Andrew Feinstein

South African politician (born 1964)

Andrew Feinstein

Feinstein in 2016

Member of the South African National Assembly
In office
1994–2001
Personal details
Born|  (1964-03-16) 16 March 1964 (age 61)
Cape Town, Cape Province, South Africa
Political party| Independent (2024–present)
Other political
affiliations|

* Labour (2015–2024)
* African National Congress (1980s–2001)
* Collective
* Transform[1]

Spouse|

Simone Sultana

(m. 1993)​

Children| 1 son and 1 daughter
Residence(s)| Camden, London, UK[2]
Education| Wynberg Boys' High School
Alma mater|

* University of Cape Town
* University of California, Berkeley
* King's College, Cambridge

Occupation| Investigative author, campaigner

Andrew Josef Feinstein[a] (born 16 March 1964) is a South African former politician, activist, filmmaker, campaigner and author, now based in London, who specialises in the investigation of the arms trade and the corruption that accompanies it. He is Executive Director of a small non-profit, Shadow World Investigations,[3][b] and serves on the board of Declassified UK. The son of a Holocaust survivor, Feinstein was the first MP to introduce a motion on the Holocaust in the South African parliament.

Feinstein was elected in South Africa's first democratic elections following the abolition of Apartheid, serving as a member of parliament from 1994 to 2001 as a member of the ruling ANC party. In 2001, in protest against the ANC's refusal to investigate allegations of huge bribes and large-scale corruption against senior ANC politicians arising from a £5 billion arms deal, he resigned his parliamentary seat and moved to London, where he works as an investigative author and campaigner. On first arriving in London he worked in investment banking for more than five years.[6]

A former member of the UK Labour Party, Feinstein is highly critical of Keir Starmer, and the direction Labour has taken under Starmer's leadership. Feinstein has lived in Starmer's constituency of Holborn and St. Pancras since 2001, has criticised Starmer for being "terrible on Gaza", and stood against Starmer in the 2024 general election, coming second with 7,312 votes (18.9%).

## Early life and education

[edit]

Andrew Feinstein was born in Cape Town to Viennese Holocaust survivor Erika (née Hemmer) and Ralph Josef Feinstein.[7] Dozens of members of his mother's family were murdered in Auschwitz concentration camp and Theresienstadt,[8] whilst she herself hid from the Nazis in Vienna.[9] Her horrific experiences shaped his political views from a very young age. Motivated by her work with anti-apartheid groups, he became involved in the then-outlawed African National Congress (ANC) from his late teens.[10]

Feinstein completed his secondary education at Wynberg Boys' High School in Cape Town in 1981; four years later he graduated with a BA (Honours) degree from the University of Cape Town. He studied graduate-level Economics & Politics from 1985 to 1987 at the University of California, and in 1990 gained a Master of Philosophy degree in Economics & Politics from the University of Cambridge.[11]

## African National Congress

[edit]

He was elected an ANC member of parliament under Nelson Mandela in the first democratic election in 1994.[10] He served as a member of the Gauteng Provincial Legislature and an advisor to Gauteng's then-MEC of Finance, Jabu Moleketi, from 1994 to 1996. He also worked as an economic advisor to then-premier Tokyo Sexwale. He was elected as a member of the South African Parliament's lower house in 1997.

Feinstein introduced the first ever motion on the Holocaust in South African parliamentary history. Feinstein stated that previous suffering – by Afrikaners at the hands of the British colonizers, or of Jews by the Nazis – in no way justified the brutal oppression of Black South Africans or Palestinians.[10][12][8]

During his time in office, he served on the Finance Committee, and chaired the sub-committee that drafted the Public Finance Management Act (Act 1 of 2000), as chair of the ANC study group on public accounts and the ANC's official spokesman on the National Assembly's public accounts committee. Feinstein was at the time referred to as "one of its most vocal and talented MPs", who argued that a thorough investigation into the South African Arms Deal had to be done.[citation needed] He resigned in 2001 when the ANC refused to launch an unfettered investigation into the matter.[13][14] He was succeeded by Geoff Doidge in both positions.

