Dianne Kohler Barnard

South African politician

Dianne Kohler Barnard

Shadow Minister of Police
In office
2006–2015
Leader| Tony Leon
Helen Zille
Mmusi Maimane
Succeeded by| Zakhele Mbhele
Shadow Minister of Health
In office
2005–2006
Leader| Tony Leon
Shadow Minister of Arts and Culture
In office
2004–2005
Leader| Tony Leon
Member of Parliament
for KwaZulu-Natal

Incumbent

Assumed office
21 May 2004
Personal details
Born|  (1955-12-02) 2 December 1955 (age 69)
Port Elizabeth, Cape Province, Union of South Africa
Political party| Democratic Alliance

Dianne Kohler Barnard is a South African politician and former journalist, and a Member of Parliament for the Democratic Alliance (DA). In October 2015, she was expelled from the party by the DA Federal Executive. In December 2015, the decision was lifted on appeal to the DA's Federal Legal Commission.[1]

She was born in Port Elizabeth,[2] and currently resides in KwaZulu-Natal, where she represents the Durban South constituency.[3]

## Career in journalism

[edit]

Kohler Barnard spent 23 years working as a radio and print journalist. She ran the KwaZulu-Natal offices of SAfm and also presented/produced the station's afternoon news programme The Editors.

Kohler Barnard is also the former chairperson of the Broadcast, Electronic Media and Allied Workers' Union in KwaZulu-Natal, and was a founder member of the inaugural SABC HIV/Aids Committee.[2]

## Politics

[edit]

Kohler Barnard moved to politics in response to increasing state interference in the management of the SABC. She was elected to parliament with the DA in 2004, and was initially spokesperson on Arts and Culture.[4]

She was subsequently appointed opposition spokesperson on Health, and was a vocal critic of incumbent Health Minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang, particularly over her support for controversial German vitamin salesman Matthias Rath. Rath attempted to sue Kohler Barnard for describing him as a "charlatan", and also tried to sue newspapers that carried the remark.[5]

Subsequently, Kohler Barnard was appointed as Shadow Minister of Police. She was also the DA's representative on the SADC observer mission to Zimbabwe for the last two elections in that country.[2]

Following a scandal (see below), she was shifted to the position of deputy spokesperson on Public Works in 2015. She was returned to the Police portfolio, but this time as Deputy Shadow Minister, in August 2017.[6]

Having previously served as Shadow Minister of Communications and Digital Technologies, Kohler Barnard was appointed Shadow Minister of State Security on 21 April 2023.[7]

## Controversy

[edit]

Kohler Barnard was almost expelled from the DA in October 2015, when it emerged that she had controversially shared on her Facebook page a post from someone else suggesting that life in South Africa was better under former apartheid President PW Botha. She deleted it after it was on her site overnight. It appeared on Twitter as shared by the ANC some weeks later. Although it had long since been deleted on FB one of the first instructions[8] to Kohler Barnard to delete the post came from former DA leader Helen Zille, who seemed to be under the impression that the post had been shared recently.[9][8][10] Kohler Barnard apologised unreservedly for her action,[11] and was subsequently demoted to the position of shadow Deputy Minister of Public Works.[12]

New DA party leader Mmusi Maimane came under pressure to expel her from the party.[13] The disciplinary panel apparently recommended that Kohler Barnard be fined R20,000, be removed from all internally elected DA positions, pay for public apologies in 5 newspapers and attend a social media management course at her own expense.[14] Following this, Kohler Barnard's membership of the DA was terminated by the DA Federal Executive.[15] She then appealed the decision to the DA Federal Legal Commission, as a result of which her expulsion was suspended for a period of 5 years.[16][17]

The controversy was alleged to harm the image of the DA, which has been trying to project itself as an anti-apartheid party,[18][19] and also caused some serious internal tension, as some have viewed the original decisions as harsh.[20]

A media report in 2016 indicated that Kohler Barnard may not have complied with all of the various sanctions placed on her by the due date.[21]

## References

[edit]

1. ^ Lindeque, Mia. "Dianne Kohler Barnard's expulsion is lifted, with conditions". ewn.co.za.
2. ^ a b c "Dianne Kohler Barnard".
3. ^ "Contact – DA in Your Area: KwaZulu-Natal".
4. ^ "Ms Dianne Kohler Barnard".
5. ^ "Cape Times". www.iol.co.za.
6. ^ "Kohler Barnard returns as shadow deputy police minister".
7. ^ Ditabo, Malaika. "Another demotion for Mazzone as she moves from state security role back to communications". News24. Retrieved 21 April 2023.
8. ^ a b "DA's Kohler-Barnard re-posts a call for the return of PW Botha". October 2015 - via www.youtube.com.
9. ^ "Kohler Barnard to face disciplinary action: Maimane | eNCA". www.enca.com.
10. ^ Gia Nicolaides. "DA MP faces disciplinary action for PW Botha post". ewn.co.za.
11. ^ "Kohler Barnard to face internal disciplinary action". Business Day Live.
12. ^ "DA 'demotes' Dianne Kohler Barnard". News24.
13. ^ Justice Malala. "Why DA leader Mmusi Maimane has to throw Kohler Barnard under the bus". Rand Daily Mail.
14. ^ "Kohler Barnard faces bills of a different sort".
15. ^ "DA terminates Kohler Barnard's membership".
16. ^ "Dianne Kohler Barnard back in the DA after expulsion is lifted".
17. ^ "Termination of DKB's DA membership suspended - Glynnis Breytenbach - POLITICS | Politicsweb".
18. ^ "BusinessLIVE".
19. ^ "Know Your DA (A Tale of Two Helens)". 14 May 2013.
20. ^ http://beta.iol.co.za/ios/news/dumped-kohlerbarnard-to-fight-back-1938617[permanent dead link]
21. ^ "Kohler-Barnard deflects sanctions questions".

