2016 Maine Question 2

Question 2: Citizen Initiative

An Act To Establish The Fund to Advance Public Kindergarten to Grade 12 Education

Results

Choice

| Votes  | %

|
|

Yes | 383,428 | 50.63%
No | 373,848  | 49.37%
Valid votes  | 757,276  | 98.13%
Invalid or blank votes  | 14,432  | 1.87%
Total votes | 771,708 | 100.00%

* * *

Yes

50–60%

50–60%

|

Elections in Maine

Federal offices

|  U.S. President

* 1820
* 1824
* 1828
* 1832
* 1836
* 1840
* 1844
* 1848
* 1852
* 1856
* 1860
* 1864
* 1868
* 1872
* 1876
* 1880
* 1884
* 1888
* 1892
* 1896
* 1900
* 1904
* 1908
* 1912
* 1916
* 1920
* 1924
* 1928
* 1932
* 1936
* 1940
* 1944
* 1948
* 1952
* 1956
* 1960
* 1964
* 1968
* 1972
* 1976
* 1980
* 1984
* Dem
* 1988
* 1992
* 1996
* 2000
* Dem
* 2004
* Dem
* 2008
* Dem
* Rep
* 2012
* Rep
* 2016
* Dem
* Rep
* 2020
* Dem
* Rep
* 2024
* Dem
* Rep

U.S. Senate

* 1820
* 1821
* 1823
* 1823
* 1827
* 1829 sp
* 1835
* 1835 sp
* 1837 sp
* 1839
* 1840
* 1843 sp
* 1846
* 1848 sp
* 1851
* 1854 sp
* 1857
* 1857 sp
* 1859
* 1861 sp
* 1863
* 1865 sp
* 1869
* 1870 sp
* 1875
* 1877
* 1877 sp
* 1880
* 1881
* 1881 sp
* 1883
* 1887
* 1889
* 1893
* 1895
* 1899
* 1901
* 1905
* 1907
* 1911
* 1912 sp
* 1913
* 1916
* 1916 sp
* 1918
* 1922
* 1924
* 1926 sp
* 1928
* 1930
* 1934
* 1936
* 1940
* 1942
* 1946
* 1948
* 1952
* 1954
* 1958
* 1960
* 1964
* 1966
* 1970
* 1972
* 1976
* 1978
* 1982
* 1984
* 1988
* 1990
* 1994
* 1996
* 2000
* 2002
* 2006
* 2008
* 2012
* 2014
* 2018
* 2020
* 2024

U.S. House of Representatives

* 1820–1821
* 1822 sp 2nd
* 1823
* 1824–1825
* 1826–1827
* 1826 sp 5th
* 1827 sp 1st
* 1828–1830
* 1830
* 1833
* 1834
* 1836
* 1838
* 1840
* 1843
* 1844
* 1846
* 1848
* 1850
* 1852
* 1854
* 1856
* 1858
* 1860
* 1860 sp 5th
* 1862
* 1864
* 1866
* 1868
* 1870
* 1872
* 1874
* 1876
* 1878
* 1880
* 1881 sp 2nd
* 1882
* 1884
* 1886
* 1888
* 1890
* 1892
* 1894
* 1896
* 1897 sp 3rd
* 1898
* 1899 sp 1st
* 1899 sp 2nd
* 1900
* 1901 sp 4th
* 1902
* 1904
* 1906
* 1908
* 1908 sp 2nd
* 1908 sp 4th
* 1910
* 1912
* 1913 sp 3rd
* 1914
* 1916
* 1918
* 1920
* 1922
* 1924
* 1926
* 1928
* 1930
* 1932
* 1934
* 1936
* 1938
* 1940
* 1940 sp 2nd
* 1942
* 1944
* 1946
* 1948
* 1950
* 1951 sp 3rd
* 1952
* 1954
* 1956
* 1958
* 1960
* 1962
* 1964
* 1966
* 1968
* 1970
* 1972
* 1974
* 1976
* 1978
* 1980
* 1982
* 1984
* 1986
* 1988
* 1990
* 1992
* 1994
* 1996
* 1998
* 2000
* 2002
* 2004
* 2006
* 2008
* 2010
* 2012
* 2014
* 2016
* 2018
* 2020
* 2022
* 2024

