City Club of Cleveland

Debate forum in Cleveland, Ohio, US

The City Club of ClevelandFormation| October 28, 1912; 112 years ago (1912-10-28)

|

Founders| Mayo Fesler and Augustus Hatton
Type| Non-Profit
Purpose| non-partisan debate forum
Headquarters| 1317 Euclid Avenue, Suite 100 Cleveland, OH 44115

Region served

| Cleveland, Ohio, (United States)

Chief Executive Officer

| Dan Moulthrop
Website| CityClub.org

The City Club of Cleveland is a non-partisan debate forum in Cleveland, Ohio. Founded in 1912, and known as "America's Citadel of Free Speech," it is one of the oldest continuous independent free speech forums in the United States.[1][2]

The City Club's home is in the Playhouse Square District, located at 1317 Euclid Avenue. The building was formerly a F.W. Woolworth department store, and was most recently occupied by Dwellworks. The City Club moved to their current location in September 2023, after four decades at the City Club Building, formerly the Citizens Building, on Euclid Avenue in Downtown Cleveland.

The mission of the City Club is to "create conversations of consequence that help democracy thrive."[2] Membership is open to anyone and all programs are open to the general public, although members are charged lower prices to attend most forums and given preference in making reservations to certain programs.[3]

## History

[edit]

The City Club was conceived at a luncheon in June 1912 organized by Mayo Fesler, secretary of the Cleveland Municipal Association, in the ideals of the Progressive Era.[4] Future Cleveland City Manager Daniel E. Morgan was its first president.[1] Since its founding, it has hosted sitting U.S. Presidents and Vice-Presidents and other notable citizens of the United States and the world.[5] Archbishop Desmond Tutu called the club "a beacon, a symbol and a sentinel for freedom, for justice, for tolerance" when he spoke there.[6]

The first President to have appeared at the City Club was Theodore Roosevelt; every President since Jimmy Carter has appeared at its podium.[7] President George W. Bush spoke to the club on the third anniversary of the United States' invasion of Iraq. Because the City Club of Cleveland does not allow questions from the audience to be pre-screened, President Ronald Reagan declined to appear before the Club, but when questions were raised by the media about his mental acuity, Reagan sought out an appearance before the Club to refute those charges.[citation needed]

The day after Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated in 1968, Senator Robert F. Kennedy gave his On the Mindless Menace of Violence speech at the club.[8]

In 1976, as part of the United States Bicentennial, the club held a forum in Britain, the club's first outside the United States.[9]

Debates before the Club have swayed Ohio elections. Before John Glenn defeated Howard Metzenbaum in the 1974 Democratic Senate primary, Glenn responded to a charge in an earlier debate that he never had to make a payroll:

> I served 23 years in the United States Marine Corps. I served through two wars. I flew 149 missions. My plane was hit by antiaircraft fire on 12 different occasions. I was in the space program. It wasn't my checkbook; it was my life on the line. It was not a nine-to-five job where I took time off to take the daily cash receipts to the bank. I ask you to go with me ... as I went the other day to a veterans hospital and look at those men with their mangled bodies in the eye and tell them they didn't hold a job. You go with me to the space program and go as I have gone to the widows and orphans of Ed White, Gus Grissom, and Roger Chaffee, and you look those kids in the eye and tell them that their dad didn't hold a job. You go with me on Memorial Day, coming up, and you stand in Arlington National Cemetery, where I have more friends than I'd like to remember, and you watch those waving flags. You stand there, and you think about this nation, and you tell me that those people didn't have a job, I'll tell you, Howard Metzenbaum, you should be on your knees every day of your life thanking God that there were some men — SOME MEN — who held a job. And they required a dedication to purpose, a love of country and a dedication to duty that was more important than life itself. And their self-sacrifice is what made this country possible ... I HAVE HELD A JOB, HOWARD! What about you?[10]

During the 2010 Congressional elections, in which the Republicans regained control of the House of Representatives, John Boehner on August 24, 2010, announced a five-point plan at the club that he said would provide an effective economic alternative to the Democrats' course.[11]

