.7  | +1.3
| Monster Raving Loony | Alan "Howling Laud" Hope | 318  | 1.2  | N/A
Majority | 2,488  | 9.7  | −16.2
Turnout | 27,161  | 50.5  | −15.6
Registered electors | 52,512  |  |
| Blaenau Gwent PV hold | Swing | −8.4  |

### Previous result

[edit]

The 2005 general election result, in the election for the Parliamentary seat, was a gain for Peter Law as an independent candidate.

General election 2005: Blaenau Gwent[13] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

| Independent | Peter Law | 20,505  | 58.2  | +58.2
| Labour | Maggie Jones | 11,384  | 32.3  | −39.7
| Liberal Democrats | Brian Thomas  | 1,511  | 4.3  | −5.0
| Plaid Cymru | John Price  | 843  | 2.4  | −8.8
| Conservative | Phillip Lee  | 816  | 2.4  | −5.2
| UKIP | Peter Osborne  | 192  | 0.5  | +0.5
Majority | 9,121  | 25.9  | N/A
Turnout | 35,251  | 66.1  | +6.6
Registered electors | 53,301  |  |
| Independent gain from Labour | Swing | +48.9  |

## Welsh Assembly by-election

[edit]

2006 Blaenau Gwent by-election

* * *

| <- 2003 | 29 June 2006 | 2007 ->

|
|

* * *

The Blaenau Gwent seat in the National Assembly for Wales.
Triggered by death of incumbent
Turnout| 49.6% (12.2%)
|  | First party  | Second party  | Third party

|
|
|

Lab

Candidate  | Trish Law | John Hopkins  | Steve Bard
Party  | Independent | Labour | Liberal Democrats
Popular vote  | 13,785 | 9,321  | 2,054
Percentage  | 50.3 | 34.0  | 6.5
Swing  | N/A | 36.2%  | 3.4%

* * *

| AM before election

Peter Law
Independent

| Subsequent AM

Trish Law
Independent

|

The Assembly by-election had to be held within twelve weeks of the vacancy arising.[3] It was announced on 11 May 2006 that the Assembly by-election would be held on 29 June.[2]

### Candidates

[edit]

Labour chose John Hopkins, who had already been selected as their 2007 Assembly election candidate, to contest the seat. John Price stood for Plaid Cymru.[1] The Liberal Democrats fielded Steve Bard, a councillor in Abertillery.[7] The Conservative candidate was Jonathan Burns, a Cardiff councillor.[9] Peter Law's widow, Trish Law, stood as an independent backed by the Blaenau Gwent People's Voice Group.[10]

The Green Party fought the Assembly election but did not stand at Westminster.[14]

### Result

[edit]

Blaenau Gwent Welsh Assembly by-election[15] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

| Independent | Trish Law | 13,785  | 50.3  | N/A
| Labour | John Hopkins  | 9,321  | 34.0  | −36.2
| Liberal Democrats | Steve Bard  | 2,054  | 7.5  | −3.4
| Plaid Cymru | John Price  | 1,109  | 4.0  | −5.6
| Conservative | Jonathan Burns  | 816  | 3.0  | −2.7
| Green | John Matthews  | 302  | 1.1  | N/A
Majority | 4,464  | 16.3  | N/A
Turnout | 27,387  | 49.6  | +12.2
Registered electors | 52,900  |  |
| Independent gain from Labour | Swing | +43.3  |

### Previous result

[edit]

In 2003, Peter Law was re-elected as the Labour Assembly member for the Blaenau Gwent constituency. By announcing that he would stand as an Independent for the parliamentary constituency he expelled himself from the Labour Party (and the Labour Assembly grouping).

Welsh Assembly Election 2003: Blaenau Gwent[16] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

| Labour | Peter Law | 13,884  | 70.2  | +9.4
| Liberal Democrats | Steve Bard  | 2,148  | 10.9  | −0.6
| Plaid Cymru | Rhys Ab Elis  | 1,889  | 9.6  | −11.6
| Conservative | Barrie O'Keefe  | 1,131  | 5.7  | +0.2
| UKIP | Roger Thomas  | 719  | 3.6  | +3.6
Majority | 11,736  | 59.4  | +18.7
Turnout | 19,771  | 37.4  | −10.7
| Labour hold | Swing |  |
Registered electors | 52,927  |  |

## Electorate and campaign timetables

[edit]

The electorate for the constituency was 52,900 as quoted by the Returning Officer's Department of Blaenau Gwent Borough Council on 14 May 2006 (-0.75% on the Westminster election and -0.05% on the Assembly election). The close of nominations for the Assembly constituency was on 2 June and for the Westminster seat 14 June.

## Campaigns

[edit]

On 27 April 2006, BBC News published allegations by Peter Law's widow that Law had believed he would be in line for a peerage should he decide not to stand in the 2005 general election. The Labour Party denied that a peerage was offered.[6]

Welsh Secretary Peter Hain attempted to build bridges with Law's supporters by apologising for imposing an all-women shortlist and suggesting that those expelled from the Labour Party might be able to rejoin. This apology was rejected by Dai Davies, Peter Law's agent and putative successor, as coming too late and being a cynical ploy to try to win the by-elections.[7]

## Opinion polls

[edit]

An opinion poll was conducted by GfK NOP between 24 May and 28 May, which asked 1,000 voters in the constituency how they would vote. The results were:

### Westminster

[edit]

House of Commons seat poll

Party  | Candidate  | %
| Labour | Owen Smith  | 47%
| Independent | Dai Davies | 35%
| Liberal Democrats | Amy Kitcher  | 6%
| Plaid Cymru | Steffan Lewis  | 6%
| Conservative | Margrit Williams  | 5%