State government

|  Gubernatorial elections

* 1820
* 1821
* 1822
* 1823
* 1824
* 1825
* 1826
* 1827
* 1828
* 1829
* 1830
* 1831
* 1832
* 1833
* 1834
* 1835
* 1836
* 1837
* 1838
* 1839
* 1840
* 1841
* 1842
* 1843
* 1844
* 1845
* 1846
* 1847
* 1848
* 1849
* 1850
* 1852
* 1853
* 1854
* 1855
* 1856
* 1857
* 1858
* 1859
* 1860
* 1861
* 1862
* 1863
* 1864
* 1865
* 1866
* 1867
* 1868
* 1869
* 1870
* 1871
* 1872
* 1873
* 1874
* 1875
* 1876
* 1877
* 1878
* 1879
* 1880
* 1882
* 1884
* 1886
* 1888
* 1890
* 1892
* 1894
* 1896
* 1898
* 1900
* 1902
* 1904
* 1906
* 1908
* 1910
* 1912
* 1914
* 1916
* 1918
* 1920
* 1922
* 1924
* 1926
* 1928
* 1930
* 1932
* 1934
* 1936
* 1938
* 1940
* 1942
* 1944
* 1946
* 1948
* 1950
* 1952
* 1954
* 1956
* 1958
* 1960
* 1962
* 1966
* 1970
* 1974
* 1978
* 1982
* 1986
* 1990
* 1994
* 1998
* 2002
* 2006
* 2010
* 2014
* 2018
* 2022

State Senate elections

* 2016
* 2018
* 2020
* 2022

State House elections

* 2016
* 2018
* 2020
* 2022

Ballot measures

|  People's vetoes

2009
Question 1

2011
Question 1

2018
Question 1 (Jun)

2020
Question 1
Citizen initiated referendums

2012
Question 1

2014
Question 1

2015
Question 1

2016
Question 1
Question 2
Question 3
Question 4
Question 5

2017
Question 1
Question 2

2018
Question 1 (Nov)

2021
Question 1

2023
Question 1
Constitutional amendments

2021
Question 3
Legislatively referred referendums

2024
Question 5

City of Portland

|  Mayoral elections

* 2011
* 2015
* 2019
* 2023

* v
* t
* e

Maine Question 2, formally An Act to Establish The Fund to Advance Public Kindergarten to Grade 12 Education,[1] was a citizen-initiated referendum question that appeared on the Maine November 8, 2016 statewide ballot. It sought to increase state aid to public schools by instituting a surcharge of 3% on Maine income taxes for those with income above $200,000 a year. As the Maine Legislature declined to enact the proposal as written, it appeared on the ballot along with elections for President of the United States, Maine's two U.S. House seats, the Legislature, and various local elections.

The question was passed by roughly 10,000 votes. The surtax created by the question was repealed as part of state budget negotiations on July 3, 2017 that added $162 million to public education funding from general revenue.

## Background

[edit]

In 2003, Maine voters passed a referendum calling for the state to pay for 55% of the cost of operating public schools, as a way to reduce pressure on local property taxes. That percentage had never been met.[2] To attempt to reach that target, a group called Stand Up for Students announced that it would start a petition drive to implement a 3% surcharge on Maine income taxes paid on those with incomes above $200,000 a year, estimated to be the top 2% of earners in Maine.[3] It is estimated that such a tax surcharge would result in $110 million a year in revenue.[4]

The petition drive was carried out by some paid signature gatherers, but was largely done by volunteers from the Maine Education Association and the Maine People's Alliance, a liberal organizing group. MEA members were offered $25 Visa gift cards for every 100 signatures they gathered.[5] The office of Maine Secretary of State Matthew Dunlap certified that the proposal qualified for the ballot on March 2, 2016, stating that 66,849 signatures were valid.[4]

The exact wording of the question was disputed. Secretary Dunlap proposed the wording "Do you want to establish a fund to support kindergarten through 12th grade public education by adding a three percent surcharge on Maine taxable income above $200,000?". During the required public comment period before the wording was finalized, the Governor's Office filed an objection to the proposed wording, stating that the word 'tax' or 'surtax' should be used instead of 'surcharge'. Doing so, they stated, would have been consistent with prior referendums calling for generating revenue. A Stand Up for Students spokesman called the objection an effort to confuse voters, citing tax cuts enacted by Governor Paul LePage. Dunlap had until June 24 to make a final decision, which was only possible to appeal by going to court.[6]

Dunlap released the final wording of the question on June 23, which read as "Do you want to add a 3% tax on individual Maine taxable income above $200,000 to create a state fund that would provide direct support for student learning in kindergarten through 12th grade public education?" [7]

## Campaign

[edit]

The Maine State Chamber of Commerce formed a PAC called No on Question 2 on August 2, 2016. Chamber President Dana Connors said that while they support strong education funding, it should be done in a manner that does not affect the economy. He went on to state that such a tax would discourage professionals from living in Maine.[8]

### Notable endorsements

[edit]

#### Supporters

[edit]

* Maine Association of School Libraries[9]
* Maine Children's Alliance[9]
* Maine Education Association[9]
* Maine Parent Teacher Association[9]
* Maine Small Business Coalition[9]
* Machinists (IAM) Local S7[9]
* Maine People's Resource Center[9]
* Maine People's Alliance[9]
* Maine AFL–CIO[9]
* Maine State Employees Association[9]
* Maine Center for Economic Policy[9]

