Asher Raby

Israeli serial killer

Asher Raby

אשר רבי

Born| 1946 (age 78–79)

Jerusalem, Mandatory Palestine

Conviction| N/A (Not guilty by reason of insanity)
Criminal penalty| Involuntary commitment
Details
Victims| 5

Span of crimes

| March – November 1979
Country| Israel
States| Tel Aviv, Central, Nablus

Date apprehended

| 17 November 1982

Asher Raby (Hebrew: אשר רבי; born 1946) is an Israeli serial killer. Subsequently declared insane, he killed five people in several attacks committed across Israel and the West Bank from March to November 1979, with the most prominent of them being Philoumenos Hasapis, the Greek Orthodox hegumen of Jacob's Well. Deemed unfit to stand trial for his crimes, he was acquitted by reason of insanity and confined to a psychiatric facility.[1]

## Early life

[edit]

Asher Raby was born in Jerusalem, Mandatory Palestine in 1946, the eldest of six children born to Afghan Jewish immigrants. He spent his childhood and teenage years in Jerusalem before the entire family moved to Tel Aviv, settling in the city's Shapira neighborhood. Sometime after their move, Raby's father died, and he took over as the main caretaker for his underage siblings.[2]

After becoming an adult, he was drafted into the Israel Defense Forces, where he served in the C4I Corps. After his release, he worked as a truck driver transporting construction materials. He served as part of a reserve unit during the Yom Kippur War.[2] After the war, his mental health rapidly deteriorated, resulting in Raby quitting his job and becoming very religious. According to neighbours, he would go out at night and cry over the destruction of the ancient Holy Temple, would not talk on Saturdays or drink tap water, instead harvesting rainwater from his yard. His clothes were usually torn and slovenly, and he rarely bathed. He sold his truck and car and donated most of the money to yeshivas, using the remainder to purchase a Torah scroll. At some point during the mid-1970s, he opened a grocery store but sold it only three months later after the business failed.[2]

## Murders

[edit]

On 7 March 1979, Raby went to a clinic on 109 Rothschild Boulevard in Tel Aviv and entered the office of Dr. David Kogan, a general practitioner and gynaecologist who worked there. Kogan had a storied history in the city, as he was known for performing abortions and for being an accomplice in a 1962 tax evasion scheme in which he and two other men who worked at a hospital for mentally-impaired children in Ramla attempted to evade IL137,000 in taxes.[3][4] In that case, he was fined IL50,000 and given a 4-month suspended sentence.[5]

Raby was seen entering the doctor's office by a couple who took notice of his slovenly and unkempt appearance. Inside, he waited until Kogan had bent down to examine him, before he pulled out a small axe he had concealed in his coat and hit the doctor on the head, killing him instantly.[6] After the murder, Raby calmly left the clinic, leaving Kogan's wife to find his body later that day.[7] While his body was sent to the Abu Kabir Forensic Institute for an autopsy, a team of investigators spearheaded by Superintendent Shmuel Carmeli looked into the patient records in an attempt to locate any possible clue to who might have killed him and when, but found nothing of value.[8] Further investigation focused on the possibility that Kogan might have been killed for botching an abortion attempt, but yet again, this line of inquiry did not lead to an arrest.[9]

On 10 April, Raby went to the house of the Badra family in Lod. He had attacked them on a previous occasion, approximately two weeks before killing Kogan, and in that case, he had stabbed some of the children and their grandmother Fatma Badra, but failed to kill them and was forced to flee.[10] At around 6:30 PM, he broke into their apartment and went to the bedroom, where he encountered the 37-year-old wife Abigail tending to two of her children. Raby pulled out a grenade and dropped it in the middle of the room. The explosion destroyed one of the walls and injured the children with shrapnel, causing them to burst out crying. This alerted the father, 40-year-old Ahmad, who came to their aid, but was confronted by Raby and gunned down with an Uzi.[10] Abigail went to see what happened but was also shot and severely injured. The two girls who accompanied their mother, 17-year-old Mona and 9-year-old Marilyn, were subsequently gunned down as well. The surviving children (13-year-old Ronit, 16-year-old Lillian and 1-year-old Fouad) and the mother were later driven to a hospital, where they managed to recover from their injuries.[11] After the killings, Raby attempted to run away but was apprehended by two neighbours; however, he threatened to set off a hand grenade he had stolen from an IDF barracks, forcing the men to release him before they could get a good look at him.[10]

In the aftermath of the attacks, police attempted to uncover a possible motive. Ahmad, an Egyptian Muslim, worked at a local Tnuva store and traded in plastic products, while his wife Abigail, a native of Acre, was an ethnic Jewish convert to Islam who had claimed that she had divine powers and could tell people's fortunes, perform witchcraft and even heal people's injuries.[12] While authorities attempted to locate potential clues, three days after the murders, a tractor driver reported that he had seen a suspicious man wearing an army uniform and armed with an Uzi sleeping under a tree in a field not far off from the Badra family household.[13] Upon attempting to approach the man, he was seemingly spooked and fled. The tractor driver provided a description of the man, describing him as about 35 years old, with long hair, a moustache and a beard, a slightly elongated face and a kippah.[10] In July, the police announced a large monetary reward for anyone who could provide information leading to the arrest of a suspect, but nothing fruitful came out of this.

