Cultural feminism

Theories that commend innate differences between women and men

Part of a series on

Feminism

History

* Feminist history
* Women's history
* American
* British
* Canadian
* German

Waves

* First
* Second
* Third
* Fourth

Timelines

* Women's suffrage
* Muslim countries
* US

* Other women's rights

Women's suffrage by country

* Austria
* Australia
* Canada
* Colombia
* India
* Japan
* Kuwait
* Liechtenstein
* New Zealand
* Spain
* Second Republic
* Francoist
* Switzerland
* United Kingdom
* Cayman Islands
* Wales
* United States
* states

Intersectional variants

* Fat
* Lesbian
* Lesbian of color
* Radical lesbianism
* Separatist
* Sex-positive
* Transfeminism
* Postgenderism
* Vegetarian ecofeminism

Socialist

* Anarchist
* Queer
* Jineology
* Marxist
* Critical theory
* Standpoint
* Materialist
* Ecofeminist
* Postcolonial
* Global
* Transnational
* Xenofeminism
* Jineoloji

Multicultural

* Africana womanism
* Black
* Hip hop
* Lesbian
* Ratchet
* Chicana
* Lesbian
* Indigenous
* Native American
* Multiracial
* Romani
* Womanism

Other variants

* Anti-abortion
* Conservative
* Equity
* Femonationalism
* Liberal
* Maternal
* Postfeminism
* Reactionary
* State
* Carceral
* Imperial
* Embedded
* Gender-critical or trans-exclusionary
* Victim
* White

Religious variants

* Atheist
* Buddhist
* Christian
* Mormon
* New
* Womanist
* Asian
* Neopagan
* Dianic Wicca
* Reclaiming
* Ecofeminist
* Hindu
* Islamic
* Jewish
* Orthodox
* Sikh

Movements and ideologies

* 4B movement

* White Feather Campaign
* Analytical
* Anti-fascist
* Anti-pornography
* Cyber
* HCI
* Networked
* Xeno
* Difference
* Cultural
* Neo
* Ecofeminism
* Eugenic
* Individualist
* Liberal
* Equality
* Social
* Labor
* Libertarian
* Lipstick
* Stiletto
* Post-structural
* Postmodern
* Radical
* Political lesbianism
* Separatist
* Technofeminism
* Women's liberation

Concepts

* Antinaturalism
* Choice feminism
* Cognitive labor
* Conscription
* Complementarianism
* Literature
* Children's literature
* Diversity (politics)
* Diversity, equity, and inclusion
* Effects on society
* Equality
* Female education
* Female genital mutilation
* Femicide
* Femonationalism
* Feminism in culture
* Feminist movement
* African-American women's suffrage movement
* Art movement
* In hip hop
* Feminist stripper
* Formal equality
* Gender equality
* Gender quota
* Gender role
* Girl power
* Honor killing
* Ideal womanhood
* Invisible labor
* Internalized sexism
* International Girl's Day and Women's Day
* Language reform
* Feminist capitalism
* Gender-blind
* Likeability trap
* Male privilege
* Matriarchal religion
* Media
* Men in feminism
* Misogyny
* Trans
* Oedipus complex
* Opposition to feminism
* Pro-feminism
* Protofeminism
* Purplewashing
* Racism
* Reproductive justice
* Sentencing disparity
* Sex workers' rights
* Sexual harassment
* Sexual objectification
* Substantive equality
* Toxic masculinity
* Transmisogyny
* Triple oppression
* Violence against women
* War on women
* Women's empowerment
* Women-only space
* Women's health
* Women's rights
* Women in the workforce

Outlooks

* Abortion-rights
* Bicycling and feminism
* Bodily integrity
* Criticism of marriage
* Views on BDSM
* Views on pornography
* Views on prostitution
* Views on sexual orientation
* Views on sexuality
* Views on transgender topics
* Reproductive rights
* Sexual and reproductive health and rights
* SCUM Manifesto

Theory

* Feminist method
* Gender studies
* Gender mainstreaming
* Gynocentrism
* Kyriarchy
* Male gaze
* Matriarchy
* Women's studies
* Men's studies
* Patriarchy
* Écriture féminine