Sometimes politicians decline to appear at forums because it would provide exposure to their opponents in a political race. Congressman Dennis Kucinich, who complained vociferously about being excluded from debates among the Democratic candidates for President, has several times refused to debate his opponent for Congress in The City Club of Cleveland debates.[12]

The club has been criticized for bestowing its "Citadel of Free Speech" award upon Justice Antonin Scalia, who then refused to allow his speech to be broadcast. The Board of Trustees of the City Club defended its actions by noting that the press was welcome to attend the special presentation and report upon the event.[13] Other recipients of the Citadel of Free Speech award include John Glenn, Martin Luther King's aide and U.N. Ambassador Andrew Young, and CNN founder Ted Turner.[14]

## Creed of the City Club

[edit]

In 1916, Ralph Hayes, then the Secretary of the City Club, penned its creed.

> — I hail and harbor and hear persons of every belief and party; for within my portals prejudice grows less and bias dwindles.

> — I have a forum – as wholly uncensored as it is rigidly impartial. "Freedom of Speech" is graven above my rostrum; and beside it, "Fairness of Speech."

> — I am the product of the people, a cross section of their community—weak as they are weak, and strong in their strength; believing that knowledge of our failings and our powers begets a greater strength.

> — I have a house of fellowship; under my roof informality reigns and strangers need no introduction.

> — I welcome to my platform the discussion of any theory or dogma or reform; but I bind my household to the espousal of none of them, for I cherish the freedom of every person's conviction and each of my kin retains his own responsibility.

> — I have no axe to grind, no logs to roll. My abode shall be the rendezvous of strong but open-minded men and my watchword shall be "information" not "reformation."

> — I am accessible to people of all sides—literally and figuratively—for I am located in the heart of the city—spiritually and geographically.

> — I am the city's club—The City Club.[4]

## Friday Forum

[edit]

The City Club's Friday Forum is broadcast live on the radio in more than 40 states from Maine to Alaska. The broadcast is initiated live on Ideastream Public Media's WKSU (relayed over a regional network including WCPN) with encore broadcasts on co-owned WCLV.[15] Most stations, including the iHeartMedia station group in Cleveland, air the Friday Forum as part of their Sunday morning public service requirements.[2]

Television broadcasts of the City Club's Friday Forum also occur over Ideastream's WVIZ and on The Ohio Channel, and are often also aired nationwide on C-SPAN as part of their regular coverage of civic and political discussions and forums throughout the United States.[16][17]

## Notable guests

[edit]

* Isabel Allende[18]
* Sherrod Brown[19]
* George W. Bush[20]
* Jimmy Carter[21]
* Bill Clinton[22]
* Ta-Nehisi Coates[23]
* Marian Wright Edelman[24]
* Robert F. Kennedy[25]
* John Kerry[26]
* Peter B. Lewis[27]
* Akil Marshall[28]
* Reverend Otis Moss Jr.[29]
* Ralph Nader[30]
* Barack Obama[31]
* Rosa Parks[32]
* Ronald Reagan[33]
* Theodore Roosevelt[34]
* Louis Stokes[35]
* Jim Thome[36]
* Archbishop Desmond Tutu[37]
* Janet Yellen[38]
* Joe Biden[39]

## References

[edit]

