Charles E. Lindblom

American political scientist (1917–2018)

Charles E. Lindblom

Born| (1917-03-21)March 21, 1917[1]
Died| January 30, 2018(2018-01-30) (aged 100)
Citizenship| American
Alma mater| University of Chicago
Known for| incrementalism (muddling through), pluralism, comparative politics
Scientific career
Fields| Political science
Institutions| Yale University
Doctoral advisor| Frank H. Knight

Charles Edward Lindblom (March 21, 1917 – January 30, 2018) was an American academic who studied economics[2] at the University of Chicago and was Sterling Professor emeritus of political science and economics at Yale University. He served as president of the American Political Science Association and the Association for Comparative Economic Studies, as well as director of Yale's Institute for Social and Policy Studies.

## Academic work

[edit]

Lindblom was one of the early developers and advocates of the theory of incrementalism in policy and decision-making.[3][4][5] That view (also called gradualism) takes a "baby-steps," "muddling through," or "Echternach-theory" approach to decision-making processes. In it, policy change is, under most circumstances, evolutionary, rather than revolutionary. He came to that view through his extensive studies of welfare policies and trade unions throughout the industrialized world. Those views are set out in two articles separated by 20 years: "The Science Of 'Muddling Through'" (1959) and “Still Muddling, Not yet through” (1979), both of which were published in Public Administration Review.

Together with his friend, colleague, and fellow Yale Professor Robert A. Dahl, Lindblom was a champion of the polyarchy (or pluralistic) view of political elites and governance in the late 1950s and the early 1960s. According to that view, no single monolithic elite controls government and society but rather a series of specialized elites competing and bargaining with one another for control. It is this peaceful competition and compromise between elites in politics and the marketplace that drives free-market democracy and allows it to thrive.

However, Lindblom soon began to see the shortcomings of polyarchy with regard to democratic governance. When certain groups of elites gain crucial advantages, become too successful and begin to collude with one another instead of compete, polyarchy can easily turn into corporatism or oligarchy.

Lindblom died on January 30, 2018, at the age of 100.[6]

### Politics and Markets (1977)

[edit]

In his best known work, Politics And Markets (1977), Lindblom notes the "privileged position of business in polyarchy". He also introduces the concept of "circularity", or "controlled volitions," in which "even in the democracies, masses are persuaded to ask from elites only what elites wish to give them." Thus, any real choices and competition are limited. Worse still, any development of alternative choices or even any serious discussion and consideration of them is effectively discouraged. An example is the political party system in the United States, which is almost completely dominated by two powerful parties, which often reduce complex issues and decisions to two simple choices. Related to that is the concurrent concentration of the mass communications media into an oligopoly, which effectively controls who gets to participate in the national dialogue and who suffers a censorship of silence.

Politics And Markets provoked a wide range of critical reactions that extended beyond the realms of academia. The Mobil Corporation took out a full page ad in The New York Times to denounce it.[7] This helped the book achieve greater notoriety, which in turn helped it get onto The New York Times Best Seller list, a rarity for a scholarly work. His criticism of democratic capitalism and polyarchy and his seeming praise for the political economy of Tito's Yugoslavia, Lindblom was (perhaps predictably) labeled a "closet communist" and a "creeping socialist" by conservative critics in the west. Marxist and communist critics chided him for not going far enough. Originally, Dahl too disagreed with many of Lindblom's observations and conclusions, but in a later work How Democratic Is the American Constitution?, he also became critical of polyarchy in general and its U.S. form in particular.

Lindblom elaborated on his work in a 1982 Journal of Politics article.[8] According to Lindblom, it is difficult for politicians to implement change when those changes adversely affect those who control capital, who also create the conditions that determine the success of society. Unlike other actors, who must proactively advocate for and against policies, the owners of capital can, by virtue of their importance for society, shape public policy decisions.[9]

In The Market System: What It Is, How It Works, and What to Make of It (2001), Lindblom echoed and expanded upon many of his concerns raised in Politics And Markets. The most important of them is that the market system is the best mechanism yet devised for creating and fostering wealth and innovation, but it is not very efficient at assigning non-economic values and distributing social or economic justice.