### Murder of Philoumenos Hasapis

[edit]

On 30 November 1979, Raby approached the Bir Ya'qub monastery in Nablus and jumped over the fence. Upon entering the building, he came across the 66-year-old Philoumenos, who was on his way to enter the confessional. Raby then pulled out a grenade and tossed it at him, destroying a nearby wall and injuring the monk, who somehow managed to survive.[6] Believing that he would identify him if he let him live, Raby then grabbed his axe and crashed it down on Philoumenos' head, killing him instantly.[14] After leaving the monastery, he went to a nearby military camp and, pretending to be homeless, was transferred to the Sheba Medical Center in Tel Aviv.[6]

Authorities were quickly dispatched to the crime scene and arrested eight suspects, including one of the monastery's security guards, all of whom were residents of the Askar refugee camp. Each of the suspects' alibis was confirmed after interrogation, and all were released without any charges.[14] Philoumenos' killing became a media sensation not only in Israel, but across the globe, with many rejecting the police's conclusion that the attack was criminal in nature and was instead the work of Zionists. Publications associated with the Greek Orthodox Church claimed that a week before the murder, a group of Zionists had gone to the monastery and claimed that it was a holy Jewish site, demanding that all the icons and crosses be removed at once. Supposedly, Father Philoumenos rebuked their claims and refused to comply, with the group threatening him before leaving. According to this version of events, that same group later returned and broke inside the monastery, pinning down and torturing the monk in an attempt to have him renounce his religion. It was claimed that they supposedly pricked his eyes, chopped off the fingers on his right hand and eventually killed him, before defacing the church with writing inscriptions and Zionist symbols and finally leaving.[15]

## Trial, acquittal, and aftermath

[edit]

On 17 November 1982, Raby attempted to climb the walls of the Bir Ya'qub monastery again but was caught in the act by a monk, who immediately called the police. After being arrested, he was brought to the police station where, after a brief interrogation, he confessed to murdering a priest in 1979 and to attempting to murder a nun in April 1982.[6] In that case, he came across Arad Sirota and a group of pilgrims, and threw a hand grenade at them – fortunately, none were killed.[16] Raby claimed that after this attack, he climbed up Mount Gerizim, where he recited the Torah for two consecutive days.[6] Initially, police were sceptical of his claims, but Raby provided intricate details that eventually linked him to Philoumenos' killing. As the interrogations went on, he admitted to the murders of Kogan and the Badras as well, claiming he had been following divine commands given to him by God, who had instructed him to rid the world of all evil.[17][18]

The arrest came as a shock to Raby's family and neighbours, all of whom considered him friendly and harmless, even if he was known to be an "eccentric."[2] Fearing the possibility of the trial being downgraded to a media circus due to the fact the murder of Philoumenos was committed beyond the Green Line, a gag order was issued on the case. Raby was initially charged solely in Philoumenos' murder, with charges for the remaining killings left pending for possible future trials, with the first case set to take place at the court in Nazareth. However, this never took place, as a psychiatric examination conducted on Raby concluded that he was unfit to stand trial due to his unstable mental health, and because of this, the presiding justice ordered that he be confined to a mental institution.[1] As Israeli law mandates confidentiality of a mental patient's status, nothing further is known of Raby's fate, and if he is still alive, he presumably remains in psychiatric care.[1]

## See also

[edit]

* List of serial killers by country

## References

[edit]

