By-elections to the 40th Canadian Parliament

2008–2011 elections for vacant seats

By-elections to the
40th Canadian Parliament

* * *

| ← 2006–2008 | 2008–2011 | 2011–2015 →

|
|

By-elections to the 40th Canadian Parliament were held to fill vacancies in the House of Commons of Canada between the 2008 federal election and the 2011 federal election. The Conservative Party of Canada led a minority government for the entirety of the 40th Canadian Parliament, with little change from by-elections.

Ten seats became vacant during the life of the Parliament. Seven of these vacancies were filled through by-elections, and three seats remained vacant when the 2011 federal election was called.

## Summary

[edit]

Analysis of byelections by turnout and vote share for winning candidate (vs 2008)  Riding and winning party  | Turnout  | Vote share for winning candidate

|
|

%  | Change (pp)  | %  | Change (pp)
Cumberland—Colchester—Musquodoboit Valley | █ Conservative | Gain  | 35.81  | -21.96 |

|  | 45.84  | 37.01 |  | 37.01

Hochelaga | █ Bloc Québécois | Hold  | 22.63  | -35.61 |

|  | 51.16  | 1.43 |  | 1.43

Montmagny—L'Islet—Kamouraska—Rivière-du-Loup | █ Conservative | Gain  | 38.93  | -20.56 |

|  | 50.46  | 8.80 |  | 8.8

New Westminster—Coquitlam | █ New Democratic | Hold  | 29.96  | -31.78 |

|  | 49.59  | 7.76 |  | 7.76

Dauphin—Swan River—Marquette | █ Conservative | Hold  | 26.62  | -28.09 |

|  | 56.49  | -4.87 |

Vaughan | █ Conservative | Gain  | 32.50  | -19.42 |

|  | 49.10  | 14.77 |  | 14.77

Winnipeg North | █ Liberal | Gain  | 30.68  | -12.17 |

|  | 46.32  | 37.11 |  | 37.11

## Overview

[edit]

By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained

|
|
|
|
|
|
|

Vaughan | November 29, 2010  | Maurizio Bevilacqua |  | Liberal | Julian Fantino |  | Conservative | Resigned to run for Mayor of Vaughan | No
Dauphin—Swan River—Marquette | November 29, 2010  | Inky Mark |  | Conservative | Robert Sopuck |  | Conservative | Resigned to run for Mayor of Dauphin | Yes
Winnipeg North | November 29, 2010  | Judy Wasylycia-Leis |  | New Democratic | Kevin Lamoureux |  | Liberal | Resigned to run for Mayor of Winnipeg | No
Cumberland—Colchester—Musquodoboit Valley | November 9, 2009  | Bill Casey |  | Independent | Scott Armstrong |  | Conservative | Resigned to accept appointment with Nova Scotia's Department of Intergovernmental Affairs  | No
Hochelaga | November 9, 2009  | Réal Ménard |  | Bloc Québécois | Daniel Paillé |  | Bloc Québécois | Resigned to run for Montreal City Council | Yes
Montmagny—L'Islet—Kamouraska—Rivière-du-Loup | November 9, 2009  | Paul Crête |  | Bloc Québécois | Bernard Généreux |  | Conservative | Resigned to enter provincial politics  | No
New Westminster—Coquitlam | November 9, 2009  | Dawn Black |  | New Democratic | Fin Donnelly |  | New Democratic | Resigned to enter provincial politics  | Yes

## 2009

[edit]

Four by-elections to fill vacant seats in the House of Commons were held on November 9, 2009. Governor General Michaëlle Jean, acting on the advice of Prime Minister Stephen Harper, issued writs of election for the by-elections on October 4.[1] All four vacancies were caused by resignations.

### New Westminster—Coquitlam

[edit]

The riding of New Westminster—Coquitlam had been vacant since April 13, when Dawn Black resigned to run in the British Columbia provincial election.