1. ^ a b "City Club of Cleveland". The Encyclopedia of Cleveland History. Case Western Reserve University. Retrieved July 23, 2020.
2. ^ a b c "Mission & Vision". City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved July 23, 2020.
3. ^ "Membership". City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved July 23, 2020.
4. ^ a b "History". City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved July 23, 2020.
5. ^ "City Club of Cleveland History". Retrieved 16 September 2014.
6. ^ Archived at Ghostarchive and the Wayback Machine: "Campaign For A New Century". YouTube. 13 August 2010.
7. ^ Cho, Janet, Plain Dealer, July 22, 2005
8. ^ Audio of the speech Archived 2011-10-01 at the Wayback Machine from the City Club
9. ^ Segal, Grant, Plain Dealer, July 30, 2011, "Bob Cavano, led City Club, several other civic groups"
10. ^ "John Glenn 'I Have Held a Job!' Quote". 15 March 2002.
11. ^ Hulse, Carl (2010-08-24). "Boehner Urges Obama to Fire Economic Team". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2022-10-07.
12. ^ [Kotz, Pete, Scene, March 20, 2007 "Kucinich is a Hypocrite" http://www.clevescene.com/scene-and-heard/archives/2007/03/20/kucinich-is-a-hypocrite]
13. ^ "Some 'Mystified' by Award to Scalia for Free Speech". Los Angeles Times. 2003-03-20. Retrieved 2022-10-07.
14. ^ Spector, Harlan, Plain Dealer, May 19, 2012, "Cleveland's City Club honors media mogul Ted Turner with free speech award"
15. ^ Venta, Lance (September 15, 2021). "Ideastream To Begin Operating WKSU; Swap Frequencies Of WCPN & WCLV Cleveland". RadioInsight. Archived from the original on September 16, 2021. Retrieved September 19, 2021 – via RadioBB.
16. ^ "The City Club Forum". WVIZ. Retrieved July 23, 2020.
17. ^ "City Club of Cleveland archive on C-SPAN.org". C-SPAN. Retrieved 1 January 2018.
18. ^ "Isabel Allende 9.8.2017". The City Club of Cleveland via YouTube. 8 September 2017. Retrieved 2021-12-08.
19. ^ "Investing in Cleveland, Not the Caymans: How to Align the Tax Code to our Nation's Interests". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
20. ^ President Discusses War on Terror and Operation Iraqi Freedom, White House Press Release, March 20, 2006 [1]
21. ^ "Jimmy Carter". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
22. ^ Remarks to the Cleveland City Club - Bill Clinton speech - Transcript, Bnet Business Network [2]
23. ^ "Between the World and Me". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
24. ^ "Ending Child Poverty Now". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
25. ^ Remarks of Senator Robert F. Kennedy to the Cleveland City Club, Cleveland, Ohio, April 5, 1968, John F. Kennedy Presidential Library & Museum [3]
26. ^ "Senator John Kerry". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
27. ^ "Peter B. Lewis". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
28. ^ Akil Marshall speaks to youths about staying on the right track in school and life., Call and Post FRIDAY, 18 JANUARY 2013 "City Club Youth Forum hosts 'Winning in America' coach". Archived from the original on 2013-04-11. Retrieved 2013-06-06.
29. ^ "Otis Moss, Jr". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
30. ^ Beres, Tom, WKYC-TV, Cleveland, October 26, 2008
31. ^ "President Obama to Deliver Remarks to The City Club of Cleveland". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
32. ^ "Rosa L. Parks". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
33. ^ Reagan, Ronald, 'Ronald Reagan, the wisdom and humor of Great Communicator', 1995 Harper Collins [4]
34. ^ BEWARE OF TAMMANY, WARNING TO SULZER; Speakers at City Club Dinner Advise Him to Appeal to the Larger Constituency., New York Times, December 20, 1912 [5]
35. ^ "The World According to Stokes". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
36. ^ "Jim Thome with Tom Hamilton". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
37. ^ "Desmond Tutu". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
38. ^ "Remarks by Janet Yellen". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2016-01-27.
39. ^ "Remarks from Senator Joseph R. Biden, Jr". The City Club of Cleveland. Retrieved 2021-12-18.

## External links

[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to City Club of Cleveland.

* Official website
* City Club Catering
* Complete as-delivered transcript and audio mp3 of Robert F. Kennedy's Mindless Menace of Violence Speech at the City Club of Cleveland AmericanRhetoric.com

* v
* t
* e

City of Cleveland

Topics|

* History
* Timeline
* Demographics
* Economy
* Media
* Flag
* Nicknames
* Notable people
* Public art
* Skyscrapers
* Cuyahoga County
* MSA
* CSA
* Bibliography

Government|

| Local|

* Mayor
* City Council
* City Hall
* Cleveland Metro School District
* Shaker Heights City School District (part)

|

State|

* Lausche State Office Building

Federal|

* Celebrezze Federal Building
* Coast Guard District 9
* Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland
* NASA Glenn Research Center
* Metzenbaum U.S. Courthouse
* Stokes U.S. Courthouse

