Eating live seafood

Human consumption of live aquatic organisms

Girl eating oysters, circa 1658 by Jan Steen

The practice of eating live seafood, such as fish, crab, oysters, baby shrimp, or baby octopus, is widespread. Oysters are typically eaten live.[1] The view that oysters are acceptable to eat, even by strict ethical criteria, has notably been propounded in the seminal 1975 text Animal Liberation, by philosopher Peter Singer. However, subsequent editions have reversed this position (advocating against eating oysters). Singer has stated that he has "gone back and forth on this over the years", and as of 2010 states that "while you could give them the benefit of the doubt, you could also say that unless some new evidence of a capacity for pain emerges, the doubt is so slight that there is no good reason for avoiding eating sustainably produced oysters".[2]

## Live seafood dishes

[edit]

Location  | Name  | Image  | Description  | Video

|
|
|
|

China  | Drunken shrimp |  | Drunken shrimp is a popular dish in parts of China. It is based on fresh-water shrimp that are placed in a strong liquor, baijiu, and then eaten, often while they are alive. Modified recipes are used in different parts of China. For example, the drunken shrimp can be cooked in boiling water instead of serving them while they are still live. In other recipes, the shrimp are boiled first and then marinated in alcohol.[3] | Drunken Shrimp on YouTube
Japan  | Ikizukuri |  | Ikizukuri, lit. "prepared alive", also called Ikezukuri is the preparation of sashimi made from live seafood. Fish such as tuna, mackerel, bream and salmon is usually used, but sometimes inkfish like octopus or shellfish like shrimp and lobster are used instead.[4] The practice is controversial, and ikizukuri is outlawed in Australia and Germany.[4]
Odori ebi |  | Odori ebi, lit. "dancing shrimp", is a sashimi delicacy in Japan. It includes live baby pink shrimp, usually dunked in Japanese rice wine, wriggling their legs and waving their antenna as they are eaten. The meal is prepared rapidly and quickly served to ensure the shrimp are still alive. Dancing shrimp are also eaten in Thailand, where they are known as Goong Ten, กุ้งเต้น.  | Eating live "dancing shrimp" in Thailand on YouTube
Korea  | San-nakji |  | Sannakji is a type of hoe, or raw dish, in Korea. It consists of usually dead but seemingly alive Octopus minor (nakji, sometimes translated as "baby octopus" due to the species' small size), cut into small pieces and immediately served, with a light sesame oil seasoning. The dish is eaten while the pieces are still squirming on the plate.[5] | Eating Live Octopus in Korea – Sannakji on YouTube
Taiwan  | Yin Yang fish |  | Yin Yang fish, or dead-and-alive fish, originated in Taiwan. It is a dish which consists of a deep-fried whole fish (usually carp) that remains alive after cooking. The fish's body is cooked while its head is wrapped in a wet cloth to keep it breathing. The fish is then covered in sauce and served live on a plate.[6] Some chefs say they prepare the fish this way to demonstrate its freshness to the customer.[7][8][9] Preparation of this dish is now banned in Taiwan, Australia and Germany.  | Eating A Deep Fried Fish That's Still Alive – Huffington Post
Widespread  | Live oyster |  | Oysters are often eaten live.[10]
Live lobster |  | Restaurants in New York City serve live lobster, advertising that they allow customers the opportunity to "pick belly sashimi out of its still moving body".[citation needed] | I eat a live lobster in Japan on YouTube

## Controversy

[edit]

Part of a series on

Animal rights

Overview

* Animal welfare
* Around the world
* History
* Timeline
* Animal cruelty
* Veganism
* Vegetarianism
* Primate rights
* in research

Movement

* Advocates
* Vegans
* Vegetarians
* Groups

Animal abuse

* Animal–industrial complex
* Killing
* Mutilation
* Wild animals
* Consumption
* Dogs
* Horses
* Cats
* Cattle
* Eating live seafood
* Bloodsports
* Bullfighting
* Hunting
* Fishing
* Animal testing
* Cosmetic
* Captivity
* Zoos
* Circuses
* Oceanariums
* Chick culling
* Fur farming
* Goldfish swallowing
* Companion animals
* Puppy mills
* Abandonment

Ideas

* Animal ethics
* Abolitionism
* Animal protectionism
* Bambi effect
* Carnism
* Personism
* Sentientism
* Speciesism

Related topics

* Cultured meat
* Environmentalism
* Radical
* Deep ecology
* Humanism
* Welfarism