## Post-ANC career

[edit]

Feinstein resigned from his seat in 2001 when the ANC refused to investigate the corruption and bribery allegations regarding the arms deal. He has since lived in London, where he is Executive Director of not-for-profit Shadow World Investigations and chaired the Aids charity Friends of the Treatment Action Campaign, and lectures and writes on South Africa and the global arms trade. He is now considered an ANC dissident and critic, with his memoirs, After the Party, being severely critical of the political culture of the ANC. He describes the ill-fated arms deal as the "point at which the ANC lost its moral compass".[15]

In an interview with Democracy Now!, he noted the ways in which the global arms trade was linked to the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting.[16]

About l'affaire Dadak, concerning the activities of a Franco-Polish arm dealer Pierre Dadak, Feinstein stated: "Dadak's story reflects the complete amoral nature of the arms trade. The distinction between arms dealers and grifters is extremely fuzzy. A lot of these people are almost caricatures, they have huge personalities, they're delusional. The extraordinary thing is how company after company, government after government, actually fall for these people. And the reason they do it is because everything that happens in this trade is secret, so it provides absolutely fertile ground for these sorts of conmen".[17]

A staunch critic of the nature and regulation of the global arms trade, Feinstein is a board member of Declassified UK, an investigative journalism website set up in 2019 by Matt Kennard and Mark Curtis to cover the UK's role on the international stage.[18]

Feinstein argued that the strategy that helped end South Africa's crime of apartheid must also be mobilized against Israeli apartheid. The BDS strategy — Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions – was very effectively utilized against apartheid South Africa.[10]

### UK Labour Party

[edit]

Feinstein joined British Labour Party shortly before Jeremy Corbyn became leader.[19][12] In December 2019, along with 42 other leading cultural figures, Feinstein signed a letter endorsing the Labour Party under Corbyn's leadership in the 2019 general election. The letter stated that "Labour's election manifesto under Jeremy Corbyn's leadership offers a transformative plan that prioritises the needs of people and the planet over private profit and the vested interests of a few."[20][21]

In December 2020, he described Keir Starmer, Corbyn's successor as the Labour Party leader, as "inauthentic" and "severely lacking in charisma".[22] After leaving the party, he remained highly critical of Starmer and the direction Labour had taken under Starmer's leadership, accusing Starmer of, among other things, being "terrible on Gaza".[23] In February 2024, it was announced that Feinstein was preparing to stand against Starmer in his constituency of Holborn and St. Pancras as an independent at the next general election, endorsed by two grassroots organisations.[24][25][23][26] In the general election on 4 July 2024, Feinstein finished second, with 7,312 votes to Starmer's 18,884.[23]

## The Shadow World

[edit]

In 2011 Feinstein's book The Shadow World: Inside the Global Arms Trade, an investigation into the global arms industry was published outside the US by Penguin in 2011 and 2012 and in the United States by Farrar, Straus and Giroux. The Washington Post described the book as "A comprehensive treatment of the arms trade, possibly the most complete account ever written."[27] Paul Rogers in The Independent commented: "one thing that has been missing has been a comprehensive book for the more general reader, along the lines of Anthony Sampson's The Arms Bazaar, back in the late 1970s. Andrew Feinstein's The Shadow World does just this, and in some ways it is even better than Sampson's influential volume. What is particularly useful is the very unusual combination of a thoroughly readable book that also provides a quite extraordinary range of sources – some 2,500 footnotes in all."[28] Feinstein reported "that the trade in weapons accounts for around 40 percent of all corruption in all world trade. The...trade in weapons is extremely closely tied into the mechanics of government. The defence manufacturers, those who make the weapons, are closely tied in to governments, to militaries, to intelligence agencies and crucially to political parties."[29]

The book was made into a feature documentary, Shadow World, by Louverture Films, directed by the Belgian Johan Grimonprez.[citation needed] Feinstein co-wrote the film and features in it. The film premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival in 2016 and won Best Documentary Feature Film at the Edinburgh International Film Festival in 2016, Tiempo de Historia Award (Best Documentary) Semana Internacional de Cine de Valladolid 2016, and Ensor Best Documentary at the Ostend Film Festival 2017.[30] It was screened at the Wales One World Film Festival in March 2017.[31]

## Personal life

[edit]

Feinstein met his Bangladeshi future wife Simone Sultana – whom he described as "highly politicised" – while at university in Cambridge.[32] Four years after they first met, they were married in King's College Chapel, Cambridge[c] on 18 December 1993, holding further celebrations a few days later with Simone's family in Bangladesh.[33] In his memoir, Feinstein praised his wife as "my best friend, my confidant and the love of my life".[34] The couple have a son and a daughter. His interests include crime fiction, football, music and film.[11] In football, he supports Arsenal.[7]

## See also

[edit]

* List of peace activists

## Books

[edit]

* After the Party:
* Feinstein, Andrew (2007). After the Party: A Personal and Political Journey Inside the ANC. Johannesburg & Cape Town: Jonathan Ball. ISBN 978-1-86842-262-3.