### Assembly

[edit]

Welsh Assembly seat poll

Party  | Candidate  | %
| Independent | Trish Law  | 43%
| Labour | John Hopkins  | 40%
| Plaid Cymru | John Price  | 6%
| Liberal Democrats | Steve Bard  | 6%
| Conservative | Jonathan Burns  | 3%
| Green | John Matthews  | 2%

## See also

[edit]

* List of United Kingdom by-elections (1979–2010)
* Blaenau Gwent

## References

[edit]

1. ^ a b c "Double poll looming in Law seat". BBC News. 26 April 2006. Retrieved 26 April 2006.
2. ^ a b "Blaenau Gwent election date set". BBC. 11 May 2006. Retrieved 11 May 2006.
3. ^ a b Shipton, Martin (26 April 2006). "Outrage at bid for early by-election". Western Mail. Retrieved 26 April 2006.
4. ^ "Losing candidate will become peer". BBC News. 11 April 2006. Retrieved 26 April 2006.
5. ^ "Peter Law, rebel who had a cause". BBC News. 25 April 2006. Retrieved 27 April 2006.
6. ^ a b "MP 'offered peerage' not to stand". BBC News. 27 April 2006. Retrieved 27 April 2006.
7. ^ a b c "All-women list apology rejected". BBC News. 8 May 2006. Retrieved 8 May 2006.
8. ^ "Viagra-firm lobbyist to stand for Labour in Blaenau Gwent". icWales. 9 May 2006. Retrieved 9 May 2006.
9. ^ a b c "Parties pick by-election hopefuls". BBC News. 9 May 2006. Retrieved 9 May 2006.
10. ^ a b "Widow gets People's Voice backing". BBC News. 16 May 2006. Retrieved 16 May 2006.
11. ^ "UKIP Annnouces [sic] that it will not stand in Blaenau Gwent by-election". United Kingdom Independence Party. 17 May 2006. Archived from the original on 16 September 2006. Retrieved 2006-06-09.
12. ^ Boothroyd, David. "Results of Byelections in the 2005-2010 Parliament". United Kingdom Election Results. Archived from the original on 27 December 2015. Retrieved 5 October 2015.
13. ^ "Election 2005, Result: Blaenau Gwent". BBC. 6 May 2005. Retrieved 31 January 2015.
14. ^ "By-Elections". by_elections.blogspot.com.
15. ^ "By-Election 2006, Result: Blaenau Gwent". Wales National Assembly. 29 June 2006. Retrieved 1 January 2020.
16. ^ "Election 2003, Result: Blaenau Gwent". BBC. 6 May 2005. Retrieved 1 January 2020.

## External links

[edit]

* Peter Law Campaign literature from the 2005 general election
* Campaign literature from the 2006 Parliamentary by-election
* Campaign literature from the 2006 Welsh Assembly by-election
* Blaenau Gwent Liberal Democrats

* v
* t
* e

« 53rd Parliament « By-elections to the 54th Parliament of the United Kingdom » 55th Parliament »

2005|

* July: Cheadle
* September: Livingston

2006|

* February: Dunfermline and West Fife
* June: Blaenau Gwent
* Bromley and Chislehurst

2007|

* July: Ealing Southall
* Sedgefield

2008|

* May: Crewe and Nantwich
* June: Henley
* July: Haltemprice and Howden
* Glasgow East
* November: Glenrothes

2009|

* July: Norwich North
* November: Glasgow North East

Lists of UK by-elections
1801–1806
1806–1818
1818–1832
1832–1847
1847–1857
1857–1868
1868–1885
1885–1900
1900–1918
1918–1931
1931–1950
1950–1979
1979–2010
2010–present
Northern Ireland
Hereditary peers

* v
* t
* e

« 1900–1949 « By-elections in Wales to the House of Commons of the United Kingdom 1950–present

1950s|

* November 1950: Abertillery
* October 1954: Aberdare
* March 1955: Wrexham
* July 1956: Newport
* February 1957: Carmarthen
* November 1958: Pontypool

1960s|

* November 1960: Ebbw Vale
* May 1962: Montgomeryshire
* March 1963: Swansea East
* April 1965: Abertillery
* July 1966: Carmarthen
* March 1967: Rhondda West
* July 1968: Caerphilly

1970s|

* April 1972: Merthyr Tydfil

1980s|

* September 1982: Gower
* May 1984: Cynon Valley
* July 1985: Brecon and Radnor
* February 1989: Pontypridd
* May 1989: Vale of Glamorgan

1990s|

* April 1991: Neath
* May 1991: Monmouth
* February 1995: Islwyn

2000s|

* February 2000: Ceredigion
* February 2002: Ogmore
* June 2006: Blaenau Gwent

2010s|

* November 2012: Cardiff South and Penarth
* May 2016: Ogmore
* April 2019: Newport West
* August 2019: Brecon and Radnorshire

* Politics portal
* United Kingdom portal
* Wales portal

* * *

Lists of UK by-elections
1801–1806
1806–1818
1818–1832
1832–1847
1847–1857
1857–1868
1868–1885
1885–1900
1900–1918
1918–1931
1931–1950
1950–1979
1979–2010
2010–present
Northern Ireland
Hereditary peers

* v
* t
* e

By-elections to the Senedd

1st|

* 2001: Swansea East

2nd|

* 2006: Blaenau Gwent

3rd|

* None

4th|

* 2013: Ynys Môn

5th|

* 2018: Alyn and Deeside

6th|

* None

Regional member changes
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template