By-election on November 9, 2009
resignation of Dawn Black

Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%
| New Democratic | Fin Donnelly | 12,129 | 49.6% | +7.8%
| Conservative | Diana Dilworth | 8,753 | 35.8% | -3.0%
| Liberal | Ken Lee | 2,514 | 10.3% | -1.0%
| Green | Rebecca Helps | 1,046 | 4.3% | -2.9%
Total valid votes  | 24,442
Total rejected ballots  | –
Turnout  | 24,442 | 29.9%
| New Democrat hold |

### Cumberland—Colchester—Musquodoboit Valley

[edit]

The riding of Cumberland—Colchester—Musquodoboit Valley had been vacant since April 30, 2009, when Bill Casey resigned to accept a posting from the provincial government of Nova Scotia.[2]

Scott Armstrong was nominated unopposed by the Conservatives. Farmer Jim Burrows defeated 2008 Liberal candidate Tracy Parsons for the Liberal nomination on September 12, 2009.

By-election on November 9, 2009
Resignation of Bill Casey

Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%
| Conservative | Scott Armstrong | 11,167 | 45.84% | +37.01%
| New Democratic | Mark Austin | 6,267 | 25.73% | +13.41%
| Liberal | Jim Burrows | 5,193 | 21.32% | +12.87%
| Green | Jason Blanch | 803 | 3.30% | +3.30%
| Christian Heritage | Jim Hnatiuk | 776 | 3.19% | +3.19%
| Independent | Kate Graves | 149 | 0.61% |
Total valid votes  | 24,359
Total rejected ballots  | –
Turnout  | 24,359 | 35.7%
| Conservative gain from Independent  |

### Montmagny—L'Islet—Kamouraska—Rivière-du-Loup

[edit]

The riding of Montmagny—L'Islet—Kamouraska—Rivière-du-Loup had been vacant since May 21, when Paul Crête resigned to run as a Parti Québécois candidate in the provincial Rivière-du-Loup by-election.

According to the Regina Leader-Post, Bernard Généreux won the by-election.[3]

By-election on November 9, 2009
resignation of Paul Crête

Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%
| Conservative | Bernard Généreux[4] | 12,162 | 42.7% | +12.07%
| Bloc Québécois | Nancy Gagnon[5] | 10,737 | 37.7% | -8.33%
| Liberal | Marcel Catellier[6][7] | 3,768 | 13.2% | -2.15%
| New Democratic | François Lapointe[8] | 1,363 | 4.8% | -0.65%
| Green | Charles Marois[9] | 472 | 1.7% | -0.49%
Total valid votes  | 28,502
Total rejected ballots  | –
Turnout  | 28,502 | 36.6%
| Conservative gain from Bloc Québécois |

### Hochelaga

[edit]

On June 25, 2009, Réal Ménard announced that he would resign from the Hochelaga constituency effective September 16 to run as a Vision Montreal candidate for borough mayor of Mercier–Hochelaga-Maisonneuve in the fall 2009 municipal elections in Montreal.[10]

Daniel Paillé won the by-election according to CBC News.[11]

By-election on November 9, 2009
resignation of Réal Ménard

Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%
| Bloc Québécois | Daniel Paillé[12] | 8,972 | 51.2% | +1.47%
| New Democratic | Jean-Claude Rocheleau[13] | 3,421 | 19.5% | +5.06%
| Liberal | Robert David[14] | 2,510 | 14.3% | -6.36%
| Conservative | Stéphanie Cloutier[15] | 1,784 | 10.2% | +1.01%
| Green | Christine Lebel[16] | 571 | 3.3% | -0.95%
| neorhino.ca | Gabrielle Anctil[17] | 129 | 0.7% | +0.2%
| Marxist–Leninist | Christine Dandenault[18] | 79 | 0.5% | +0.12%
| Independent | John Turmel[18] | 71 | 0.4% | ø
Total valid votes  | 17,526
Total rejected ballots  | –
Turnout  | 17,526 | 22.3%
| Bloc Québécois hold | Swing | {{{3}}}

## 2010

[edit]

Three by-elections were held on November 29, 2010, in order to fill vacancies in the House of Commons of Canada for two seats in Manitoba and one seat in Ontario. Until pre-empted by the issuance of writs for the 41st federal election, a further three by-elections were pending for one seat in Alberta, one seat in Quebec and one seat in British Columbia.[19]