– People with impaired vision might prefer this edition, as it is printed in a larger font than the 2009 edition.
* Feinstein, Andrew (2009). After the Party: Corruption, the ANC and South Africa's Uncertain Future. London; New York: Verso. ISBN 978-1-84467-356-8.

– with additional preface and afterword
* Feinstein, Andrew (2012). The Shadow World: Inside the Global Arms Trade. London: Penguin Books. ISBN 978-0-141-04005-9.
* Michie, Rhona; Feinstein, Andrew; Rogers, Paul, eds. (2024). Monstrous Anger of the Guns: How the Arms Trade Is Ruining the World and What We Can Do About It. Preface by Jeremy Corbyn. London: Pluto Press; Peace & Justice Project. ISBN 978-0-7453-5036-3.

## Notes and references

[edit]

### Notes

[edit]

1. ^ pronounced "fine-steen"
2. ^ Corruption Watch Ltd, a company Feinstein co-founded in late 2009, changed its name to Shadow World Investigations in December 2019[4] and was legally renamed in 2021.[5]
3. ^ This was the "first-ever ceremony in the 700-year history of King's College Chapel in which neither bride nor groom was Anglican." (Feinstein 2007, pp. 7–8; Feinstein 2009, pp. 7–8)

### Citations

[edit]

1. ^ Candidates.
2. ^ "About" page on Feinstein's website
3. ^ "Andrew Feinstein". Shadow World Investigations. 2004. Retrieved 3 July 2024.
4. ^ @CorruptnWatchUK "Corruption Watch UK has become two separate organisations", X (formerly Twitter). 2 December 2019. Retrieved 30 June 2024.
5. ^ Companies House: SWI.
6. ^ Feinstein video 5 June 2024, at 1:02:33.
7. ^ a b Kamugasa 2020.
8. ^ a b Feinstein 2019.
9. ^ Feinstein video 29 Oct 2020.
10. ^ a b c d Feinstein 2023.
11. ^ a b Who's Who SA — Andrew Feinstein.
12. ^ a b Snow 2020.
13. ^ Statement by Andrew Feinstein MP – 30 August 2001 Archived 23 March 2009 at the Wayback Machine
14. ^ Chambers 2019.
15. ^ Corruption Watch 2014.
16. ^ Democracy Now! 2012.
17. ^ Belford et al. 2018.
18. ^ Daily Maverick 2020.
19. ^ Feinstein video 5 June 2024, at 1:09:00.
20. ^ The Guardian 2019.
21. ^ Proctor 2019.
22. ^ Rose Report video 2020.
23. ^ a b c Mulla 2024.
24. ^ Hearst 2024.
25. ^ Mair 2024.
26. ^ Carter 2024.
27. ^ Tirman 2011.
28. ^ Rogers 2011.
29. ^ Feinstein 2013.
30. ^ Louverture Films.
31. ^ Culture Colony 2017.
32. ^ Feinstein 2007, p. 7; Feinstein 2009, p. 8
33. ^ Feinstein 2007, p. 25; Feinstein 2009, p. 23
34. ^ Feinstein 2007, p. xiv; Feinstein 2009, p. xxi

### Videos

[edit]

* Feinstein, Andrew (29 October 2020). "I Lost 39 Members of My Family in the Holocaust, Jeremy Corbyn is No Antisemite". Double Down News. Retrieved 31 October 2020 – via YouTube. (7:49 minutes)
* Feinstein, Andrew (26 December 2020). "Andrew Feinstein on Keir Starmer, the Weaponisation of Antisemitism & Purging the Left from Labour" (Interview). Interviewed by Shlomo Anker. The Rose Report. Retrieved 4 July 2024 – via YouTube. (11:55 minutes)
* Feinstein, Andrew (5 June 2024). "The anti-apartheid activist who could stop the UK's likely next PM". Unapologetic (Interview). Interviewed by Roger Waters. Middle East Eye. Retrieved 4 July 2024 – via YouTube. (1 hour 50 minutes)
* Feinstein, Andrew (5 July 2024). "Not the General Election 2024" (Interview). Interviewed by Crispin Flintoff – via YouTube. (9:30 minutes; part of a 7hr 22min 38sec video)

### Sources (excluding videos)

[edit]