## Offices held

[edit]

Political offices

Preceded by

|  South African Shadow Minister of State Security
2023–present  |  Succeeded by

Incumbent

Preceded by

|  South African Shadow Minister of Communications and Digital Technologies
2020–2022  | Succeeded by

Preceded by

James Masango

|  South African Shadow Deputy Minister of Public Works
2015–2020  | Succeeded by

Preceded by

Roy Jankielsohn

|  South African Shadow Minister of Police
2006–2015  | Succeeded by

Zakhele Mbhele

Preceded by

Ryan Coetzee

|  South African Shadow Minister of Health
2005–2006  | Succeeded by

Gareth Morgan

Preceded by

Sydney Opperman

|  South African Shadow Minister of Arts and Culture
2004–2005  | Succeeded by

Desiree van der Walt

* v
* t
* e

Official Opposition Shadow Cabinet of South Africa

Leadership:|

* John Steenhuisen (Leader of the Opposition)

Shadow Ministers:|

* Basson
* Bergman
* Breytenbach
* Bryant
* Clarke
* De Villiers
* Graham
* Gwarube
* Hunsinger
* Khanyile
* King
* Kohler Barnard
* Lorimer
* Macpherson
* Malatsi
* Marais
* Masango
* Mbhele
* Mileham
* Mphithi
* Nodada
* Powell
* Schreiber
* Whitfield

Shadow Deputy Ministers:|

* Abrahams
* Bagraim
* Bouw-Spies
* Chetty
* Cuthbert
* George
* Gondwe
* Horn
* Hicklin
* Krüger
* Mabhena
* Marais
* Mbabama
* McGluwa
* Phillips
* Sharif
* Shelembe
* Stubbe
* Terblanche
* Van der Walt
* Van Dyk

Other Members in Attendance:|

* Lees
* Marais
* Sarupen
* Van Minnen

* v
* t
* e

Current members of the National Assembly of South Africa by party

ANC|

* Didiza
* Adams
* Aphiri
* Bila
* Bilankulu
* Boshielo
* Botes
* Burns-Ncamashe
* Capa
* Chabane
* Chauke
* Chikunga
* Cloete
* Creecy
* Dhlomo
* Davids
* Dikgale
* Diireko
* Dithebe
* Dlakude
* Dlelanga
* Dugmore
* Dunjwa
* Frolick
* Gantsho
* Gigaba
* Gina
* Godlimpi
* Godongwa
* Govana
* Gungubele
* Hala
* Hassan
* Hlongo
* Jama
* Kegakilwe
* Kekana
* Kgabo
* Khumalo
* Koornhof
* Kubayi
* Kumbaca
* Lamola
* Legoete
* Lekganyane
* Letsie
* Letsike
* Ligaraba
* Louw
* Lucas
* Mabe
* Maduna
* Maeco
* Magagula
* Mahambehlala
* Mahlangu
* Mahlaule
* Mahlobo
* Mahumapelo
* Maimela
* Majodina
* Makasi
* Makgato
* Makhubela-Mashele
* Malematja
* Manamela
* Maneli
* Mantashe
* Masemola
* Mashatile
* Masina
* Masondo
* Maswangayi
* Mathabatha
* Mathafa
* Mathale
* Mbiyo
* T Mchunu
* S Mchunu
* Meth
* Mgcina
* Mgweba
* Mhaule
* Mhlauli
* Mkhize
* Mkutu
* Mmolotsane
* Modise
* Moela
* Mofokeng
* Mohai
* Mokoena
* Molwele
* Moraka
* Morolong
* Mosikatsi
* Motaung
* Motshekga
* Motsoaledi
* Mrara
* Mtolo
* Munyai
* Muthambi
* Mvana
* Nalumango
* Ndabeni-Abrahams
* Ndalane
* Ndamase
* Neale-May
* Nel
* Tshabalala
* Nkabane
* Nkopane
* N Nkosi
* Nkosi
* Nontsele
* Nqola
* Ntshalintshali
* Ntshavheni
* Ntuli
* Nzimande
* Nzuza
* Phaahla
* Phiri
* Pholwane
* Plaatjies
* Pule
* Ramaila
* K Ramokgopa
* M Ramokgopa
* Ramolobeng
* Sangoni
* Sapo
* Seabi
* Seate
* Segede
* Sekoati
* Selamolela
* Senne
* Shabangu
* Shiviti
* Sibiya
* Simelane
* Siweya
* Skosana
* Sokanyile
* Sokopo
* Sompa-Masiu
* Sotyu
* Subrathie
* Swarts
* Tau
* Tikana-Gxotiwe
* Tlhong
* Tolashe
* Tshotetsi
* Xaba-Ntshaba
* Xego
* Zikalala