* Animals portal

* v
* t
* e

Octopuses are eaten alive in several countries around the world, including the United States.[11][12] Animal welfare groups have objected to this practice on the basis that octopuses can experience pain.[13] In support of this, since September 2010, octopuses being used for scientific purposes in the European Union are protected by EU Directive 2010/63/EU "as there is scientific evidence of their ability to experience pain, suffering, distress and lasting harm."[14] In the United Kingdom, this means that octopuses used for scientific purposes must be killed humanely, according to prescribed methods (known as "Schedule 1 methods of euthanasia").[15]

London resident Louis Cole ran a YouTube channel in which he ate live seafood.[16] The Guardian commented on the ethical issues raised by the behaviour of Coles that: "It seems objectively less cruel to kill a scorpion instantly than to rear chickens in battery cages or pigs in the most miserable pork farms".[16]

## Health issues

[edit]

In India, the government provides support for an annual fish medicine festival in Hyderabad, where asthma patients are given a live sardine to eat which is supposed to cure their asthma.[17]

Improperly handled food, uncooked food, raw fish consumption and water contamination can transmit parasitic infections. Parasitic infections are common worldwide, although they are major health concerns in tropical countries.[18]

Infection by the fish tapeworm Diphyllobothrium latum is seen in countries where people eat raw or undercooked fish.[19]

## See also

[edit]

* Food portal
* Oceans portal

* Eating live animals
* Eating raw fish
* Ethics of eating meat
* Goldfish swallowing
* Monkey brains (cuisine)
* Odorigui, Japanese term for consumption of live seafood while it is still moving
* Pain in crustaceans
* Pain in fish
* Pain in invertebrates

## References

[edit]

1. ^ Kurlansky, Mark (2009) The Big Oyster: A Molluscular History of New York Random House. ISBN 9781409077930.
2. ^ Cox, Christopher (April 7, 2010). "Consider the Oyster: Why even strict vegans should feel comfortable eating oysters by the boatload". Slate. Archived from the original on April 10, 2010. Retrieved 2010-04-12.
3. ^ 醉蝦 Archived August 17, 2011, at the Wayback Machine
4. ^ a b "The Times & The Sunday Times". The Times. Retrieved 27 April 2018.
5. ^ South Korean fishermen, health officials tangle over octopus Loa Angeles Times, 29 October 2010.
6. ^ "Chinese diners eat live fish in YouTube video". Telegraph.co.uk. 18 November 2009. Archived from the original on 10 July 2015. Retrieved 26 July 2015.
7. ^ Nguyen, ThienVinh (18 March 2010). "Eating A Deep Fried Fish That's Still Alive (VIDEO)". Archived from the original on 4 September 2017. Retrieved 27 April 2018 - via Huff Post.
8. ^ Leach, Ben (18 November 2009). "Chinese diners eat live fish in YouTube video". The Daily Telegraph. London. Archived from the original on 9 January 2018.
9. ^ http://www.islandcrisis.net/2009/11/fried-living-fish/ Archived 2012-02-20 at the Wayback Machine (defunct 28 June 2015)
10. ^ Kurlansky, Mark (2009) The Big Oyster: A Molluscular History of New York Archived 2015-05-19 at the Wayback Machine Random House. ISBN 9781409077930.
11. ^ Eriksen, L. (November 10, 2010). "Live and let dine". The Guardian. Archived from the original on September 6, 2015. Retrieved April 15, 2015.
12. ^ Killingsworth, S. (October 3, 2014). "Why not eat octopus?". The New Yorker. Archived from the original on April 10, 2016. Retrieved April 15, 2016.
13. ^ Ferrier, M. (May 30, 2010). "Macho foodies in New York develop a taste for notoriety". Archived from the original on March 19, 2016. Retrieved April 15, 2016.
14. ^ "Animals used for scientific purposes". European Commission. Retrieved April 15, 2016.
15. ^ "The Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 Amendment Regulations 2012". Archived from the original on February 11, 2016. Retrieved April 15, 2016.
16. ^ a b The man who eats live animals Archived 2014-01-06 at the Wayback Machine The Guardian, 17 April 2012.
17. ^ Indians eat live sardines to cure asthma Archived 2015-09-25 at the Wayback Machine The Telegraph, 20 May 2012.
18. ^ "CDC - Parasites - Parasitic Transmission". www.cdc.gov. 2023-06-12. Retrieved 2023-08-14.
19. ^ U.S. National Library of Medicine, Medline Plus, "Fish Tapeworm," "Fish tapeworm infection: MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia". Archived from the original on 2012-09-16. Retrieved 2012-09-18..

