Black women in American law

African-American women lawyers in the United States face "dual discrimination" for being both Black and women.[1] As of 2022, less than 1% of law firm partners were Black women.[2]

To fight against discrimination, Black women lawyers have founded numerous advocacy organizations. For example, the Black Women Lawyers’ Association of Greater Chicago was formed in 1977. It primarily funds scholarships for Black female law students.[2]

## History[edit]

### 1870s–1930s[edit]

Howard University opened in 1869, and it was the first law school in the United States to open admissions to both male and female applicants. The first Black female lawyer in the United States was Charlotte E. Ray. She attended Howard University, becoming the first Black woman to graduate from an American law school in 1872.[3] Ray was followed by former anti-slavery activist Mary Ann Shadd Cary, who graduated from Howard in 1883.[4] Both women set up law practices in Washington DC, but their businesses did not survive long. The belief that Black women were unqualified to be lawyers was the general attitude of the time. The principal challenge for Black women lawyers of this period was entering the profession. Despite discrimination that they faced, more Black women began to enter the field. Violette Neatley Anderson and Edith Sampson both focused their careers on helping impoverished Black people in Chicago. [3] Ida Platt was the first Black woman admitted to the bar in the state of Illinois in 1894. Her experience differed from other Black women lawyers because she was white-passing.[5] In 1897, Lutie Lytle became the first Black woman faculty member of a law school when she joined Central Tennessee College.[6] In 1926, Clara Burrill Bruce became the first Black editor-in-chief of the Boston University Law Review.[7] In 1927, Sadie Tanner Mossell Alexander became first Black woman to receive a law degree from the University of Pennsylvania Law School.[8] She went on to become the first Black woman to practice law in Pennsylvania.[9] Jane Bolin became the first Black woman judge in the United States in 1939.[10]

### 1940s–early 1960s[edit]

With the onset of World War II, more Black women gained the opportunity to attend law school. They filled the vacancies of men who went off to fight in the war. This contributed to a surge in degrees received by Black women in the late 1940s and early 1950s. From 1952-1953, Black women received 62.4% of all degrees from historically Black colleges and institutions.[11] New Black women lawyers entered the profession as the Civil Rights Movement was emerging, so many engaged in legal activism to promote equal rights and combat racial discrimination.[3] While they made important contributions to the movement, a lack of visibility persisted. The work of Black men was more widely emphasized.[11]

Constance Baker Motley was a prominent figure of this period. She began her career as a lawyer, handling many cases involving discrimination. She worked for the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) in the 1950s.[3] In a society where Black women were considered intellectually inferior, Motley's competence was frequently questioned. Many male lawyers attempted to convince judges in the courtroom that she was unqualified to argue a case. Despite these incidents, Motley advanced in career, eventually becoming the first Black woman appointed to a federal court in 1966.[11] Challenges to her competence continued in her time as a judge. Motley was asked to recuse herself from a gender-discrimination case against Sullivan & Cromwell in New York on the grounds that her identity as a Black woman gave her a conflict of interest. She argued against this idea, affirming that her identity did not affect her ability to be impartial.[12]

Other influential Black women lawyers of this period made progress for racial justice. In 1955, Frankie Freeman (also a lawyer for the NAACP) won the case David v. St Louis Housing Authority, which ruled that the St. Louis Housing Authority could not engage in racially discriminatory practices when renting properties to clients.[3] Ada Lois Sipuel Fisher was the plaintiff in the early landmark civil rights case, Sipuel v. Board of Regents of the University of Oklahoma.[13] She was initially denied admission to the University of Oklahoma law school, so she sued the university on the grounds of segregation. The subsequent ruling lead to her eventual admission to the university. Sipuel was later appointed to the Board of Regents of the University of Oklahoma in 1992.[3]

### Late 1960s–1970s[edit]

Black women lawyers in the late 1960s and into the 1970s began to draw attention to the simultaneous discrimination against Black women in law. While these women were still involved with legal activism in the realm of racial justice, they began to incorporate gender issues into their legal work and scholarship. Conversations about the challenges faced by Black women for their dual identities were met with resistance from both Black men and white women in social justice organizations. Pauli Marray outlined connections between race and gender with her "race-gender analogy argument" that was intended to draw comparisons between discrimination against Black people and discrimination against women. Her goal was to emphasize the lack of inclusion for women in racial justice reform movements. Although her argument treated race and gender as mutually exclusive entities, Marray's work set the stage for the concept of intersectionality.[3]