## Select bibliography

[edit]

* Lindblom, Charles E. (1959), "The handling of norms in policy analysis", in Abramovitz, Moses; et al. (eds.), The allocation of economic resources: essays in honor of Bernard Francis Haley, Stanford, California: Stanford University Press, OCLC 490147128.
* Lindblom, Charles E. (1959), The science of 'muddling through'. Public Administration Review, 19, pp. 79–88.
* Lindblom, Charles E.; Braybrooke, David (1963), A strategy of decision: policy evaluation as a social process. Free Press.
* Lindblom, Charles E. (1965), The intelligence of democracy, Free Press.
* Lindblom, Charles E.; Dahl, Robert A. (1976), Politics, economics, and welfare: planning and politico-economic systems resolved into basic social processes, with a new preface by the authors. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
* Lindblom, Charles E. (1977), Politics and markets: the world's political-economic systems, New York: Basic Books.
* Lindblom, Charles E. (1979), Still muddling, not yet through "Public Administration Review", 39, pp. 517–526.
* Lindblom, Charles E.; Cohen, David K. (1979), Usable knowledge: social science and social problem solving, New Haven : Yale University Press
* Lindblom, Charles E. (1984), The policy-making process (2nd edition), Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.
* Lindblom, Charles E. (1990), "Inquiry and change: the troubled attempt to understand and shape society", Yale University Press
* Lindblom, Charles E.; Woodhouse, Edward J. (1993), The policy-making process, 3rd. ed. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
* Lindblom, Charles E. (2001), The market system: what it is, how it works, and what to make of it, Yale University Press.
* Blockland, Hans; Rune Premfors, and Ross Zucker (2018), "In Memoriam: Charles Edward Lindblom, APSA President (1980–1981)" PS: Political Science & Politics (Vol. 51, No.2, April 2018).

## References

[edit]

1. ^ "California, Birth Index, 1905–1995". FamilySearch. Retrieved 2 August 2013.
2. ^ Premfors, Rune (1981). "Charles Lindblom and Aaron Wildavsky". British Journal of Political Science. 11 (2): 201–225. doi:10.1017/S000712340000257X. ISSN 0007-1234. JSTOR 193583. S2CID 145720891.
3. ^ Migone, Andrea; Howlett, Michael (2016-07-07). Lodge, Martin; Page, Edward C.; Balla, Steven J. (eds.). Charles E. Lindblom, "The Science of Muddling Through". Vol. 1\. Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199646135.013.33. ISBN 978-0-19-964613-5.
4. ^ Bendor, Jonathan (1995). "A Model of Muddling Through". American Political Science Review. 89 (4): 819–840. doi:10.2307/2082511. ISSN 1537-5943. JSTOR 2082511. S2CID 145339241.
5. ^ Allison, Christine Rothmayr; Saint-Martin, Denis (2011). "Half a century of "muddling": Are we there yet?". Policy and Society. 30 (1): 1–8. doi:10.1016/j.polsoc.2010.12.001. hdl:1866/18545. ISSN 1449-4035. S2CID 143551170.
6. ^ "Charles Edward Lindblom Obituary, Santa Fe New Mexican". Legacy.com. Retrieved 13 February 2017.
7. ^ Mobil Corporation, 'Business and Pluralism,' New York Times, 9 February 1978, A21
8. ^ Lindblom, Charles E. (1982-05-01). "The Market as Prison". The Journal of Politics. 44 (2): 324–336. doi:10.2307/2130588. ISSN 0022-3816. JSTOR 2130588. S2CID 153609636.
9. ^ Fung, Archon (2008-01-01). "The Principle of Affected Interests: An Interpretation and Defense". `{{cite journal}}`: Cite journal requires `|journal=` (help)

## External links

[edit]

Wikiquote has quotations related to Charles E. Lindblom.

* Yale Faculty Biography
* Making Moral Sense of the Market: A Presbyterian minister's perspective on Lindblom
* A concise but complete summary of Lindblom's The Policy Making Process
* Text of: Still muddling through

* v
* t
* e

Presidents of the American Political Science Association

1903–1925|

* Frank Johnson Goodnow (1903–1905)
* Albert Shaw (1905–1906)
* Frederick N. Judson (1906–1907)
* James Bryce (1907–1908)
* A. Lawrence Lowell (1908–1909)
* Woodrow Wilson (1909–1910)
* Simeon E. Baldwin (1910–1911)
* Albert Bushnell Hart (1911–1912)
* Westel W. Willoughby (1912–1913)
* John Bassett Moore (1913–1914)
* Ernst Freund (1914–1915)
* Jesse Macy (1915–1916)
* Munroe Smith (1916–1918)
* Henry Jones Ford (1918–1919)
* Paul Samuel Reinsch (1919–1920)
* Leo Stanton Rowe (1920–1921)
* William Archibald Dunning (1921–1922)
* Harry Augustus Garfield (1922–1923)
* James Wilford Garner (1923–1924)
* Charles Edward Merriam (1924–1925)