## External links

[edit]

* Macho foodies in New York develop a taste for notoriety The Observer, Sunday 30 May 2010.
* Foods to Try Before You Die Fox News, 19 October 2009.
* Lobsters and Crabs Feel Pain, Study Shows Discovery News, 27 March 2009.
* Do fish feel pain? HowStuffWorks. Retrieved 27 May 2012.

* v
* t
* e

Animal welfare

Issues|

* Abandoned pets
* Animal husbandry
* Animal testing
* Animals in sport
* Artificial insemination
* Barn fire
* Battery cage
* Beak trimming
* Bile bear
* Blood sports
* Captivity
* Chick culling
* Culling
* Concentrated animal feeding operation
* Cow-calf separation
* Dairy farming
* Discretionary invasive procedures on animals
* Eating live animals
* Eating live seafood
* Eyestalk ablation
* Feedback (pork industry)
* Foam depopulation
* Foie gras controversy
* Forced molting
* Fur farming
* Gestation crate
* Hunting
* Horse pain caused by the bit
* Intensive animal farming
* Intensive pig farming
* Livestock branding
* Livestock dehorning
* Livestock transportation
* Pet rental
* Poultry farming
* Puppy mill
* Testing cosmetics on animals
* Ventilation shutdown
* Vivisection
* Welfare of farmed insects
* Wild animal welfare
* Wildlife farming
* Zoos

Concepts|

* Abnormal behaviours in animals
* Animal psychopathology
* Animal shelter
* Animal welfare science
* Anthrozoology
* Behavioral enrichment
* Compassionate conservation
* Conservation welfare
* Ethics of uncertain sentience
* Ethical omnivorism
* Five Domains model
* Five Freedoms
* Humane law enforcement
* Intrinsic value in animal ethics
* Rescue group
* RSPCA Assured
* Three Rs principles
* Welfare biology

Pain|

* Pain in amphibians
* Pain in cephalopods
* Pain in crustaceans
* Pain in fish
* Pain in invertebrates
* Grimace scale

Organisations|

* ASPCA
* Animal Defence and Anti-Vivisection Society
* Animal Defenders International
* Animal Welfare Committee
* Animal Welfare Party
* Animals' Friend Society
* American Humane
* Animal Aid Unlimited
* Animal Welfare Board of India
* Animal Welfare Institute
* Animal Welfare Investigations Project
* Badger Trust
* Band of Mercy
* Battersea
* Best Friends Animal Society
* Blue Cross
* Blue Cross of India
* Care for the Wild International
* Cats Protection
* Church Society for the Promotion of Kindness to Animals
* Compassion in World Farming
* CAWF
* Cinnamon Trust
* Dogs Trust
* DSPA
* DSPCA
* Eurogroup for Animals
* Four Paws
* FRAME
* Hedgehog Care
* Humane Canada
* Humane Farm Animal Care
* HSUS
* Humane Society International
* Humane Slaughter Association
* International Animal Rescue
* IFAW
* International Society for Applied Ethology
* ISPCA
* List of animal welfare organizations
* League Against Cruel Sports
* Marine Connection
* National Society for the Abolition of Cruel Sports
* Network for Animals
* Lord Dowding Fund for Humane Research
* MSPCA-Angell
* National Animal Welfare Trust
* National Anti-Vivisection Society
* National Council for Animals' Welfare
* OneKind
* Party for Animal Welfare
* People for Animals
* People's Dispensary for Sick Animals
* RNZSPCA
* RSPCA
* RSPCA Australia
* Save Me
* Scottish Animal Welfare Commission
* SSPCA
* Tiggywinkles
* Toronto Humane Society
* UFAW
* Wildlife Aid Foundation
* World Animal Protection
* World Horse Welfare

Publications|

* American Humane Magazine
* Animal Protection
* Animal Welfare
* AWI Quarterly
* Cruel Sports
* Human Advocate
* Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science
* Our Dumb Animals
* The Animals' Friend
* The Animals' Guardian
* The Cat
* The Zoophilist

Books|

* A Few Notes on Cruelty to Animals (1846)
* Black Beauty (1877)
* Diet for a New America (1987)
* Min ko vill ha roligt (1990)
* Miracle Dog (2005)
* Striking at the Roots (2007)
* Pawprints of Katrina (2008)
* No Animals Were Harmed (2011)