### Background

[edit]

The three seats were vacant due to the resignations of Inky Mark, Judy Wasylycia-Leis, and Maurizio Bevilacqua from the House of Commons. The incumbents had resigned their seats to run for the mayoralty of their hometowns in municipal elections. Bevilacqua was subsequently elected mayor of Vaughan, Ontario while Wasylycia-Leis and Mark were defeated in their attempts. A further three seats, Calgary Centre-North, Haute-Gaspésie—La Mitis—Matane—Matapédia and Prince George—Peace River also became vacant in late October or November, however these vacancies occurred too late to be included in the November 29 by-election call.

### Timing

[edit]

Under Canadian election law, a by-election must be formally announced no earlier than 11 days and no later than 180 days after a vacancy officially takes effect. Due to the timing of the respective resignations, this means that the date of the Winnipeg North by-election had to be announced by October 27, while the scheduling period for all of the other four by-elections extended into 2011.[20] Consequently, the Winnipeg North by-election had to be called at least a week before the window opened in which Prince George—Peace River and Haute-Gaspésie—La Mitis—Matane—Matapédia by-elections could be called.

When multiple vacancies exist, it is customary, though not mandatory, for by-elections to be held on the same date.

### Dauphin—Swan River—Marquette

[edit]

A by-election was held in the Manitoba federal riding of Dauphin—Swan River—Marquette as incumbent MP Inky Mark resigned effective September 15, 2010 as the Conservative Party of Canada Member of Parliament in order to run unsuccessfully for mayor of Dauphin, Manitoba.[21]

By-election on November 29, 2010
resignation of Inky Mark on September 15, 2010

Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%
| Conservative | Robert Sopuck | 8,176 | 56.7% | -4.66%
| New Democratic | Denise Harder | 3,785 | 26.3% | +9.67%
| Liberal | Christopher Scott Sarna | 1,481 | 10.3% | -3.67%
| Green | Kate Storey | 809 | 5.6% | -0.91%
| Christian Heritage | Jerome Dondo | 160 | 1.1% | -0.10%
Total valid votes  | 14,411
Total rejected ballots  | –
Turnout  | – | 26.9
| Conservative hold |

### Vaughan

[edit]

A by-election was held in the Ontario federal riding of Vaughan as Liberal Maurizio Bevilacqua resigned to run successfully for mayor of Vaughan, Ontario.[22]

* v
* t
* e

Canadian federal by-election, November 29, 2010: Vaughan
resignation of Maurizio Bevilacqua on September 2, 2010

Party  | Candidate  | Votes | % | ±% | Expenditures
| Conservative | Julian Fantino | 19,290 | 49.10 | +14.77 | –
| Liberal | Tony Genco | 18,326 | 46.65 | -2.53 | –
| New Democratic | Kevin Bordian | 661 | 1.68 | -7.96 | –
| Green | Claudia Rodriguez-Larrain | 481 | 1.22 | -5.64 | –
| Libertarian | Paolo Fabrizio | 251 | 0.64 | – | –
| Independent | Leslie Bory | 111 | 0.28 | – | –
| Progressive Canadian | Dorian Baxter | 110 | 0.28 | – | –
| United | Brian Jedan | 55 | 0.14 | – | –
Total valid votes/expense limit  | 39,285 | 100.00 |   | $114,412
Total rejected ballots  | 231 | 0.58 | -0.16
Turnout  | 39,516 | 32.50 | -19.42
| Conservative gain from Liberal | Swing | -8.6

### Winnipeg North

[edit]

A by-election was held in the Manitoba federal riding of Winnipeg North after New Democratic Party MP Judy Wasylycia-Leis resigned to run unsuccessfully for Mayor of Winnipeg. The seat had been vacant for almost seven months by the time of the vote.