### 1980s–present[edit]

Increased inclusion of Black women in legal scholarship in the 1980s contributed to the rise of research on the intersection of the two identities. Rather than simply comparing race and gender, Black women lawyers began to focus on the specific struggles faced by Black women. The intersectionality approach was created by Kimberlé Crenshaw in the 1980s. She claimed that society could not consider just blackness or just womanhood when confronting the unique discrimination faced by Black women. The intersection of the two identities of Black and female created different axes of oppression that could not be fully explained by traditional interpretations of racial injustice or injustice against women. The story of Anita Hill, another Black female lawyer, highlights aspects of the intersectionality approach. Criticisms directed at her were those that were historically targeted towards women and Black people separately. She experienced both simultaneously.[3]

Black women of this period continued to break barriers. Historian Annette Gordon-Reed became the first Black woman editor of the Harvard Law Review in 1982.[14] In 2021, there were 28 Black women law school deans in the United States, an all time high.[15] In 2018, 19 Black women were elected to the Harris County courts in Houston.[16] In 2022, Ketanji Brown Jackson became the first Black woman to serve as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States.[17]

## Scholarship[edit]

Academics and lawyers have written about the intersection of Black women and the legal profession on numerous occasions. In 2000, J. Clay Smith Jr., Dean of the Howard University School of Law, published Rebels in Law: Voices in History of Black Women Lawyers with the University of Michigan Press.[18] In 2019, Tsedale M. Melaku's book, You Don't Look Like a Lawyer: Black Women and Systemic Gendered Racism was published by Rowman & Littlefield.[19]

Many of these academic works center the concept of intersectionality. Scholars argue that while the number of Black women in law is increasing, their opportunities for advancement remain limited. They are still considered less capable and less qualified than their white or male counterparts. They are assigned lower-profile cases and passed over for promotions.[1] Tsedale M. Melaku argues in her book that Black women face obstacles when trying to network and form social relationships, and this affects their career advancement. Those holding the seat of power within law firms are typically white men. She claims white men can relate to white women because their presence evokes a sort of sympathy associated with white womens’ similarities to their mothers and wives. White men can relate to Black men on the common ground of manhood. Black women are left with no relation and are thus overlooked by the white men in power. Melaku describes another challenge for Black women in legal professions called "the inclusion tax concept." Black women must use more time, money, and energy to conform to the workplace standards set by white men. This involves discussions of which appearances are deemed professional, specifically about Black women’s hair. She argues that this further contributes to the lack of career advancement for Black women in law firms.[19]

Taneisha N. Means examines discrimination against Black women judges in her article "Her Honor: Black Women Judges' Experiences with Disrespect and Recusal Requests in the American Judiciary" in Journal of Women, Politics & Policy. Despite higher law school attendance rates for Black women than Black men, Black women remain less represented in the courts. Means argues that when evaluating candidates for judicial appointments, the American Bar Association (ABA) is far more likely to give white people and men higher ratings, indicating that they are more qualified (even if that it is not actually true). This affects Black women’s ability to be appointed as judges. Even when they make it to the bench, they face discrimination in the form of “having their legitimacy, authority, and competence questioned.” In line with the story of Constance Baker Motley, many Black women are asked to recuse themselves from cases under claims that their identity as Black women will reduce their ability to be impartial.[20]

Scholars claim that despite major advancements, Black women remain heavily sidelined in legal professions. In a journal article about the concept of intersectionality, Anna Carastathis claims that even the concept of intersectionality itself has been incorporated under the umbrella of women's studies, and attention to its origins in Black feminist thought are often overlooked.[21]