Areas of study

* Anthropology
* Archaeology
* Architecture
* Art
* Art criticism
* Literary criticism
* Film theory
* Science fiction
* Biology
* Composition studies
* Criminology
* Pathways perspective
* Economics
* FDPA
* Geography
* International relations
* Constructivism
* Legal theory
* Pedagogy
* Philosophy
* Aesthetics
* Empiricism
* Epistemology
* Ethics
* Justice ethics
* Existentialism
* Metaphysics
* science
* Political ecology
* Political theory
* Pornography
* Psychology
* Therapy
* Revisionist mythology
* Sex wars
* Sexology
* Sociology
* Technoscience
* Theology
* womanist theology

By continent/country

* Africa
* Democratic Republic of the Congo
* Egypt
* Ethiopia
* Ghana
* Mali
* Nigeria
* Senegal
* South Africa
* Albania
* Australia
* Bangladesh
* Canada
* China
* Denmark
* Finland
* France
* Germany
* Greece
* Hong Kong
* India
* Indonesia
* Iran
* Iraq
* Republic of Ireland
* Israel
* Italy
* Japan
* Latin America
* Argentina
* Brazil
* Chile
* Haiti
* Honduras
* Mexico
* Paraguay
* Trinidad and Tobago
* Lebanon
* Malaysia
* Nepal
* Netherlands
* New Zealand
* Northern Cyprus
* Norway
* Pakistan
* Philippines
* Poland
* Russia
* Saudi Arabia
* South Korea
* Sweden
* Syria
* Taiwan
* Thailand
* Turkey
* Vietnam
* Ukraine
* United Kingdom
* United States
* History of women

Lists and categories

|  Lists

* Articles
* Feminists
* by nationality
* Literature
* American feminist literature
* Feminist comic books
* Feminist songs

* Conservative feminisms
* Ecofeminist authors
* Feminist art critics
* Feminist economists
* Feminist philosophers
* Feminist poets
* Feminist rhetoricians
* Jewish feminists
* Muslim feminists
* Feminist parties
* Suffragists and suffragettes
* Women's rights activists
* Women's studies journals
* Women's suffrage organizations

Categories

* Women's rights by country
* Feminists by nationality

Feminism portal

* v
* t
* e

Cultural feminism is a term used to describe a variety of feminism that attempts to revalue and redefine attributes culturally ascribed to femaleness.[1][2] It is also used to describe theories that commend innate differences between women and men.[3]

Cultural feminists diverged from radical feminists when they rejected the problematization of femininity and returned to an essentialist view of gender differences in which they regard "female nature" as superior.[1][4][5]

## Origins of the term

[edit]

Unlike radical feminism or socialist feminism, cultural feminism was not an ideology widely claimed by proponents but was more commonly a pejorative label ascribed by its opponents. In 1975, Brooke Williams was the first to describe the "depoliticization of radical feminism" as "cultural feminism".[6] However, the term had surfaced as early as 1971, when Frances Chapman, in a letter printed in Off Our Backs, condemned the literary magazine Aphra as having "served the cause of cultural feminism".[7] Socialist feminist Elizabeth Diggs, in 1972, used the label "cultural feminism" to apply to all of radical feminism.[8]

Redstockings founder Ellen Willis affirmed that "The great majority of women who presently call themselves 'radical feminists' in fact subscribe to a politics more accurately labeled 'cultural feminist'. [...] Though cultural feminism came out of the radical feminist movement, the premises of the two tendencies are antithetical. Yet on the left and elsewhere the distinction is rarely made."[9] However, there are scholars such as Rosemarie Tong who conceptualize cultural feminism as a perspective within radical feminism.[2]

## Theory

[edit]

Cultural feminism places women in a position overdetermined by patriarchal systems.[1] Linda Alcoff makes the point that "the cultural feminist reappraisal construes woman's passivity as her peacefulness, her sentimentality as her proclivity to nurture, her subjectiveness as her advanced self-awareness".[1]