1. ^ a b c Aya Orenstein (17 December 1982). "הנאשם ברצח הכומר – לה ס ת כלות פ סי כ י אט ר ית" [THE DEFENDANT IN THE MURDER OF THE PRIEST – SENT OFF TO PSYCHIATRIST] (in Hebrew). Maariv – via National Library of Israel.
2. ^ a b c d Yitzchak Bachadrin (3 December 1982). "דודיידו III 1 _וו L הו HIL -ע , ד JO וד! -'II ? ! ווו , IIIUP I * JU דו B FJ ה U -ד_? !?! 11•? LIRA 3 לו]!™! ווו שייבש ;_MTPIN" [This is how Asher Raby, suspected of murdering the gynaecologist and the monk, is described by acquaintances] (in Hebrew). Maariv – via National Library of Israel.
3. ^ "נעצר חשוד בהעלמת 28 אלף לירות" [A SUSPECT HAS BEEN ARRESTED FOR THE MISSING 28,000 POUNDS] (in Hebrew). Haaretz. 5 April 1962 – via National Library of Israel.
4. ^ "רופא מואשם בהעלמת 137 אלף ל"י חשד" [A DOCTOR IS ACCUSED OF CONCEALING 137,000 POUNDS] (in Hebrew). Maariv. 17 August 1962 – via National Library of Israel.
5. ^ "קנסות כבדים לעברייני מם" [HEAVY FINES FOR TAX EVADERS] (in Hebrew). LaMerhav. 9 July 1964 – via National Library of Israel.
6. ^ a b c d e Yoffi Viter and Amos Lev (2 December 1982). "המשטרה חוקרת מחדש מעשי רצח ב לת י ־ מפו ע נ ח י ם ש ב וצ ע ו ב ג ר ז ן" [THE POLICE ARE RE-INVESTIGATING MURDERS IN BETHLEHEM.] (in Hebrew). Maariv – via National Library of Israel.
7. ^ "גנ י קולוג נרצח במרפאתו בת"א" [GYNECOLOGIST WAS MURDERED IN HIS CLINIC IN TEL AVIV] (in Hebrew). Davar. 8 March 1979 – via National Library of Israel.
8. ^ "מחפשים שלושת שהיו במידפ^ת חגעקולוג שנרצח" [LOOKING FOR THREE WHO WERE ON WAITING LIST OF MURDERED GYNECOLOGIST] (in Hebrew). Maariv. 9 March 1979 – via National Library of Israel.
9. ^ "האם אירעו תקלות במיהלד טיפולו של ד"ד קוגן בנשים?" [WERE THERE ANY ERRORS IN D.D. KOGAN'S TREATMENT OF WOMEN?] (in Hebrew). Maariv. 12 March 1979 – via National Library of Israel.
10. ^ a b c d ""האלמוני שרצח אב ושתי בנותיו בלוד הוא שדקר בני אותה משפחה לפני 6 שבועות"" [THE MYSTERIOUS PERSON WHO MURDERED A FATHER AND HIS TWO DAUGHTERS IN LOD STABBED MEMBERS OF THE SAME FAMILY 6 WEEKS AGO] (in Hebrew). Maariv. 11 April 1979 – via National Library of Israel.
11. ^ "אבובנוגהרגח האם ד5 ילדים נפצעויר ב י ות בלוד" [Five people injured at a house in Lod] (in Hebrew). Davar. 11 April 1979 – via National Library of Israel.
12. ^ Reuven Shapira (13 April 1979). "טיפול הוטל על הרצח בלוד" [Murder in Lod under investigation] (in Hebrew). Davar – via National Library of Israel.
13. ^ Reuven Shapira (23 April 1979). "חיפושים נרחבים אחר רוצח המשפחה בלוד" [EXTENSIVE SEARCH FOR KILLER OF FAMILY IN LOD] (in Hebrew). Davar – via National Library of Israel.
14. ^ a b Amos Lev (7 December 1979). "תעלומת הרצח בנזוזר" [THE MYSTERIOUS MURDER OF PHILOUMENOS] (in Hebrew). Maariv – via National Library of Israel.
15. ^ David Gurevich, and Yisca Harani. "Philoumenos of Jacob's Well: The Birth of a Contemporary Ritual Murder Narrative." Israel Studies, vol. 22, no. 2, 2017, pp. 26–54. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/10.2979/israelstudies.22.2.02.
16. ^ "כתב־אישום נגד אשר רבי ן על רצח הכומר בשכם" [AN INDICTMENT AGAINST ASHER RABY FOR THE MURDER OF A PRIEST IN NABLUS] (in Hebrew). Davar. 15 December 1982 – via National Library of Israel.
17. ^ Reuven Shapira (5 December 1982). "החוזר בתשובה חשוד גם ברצח שלושה בני משפחה ערבית מלוד" [THE CONVERT IS ALSO SUSPECTED OF MURDERING THREE MEMBERS OF AN ARAB FAMILY IN LOD] (in Hebrew). Davar – via National Library of Israel.
18. ^ "הנאשם ברצה הנזיר האמין שהמנזר בנוי על בית המקדש" [THE DEFENDANT WANTED THE MONK TO BELIEVE THAT THE MONASTERY WAS BUILT ON THE TEMPLE] (in Hebrew). Davar. 17 December 1982 – via National Library of Israel.