Activists
and workers|

| Contemporary|

* Michael C. Appleby
* Cynthia Bathurst
* Matthew E. Bershadker
* Christa Blanke
* Moira Brown
* Jan Cameron
* Judy MacArthur Clark
* Kendra Coulter
* Peter Ronald Davies
* Petra Deimer
* Alanna Devine
* Robin Ganzert
* Celia Hammond
* Alison Hanlon
* Brian Hare
* Kathrin Glock
* Emily Patterson-Kane
* Philip Lymbery
* Damien Mander
* Christine Nicol
* Wayne Pacelle
* Sharon Pincott
* Ilka Reinhardt
* Jill Robinson
* Naomi Sagara
* Sepehr Salimi
* Adolfo Sansolini
* Rakesh Shukla
* Karen Stockin
* Patti Strand
* Sally Varma
* Tina M. Widowski

|

Historical|

* Gertrude Ansell
* Emily Appleton
* Gertrude Baillie-Weaver
* H. Baillie-Weaver
* Madeleine Bemelmans
* Henry Bergh
* Annie Bradshaw
* Victoria Braithwaite
* Mary Brancker
* Benjamin Bryan
* Roger A. Caras
* Ada Cole
* Edith Cole
* Jim Cronin
* Brian Davies
* Gerard Lysley Derriman
* Maria Dickin
* Marjorie Doggett
* Muriel Dowding
* Alice Drakoules
* Sarah J. Eddy
* Thomas Erskine
* Agnes Estcourt-Oswald
* Edward G. Fairholme
* Aida McAnn Flemming
* Lucy Furman
* Basil Goldstone
* Julia Goddard
* Robert Gower
* Norman Child Graham
* Colesworthey Grant
* George Greenwood
* Peter Gurney
* Catherine Victoria Hall
* Edward Hemingway
* Rachel Hirschfeld
* Sjoerd Hofstra
* Clive Hollands
* Douglas Houghton
* John A. Hoyt
* W. Hugenholtz
* Rowland Johns
* Velma Bronn Johnston
* Albert Knapp
* Agnes von Konow
* Titus Lander
* Carla Lane
* Etta Lemon
* Victoria Lidiard
* George Watson Little
* Alasdair Alpin MacGregor
* Terry Maple
* Fergus MacCunn
* Frederick Messer
* Richard Martin
* Shirley McGreal
* Lady Mount Temple
* Harriet Nevins
* Felix Ortt
* Catherine Louisa Pirkis
* Eliza Phillips
* Maude Gillette Phillips
* Duchess of Portland
* Samuel Jackson Pratt
* Nancy Price
* Wilfred Risdon
* Peter Roberts
* Jules Rühl
* Jan Salter
* Olive Smith-Dorrien
* Catherine Smithies
* Thomas Bywater Smithies
* Herbert Snow
* Ellin Prince Speyer
* Christine Stevens
* Douglas S. S. Steuart
* Elisabeth Svendsen
* Mary Tealby
* Ralph Waldo Trine
* Sidney Trist
* Ethel Venton
* M. Dudley Ward
* Jessey Wade
* Christopher Wathes
* Franz Weber
* Caroline Earle White
* Emily Williamson
* H. Fergie Woods
* Alice Morgan Wright
* Gretchen Wyler

Scholars
and writers|

| Contemporary|

* Arnold Arluke
* Jonathan Balcombe
* Michael Balls
* Geoffrey Barstow
* Marc Bekoff
* Donald Broom
* Marian Dawkins
* Bob Fischer
* Bruce Fogle
* Jane Goodall
* Temple Grandin
* Celia Haddon
* Jane Hurst
* Erich Hoyt
* Barbara J. King
* Alistair Lawrence
* David Macdonald
* Jeremy Marchant
* Jeff McMahan
* Daniel Mills
* Sy Montgomery
* Virginia Morell
* Yew-Kwang Ng
* Caitlin O'Connell-Rodwell
* Clare Palmer
* Susan J. Pearson
* Dale Peterson
* Jessica Pierce
* Diana Reiss
* Carl Safina
* Matthew Scully
* Paul Shapiro
* Jennifer Skiff
* Brian Tomasik
* Peter Wohlleben

|

Historical|

* George T. Angell
* Patrick Bateson
* Beddow Bayly
* Ernest Bell
* Edward Berdoe
* Arthur Broome
* Jean Burden
* Gerald Carson
* W. H. Cock
* Stephen Coleridge
* Christian Adam Dann
* J. Morewood Dowsett
* Audrey Eyton
* George Fleming
* Ralph Fletcher
* Ruth Harrison
* Caroline van der Hucht-Kerkhoven
* C. W. Hume
* E. Douglas Hume
* Beatrice Lindsay
* James Macaulay
* Basheer Ahmad Masri
* Francis Orpen Morris
* George Nicholson
* Siobhan O'Sullivan
* Charles Reinhardt
* Francis H. Rowley
* W. M. S. Russell
* Chris Sherwin
* Colin Spedding
* William O. Stillman
* John Styles
* Bell Taylor
* Ernst von Weber
* D. G. M. Wood-Gush
* Frans de Waal
* Meta Wellmer
* Hugh Wirth
* William Youatt
* Thomas Young