Similar lines of thought have been traced to earlier periods. Jane Addams and Charlotte Perkins Gilman argued that in governing the state, cooperation, caring, and nonviolence in the settlement of conflicts society seem to be what was needed from women's virtues.[10] Josephine Donovan argues that the nineteenth century journalist, critic, and women's rights activist, Margaret Fuller, initiated cultural feminism in Woman in the Nineteenth Century (1845). She stressed the emotional, intuitive side of knowledge and expressed an organic worldview that is quite different from the mechanistic view of Enlightenment rationalists.[11][12]

However, it was Alice Echols' article, "Cultural Feminism: Feminist Capitalism and the Anti-Pornography Movement", that led to the widespread adoption of the term to describe contemporary feminists, not their historical antecedents. According to Echols, cultural feminism “equates women's liberation with the development and preservation of a female counterculture.”[4]: 35 Her examples of cultural feminists are Kathleen Barry, Susan Brownmiller, Mary Daly, Andrea Dworkin, Susan Griffin, Robin Morgan, Janice Raymond, Adrienne Rich, and Florence Rush.[1][13]

Mary Daly linked "female energy", or her term Gyn/Ecology, to the female "life-affirming, life-creating biological condition" that is victimized by male aggression as a result of "male barrenness".[1] Adrienne Rich asserts that female biology has “radical” potential that has been suppressed by its reduction by men.[14] Some cultural feminists desired the separation of women-only, women-run centers and spaces to “challenge negative gendered constructions.”[15] This form of separatism within cultural feminism was criticized for ignoring structural patriarchy to instead blame men as individuals for women's oppression.[15] In addition to physical separation, cultural feminists called for “separation from male values.”[4]

Women are identified as the most important and most marginalized group. Daly asserted that other categories of identity including ethnicity and class are male-defined groups, and women who identify them are being divided from other women.[1] Rich declares the “social burden” placed on women is greater and more complex than even the burden of slavery.[14]

Motherhood and child-bearing is another popular topic in cultural feminist theory. Rich theorized motherhood as an institution, constructed to control women, which is different from authentic, natural motherhood.[14] Cultural feminists declare the relationship between mother and daughter, and therefore all women, has been destroyed by patriarchy and must be repaired.[4]

In her exhaustive study of second-wave feminist theory, Love and Politics: Radical Feminist and Lesbian Theories,[16] Carol Anne Douglas (long-time critic at Off Our Backs) included the influence of Susan Griffin's popular book Woman and Nature: The Roaring Inside Her as central to the development of this strain of theory. Notably, this chapter of Douglas' book is titled Male biology as a problem and the analysis of Griffin's ideas is subtitled Woman the Natural.[16]

## Criticisms

[edit]

In a 2004 article for the Journal of Women in Culture and Society, Kristen Ghodsee notes several forms of criticism coming from women of color and women of developing countries, who believe that "the idea of a global sisterhood erases important differences in power and access to resources among women of varying races, ethnicities, and nationalities".[17]: 727 A common concern, particularly among women of color and women of developing countries, is that cultural feminism only includes white, upper-class women, instead of taking into account women of different color and status.[17]: 727 This concern is reflected by Audre Lorde in “An Open Letter to Mary Daly” in which Lorde expresses disappointment that Daly excluded the heritage and herstories of Lorde and other non-European women in her cultural feminist book, while selectively using non-European women's words out of context to prove her points and to describe “female victimization”.[18]

Another concern is the belief that cultural feminists "have not challenged the defining of woman but only the definition given by men" and therefore perpetuate gender essentialism[19]: 11 When cultural feminists claim issues like patriarchy and rape are inherent products of male biology and behavior, the opportunity to critique and challenge the structures behind these issues disappears.[4] Furthermore, essentialist definitions of “woman” reinforce the oppressive requirement for women to live up to “an innate ‘womanhood’ they will be judged by.”[4] Alice Echols stated that cultural feminists believe in order to combat “male lasciviousness,” women should demand respect by repressing their sexualities and proposing a conservative "female standard of sexuality".[4]: 52 She critiques this concept for attempting to control women's sexual expression to hold women responsible for perceived problems with male sexuality.[4]: 52

