Dunham Massey Hall sundial

Sculpture depicting a kneeling black man holding a sundial on his head

Dunham Massey Hall sundial

The sundial in 2016

Artist| attributed to Andries Carpentière after Jan van Nost
Year| early 18th century
Medium| Polychromed lead and bronze on a stone plinth
Subject| Generic figure personifying the continent of Africa
Dimensions| 185 cm × 114 cm (73 in × 45 in)
Designation| Grade II listed
Condition| Removed
Location| Dunham Massey Hall
Coordinates| 53°22′57″N 2°23′59″W﻿ / ﻿53.38256°N 2.39979°W﻿ / 53.38256; -2.39979
Owner| National Trust
Website| nationaltrustcollections.org.uk

The Dunham Massey Hall sundial is a lead sculpture depicting a kneeling Black man holding a sundial on his head. It was created during the early 18th century, and until 2020 stood outside Dunham Massey Hall, a stately home in Cheshire, England.

Its subject matter attracted criticism and in 2020 the National Trust removed it amid the global wave of statue removals connected with the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests in the wake of the murder of George Floyd. It is currently held in storage.

## Description

[edit]

The sundial sculpture is a black, polychromed cast-lead statue. It depicts a life-size kneeling figure of an African man wearing a feathered loincloth and holding a stone and brass sundial on his head. The figure's eyes are painted white with blue pupils, and the loincloth is painted blue and green. It dates from the 18th century and has been attributed to Andries Carpentière (1677–1737). It is thought that it was cast after a model by Jan van Nost (c.1660–1729) which was installed in 1701 in the Privy Garden of Hampton Court Palace.[1] It was probably commissioned by George Booth, 2nd Earl of Warrington (1675–1758).

The figure has been categorised as an example of a tradition in western art history called the "blackamoor", a personification of the continent of Africa, and as an anonymous ‘kneeling slave’. The blackamoor caricatures appeared in a wide range of arts including sculpture, painting, architectural decoration, ceramics, silverware and furniture, and generally depicted a generic black person in exoticised costume and posted in a servile position, holding an object.[1]

Close to the sculpture was a plaque containing the words: “This sundial is in the style of one commissioned by King William III. It represents Africa, one of four continents known at the time. The figure depicts a Moor, not a slave, and he has knelt here since before 1750.”[2]

## Controversy and removal

[edit]

In June 2020, the National Trust announced that it was "reviewing" the statue amid the global wave of statue removals during the Black Lives Matter protests.[2][3]

Shortly afterwards, the Trust took the decision to remove the statue from its prominent location outside Dunham Massey Hall, stating that the sculpture "caused upset and distress because of the way it depicts a black person and because of its prominence at the front of the house". The National Trust also stated that it did not plan to "censor or deny" colonial history, but intended to devise a new way of displaying it "in a way that fully acknowledges the appalling histories of slavery and the slave trade". Historic England noted that the National Trust had not requested listed building consent prior to the removal of the Grade II-listed sundial.[4][5]

* Detail of the statue

* Position of the sculpture in front of the Hall prior to 2020

* National Trust notice explaining the sculpture's removal

## References

[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Sundial on garden forecourt, Dunham Massey Hall.

1. ^ a b Rylance-Watson, Alice. "A sundial borne by a life-size, kneeling figure of an African man 936871". www.nationaltrustcollections.org.uk. National Trust. Retrieved 21 September 2021.
2. ^ a b Fitzpatrick, John (12 June 2020). "National Trust removes 'degrading' statue of kneeling black man from stately home". The Telegraph. ISSN 0307-1235. Retrieved 23 June 2020.
3. ^ "Dunham Massey says it is "reviewing" a statue depicting a black figure carrying a sundial". Altrincham Today. 10 June 2020. Retrieved 14 June 2020.
4. ^ "Stately home's 'degrading' statue removed". BBC News. 12 June 2020. Retrieved 14 June 2020.
5. ^ "Dunham Massey removes sundial statue as National Trust admits it causes "upset and distress"". Altrincham Today. 11 June 2020. Retrieved 14 June 2020.