With the addition of the Pirate Party candidate Jeff Coleman, the by-election in Winnipeg North marked the first election or by-election to run a member of the Pirate Party outside of Europe.[23]

By-election on November 29, 2010
resignation of Judy Wasylycia-Leis on April 30, 2010

Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%
| Liberal | Kevin Lamoureux | 7,303 | 46.3 | +37.08
| New Democratic | Kevin Chief | 6,508 | 41.2 | −21.41
| Conservative | Julie Javier | 1,645 | 10.4 | −11.95
| Green | John Harvie | 114 | 0.7 | −4.05
| Pirate | Jeff Coleman | 94 | 0.6 | N/A
| Communist | Frank Komarniski | 71 | 0.4 | −0.27
| Christian Heritage | Eric Truijen | 45 | 0.3 | N/A
Total valid votes  | 15,780
Total rejected ballots  | –
Turnout  | – | 30.8
| Liberal gain from New Democrat |

## 2011

[edit]

### Cancelled by-elections

[edit]

Until pre-empted by the issuance of writs for the 41st federal election, three federal by-elections were pending in 2011 to fill vacant seats in the House of Commons.

#### Calgary Centre-North

[edit]

A by-election call was pending in the Alberta federal riding of Calgary Centre-North, where Conservative MP Jim Prentice announced on November 4, 2010 he was resigning as Environment Minister effective immediately and that he would be resigning as Member of Parliament for Calgary Centre-North by the end of the year to take a job as vice-chairman of the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce.[24] Prentice resigned as the Conservative Member of Parliament for Calgary Centre-North on November 14, 2010.[25] The Prime Minister theoretically had until May 2, 2011 to call a by-election.

Soon after the announcement of Prentice's impending resignation, both Ric McIver and Barb Higgins – the second and third place mayoralty finishers in the 2010 municipal election in Calgary – expressed interest in running for the Conservative Party nomination in Calgary Centre-North.[26] Current Calgary-Foothills MLA Len Webber and recent aldermanic candidate Sean Chu were also rumored to be testing the waters. Ultimately, university administrator and Calgary—Nose Hill riding president Michelle Rempel was acclaimed as the Conservative candidate on December 17, 2010.[27]

Former Ontario Liberal MP Robert Nault and former mayor of Calgary Dave Bronconnier were rumored to be seeking the Liberal nomination. However, Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff appointed Stephen Randall – a University of Calgary professor and the former dean of the Faculty of Social Sciences – as the party's candidate on January 6, 2011.[28]

Heather MacIntosh was nominated to replace Dr. Eric Donovan as the Green Party candidate after winning a three way nomination contest on October 26, 2010.

By-election on superseded by federal election
resignation of Jim Prentice on November 14, 2010

Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%
| Conservative | Michelle Rempel | 28,443 | 56.45% | -0.08%
| New Democratic | Paul Vargis | 8,030 | 15.94% | +0.62%
| Liberal | Stephen Randall | 7,114 | 14.12% | +2.35%
| Green | Heather MacIntosh | 6,558 | 13.02% | -2.09%
| Marxist–Leninist | Peggy Askin | 209 | 0.41% | +0.03%
Total valid votes  | 50,384 | 100.00%
Total rejected ballots  | –
Turnout  | 50,384 | 60.1%

#### Haute-Gaspésie—La Mitis—Matane—Matapédia

[edit]

A by-election was pending in the Quebec federal riding of Haute-Gaspésie—La Mitis—Matane—Matapédia, where Bloc Québécois MP Jean-Yves Roy resigned on October 22, 2010 as a result of chronic health problems.[29] The Prime Minister theoretically had until April 20, 2011 to drop the writ for a by-election in that riding.

By-election on superseded by general election
resignation of Jean-Yves Roy on October 22, 2010

Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%
| Bloc Québécois | Jean-François Fortin | 12,633 | 36.05 | -1.48
| Liberal | Nancy Charest | 8,964 | 25.58 | -10.02
| New Democratic | Joanie Boulet | 7,484 | 21.36 | +16.67
| Conservative | Allen Cormier | 5,253 | 14.99 | -3.08
| Green | Louis Drainville | 707 | 2.02 | -1.55
Total valid votes  | 35,041 | 100.00
Total rejected ballots  | 393 | 1.11 | +0.07
Turnout  | 35,434 | 59.81 | +5.43
Eligible voters  | 59,242 | –