This biological determinism also reflects on cultural feminists' opinions of transgender women. Echols describes cultural feminist attribution of transgender women to male rapaciousness as inappropriate and explains that cultural feminists dislike transgender women for accusations that they “undermine the salience of gender, and erase the boundaries between genders,” appropriate the female body (which cultural feminists regard as a kind of rape), and threaten to bring the “residual heterosexuality” out of lesbians in lesbian-feminist spaces.[4] Trans-exclusionary radical feminism is said to have its origins in cultural feminism.[20]

Cultural feminism has also been criticized for engaging in capitalism, a practice which some feminists consider contradictory to feminist values and counterproductive to the feminist movement. To highlight problems with feminist capitalism, Echols analyzed the implementation, practices, and outcomes of the Feminist Economic Network (FEN), a feminist business that intended to use capitalism to help women overcome patriarchal barriers by lending money from feminist credit unions to feminist owned businesses.[21] She found the network exploited employees, rejected democracy, collectivity, and accountability, and justified hierarchies of power within the business by claiming sisterhood ensures individual empowerment leads to collective empowerment for women.[4] Echols's findings can be expanded upon by a critique of cultural feminist business practices in Off Our Backs. The authors explain that the “feminist” businesses cultural feminists advocate for depoliticize feminism, are inherently hierarchal, have minimal access to political economic influence, and are implicitly reformist. Additionally, the authors point out the flaws in cultural feminists’ attempts to counter oppression through membership in an oppressive economic system, use of bootstrap theory, and turning feminism into both a commodity and market which ultimately serves “male” capitalism.[13]

Verta Taylor and Leila J. Rupp have argued that critiques of cultural feminism are often an attack on lesbian feminism.[6] Suzanne Staggenbourg's case study of Bloomington, Indiana led her to conclude that engagement in activities labeled as cultural feminist "provides little evidence that cultural feminism led to a decline in political activity in the women's movement."[22]: 507

## See also

[edit]

* Appeal to nature
* Difference feminism
* Ecofeminism
* Female chauvinism
* Feminist metaphysics
* Feminist sex wars
* Gender essentialism
* New feminism
* Political lesbianism
* TERFism

## References

[edit]

1. ^ a b c d e f g Alcoff, Linda (1988). "Cultural Feminism versus Post-Structuralism: The Identity Crisis in Feminist Theory". Signs. 13 (3): 405–436\. ISSN 0097-9740.
2. ^ a b Tong, Rosemarie (2009). "Radical Feminism: Libertarian and Cultural Perspectives". Feminist thought: a more comprehensive introduction (3rd ed.). Boulder, Colo: Westview. ISBN 978-0-8133-4375-4.
3. ^ Kramarae, Cheris; Spender, Dale (2000). Routledge International Encyclopedia of Women: Global Women's Issues and Knowledge. New York: Routledge. p. 746\. ISBN 978-0415920902.
4. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Echols, Alice (1983). "Cultural Feminism: Feminist Capitalism and the Anti-Pornography Movement". Social Text (7): 34–53\. doi:10.2307/466453. ISSN 0164-2472. JSTOR 466453.
5. ^ Evans, Judy (1995). "Cultural Feminism: Feminism's First Difference". Feminist Theory Today : an Introduction to Second-Wave Feminism. SAGE Publications. p. 73\. ISBN 9781446264935. OCLC 874319830.
6. ^ a b Taylor, Verta; Rupp, Leila J. (1993). "Women's Culture and Lesbian Feminist Activism: A Reconsideration of Cultural Feminism". Signs. 19 (1): 32–61\. ISSN 0097-9740.
7. ^ Frances Chapman, "goodbye," Off Our Backs 1, no. 19 (25 March 1971): 14.
8. ^ Elizabeth Diggs, "What Is the Women's Movement?", Women: A Journal of Liberation 2, no. 4 (1972): 11-12, 20.
9. ^ Willis, Ellen (1984). "Radical Feminism and Feminist Radicalism". Social Text (9/10): 91–118\. doi:10.2307/466537. ISSN 0164-2472.
10. ^ Ritzer, George. Contemporary Sociological Theory and Its Classical Roots. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2007. ISBN 978-0-07-299759-0
11. ^ Donovan, Josefine. Feminist Theory. 3d ed. (New York: Continuum, 1985.
12. ^ Levine, Amy-Jill; Blickenstaff, Marianne (2004). A Feminist Companion to the Acts of the Apostles. London: T & T Clark. p. 242\. ISBN 978-0-8264-6252-7.
13. ^ a b "god, mom & apple pie: "feminist" businesses as an extension of the american dream". Off Our Backs. 5 (11): 18–20\. 1976. ISSN 0030-0071. JSTOR 25772445.
14. ^ a b c Rich, Adrienne Cécile. (1997). Of woman born : motherhood as experience and institution. Virago. ISBN 0860680312. OCLC 263689375.
15. ^ a b Bromley, Victoria L. (2012). Feminisms Matter: Debates, Theories, Activism. University of Toronto Press. ISBN 9781442605008.
16. ^ a b Douglas, Carol Anne (July 1990). Love and Politics : Radical Feminist and Lesbian Theories. San Francisco, CA, USA: ISM PRESS. ISBN 9780910383172.
17. ^ a b Ghodsee, Kristen (Spring 2004). "Feminism by Design: Emerging Capitalisms, Cultural Feminism, and Women's Nongovernmental Organizations in Post Socialist Eastern Europe". Journal of Women in Culture and Society. 29 (3): 772–753\. doi:10.1086/380631. S2CID 145465152.
18. ^ Lorde, Audre (2022-03-15), "An Open Letter to Mary Daly", This Bridge Called My Back, Fortieth Anniversary Edition, SUNY Press, pp. 90–93, doi:10.1515/9781438488295-033, ISBN 978-1-4384-8829-5
19. ^ Blumenthal, Dannielle (1997). Women and Soap Opera: A Cultural Feminist Perspective. Praeger. ISBN 9780275960391. Retrieved 12 November 2018.
20. ^ Bassi, Serena; LaFleur, Greta (2022-08-01). "Introduction". TSQ: Transgender Studies Quarterly. 9 (3): 311–333\. doi:10.1215/23289252-9836008. ISSN 2328-9252.
21. ^ Bruneau, Camille (2021-01-14). "How do patriarchy and capitalism jointly reinforce the oppression of women?". CADTM. Retrieved 2021-01-14.
22. ^ Staggenborg, Suzanne (2001). "Beyond Culture versus Politics: A Case Study of a Local Women's Movement". Gender and Society. 15 (4): 507–530\. ISSN 0891-2432.