* v
* t
* e

Monuments and memorials removed during the George Floyd protests

United States

| Alabama|

* Birmingham – Confederate Soldiers and Sailors Monument; Charles Linn
* Huntsville – Confederate Soldier Memorial ✻
* Mobile – Raphael Semmes

|

Arkansas|

* Bentonville – Confederate Monument ✻
* Little Rock – Company A, Capitol Guards
* Pine Bluff – Confederate Monument

California|

* Carmel-by-the-Sea – Junípero Serra
* Chula Vista – Christopher Columbus
* Los Angeles – Junípero Serra
* Sacramento – Columbus' Last Appeal to Queen Isabella ✻; Junípero Serra; John Sutter
* San Francisco – Christopher Columbus; Ulysses S. Grant; Francis Scott Key; Junípero Serra
* Ventura – Junípero Serra ✻

Connecticut|

* Bridgeport – Christopher Columbus
* Hartford – Christopher Columbus ✻
* Middletown – Christopher Columbus
* New Haven – Christopher Columbus ✻
* New London – Christopher Columbus ✻
* Norwalk – Christopher Columbus

Delaware|

* Dover – Delaware Law Enforcement Memorial
* Wilmington – Christopher Columbus; Caesar Rodney

District of Columbia|

* Washington – Albert Pike

Florida|

* Jacksonville – Confederate Memorial; Florida's Tribute to the Women of the Confederacy ✻
* Palatka – Putnam County Confederate Memorial ✻
* Quincy – Gadsden Confederate Memorial

Georgia|

* Athens – Confederate Monument
* Decatur – DeKalb County Confederate Monument

Indiana|

* Indianapolis – Confederate Soldiers and Sailors Monument

Kentucky|

* Frankfort – Jefferson Davis
* Louisville – John B. Castleman; Louis XVI

Louisiana|

* New Orleans – John McDonogh

Massachusetts|

* Boston – Christopher Columbus; Emancipation Memorial

Michigan|

* Dearborn – Orville L. Hubbard
* Detroit – Christopher Columbus

Minnesota|

* Minneapolis – Calvin Griffith
* Saint Paul – Christopher Columbus

Missouri|

* St. Louis – Christopher Columbus

Nevada|

* Las Vegas – Hey Reb!

New Jersey|

* Camden – Christopher Columbus
* Newark – Christopher Columbus
* West Orange – Christopher Columbus ✻

New Mexico|

* Albuquerque – Juan de Oñate
* Alcalde – Juan de Oñate
* Santa Fe – Diego de Vargas

New York|

* Albany – Philip Schuyler ✻
* Buffalo – Christopher Columbus
* Hempstead – Thomas Jefferson
* New York City – Theodore Roosevelt
* Rochester – Frederick Douglass

North Carolina|

* Asheville – Vance Monument ✻
* Charlotte – Jerry Richardson
* Raleigh – North Carolina Women of the Confederacy; Josephus Daniels; Henry Lawson Wyatt
* Rocky Mount – Nash County Confederate Monument ✻
* Salisbury – Gloria Victis ✻
* Wilmington – Confederate Memorial; George Davis

Ohio|

* Columbus – Christopher Columbus (City Hall); Christopher Columbus (Columbus State Community College)

Oregon|

* Eugene – The Pioneer; The Pioneer Mother
* Portland – Captain William Clark Monument; Thompson Elk Fountain; Thomas Jefferson; Abraham Lincoln; Theodore Roosevelt; Harvey W. Scott; George Washington

Pennsylvania|

* Philadelphia – Christopher Columbus ✻; Frank Rizzo; George Whitefield

Rhode Island|

* Providence – Christopher Columbus

South Carolina|

* Columbia – Christopher Columbus
* Charleston – John C. Calhoun

Tennessee|

* Nashville – Edward W. Carmack; Sam Davis ✻

Texas|

* Beaumont – Our Confederate Soldiers
* Dallas – Confederate War Memorial; One Riot, One Ranger
* Denton – Confederate Soldier Monument ✻
* Fort Worth – Confederate Monument
* Houston – Christopher Columbus; Richard W. Dowling ✻; Spirit of the Confederacy

Virginia|

* Alexandria – Appomattox
* Fredericksburg – Slave Auction Block
* Norfolk – Confederate Monument
* Portsmouth – Confederate Monument
* Roanoke – Robert E. Lee
* Richmond – Christopher Columbus; Jefferson Davis; Howitzer Monument ✻; Stonewall Jackson; Robert E. Lee; Matthew Fontaine Maury; Richmond Police Memorial; J. E. B. Stuart; Williams Carter Wickham

Wisconsin|

* Madison – Forward; Hans Christian Heg

Other countries

| Belgium|

* Antwerp – Leopold II
* Ghent – Leopold II

|

New Zealand|

* Hamilton – John Fane Charles Hamilton

United Kingdom|

* Bristol – Edward Colston
* Cambridge – Sir Ronald Fisher window
* Greater Manchester – Dunham Massey Hall sundial
* London – John Cass; Robert Clayton ✻; Thomas Guy ✻; Robert Milligan

Key: ✻ Pending removal
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template