Categories|

* Animal advocacy parties
* Animal killing
* Animal rights
* Animal welfare and rights legislation
* Animal welfare in sports
* Animal sacrifice
* Animal sanctuaries
* Animal testing
* Animal welfare and rights by country
* Cruelty to animals
* Dishes involving the consumption of live animals
* Ethically disputed business practices towards animals
* Fur trade
* Pain in animals
* People associated with animal welfare
* Vivisection
* Whaling

Religious
considerations|

* Dhabihah
* Jhatka
* Kutha
* Shechita
* Tza'ar ba'alei chayim

Rituals and
festivals|

* Blessing of animals
* Bous al carrer
* Cock throwing
* Combat de Reines
* Eid al-Adha
* Gadhimai festival
* Goat throwing
* Goose pulling
* International Primate Day
* Kapparot
* Dog Meat Festival
* Monkey Buffet Festival
* October Horse
* Pushkar Camel Fair
* Rapa das Bestas of Sabucedo
* Running of the bulls
* Surin Elephant Round-up
* Toro embolado
* World Animal Day

Legislation|

* Animal testing regulations
* Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 (UK)
* Animal Welfare Act 1999 (NZ)
* Animal Welfare Act 2006 (UK)
* Animal Welfare Act of 1966 (US)
* Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022 (UK)
* Cruelty to Animals Act 1876 (UK)
* EU Directive 2010/63/EU (EU)
* EU Directive 1999/74/EC (EU)
* Horse Protection Act of 1970 (US)
* Hunting Act 2004 (UK)
* List of international animal welfare conventions
* Philippine Animal Welfare Act 1998 (Philippines)

Related|

* List of animal rights advocates
* List of animal sanctuaries

* Category

* v
* t
* e

Seafood

Fish|

* Anchovy
* Barramundi
* Billfish
* Carp
* Catfish
* Cod
* Eel
* Flatfish
* Flounder
* Herring
* Mackerel
* Salmon
* Sardine
* Shark
* Sturgeon
* Swordfish
* Tilapia
* Trout
* Tuna
* Whitebait

Shellfish|

* Abalone
* Cockles
* Conch
* Crab
* Crayfish
* Geoduck
* Krill
* Lobster
* Mussels
* Oysters
* Prawn/Shrimp
* Scallops
* Sea urchins
* Crustaceans
* Molluscs

Other seafood|

* Jellyfish
* Marine mammals
* Whale
* Octopus
* Sea cucumber
* Seaweed
* Squid
* Algae
* List of seafoods
* more...

Processed
seafood|

* Caviar
* Dried fish
* Canned fish
* Cod liver oil
* Cured fish
* Fermented fish
* Fish fillet
* Fish head
* Fish oil
* Fish sauce
* Fish paste
* Fish steak
* Fish stock
* Lutefisk
* Salted fish
* Salted squid
* Shark liver oil
* Shrimp paste
* Smoked fish
* Stockfish
* Surimi
* Roe
* more...

Seafood dishes|

* List of seafood dishes
* List of crab dishes
* List of fish dishes
* List of raw fish dishes
* List of tuna dishes
* Bisque
* Chowder
* Fish and chips
* Fish pie
* Fish soup
* Fried fish
* Seafood boil
* Shark fin soup
* Sushi
* Sushi bake
* more...

Health hazards|

* Ciguatera
* Fish diseases and parasites
* Mercury in fish
* Metagonimiasis
* Scombroid food poisoning
* Shellfish poisoning

Advisory services|

* Seafood mislabelling
* Sustainable seafood
* Sustainable seafood advisory lists and certification

Animal welfare|

* Declawing of crabs
* Eyestalk ablation
* Eating live seafood
* Goldfish swallowing
* Live fish trade
* Pain in fish
* Pain in crustaceans
* Shark finning

Related topics|

* Fish preservation
* Fish processing
* Gathering seafood by hand
* History of seafood
* History of sushi
* List of seafood companies
* Pescetarianism
* Raw bar
* Salmon cannery
* Seafood restaurant

* Food portal
* Category: Seafood

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template