## Further reading

[edit]

* Deegan, Mary Jo (1988). "Jane Addams on Cultural Feminism". Jane Addams and the Men of the Chicago School, 1892–1918. Routledge. pp. 226–230\. ISBN 978-0887380778.
* Balbert, Peter (1989). D. H. Lawrence and the Phallic Imagination: Essays on Sexual Identity and Feminist Misreading. London: Macmillan Press. ISBN 978-0-333-43964-7.
* Roseneil, Sasha (1995). "The Coming of Age of Feminist Sociology: Some Issues of Practice and Theory for the Next Twenty Years". The British Journal of Sociology. 46 (2): 191–205\. doi:10.2307/591785. ISSN 0007-1315.
* "'I'm Not a Feminist, But...'". letter to a friend. still no pod. October 24, 2005.
* Pollitt, Katha (March 2015). "Why Feminism Should Focus Less on Culture". The Progressive.

* v
* t
* e

Culture

Outline

Sciences|

* Cultural anthropology
* Cultural astronomy
* Cultural ecology
* Cultural geography
* Cultural neuroscience
* Cultural studies
* Culturology
* Culture theory

Subfields|

* Bioculture
* Cross-cultural studies
* Cross-cultural communication
* Cross-cultural leadership
* Cross-cultural psychiatry
* Cross-cultural psychology
* Cultural analytics
* Cultural economics
* Cultural entomology
* Cultural history
* Cultural mapping
* Cultural mediation
* Cultural psychology
* Cultural values
* Culturomics
* Intercultural learning
* Intercultural relations
* Philosophy of culture
* Popular culture studies
* Postcritique
* Semiotics of culture
* Sociology of culture
* Sound culture
* Theology of culture
* Transcultural nursing