#### Opponents

[edit]

* John Baldacci, former Governor of Maine[10]
* Paul LePage, Governor of Maine[10]
* Stephen Bowen, former Commissioner of the Maine Department of Education[10]
* Jim Rier, former Commissioner of the Maine Department of Education[10]
* Maine Heritage Policy Center[11]
* Maine State Chamber of Commerce[10]
* Bangor Daily News[12]
* MaineToday Media newspapers; Portland Press Herald, Kennebec Journal, Morning Sentinel[13]

### Polling

[edit]

Date of opinion poll  | Conducted by  | Sample size
(likely voters)  | Yes  | No  | Undecided  | Margin of Error

|
|
|
|
|
|

October 20–25, 2016[14] | University of New Hampshire  | 761  | 57% | 34%  | 9%  | ±3.6%
September 15–20, 2016[15] | University of New Hampshire  | 506  | 60% | 32%  | 8%  | ±4.3%

## Results

[edit]

Uncertified results indicated that Question 2 passed by a margin of around 10,000 votes. Due to the closeness of the result, opponents of Question 2 filed a petition for a recount, then withdrew their petition on November 29.[16][17]

Question 2 Results[18] County  | Yes  | Votes  | No  | Votes

|
|
|
|

Androscoggin | 49.84% | 28,133 | 50.16% | 28,317
Aroostook | 51.55% | 18,209 | 48.45% | 17,117
Cumberland | 52.44% | 91,039 | 47.56% | 82,568
Franklin | 48.69% | 8,200 | 51.31% | 8,641
Hancock | 48.72% | 15,831 | 51.28% | 16,662
Kennebec | 49.56% | 33,211 | 50.44% | 33,807
Knox | 53.67% | 12,555 | 46.33% | 10,839
Lincoln | 49.67% | 10,850 | 50.33% | 10,993
Oxford | 50.49% | 16,089 | 49.51% | 15,777
Penobscot | 47.10% | 38,369 | 52.90% | 43,102
Piscataquis | 42.23% | 3,948 | 57.77% | 5,401
Sagadahoc | 51.40% | 11,313 | 48.60% | 10,698
Somerset | 46.04% | 12,165 | 53.96% | 14,258
Waldo | 51.27% | 11,776 | 48.73% | 11,192
Washington | 46.49% | 7,759 | 53.51% | 8,930
York | 52.80% | 61,137 | 47.20% | 54,663
UOCAVA | 76.31% | 2,844 | 23.69% | 883
Total | 50.63% | 383,428 | 49.37% | 373,848

## Repeal

[edit]

The creation of the surtax became a point of contention in state budget negotiations for the 2017–2018 budget, with Governor LePage and minority House Republicans opposed to any tax increases in the budget. A budget that did not eliminate the surtax passed the Republican-controlled Maine Senate, but not the House, leading to a shutdown of Maine state government at the end of the fiscal year on June 30.[19] Three days later, negotiators agreed to, and LePage signed, a budget that eliminated the surtax but added an additional $162 million for public education to the budget.[20]

## References

[edit]

1. ^ "Maine Citizen's Guide to the Referendum Election" (PDF). State of Maine Office of the Secretary of State. Archived (PDF) from the original on October 18, 2016. Retrieved October 15, 2016.
2. ^ "Moody's: Maine budget 'credit negative' for cities, towns". Bangor Daily News. July 10, 2015. Retrieved March 12, 2016.
3. ^ "Group proposes taxing top 2 percent to help state meet education funding law". Bangor Daily News. October 7, 2015. Retrieved March 12, 2016.
4. ^ a b "Petition to force more Maine school aid clears ballot hurdle". Bangor Daily News. March 2, 2016. Retrieved March 12, 2016.
5. ^ "Group that wants Maine to spend more on public schools nears petition goal". Bangor Daily News. December 17, 2015. Retrieved March 12, 2016.
6. ^ "LePage Administration Challenges Wording of Education Ballot Question". MPBN. June 13, 2016. Retrieved June 13, 2016.
7. ^ "Maine secretary of state revises wording of all five November ballot questions". Bangor Daily News. June 23, 2016. Retrieved June 23, 2016.
8. ^ "Maine Chamber of Commerce forms PAC to oppose new tax to fund education". Bangor Daily News. August 2, 2016. Retrieved August 2, 2016.
9. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k "Endorsements". Stand Up for Students. Citizens Who Support Maine’s Public Schools. Archived from the original on September 16, 2016. Retrieved September 15, 2016.
10. ^ a b c d e "John Baldacci opposes ballot bid to tax high earners more to hike school aid". September 15, 2016.
11. ^ "The Wrong Choice for ME: Question 2 Report". October 11, 2016.
12. ^ "With Question 2, Maine gets higher taxes, same education system that needs improving". Bangor Daily News. October 15, 2015. Retrieved October 16, 2016.
13. ^ The Editorial Board (October 30, 2016). "Our View: Vote 'no' on Question 2: Make Augusta fix schools".
14. ^ Murphy, Edward D. (October 31, 2016). "Leads shrink for 4 of the 6 Maine ballot issues, poll indicates".
15. ^ "Education tax poll data". September 28, 2016.
16. ^ Carrigan, Don. "Petitions for recount on Questions 1 and 2". WSCH6 Portland. WCSH-TV. Retrieved March 10, 2017.[permanent dead link‍]
17. ^ Graham, Gilligan (November 29, 2016). "Group withdraws request for recount of education surcharge vote". The Portland Press-Herald. MaineToday Media. Retrieved March 10, 2017.
18. ^ "Tabulations for Elections held in 2016". Bureau of Corporations, Elections & Commissions. Maine Department of the Secretary of State. Retrieved March 9, 2017.
19. ^ "With no budget deal, Maine partially shuts its government". Boston Globe. July 1, 2017. Retrieved March 20, 2018.
20. ^ "LePage signs budget, ending state government shutdown after 3 days". Portland Press Herald. July 4, 2017. Retrieved March 20, 2018.