#### Prince George—Peace River

[edit]

A by-election was pending in the British Columbia federal riding of Prince George—Peace River due to the resignation of Conservative MP Jay Hill on October 25, 2010. Prime Minister Harper had until April 22, 2011 to call a by-election.[30]

Notably, in his resignation announcement Hill appeared to suggest that he expected the 41st federal election to be called before a by-election could take place in this riding. He was correct; the Harper government lost a confidence motion on March 25, 2011, triggering an election.[31]

Persons seeking the Conservative Party nomination were former Prince George mayor Colin Kinsley,[30] Tumbler Ridge councilor Jerrilyn Schembri, Prince George city councilor Cameron Stolz, Fort St. John councillors Don Irwin and Dan Davies and Conservative riding association CEO Bob Zimmer.[32] Bob Zimmer was declared the Conservative candidate following a March 11, 2011 nomination meeting in Prince George.[33]

Hilary Crowley was announced as the Green Party candidate on November 12, 2010.[34] Former Deputy Premier and Prince George area MLA, Lois Boone as acclaimed as the NDP candidate on November 27, 2010.[35]

On March 28, 2011, lawyer Ben Levine was nominated as the Liberal candidate.[36]

By-election on superseded by general election
resignation of Jay Hill on October 25, 2010

Party  | Candidate  | Votes  | %  | ±%
| Conservative | Bob Zimmer | 23,946 | 62.12 | -1.47
| New Democratic | Lois Boone | 9,876 | 25.62 | +8.04
| Green | Hilary Crowley | 2,301 | 5.97 | -4.44
| Liberal | Ben Levine | 2,008 | 5.21 | -3.20
| Pirate | Jeremy Cote | 415 | 1.08 |
Total valid votes  | 38,546 | 100.00
Total rejected ballots  | –
Turnout  | – | –

## See also

[edit]

* List of federal by-elections in Canada

## References

[edit]

1. ^ "Elections Canada". Elections.ca. Retrieved June 13, 2012.
2. ^ "Bill Casey leaving politics for government job"[permanent dead link], Truro Daily News, April 27, 2009.
3. ^ [1][dead link]
4. ^ http://www.radio-canada.ca/regions/est-quebec/2009/09/23/002-investiture_genereux.shtml Radio-Canada.ca (in French)
5. ^ Article title[usurped] (in French)
6. ^ "Le Parti libéral du Canada (Québec) annonce la candidature de Marcel Catellier à l'élection partielle dans Montmagny - L'Islet - Kamouraska - Rivière-du-Loup". Cnw.ca. Retrieved June 13, 2012.
7. ^ http://www.infodimanche.com/index.asp?s=detail_actualite&ID=132701 (in French)
8. ^ http://punditsguide.ca/ Pundit's Guide
9. ^ "Green Party of Canada". Archived from the original on February 4, 2012. Retrieved August 25, 2017.
10. ^ "Bloc MP runs for municipal politics". CTV News, June 25, 2009.
11. ^ "CBCNews.ca". Cbc.ca. November 9, 2009. Retrieved June 13, 2012.
12. ^ "Day 32: Daniel Paillé « Canadian By-Elections". Canadianbyelections.wordpress.com. October 9, 2009. Retrieved June 13, 2012.
13. ^ https://www.ledevoir.com/2009/08/04/261570.html Le Devoir (in French)
14. ^ http://www.cnw.ca/fr/releases/archive/October2009/06/c4616.html (in French)
15. ^ Campaign Website
16. ^ Green Party of Canada
17. ^ http://www.neorhino.ca/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1036&Itemid=1 Neorhino.ca (in French)
18. ^ a b "Elections Canada". Elections.ca. Retrieved June 13, 2012.
19. ^ "Harper calls 3 by-elections, including Grit stronghold Vaughan", Globe and Mail, October 24, 2010
20. ^ "The Emerging Shape of the By-Election Calendar". Pundits' Guide, October 2010.
21. ^ "Inky hopes to make a Mark as mayor again", Winnipeg Free Press, August 17, 2010
22. ^ "Bevilacqua confirms Vaughan mayoral run", CBC News, September 3, 2010
23. ^ "Winnipeg North first Canadian battleground for Pirate Party". The Toronto Star. November 4, 2010.
24. ^ Jim Prentice leaves politics for CIBC. The Globe and Mail, November 4, 2010.
25. ^ "Jim Prentice to resign", Toronto Sun, November 4, 2010
26. ^ "Mayoral hopefuls eye federal run". CTV News, November 5, 2010.
27. ^ "New Tory candidate acclaimed in Prentice's old riding"[permanent dead link]The Calgary Herald, December 18, 2010.
28. ^ "Liberals pick candidate to fight for Prentice's old seat" Archived 2011-02-25 at the Wayback MachineThe Calgary Herald, January 7, 2011.
29. ^ "Jean-Yves Roy quitte la politique", Radio-Canada, October 22, 2010
30. ^ a b "Kinsley seeks Conservative nod in Prince George-Peace River", Prince George Free News, October 22, 2010
31. ^ Gloria Galloway (December 17, 2011). "Harper government falls in historic Commons showdown". Toronto: The Globe and Mail. Retrieved June 13, 2012.
32. ^ "Five candidates now in the running for Conservative nomination". energeticcity.ca, October 8, 2010.
33. ^ Williams, Arthur. "Zimmer wins Conservative nomination".The Prince George Citizen, March 12, 2011.
34. ^ "Green Party announces federal candidate for riding". energeticcity.ca, November 12, 2010.
35. ^ "Lois Boone Nabs Candidacy for NDP Prince George-Peace River MP By-election" Archived 2011-07-12 at the Wayback Machine. hqprincegeorge.com, November 27, 2010.
36. ^ "Local lawyer to represent Liberal Party". Prince George Citizen. March 29, 2011. Retrieved June 13, 2012.