Types|

* Constructed culture
* Dominant culture
* Folk culture
* High culture
* Individualistic culture
* Legal culture
* Microculture
* Official culture
* Political culture
* Civic
* Popular culture
* Low culture
* Media culture
* Recombinant culture
* Remix culture
* Trash culture
* Urban
* Primitive culture
* Resistance through culture
* Subculture
* Alternative culture
* Counterculture
* Fandom
* Far-right subcultures
* Underground culture
* Youth subculture
* list
* Super culture
* Vernacular culture
* Culture by location

Aspects|

* Acculturation
* Cultural appreciation
* Cultural appropriation
* Cultural area
* Cultural artifact
* Cultural baggage
* Cultural bias
* Cultural capital
* Cross-cultural
* Cultural communication
* Cultural conflict
* Cultural cringe
* Cultural dissonance
* Cultural emphasis
* Cultural framework
* Cultural heritage
* Destroyed
* Cultural icon
* Cultural identity
* Cultural industry
* Cultural invention
* Cultural landscape
* Cultural learning
* Cultural leveling
* Cultural memory
* Cultural pluralism
* Cultural practice
* Cultural property
* Cultural reproduction
* Cultural system
* Cultural technology
* Cultural universal
* Cultureme
* Enculturation
* High- and low-context cultures
* Interculturality
* Internet culture
* Manuscript culture
* Material culture
* Non-material culture
* Organizational culture
* Assessment culture
* Design culture
* Journalism culture
* Print culture
* Protoculture
* Relational mobility
* Safety culture
* Symbolic culture
* Technoculture
* Trans-cultural diffusion
* Transculturation
* Visual culture

Politics|

* Colonial mentality
* Consumer capitalism
* Cross cultural sensitivity
* Cultural assimilation
* Cultural attaché
* Cultural backwardness
* Cultural Bolshevism
* Cultural conservatism
* Cultural contracts
* Cultural deprivation
* Cultural diplomacy
* Cultural environmentalism
* Cultural exception
* Cultural feminism
* Cultural genocide
* Cultural globalization
* Cultural hegemony
* Cultural imperialism
* Cultural intelligence
* Cultural liberalism
* Cultural nationalism
* Cultural pessimism
* Cultural policy
* Cultural racism
* Cultural radicalism
* Cultural retention
* Cultural Revolution
* Cultural rights
* Cultural safety
* Cultural silence
* Cultural subsidy
* Cultural Zionism
* Culture change
* Culture minister
* Culture of fear
* Culture war
* Deculturalization
* Dominator culture
* Interculturalism
* Monoculturalism
* Multiculturalism
* Biculturalism
* Multiracial democracy
* Pluriculturalism
* Polyculturalism
* Transculturism

Religions|

* Buddhism
* Christianity
* Catholicism
* Cultural Christians
* Protestantism
* Role of Christianity in civilization
* Eastern Orthodoxy
* Mormonism
* Cultural Hindus
* Islam
* Cultural Muslims
* Judaism
* Sikhism

Related|

* Algorithmic culture
* Animal culture
* Archaeological culture
* Bennett scale
* Cannabis culture
* Circuit of culture
* Civilization
* Coffee culture
* Cringe culture
* Cross-cultural
* Cultural center
* Cultural competence
* Cultural critic
* Cultural determinism
* Cultural diversity
* Cultural evolutionism
* Cultural homogenization
* Cultural institution
* Cultural jet lag
* Cultural lag
* Cultural literacy
* Cultural mosaic
* Cultural movement
* Cultural mulatto
* Cultural probe
* Cultural relativism
* Cultural tourism
* Pop-culture
* Cultural translation
* Cultural turn
* Cultural sensibility
* Culture and menstruation
* Culture and positive psychology
* Culture and social cognition
* Culture gap
* Culture hero
* Culture industry
* Culture shock
* Culturgen
* Children's culture
* Culturalism
* Cyberculture
* Death and culture
* Disability culture
* Deaf culture
* Drinking culture
* Drug culture
* Eastern culture
* Emotions and culture
* Historical culture
* Intercultural communication
* Intercultural competence
* Languaculture
* Living things in culture
* Media culture
* Oppositional culture
* Participatory culture
* Permission culture
* Rape culture
* Remix culture
* Tea culture
* Transformation of culture
* Urban culture
* Welfare culture
* Western culture
* Youth culture

* Category

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template