## See also[edit]

* Women in law
* List of first women lawyers and judges in the United States

## References[edit]

1. ^ a b Burleigh, Nina; Goldberg, Stephanie Benson (1988). "Black Women Lawyers Coping With Dual Discrimination". ABA Journal. 74 (6): 64–68. ISSN 0747-0088. JSTOR 20759953.
2. ^ a b Crossley, Nakhia (June 10, 2022). "For Black women lawyers, the needle has barely moved at law firms". Crain's Chicago Business.
3. ^ a b c d e f g h Hearne, Brittany N.; McCammon, Holly J. (2018-02-15). Black Women Cause Lawyers. Vol. 1\. Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/oso/9780190265144.003.0011.
4. ^ "Mary Ann Shadd Cary". Historical Marker Database. Retrieved September 24, 2015.
5. ^ Jordan, Gwen (2017). "A Woman of Strange, Unfathomable Presencee: Ida Platt's Lived Experience of Race, Gender, and Law, 1863-1939". SSRN Electronic Journal. doi:10.2139/ssrn.2965083. ISSN 1556-5068.
6. ^ http://wlh.law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/cunnea-timeline.pdf [bare URL PDF]
7. ^ Jackson, Stacy (2023-01-01). "Three Black Women Law Students Make History As Editors of Three of Penn's Seven Law Journals". Black Enterprise. Retrieved 2024-02-17.
8. ^ Mack, Kenneth Walter (2001–2002). "A Social History of Everyday Practice: Sadie T.M. Alexander and the Incorporation of Black Women into the American Legal Profession, 1925-1960". Cornell Law Review. 87: 1405.
9. ^ "Lawyer Sadie Alexander, a Black pioneer dies at 91". Associated Press. November 3, 1989. Retrieved September 10, 2015. "Sadie Tanner Mosell Alexander, a lawyer and civil rights advocate who achieved many firsts as a black woman, has died of pneumonia at age 91. ..."
10. ^ Goodwin, David L. (February 13, 2017). "1st African-American female judge 'showed the strength of the subtle'". The Poughkeepsie Journal. Archived from the original on 16 December 2019. Retrieved 27 March 2018.
11. ^ a b c Smith, John Clay (1997). "Black women lawyers: 125 years at the bar; 100 years in the legal academy". Howard Law Journal. 40 (2): 365–398 - via HeinOnline.
12. ^ Brown-Nagin, Tomiko (2017). "Identity Matters: The Case of Judge Constance Baker Motley". Columbia Law Review. 117 (7): 1691–1739. ISSN 0010-1958. JSTOR 44425407.
13. ^ Cross, George Lynn (1975). Blacks in White College – Oklahoma's Landmark Cases (1st ed.). Norman: University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 9780806112664. Retrieved July 9, 2021 - via Internet Archive. LCCN 75-1432; ISBN 0-8061-1266-2, 0-8061-1267-0; OCLC 878136644 (all editions)
14. ^ "Annette Gordon-Reed". History Makers. Retrieved 2024-02-16.
15. ^ Norwood, Candice (2022-02-08). "More Black women are leading U.S. law schools and changing the conversation on race and gender". The 19th. Retrieved 2024-02-17.
16. ^ Dewey, Katrina (2022-02-03). "The 19: Creating Black Girl Magic in Texas Courts". Lawdragon. Retrieved 2024-04-29.
17. ^ Bowles, Dorcas Davis; Hopps, June Gary; Strickland, Christopher (2022). "Two Firsts: A Brief Glimpse into the Lives of the First Woman-Sandra Day O'Connor and the First Black Woman- Ketanji Brown Jackson to Serve on the Supreme Court of the United States". Phylon. 59 (1): 49–70. ISSN 0031-8906. JSTOR 27150914.
18. ^ Smith, John Clay. Rebels in Law. University of Michigan Press.
19. ^ a b Melaku, Tsedale M. (2019). You don't look like a lawyer: black women and systemic gendered racism. Lanham Boulder New York: Rowman & Littlefield. ISBN 978-1-5381-0792-8.
20. ^ Means, Taneisha N. (2022-07-03). "Her Honor: Black Women Judges' Experiences with Disrespect and Recusal Requests in the American Judiciary". Journal of Women, Politics & Policy. 43 (3): 310–327. doi:10.1080/1554477X.2022.2068120. ISSN 1554-477X.
21. ^ Carastathis, Anna (May 2014). "The Concept of Intersectionality in Feminist Theory". Philosophy Compass. 9 (5): 304–314. doi:10.1111/phc3.12129. ISSN 1747-9991.