Public safety|

* EMS
* Fire
* Police

Transportation|

| Land|

* RTA
* Shoreway
* Detroit–Superior Bridge
* Hope Memorial Bridge

|

Air|

* Burke Lakefront Airport
* Hopkins International Airport

Water|

* Goodtime III
* Port of Cleveland

Healthcare|

* Cleveland Clinic
* Health Education Campus
* University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center
* Rainbow Babies & Children's Hospital
* MetroHealth System
* St. Vincent Charity Medical Center

Culture|

| Historic places|

* City Club of Cleveland
* Cleveland Arcade
* Cleveland Public Library
* Cleveland Trust Company Building
* Dunham Tavern
* Erie Street Cemetery
* Euclid Avenue
* Grays Armory
* Lake View Cemetery
* James A. Garfield Memorial
* Perry Monument
* Public Square
* Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument
* Terminal Tower
* West Side Market

|

Museums|

* A Christmas Story House
* Cleveland History Center
* Cleveland Museum of Art
* Cleveland Museum of Natural History
* Children's Museum of Cleveland
* Cleveland Hungarian Museum
* Cozad–Bates House Interpretive Center
* Dittrick Museum of Medical History
* Great Lakes Science Center
* Steamship William G. Mather Museum
* NASA Glenn Visitors Center
* International Women's Air & Space Museum
* Italian American Museum of Cleveland
* Learning Center and Money Museum
* Museum of Contemporary Art Cleveland
* Rock and Roll Hall of Fame
* Ukrainian Museum-Archives
* USS Cod

Parks and nature|

* Cleveland Botanical Garden
* Cleveland Metroparks
* Cleveland Metroparks Zoo
* Cuyahoga River
* Gordon Park
* Greater Cleveland Aquarium
* Lake Erie
* Lake Link Trail
* The Mall
* Rockefeller Park
* Cleveland Cultural Gardens
* Wade Park
* Willard Park

Performing arts|

* Cleveland Ballet
* Cleveland Cinematheque
* Cleveland Orchestra
* Severance Hall
* Cleveland Playhouse
* Cleveland Public Theatre
* Great Lakes Theater
* Karamu House
* Maltz Performing Arts Center
* Near West Theatre
* Playhouse Square
* Talespinner Children's Theatre

Sports, concert,
and convention venues|

* Agora Theatre and Ballroom
* Cleveland Masonic Temple
* Huntington Bank Field
* Huntington Convention Center
* I-X Center
* Jacobs Pavilion
* Progressive Field
* Public Auditorium
* Rocket Arena
* Wolstein Center

Traditions|

* Feast of the Assumption
* Dyngus Day
* International Film Festival
* Kurentovanje
* Saint Patrick's Day
* Sweetest Day
* Thyagaraja Festival

Neighborhoods|

* Broadway–Slavic Village
* Brooklyn Centre
* Buckeye–Shaker
* Buckeye–Woodhill
* Central
* Clark–Fulton
* Collinwood
* Cudell
* Cuyahoga Valley
* The Flats
* Whiskey Island
* Detroit–Shoreway
* Downtown
* Campus District
* Civic Center
* East 4th Street
* Gateway District
* Nine-Twelve District
* North Coast Harbor
* Short Vincent
* Superior Arts District
* Warehouse District
* Edgewater
* Euclid–Green
* Fairfax
* Glenville
* Goodrich–Kirtland Park
* Asiatown
* Hough
* Kinsman
* Lee–Miles
* Mount Pleasant
* Ohio City
* Old Brooklyn
* St. Clair–Superior
* Stockyards
* Tremont
* Duck Island
* Union–Miles Park
* University Circle
* Little Italy
* West Boulevard
* West Park
* Bellaire–Puritas
* Hopkins
* Jefferson
* Kamm's Corners

Sports|

| Major League|

* NFL: Cleveland Browns
* NBA: Cleveland Cavaliers
* MLB: Cleveland Guardians
* WNBA: Cleveland WNBA team (2028)

|

Minor League|

* G League: Cleveland Charge
* MLIS: Cleveland Crunch
* AHL: Cleveland Monsters

College|

* NCAA D1 (Horizon League):  Cleveland State Vikings
* NCAA D3 (UAA):  Case Western Reserve Spartans

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template