## External links

[edit]

* Stand Up for Students, supporters of the initiative
* No Gain 2 Maine Archived October 23, 2016, at the Wayback Machine opponents of the initiative

* v
* t
* e

Elections and referendums in Maine

Presidential elections|

* 1820
* 1824
* 1828
* 1832
* 1836
* 1840
* 1844
* 1848
* 1852
* 1856
* 1860
* 1864
* 1868
* 1872
* 1876
* 1880
* 1884
* 1888
* 1892
* 1896
* 1900
* 1904
* 1908
* 1912
* 1916
* 1920
* 1924
* 1928
* 1932
* 1936
* 1940
* 1944
* 1948
* 1952
* 1956
* 1960
* 1964
* 1968
* 1972
* 1976
* 1980
* 1984
* 1988
* 1992
* 1996
* 2000
* 2004
* 2008
* 2012
* 2016
* 2020
* 2024

Senate elections|

| Class 1|

* 1916
* 1922
* 1928
* 1934
* 1940
* 1946
* 1952
* 1958
* 1964
* 1970
* 1976
* 1982
* 1988
* 1994
* 2000
* 2006
* 2012
* 2018
* 2024

|

Class 2|

* 1918
* 1924
* 1930
* 1936
* 1942
* 1948
* 1954
* 1960
* 1966
* 1972
* 1978
* 1984
* 1990
* 1996
* 2002
* 2008
* 2014
* 2020

House elections|

* 1998
* 2000
* 2002
* 2004
* 2006
* 2008
* 2010
* 2012
* 2014
* 2016
* 2018
* 2020
* 2022
* 2024

Gubernatorial elections|

* 1820
* 1821
* 1822
* 1823
* 1824
* 1825
* 1826
* 1827
* 1828
* 1829
* 1830
* 1831
* 1832
* 1833
* 1834
* 1835
* 1836
* 1837
* 1838
* 1839
* 1840
* 1841
* 1842
* 1843
* 1844
* 1845
* 1846
* 1847
* 1848
* 1849
* 1850
* 1852
* 1853
* 1854
* 1855
* 1856
* 1857
* 1858
* 1859
* 1860
* 1861
* 1862
* 1863
* 1864
* 1865
* 1866
* 1867
* 1868
* 1869
* 1870
* 1871
* 1872
* 1873
* 1874
* 1875
* 1876
* 1877
* 1878
* 1879
* 1880
* 1882
* 1884
* 1886
* 1888
* 1890
* 1892
* 1894
* 1896
* 1898
* 1900
* 1902
* 1904
* 1906
* 1908
* 1910
* 1912
* 1914
* 1916
* 1918
* 1920
* 1922
* 1924
* 1926
* 1928
* 1930
* 1932
* 1934
* 1936
* 1938
* 1940
* 1942
* 1944
* 1946
* 1948
* 1950
* 1952
* 1954
* 1956
* 1958
* 1960
* 1962
* 1966
* 1970
* 1974
* 1978
* 1982
* 1986
* 1990
* 1994
* 1998
* 2002
* 2006
* 2010
* 2014
* 2018
* 2022
* 2026

Legislative elections|

| State Senate|

* 2018
* 2020
* 2022
* 2024

|

State House|

* 2018
* 2020
* 2022
* 2024

Referendums|

* 2009
* 2011
* 2012
* 2014
* 2015
* 2016
* 2017
* 2018
* 2020
* 2021
* 2023
* 2024

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template