* v
* t
* e

Federal elections and referendums in Canada

General elections|

* 1867
* 1872
* 1874
* 1878
* 1882
* 1887
* 1891
* 1896
* 1900
* 1904
* 1908
* 1911
* 1917
* 1921
* 1925
* 1926
* 1930
* 1935
* 1940
* 1945
* 1949
* 1953
* 1957
* 1958
* 1962
* 1963
* 1965
* 1968
* 1972
* 1974
* 1979
* 1980
* 1984
* 1988
* 1993
* 1997
* 2000
* 2004
* 2006
* 2008
* 2011
* 2015
* 2019
* 2021
* 2025
* Next

By-elections|

* 1st (1867–1872)
* 2nd (1873–1874)
* 3rd (1874–1878)
* 4th (1879–1882)
* 5th (1883–1887)
* 6th (1887–1891)
* 7th (1891–1896)
* 8th (1896–1900)
* 9th (1901–1904)
* 10th (1905–1908)
* 11th (1909–1911)
* 12th (1911–1917)
* 13th (1918–1921)
* 14th (1921–1925)
* 15th (1926)
* 16th (1926–1930)
* 17th (1930–1935)
* 18th (1936–1940)
* 19th (1940–1945)
* 20th (1945–1949)
* 21st (1949–1953)
* 22nd (1953–1957)
* 23rd (1957–1958)
* 24th (1958–1962)
* 25th (1962–1963)
* 26th (1963–1965)
* 27th (1965–1968)
* 28th (1968–1972)
* 29th (1973–1974; no by-elections)
* 30th (1974–1979)
* 31st (1979)
* 32nd (1980–1984)
* 33rd (1984–1988)
* 34th (1988–1993)
* 35th (1994–1997)
* 36th (1997–2000)
* 37th (2000–2004)
* 38th (2004–2006)
* 39th (2006–2008)
* 40th (2008–2011)
* 41st (2011–2015)
* 42nd (2015–2019)
* 43rd (2019–2021)
* 44th (2021–2025)
* 45th (2025–present)

Referendums|

* 1898
* 1942
* 1992

* Federal political parties
* Federal electoral districts
* Historical federal electoral districts

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template