2013 Miranda state by-election

By-election in New South Wales, Australia

2013 Miranda state by-election

* * *

|  | 19 October 2013 |

|
|

|   | First party  | Second party

|
|

|  |
Candidate  | Barry Collier | Brett Thomas
Party  | Labor | Liberal
Popular vote  | 18,812 | 15,883
Percentage  | 46.5% | 39.2%
Swing  |  24.2  |  21.5
TPP | 55.1% | 44.9%
TPP swing  |  26.1  |  26.1

* * *

Miranda in southern metropolitan Sydney.

* * *

| MP before election

Graham Annesley
Liberal

| Elected MP

Barry Collier
Labor

|

A by-election for the New South Wales Legislative Assembly seat of Miranda occurred on 19 October 2013. The by-election was triggered by the resignation of Graham Annesley (Liberal), which was announced on 28 August 2013. Barry Collier (Labor) won the seat with a 55 percent two-party vote from a 26-point two-party swing, the largest swing in New South Wales history.[1][2][3][4]

## Background

[edit]

The Liberal member for Miranda, Graham Annesley, resigned from the New South Wales Parliament and as Minister for Sport and Recreation on 28 August 2013 to take up the post of chief executive officer of the Gold Coast Titans rugby league team.[5] Annesley in his resignation to Parliament said he never regarded himself as a politician and that there were many aspects of politics he did not care for and he has always felt more at home as a sports administrator.[6][7]

A central Sutherland Shire electorate, Miranda crosses the peninsula between the Georges River and Port Hacking. It includes the suburbs of Como, Bonnet Bay, Oyster Bay, Kareela, Kirrawee, Gymea, Gymea Bay, Grays Point and parts of Sylvania, Miranda and Jannali. The seat's federal equivalent is in the western half of the Division of Cook.[1]

Created in 1971, Miranda had traditionally been a Liberal electorate. It had only been won by Labor in landslide elections, two under Neville Wran in 1978 and 1981, and again under Bob Carr in 1999 and in 2003. According to ABC psephologist Antony Green, the seat should have been recovered by the Liberals in 2007 but was narrowly retained by Labor. Going into the 2011 election, Miranda was Labor's most marginal seat, with a 0.8 percent two-party margin. In the 2011 election, the Liberals won government in a landslide. In the process, they picked up a large enough swing in Miranda to turn it into a very safe Liberal seat on paper in one stroke, with a 21.0 percent two-party margin. There were 39 seats held by the Coalition on smaller margins.[1]

## Campaign

[edit]

Questions were raised over the Liberal-controlled Sutherland Shire Council's alleged property development favours in their draft Local Environmental Plan.[8]

Internal Liberal Party polling conducted two weeks before the by-election produced a 54–46 lead to Labor indicating a 25-point two-party swing against the Liberal government,[9][10] however a follow-up internal Liberal Party poll had the Liberals "marginally in front".[11] Sportsbet offered $1.25 for the Liberals against $3.50 for Labor[12] with Antony Green predicting a Liberal retain.[1] Both major party leaders played down expectations of a win.[11]

## Dates

[edit]

Date  | Event [1][13][14]

|

20 September 2013  | Writ of election issued by the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly and close of the electoral roll.[15]
2 October 2013  | Close of party nominations
3 October 2013  | Close of independent nominations
8 October 2013  | Pre-poll and iVote voting began
18 October 2013  | Pre-poll and iVote voting closed
19 October 2013  | Polling day, between the hours of 8 am and 6 pm
23 October 2013  | Postal vote declaration closed

## Candidates

[edit]

The six candidates in ballot paper order were:

Candidate nominations [13][16]

| Greens NSW | Murray Scott  | Retired physicist, worked for AAEC and CSIRO at Lucas Heights.[1]
| Independent | Lisa Walters  | Campaigned against a new rail timetable which cut the number of trains stopping at Como station.[1]
| Labor Party | Barry Collier | Miranda Labor MP 1999–2011.[1][17]
| Christian Democratic Party | George Capsis  | Former Sutherland Shire Councillor 2008–2012 and Deputy Mayor 2011–2012, CDP upper house candidate federally in 2001 and 2004 and state in 2003.[1][18]
| Liberal Party | Brett Thomas  | Former Sutherland Shire Councillor 1995–1999, Liberal candidate for Menai in 1999 and 2003.[1][19]
|  | John Brett  | Retired road and rail engineer, independent candidate for Miranda in 2007 on 1.6% and 2011 on 4.7% primary vote.[1][20]

## Results

[edit]