DA|

* Steenhuisen
* Abrahams
* Alexander
* Atkinson
* Aucamp
* Bagraim
* Baptie
* Basson
* Bateman
* Bath
* Bergman
* Bollman
* Bouw-Spies
* Breytenbach
* Burke
* Cameron
* Chance
* Chetty
* Christians
* Christie
* Clarke
* Cuthbert
* De Blocq
* De Villiers
* Engelbrecht
* Essack
* George
* Gondwe
* Graham
* Gwarube
* Hattingh
* Horn
* Hunsinger
* Ismail
* Jordaan
* Kgobisa-Ngcaba
* Khakhau
* Khanyile
* Klopper
* Kohler Barnard
* Krüger
* Labuschagne
* Le Roux
* Linde
* Lorimer
* Lotriet
* Mabhena
* Macpherson
* Madikizela
* Malatsi
* Marais
* Maseko
* Mazzone
* Mbiko
* McGluwa
* Mdluli
* Michalakis
* Mileham
* Moore
* Motshidi-Bodlani
* Mphithi
* Myburgh
* Nhanha
* Nodada
* Peach
* Poole
* Potgieter
* Powell
* Ramongalo
* Roos
* Sarupen
* Sharif
* Schickerling
* Schreiber
* Seitlholo
* Shelembe
* Singh
* Sithole
* Smit
* Smith
* Van der Walt
* Van Zyl
* Vilakazi
* Wakelin
* Whitfield
* Zondi

MK|

* Hlophe
* Abader
* Buthelezi
* Cele
* Douglas
* Gama
* Gamede
* M Gasa
* N Gasa
* Gcwabaza
* Kubheka
* Kobane
* Litchfield-Tshabalala
* E Madlala
* K Madlala
* Mafagane
* Makhubele
* Malinga
* Manyi
* Matutu
* Mbatha
* Mbele
* Mchunu
* Mjadu
* P Mkhize
* Siphetho Mkhize
* Siyabonga Mkhize
* Mngxitama
* Molefe
* Montana
* Moodley
* Motaung
* Motubatse
* Msezane
* Mthethwa
* Mtolo
* Mtshweni
* Muhammad
* Mwali
* Nchabeleng
* Ncube
* Ndhlela
* Ngubane
* Nomvalo
* Ntshaba
* Ntshingila
* Nxumalo
* Reddy
* Rweqana
* Selepe
* Shangase
* Shezi
* Shongwe
* Skosana
* Taaibosch
* Themba
* Van Rooyen
* Zuma-Sambudla

EFF|

* Malema
* Arries
* Blose
* Diale
* Chirwa
* Marshall Dlamini
* Mbali Dlamini
* Gcilishe
* Khawula
* Komane
* Letlape
* Lonzi
* Mailola
* Managa
* Maotwe
* Marais
* Mashabela
* Mathulelwa
* Mathys
* Matiase
* Matiwane
* Mente
* Mhlongo
* Mkhaliphi
* Mkhonto
* Mogale
* Mohlala
* Mokwele
* Mthethwa
* Niehaus
* Nolutshungu
* Ntlangwini
* Pambo
* Paulsen
* Shikwambana
* Tafeni
* Thambo
* Thembekwayo
* Tito

IFP|

* Hlabisa
* E Buthelezi
* Z Buthelezi
* Cebekhulu
* Hadebe
* Hlengwa
* Langa
* Luthuli
* Machi
* Majozi
* Mhlongo
* Mncwango
* Ngcobo
* Singh
* Van der Merwe
* Zondo

PA|

* McKenzie
* Basson
* Daniels
* Hendricks
* Mathopa
* Peters
* Petersen
* Sauls
* Van Wyk

FF+|

* Mulder
* Boshoff
* Denner
* Groenewald
* Van Staden
* Wessels

ActionSA|

* Trollip
* Beesley
* James
* Kobe
* Letlape
* Ngobeni

ACDP|

* Meshoe
* Swart
* Thring

UDM|

* Holomisa
* Kwankwa
* Nontenja

Rise Mzansi|

* Zibi
* Gana

BOSA|

* Maimane
* Hlazo-Webster

ATM|

* Zungula
* Marawu

Al Jama-ah|

* Moosa
* Hendricks

NCC|

* Adams
* Frenchman

PAC|

* Nyhontso

UAT|

* Mahlatsi

Good|

* De Lille

Party leaders in italics
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template