Attempted murder

Crime of attempt in various jurisdictions

This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages)

The examples and perspective in this article deal primarily with the United Kingdom and do not represent a worldwide view of the subject. You may improve this article, discuss the issue on the talk page, or create a new article, as appropriate. (July 2009) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

|

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.
Find sources: "Attempted murder" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (August 2011) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

|

(Learn how and when to remove this message)

Part of a series on

Homicide
Murder

Note: Varies by jurisdiction

* Assassination
* Attempted murder
* Child murder
* Consensual homicide
* Contract killing
* Crime of passion
* Depraved-heart murder
* Felony murder rule
* Foeticide
* Honor killing
* Human cannibalism
* Child cannibalism
* Human sacrifice
* Child sacrifice
* Internet homicide
* Lonely hearts killer
* Lust murder
* Lynching
* Mass murder
* Mass shooting
* Mass stabbing
* Misdemeanor murder
* Murder for body parts
* Murder–suicide
* Poisoning
* Proxy murder
* Pseudocommando
* Serial killer
* Angel of mercy
* Spree killer
* Thrill killing
* Torture murder
* Vehicle-ramming attack
* Wrongful execution
* Judicial murder

Manslaughter

* In English law
* Voluntary manslaughter
* Negligent homicide
* Vehicular homicide

Non-criminal homicide

Note: Varies by jurisdiction

* War
* Assisted suicide
* Capital punishment
* Euthanasia
* Foeticide
* Justifiable homicide
* "License to kill"

Family

* Avunculicide/Nepoticide
* Familicide
* Mariticide
* Uxoricide
* Prolicide
* Filicide
* Infanticide
* Neonaticide
* Siblicide
* Fratricide
* Sororicide
* Parricide
* Matricide
* Patricide
* Senicide

Other

* Crucifixion
* Deicide
* Democide
* Friendly fire
* Gendercide
* Femicide
* Androcide
* Genocide
* Omnicide
* Regicide
* Stoning
* Suspicious death
* Tyrannicide
* War crime

* v
* t
* e

Criminal law
Elements

* Actus reus
* Mens rea
* Causation
* Concurrence

Scope of criminal liability

* Accessory
* Accomplice
* Complicity
* Corporate
* Principal
* Vicarious

Severity of offense

* Felony (or Indictable offense)
* Infraction (also called violation)
* Misdemeanor (or Summary offense)

Inchoate offenses

* Attempt
* Conspiracy
* Incitement
* Solicitation

Offense against the person

* Assassination
* Assault
* Battery
* Child abuse
* Criminal negligence
* Defamation
* Domestic violence
* False imprisonment
* Frameup
* Harassment
* Home invasion
* Hate crime
* Homicide
* Human trafficking
* Intimidation
* Kidnapping
* Menacing
* Manslaughter (corporate)
* Mayhem
* Murder
* felony
* Negligent homicide
* Robbery
* Stalking
* Stabbing
* Torture

Sexual offenses

* Adultery
* Bigamy
* Child sexual abuse
* Cybersex trafficking
* Fornication
* Homosexuality
* Incest
* Indecent exposure
* Masturbation
* Obscenity
* Prostitution
* Rape
* Pederasty
* Sex trafficking
* Sexual assault
* Sexual slavery
* Voyeurism

Crimes against property

* Arson
* Arms trafficking
* Blackmail
* Bribery
* Burglary
* Cybercrime
* Embezzlement
* Extortion
* False pretenses
* Forgery
* Fraud
* Gambling
* Intellectual property violation
* Larceny
* Looting
* Payola
* Pickpocketing
* Possessing stolen property
* Robbery
* Smuggling
* Tax evasion
* Theft
* Trespass to land
* Vandalism, Mischief

Crimes against justice

* Compounding
* Malfeasance in office
* Miscarriage of justice
* Misprision
* Obstruction
* Perjury
* Perverting the course of justice

Crimes against the public

* Apostasy
* Begging
* Corruption
* Censorship violation
* Dueling
* Genocide
* Hostage-taking
* Ethnic cleansing
* Smuggling
* Illegal consumption (such as prohibition of drugs, alcohol, and smoking)
* Miscegenation
* Piracy
* Regicide
* Terrorism
* Usurpation
* War crimes

Crimes against animals

* Cruelty to animals
* Poaching
* Wildlife smuggling
* Bestiality

Crimes against the state

* Lèse-majesté
* Treason
* Espionage
* Secession
* Sedition
* Subversion

Defenses to liability

* Actual innocence
* Automatism
* Consent
* Defense of property
* Diminished responsibility
* Duress
* Entrapment
* Ignorantia juris non excusat
* Infancy
* Insanity
* Justification
* Mistake (of law)
* Necessity
* Provocation
* Self-defense

Other common-law areas

* Contracts
* Defenses
* Evidence
* Property
* Torts
* Wills, trusts and estates

Portals

* Law

* v
* t
* e

Attempted murder is a crime of attempt in various jurisdictions.