2013 Miranda by-election
Saturday 19 October[13][21] Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%

|
|
|
|

| Labor | Barry Collier | 18,812  | 46.5  | +24.2
| Liberal | Brett Thomas  | 15,883  | 39.2  | −21.5
| Christian Democrats | George Capsis  | 2,840  | 7.0  | +3.5
| Greens | Murray Scott  | 1,757  | 4.3  | −4.4
| Independent | Lisa Walters  | 842  | 2.1  | +2.1
| Independent | John Brett  | 342  | 0.8  | −3.9
Total formal votes  | 40,476  | 98.0  | +0.7
Informal votes  | 813  | 2.0  | −0.7
Turnout | 41,289  | 84.8  | −10.0
Two-party-preferred result
| Labor | Barry Collier | 20,751  | 55.1  | +26.1
| Liberal | Brett Thomas  | 16,916  | 44.9  | −26.1
| Labor gain from Liberal | Swing | +26.1 |

Labor won the seat with a two-party preferred swing of 26.1 percent, the largest by-election swing in the state's history,[3][4] outdoing even the 2010 Penrith by-election result. Premier Barry O'Farrell claimed Annesley's "unexpected, mid-term resignation" as the reason for the loss and rejected claims of a backlash against the Liberal government.[22] Labor's Collier said the major issues for local voters were overdevelopment in the Sutherland Shire, the frequent closure of fire stations (uniformed firefighters were at polling stations protesting against the Liberal government), cuts to TAFE, and poor transport services at the Jannali and Kogarah train stations.[2][23] Labor leader John Robertson released a statement claiming there was a clear message to the Liberal government from Miranda voters, saying "The people of the shire have sent Barry O'Farrell the strongest of messages tonight ... in the last two-and-a-half years Barry O'Farrell and his government have taken families for granted ... Barry Collier was an outstanding local candidate who ran a strong community campaign, standing up for the Shire against Liberal cuts to services".[4][22]

## See also

[edit]

* Electoral results for the district of Miranda
* List of New South Wales state by-elections

## References

[edit]

1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k "2013 Miranda By-election". ABC News. Archived from the original on 12 July 2022. Retrieved 18 October 2013.
2. ^ a b Needham, Kirsty (19 October 2013). "Labor regains southern Sydney seat of Miranda". The Sydney Morning Herald. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024.
3. ^ a b Bashan, Yoni; Silmalis, Linda (19 October 2013). "Miranda voters' ire shown in stunning 28pc swing to Labor at by-election". The Sunday Telegraph. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024 – via news.com.au.
4. ^ a b c Green, Antony (19 October 2013). "Labor's Barry Collier returns to NSW Parliament after record swing against O'Farrell Government in Miranda by-election". ABC News. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024.
5. ^ Graham Annesley, Minister for Sport and Recreation (28 August 2013). "Resignation of Minister for Sport and Recreation". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). New South Wales: Legislative Assembly. p. 22932\. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024. Retrieved 7 September 2013.
6. ^ Clennell, Andrew (28 August 2013). "Barry O'Farrell announces Sports Minister Graham Annesley has resigned". www.dailytelegraph.com.au. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024.
7. ^ Gerathy, Sarah (28 August 2013). "Graham Annesley resigns from NSW ministry to take up role as Gold Coast Titans chief". ABC News. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024.
8. ^ "By-election battle draws more attention to Shire LEP and favours allegations". St George & Sutherland Shire Leader. 17 October 2013. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024.
9. ^ Clennell, Andrew (14 October 2013). "Liberals facing a by-election hiding". www.dailytelegraph.com.au. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024.
10. ^ "Libs to 'get a kicking' in NSW by-election". NineMSN. 15 October 2013. Archived from the original on 19 October 2013.
11. ^ a b Clennell, Andrew (18 October 2013). "Premier expecting Miranda by-election loss as electorate protests former sports minister Graham Annesley's early resignation". www.dailytelegraph.com.au. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024.
12. ^ Bowe, William (18 October 2013). "Miranda by-election: October 19". The Poll Bludger. Archived from the original on 9 September 2017. Retrieved 12 March 2021.
13. ^ a b c Report on the Conduct of the Election Miranda State By-election (PDF) (Report). Level 25, 201 Kent Street, Sydney NSW Australia 2000: The New South Wales Electoral Commission (NSWEC). 22 January 2014. Archived (PDF) from the original on 9 March 2024.`{{cite report}}`: CS1 maint: location (link)
14. ^ "Miranda State By-election". Electoral Commission of New South Wales. Retrieved 9 October 2013.
15. ^ Tony Duckmanton, Government Printer; Ronda Clark, Clerk of the Legislative Assembly (20 September 2013). "Special Supplement" (PDF). Government Gazette of the State of New South Wales. p. 4175\. ISSN 0155-6320. Archived (PDF) from the original on 20 October 2022. Retrieved 12 October 2019.
16. ^ Trembath, Murray (18 October 2013). "Miranda voters head to the polls - see candidate profiles". St George & Sutherland Shire Leader. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024.
17. ^ "Old Labor hand to contest NSW seat". AAP. 23 September 2013. Archived from the original on 19 October 2013. Retrieved 9 October 2013 – via ninemsn.
18. ^ "Councillors of the Sutherland Shire 1906 and onwards" (PDF). Local Studies, Central Library, corner Belmont and Stapleton Street, Sutherland: Sutherland Shire Council. 25 September 2012. Archived from the original on 19 October 2013.
19. ^ Raue, ben (5 October 2013). "Miranda by-election, 2013". The Tally Room. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024. Retrieved 9 October 2013.
20. ^ Trembath, Murray (22 November 2012). "Cronulla Beach work queried". St George & Sutherland Shire Leader. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024. Retrieved 9 October 2013.
21. ^ "Results: 2013 Miranda by-election". ABC News. Archived from the original on 5 December 2020. Retrieved 12 October 2019.
22. ^ a b "ALP wins NSW by-election". Sky News. 19 October 2013. Archived from the original on 19 October 2013.
23. ^ Trembath, Murray (19 October 2013). "Collier reclaims Miranda with a record swing". St George & Sutherland Shire Leader. Archived from the original on 19 May 2024.