* "Andrew Feinstein — Who's Who SA". Archived from the original on 23 June 2012. Retrieved 3 January 2018.
* "The arms deal: what you need to know". Corruption Watch. 22 January 2014. Retrieved 18 January 2021.
* "As U.S. Faces Gun Epidemic Post-Newtown, Obama Urged to Break With NRA & Back Global U.N. Arms Treaty". Democracy Now!. 26 December 2012.
* Belford, Aubrey; Ciesla, Wojciech; Gesina-Torres, Endy; Sarcevic, Lejla (24 February 2018). "How a French Fraudster Climbed the World of International Arms Dealing". Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Unit. Retrieved 18 April 2020.
* Bennett, Ronan; et al. (3 December 2019). "Vote for hope and a decent future". Letters. The Guardian. Retrieved 4 December 2019.
* "Candidates". Candidates. Retrieved 24 May 2024.
* Carter, Fin (4 July 2024). "The left-winger trying to take Starmer's seat". Prospect. Retrieved 8 July 2024.
* Chambers, Dave (29 March 2019). "Activists urge UCT to support academic boycott of Israeli universities". TimesLIVE. Retrieved 18 January 2021.
* "Declassified UK". Daily Maverick. 4 March 2020. Retrieved 18 January 2021.
* Feinstein, Andrew (19 January 2013). "Is society inherently corrupt? A look at the global arms industry and the effect corruption has on our politics, society and culture". South to North (Interview). Interviewed by Redi Tlhabi. Al Jazeera.
* Feinstein, Andrew [@andrewfeinstein] (26 November 2019). "I am Jewish, the son of a Holocaust survivor who lost dozens of her family in the camps. I was the 1st MP to introduce a motion on the Holocaust in the SA Parliament. I've lectured at Auschwitz on genocide prevention. I unequivocally support Jeremy Corbyn & want him as the next PM" (Tweet) – via Twitter.
* Feinstein, Andrew (5 July 2023). "Sanctions Mark II". New Internationalist. Retrieved 4 July 2024.
* Hearst, Katherine (12 February 2024). "UK: Anti-apartheid campaigner Andrew Feinstein set to challenge Starmer in upcoming elections". Middle East Eye. Retrieved 13 February 2024.
* Kamugasa, Stephen (10 August 2020). "Representative Democracy: An Interview with Andrew Feinstein". The Kamugasa Challenge. Retrieved 18 January 2021.
* Mair, Alex (3 July 2024). "An Independent, Pro-Gaza Candidate Claims he can Block Keir Starmer's Election this Thursday". Byline Times. Retrieved 5 July 2024.
* Mulla, Imran (5 July 2024). "Keir Starmer wins reelection in Holborn and St Pancras but vote share slashed". Middle East Eye. Retrieved 8 July 2024.
* Proctor, Kate (3 December 2019). "Coogan and Klein lead cultural figures backing Corbyn and Labour". The Guardian. Retrieved 4 December 2019.
* Rogers, Paul (18 November 2011). "The Shadow World: Inside the Global Arms Trade by Andrew Feinstein". The Independent. Archived from the original on 20 November 2011.
* "Shadow World". Louverture Films.
* "Shadow World Investigations Ltd: Company number 07087435". Companies House. Retrieved 30 June 2024.
* Snow, Jon (29 October 2020). "'I have never seen any evidence of racism, of antisemitism or anything closely related to' – Jewish Labour member Andrew Feinstein on Corbyn". Channel 4 News. Retrieved 18 January 2021.
* Tirman, John (4 November 2011). "The Shadow World: Inside the Global Arms Trade by Andrew Feinstein". The Washington Post.
* "WOW Wales One World Film Festival". Culture Colony (in Welsh). 17 March 2017. Retrieved 8 October 2022.

## Further reading

[edit]

* Israel 'WORSE Than Apartheid': South African Jewish Former ANC Politician Andrew Feinstein, Owen Jones interviewing Feinstein about Palestine, South Africa and the ICJ case, South Africa's genocide case against Israel, 5 January 2024
* The One Video Keir Starmer Doesn't Want You To See (7:49mins)
* Interview with Roger Waters: "Keir Starmer is a Snake", Double Down News, 27 June 2024 (31:30 mins)

## External links

[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Andrew Feinstein.

* Official website
* Profile of, and editorials by, Feinstein on The Guardian

Authority control databases

International|

* ISNI
* VIAF
* FAST
* WorldCat

National|

* Germany
* United States
* Netherlands
* Norway
* Poland
* Israel

Academics|

* CiNii

Artists|

* MusicBrainz

People|

* DDB

Other|

* IdRef
* Yale LUX

*[m.]: married