## Canada

[edit]

Section 239 of the Criminal Code makes attempted murder punishable by a maximum of life imprisonment. If a gun is used, the minimum sentence is four, five or seven years, dependent on prior convictions and relation to organized crime.[1]

## United Kingdom

[edit]

### England and Wales

[edit]

In English criminal law, attempted murder is the crime of simultaneously preparing to commit an unlawful killing and having a specific intention to cause the death of a human being under the King's Peace. The phrase "more than merely preparatory" is specified by the Criminal Attempts Act 1981 to denote the fact that preparation for a crime by itself does not constitute an "attempted crime".

In England and Wales, as an "attempt", attempted murder is an offence under section 1(1) of the Criminal Attempts Act 1981 and is an indictable offence which carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment (the same as the mandatory sentence for murder). The corresponding legislation for Northern Ireland is section 3(1) of the Criminal Attempts and Conspiracy (Northern Ireland) Order 1983 (No.1120 (N.I.13)).

The mens rea (Latin for the "guilty mind") for murder is an intention to kill or cause grievous bodily harm,[2] whereas attempted murder depends on an intention to kill and an overt act towards committing homicide. Attempted murder is only the planning of a murder and acts taken towards it, not the actual killing, which is the murder. This makes the offence very difficult to prove and it is more common for a lesser charge to be preferred under the Offences against the Person Act 1861.

However, in R v Morrison [2003] 1 WLR 1859, the Court of Appeal considered the issue of alternative verdicts on an indictment with a single count of attempted murder. Morrison had gone into a shop with two other men on a robbery with a firearm. They demanded money and one of the men shot at the shopkeeper who suffered only minor injury. The prosecution had many opportunities to add other counts before the trial but failed to act. Having heard the case, the judge expressed his view that the jury could consider an attempted grievous bodily harm (GBH) under section 18 of the 1861 Act and Morrison was duly convicted of attempting to cause grievous bodily harm. The Court of Appeal confirmed that attempting to cause grievous bodily harm is a valid alternative to attempted murder because there can be no intention to kill someone without the intention also to cause grievous bodily harm.

This is a practical decision to ensure that the criminal justice system did not allow a guilty person to walk away because only one charge had been preferred. But it is not necessarily a good general principle[citation needed] because, in euthanasia for example, a person assisting intends to cause death, but with no suffering. That attempting to cause grievous bodily harm must be an alternative verdict should the intended victim not die would be a strange outcome because there is no intention to cause any long-lasting and serious injury: the two attempted offences have different mens rea requirements so that proof of intent to murder would not necessarily meet the requirement for section 18 of the 1861 Act.

First, acting deliberately and intentionally or recklessly with extreme disregard for human life, the person attempted to kill someone; and the person did something that was a substantial step toward committing the crime. Mere preparation is not considered a substantial step toward committing a crime.

#### Proof of mens rea

[edit]

Main article: Mens rea

There must be more than merely preparatory acts and, although the defendant may threaten death, this may not provide convincing evidence of an intention to kill unless the words are accompanied by relevant action, e.g. finding and picking up a weapon and making serious use of it, or making a serious and sustained physical attack without a weapon.

#### Duress, necessity and marital coercion

[edit]

The defences of duress and necessity are not available to a person charged with attempted murder. Conversely, the statutory defence of marital coercion is, on the face of the statute, available to a wife charged with attempted murder.[3][4]

#### History

[edit]

Prior to 1967, sections 11 to 15 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861 created a number of offences of attempting to commit murder by various specified means (ss.11 to 14), and an offence of attempting to commit murder by any means not specified in those offences (s.15).

After the repeal of these offences by the Criminal Law Act 1967, attempted murder was allowed to subsist at common law until the enactment of the 1981 Act.