* v
* t
* e

By-elections of the 55th New South Wales parliament (2011–2015)

2011|

* Clarence

2012|

* Heffron
* Sydney

2013|

* Northern Tablelands
* Miranda

2014|

* Charlestown
* Newcastle

* 1st (1856–1858)
* 2nd (1858–1859)
* 3rd (1859–1860)
* 4th (1860–1864)
* 5th (1864–1869)
* 6th (1869–1872)
* 7th (1872–1874)
* 8th (1874–1877)
* 9th (1877–1880)
* 10th (1880–1882)
* 11th (1882–1885)
* 12th (1885–1887)
* 13th (1887–1889)
* 14th (1889–1891)
* 15th (1891–1894)
* 16th (1894–1895)
* 17th (1895–1898)
* 18th (1898–1901)
* 19th (1901–1904)
* 20th (1904–1907)
* 21st (1907–1910)
* 22nd (1910–1913)
* 23rd (1913–1917)
* 24th (1917–1920)
* 25th (1920–1922)
* 26th (1922–1925)
* 27th (1925–1927)
* 28th (1927–1930)
* 29th (1930–1932)
* 30th (1932–1935)
* 31st (1935–1938)
* 32nd (1938–1941)
* 33rd (1941–1944)
* 34th (1944–1947)
* 35th (1947–1950)
* 36th (1950–1953)
* 37th (1953–1956)
* 38th (1956–1959)
* 39th (1959–1962)
* 40th (1962–1965)
* 41st (1965–1968)
* 42nd (1968–1971)
* 43rd (1971–1973)
* 44th (1973–1976)
* 45th (1976–1978)
* 46th (1978–1981)
* 47th (1981–1984)
* 48th (1984–1988)
* 49th (1988–1991)
* 50th (1991–1995)
* 51st (1995–1999)
* 52nd (1999–2003)
* 53rd (2003–2007)
* 54th (2007–2011)
* 55th (2011–2015)
* 56th (2015–2019)
* 57th (2019–2023)
* 58th (2023–2027)

* v
* t
* e

Results of New South Wales State elections

Legislative Assembly|

| Colonial|

* 1856
* 1858
* 1859
* 1860
* 1864–65
* 1869–70
* 1872
* 1874–75
* 1877
* 1880
* 1882
* 1885
* 1887
* 1889
* 1891
* 1894
* 1895
* 1898

|

State|

* 1901
* 1904
* 1907
* 1910
* 1913
* 1917
* 1920
* 1922
* 1925
* 1927
* 1930
* 1932
* 1935
* 1938
* 1941
* 1944
* 1947
* 1950
* 1953
* 1956
* 1959
* 1962
* 1965
* 1968
* 1971
* 1973
* 1976
* 1978
* 1981
* 1984
* 1988
* 1991
* 1995
* 1999
* 2003
* 2007
* 2011
* 2015
* 2019
* 2023

Legislative Council|

| Colonial|

* 1843
* 1848
* 1851

|

State|

* 1978
* 1981
* 1984
* 1988
* 1991
* 1995
* 1999
* 2003
* 2007
* 2011
* 2015
* 2019
* 2023

By-elections|

* Legislative Assembly
* Legislative Council (historic)

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template