1925–1950|

* Charles A. Beard (1925–1926)
* William B. Munro (1926–1927)
* Jesse S. Reeves (1927–1928)
* John A. Fairlie (1928–1929)
* Benjamin F. Shambaugh (1929–1930)
* Edward Samuel Corwin (1930–1931)
* William F. Willoughby (1931–1932)
* Isidor Loeb (1932–1933)
* Walter J. Shepard (1933–1934)
* Francis W. Coker (1934–1935)
* Arthur N. Holcombe (1935–1936)
* Thomas Reed Powell (1936–1937)
* Clarence Addison Dykstra (1937–1938)
* Charles Grove Haines (1938–1939)
* Robert C. Brooks (1939–1940)
* Frederic A. Ogg (1940–1941)
* William Anderson (1941–1942)
* Robert E. Cushman (1942–1943)
* Leonard D. White (1943–1944)
* John Gaus (1944–1945)
* Walter F. Dodd (1945–1946)
* Arthur MacMahon (1946–1947)
* Henry R. Spencer (1947–1948)
* Quincy Wright (1948–1949)
* James K. Pollock (1949–1950)

1950–1975|

* Peter H. Odegard (1950–1951)
* Luther Gulick (1951–1952)
* E. Pendleton Herring (1952–1953)
* Ralph Bunche (1953–1954)
* Charles McKinley (1954–1955)
* Harold Lasswell (1955–1956)
* Elmer Eric Schattschneider (1956–1957)
* V. O. Key Jr. (1957–1958)
* R. Taylor Cole (1958–1959)
* Carl Brent Swisher (1959–1960)
* Emmette Redford (1960–1961)
* Charles S. Hyneman (1961–1962)
* Carl Joachim Friedrich (1962–1963)
* C. Herman Pritchett (1963–1964)
* David Truman (1964–1965)
* Gabriel Almond (1965–1966)
* Robert A. Dahl (1966–1967)
* Merle Fainsod (1967–1968)
* David Easton (1968–1969)
* Karl Deutsch (1969–1970)
* Robert E. Lane (1970–1971)
* Heinz Eulau (1971–1972)
* Robert E. Ward (1972–1973)
* Avery Leiserson (1973–1974)
* J. Austin Ranney (1974–1975)

1975–2000|

* James MacGregor Burns (1975–1976)
* Samuel Beer (1976–1977)
* John Wahlke (1977–1978)
* Leon Epstein (1978–1979)
* Warren Miller (1979–1980)
* Charles E. Lindblom (1980–1981)
* Seymour Martin Lipset (1981–1982)
* William H. Riker (1982–1983)
* Philip Converse (1983–1984)
* Richard Fenno (1984–1985)
* Aaron Wildavsky (1985–1986)
* Samuel P. Huntington (1986–1987)
* Kenneth Waltz (1987–1988)
* Lucian Pye (1988–1989)
* Judith N. Shklar (1989–1990)
* Theodore J. Lowi (1990–1991)
* James Q. Wilson (1991–1992)
* Lucius Barker (1992–1993)
* Charles O. Jones (1993–1994)
* Sidney Verba (1994–1995)
* Arend Lijphart (1995–1996)
* Elinor Ostrom (1996–1997)
* M. Kent Jennings (1997–1998)
* Matthew Holden (1998–1999)
* Robert Keohane (1999–2000)

2000–present|

* Robert Jervis (2000–2001)
* Robert D. Putnam (2001–2002)
* Theda Skocpol (2002–2003)
* Susanne Hoeber Rudolph (2003–2004)
* Margaret Levi (2004–2005)
* Ira Katznelson (2005–2006)
* Robert Axelrod (2006–2007)
* Dianne Pinderhughes (2007–2008)
* Peter J. Katzenstein (2008–2009)
* Henry E. Brady (2009–2010)
* Carole Pateman (2010–2011)
* G. Bingham Powell (2011–2012)
* Jane Mansbridge (2012–2013)
* John Aldrich (2013–2014)
* Rodney E. Hero (2014–2015)
* Jennifer Hochschild (2015–2016)
* David A. Lake (2016–2017)
* Kathleen Thelen (2017–2018)
* Rogers Smith (2018–2019)
* Paula D. McClain (2019–2020)
* Janet M. Box-Steffensmeier (2020–2021)
* John Ishiyama (2021–2022)
* Lisa Martin (2022–2023)
* Mark E. Warren (2023–present)

Authority control databases

International|

* ISNI
* VIAF
* FAST
* WorldCat

National|

* Germany
* United States
* France
* BnF data
* Japan
* Czech Republic
* Spain
* Netherlands
* Latvia
* Korea
* Sweden
* Poland
* Israel
* Catalonia
* Belgium

Academics|

* CiNii
* Mathematics Genealogy Project

Other|

* IdRef
* SNAC

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template