### Scotland

[edit]

Attempted murder is a crime at common law in Scotland. Attempted murder is the same as the offence of murder in Scots law with the only difference being that the victim has not died.[5] The offence of murder was defined in Drury v HM Advocate:

> [M]urder is constituted by any wilful act causing the destruction of life, by which the perpetrator either wickedly intends to kill or displays wicked recklessness as to whether the victim lives or dies.

Intention can be inferred from the circumstances of the case. Wicked recklessness is determined objectively[6] and is "recklessness so gross that it indicates a state of mind which falls to be treated as wicked and depraved as the state of mind of a deliberate killer."[7] As with all common law offences in Scotland, the maximum punishment available is life imprisonment.

## Two crows joke

[edit]

There is a joke, labelled as a geek-joke or a dad joke:

> \- What do you call two crows on a branch?
>  \- Attempted murder.

> — unknown

The joke is also presented as a picture of two crows on a branch or a bench, and then just the text "Attempted murder" beneath. A group of crows is called a murder as a collective noun. Since just two crows is not considered a group it is not a complete murder.[8]

## See also

[edit]

* Death threat
* People v. Superior Court (Decker)
* State v. Mitchell

## References

[edit]

1. ^ Criminal Code, RSC 1985, c C-46, s 239.
2. ^ Herring, Jonathan (5 May 2022). Criminal Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (10 ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press. p. 221\. ISBN 9780192855923. Retrieved 16 May 2024.
3. ^ Criminal Justice Act 1925 (15 & 16 Geo.5 c.86), section 47
4. ^ Criminal Justice Act (Northern Ireland) 1945 (c.15)(N.I.), section 37
5. ^ Cawthorne v HMA, 1968 JC 32, 36 per LJ-G Clyde.
6. ^ Broadley v HMA, 1991 JC 108, 114 per LJ-C Ross.
7. ^ Scott v HMA, 1996 JC 1, 5 (opinion of the court)
8. ^ Mudie, Keir (13 July 2013). "The world's geekiest jokes explained after Reddit challenge to find most intellectual gag". Irish Mirror. Retrieved 9 May 2024.

Authority control databases: National |

* France
* BnF data

|

* v
* t
* e

Types of crime

Note: Crimes vary by jurisdiction. Not all types are listed here.

Classes|

* Infraction
* Misdemeanor
* Felony
* Summary
* Indictable
* Hybrid
* Corruption

* Law portal

Against the person|

* Assassination
* Assault
* Battery
* Child abuse
* Criminal negligence
* Defamation
* Domestic violence
* False imprisonment
* Frameup
* Harassment
* Home invasion
* Hate crime
* Homicide
* Human trafficking
* Intimidation
* Kidnapping
* Menacing
* Manslaughter (corporate)
* Mayhem
* Murder
* felony
* Negligent homicide
* Robbery
* Stalking
* Stabbing
* Torture

Against property|

* Arson
* Arms trafficking
* Blackmail
* Bribery
* Burglary
* Cybercrime
* Embezzlement
* Extortion
* False pretenses
* Forgery
* Fraud
* Gambling
* Intellectual property violation
* Larceny
* Looting
* Payola
* Pickpocketing
* Possessing stolen property
* Robbery
* Smuggling
* Tax evasion
* Theft
* Trespass to land
* Vandalism, Mischief

Against the public|

* Apostasy
* Begging
* Corruption
* Censorship violation
* Dueling
* Genocide
* Hostage-taking
* Ethnic cleansing
* Smuggling
* Illegal consumption (such as prohibition of drugs, alcohol, and smoking)
* Miscegenation
* Piracy
* Regicide
* Terrorism
* Usurpation
* War crimes

Against the state|

* Lèse-majesté
* Treason
* Espionage
* Secession
* Sedition
* Subversion

Against justice|

* Compounding
* Malfeasance in office
* Miscarriage of justice
* Misprision
* Obstruction
* Perjury
* Perverting the course of justice

Against animals|

* Cruelty to animals
* Poaching
* Wildlife smuggling
* Bestiality

Sexual offenses|

* Adultery
* Bigamy
* Child sexual abuse
* Cybersex trafficking
* Fornication
* Homosexuality
* Incest
* Indecent exposure
* Masturbation
* Obscenity
* Prostitution
* Rape
* Pederasty
* Sex trafficking
* Sexual assault
* Sexual slavery
* Voyeurism

Inchoate offenses|

* Attempt
* Conspiracy
* Incitement
* Solicitation

* WikiSource
* Wikimedia Commons
* Wikiquote
* Wikinews
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template