Economism

Ideology; term in Marxist discourse

Economism is a direct reduction of any political or cultural phenomena or activities to economics.

In particular, "economism" was a movement in early Russian Social Democratic Labour Party whose position was that the workers' struggle must be only economical and not political.[1]

Robert M. Young used the term as a synonym to Vulgar Marxism, which he defined as "the most orthodox [position in Marxism which] provides one-to-one correlations between the socio-economic base and the intellectual superstructure".[2]

## In Marxist analysis

[edit]

### Lenin

[edit]

The term economism was used by Lenin in his critique of the trade union movement, in reference to how working class demands for a more global political project can become supplanted by purely economic demands.[3] Economistic demands include higher wages, shorter working hours, secure employment, health care, and other benefits.[3]

In his criticism of economism, Lenin's view was that the political figure of the worker could not necessarily be inferred from the worker's social position.[4] Under capitalism, the worker's labor power is commodified and sold in exchange for wages.[4] While negotiating the sale of labor power is necessary for survival under capitalism, Lenin argued that participating in that negotiation did not guarantee a worker's political existence and in fact obscured the underlying political stakes.[4]

Lenin used the term in his attacks on a trend in the early Russian Social Democratic Labour Party around the newspaper Rabochaya Mysl.[5] Among the representatives of Russian economicism were Nikolai Lochoff, Yekaterina Kuskova, Alexander Martynov, Sergei Prokopovich, Konstantin Takhtarev [ru] and others.[6]

### Cultural Revolution

[edit]

The charge of economism is frequently brought against revisionists by anti-revisionists when economics, instead of politics, is placed in command of society; and when primacy of the development of the productive forces is held over concerns for the nature and relations surrounding those productive forces.

"Smashing Economism", 1967 Chinese Propaganda Poster.

Economism became a familiar term in Chinese political discourse only during the Cultural Revolution.[3] Mao Zedong criticized the material incentives of economism, arguing that production must be led by revolutionary politics and to reward productivity with money promoted the wrong values and was inconsistent with making factories a bastion of proletarian politics.[7]

In particular, economism became the most important issue during the Shanghai People's commune.[3] Although many historical narratives of the Cultural Revolution have described economism as an effort on the part of the Chinese Communist Party leadership to bribe workers into political passivity, more recent scholarship argues that those narratives are only "partially correct, at best."[8] Academic Yiching Wu argues, for example, that although local bureaucrats were in fact willing to make economistic concessions to workers, they had no control over the eruption of worker grievances and demands.[8] Instead, economistic demands during this period were rooted in worker's actual conditions and driven by factors including the deterioration of work conditions during the state-driven economic accumulation of the late 1950s, the weakness of Chinese trade unions, and the collapse of the economy during the Great Leap Forward.[9]

## Other uses

[edit]

The term is often used to criticize economics as an ideology in which supply and demand are the only important factors in decisions and outstrip or permit ignoring all other factors.[10] It is believed to be a side effect of neoclassical economics and blind faith in an "invisible hand" or laissez-faire means of making decisions, extended far beyond controlled and regulated markets and used to make political and military decisions.[10] Conventional ethics would play no role in decisions under pure economism, except insofar as supply would be withheld, demand curtailed, by moral choices of individuals.[10] Thus, critics of economism insist on political and other cultural dimensions in society.[10]

Old Right social critic Albert Jay Nock used the term more broadly, denoting a moral and social philosophy "which interprets the whole sum of human life in terms of the production, acquisition, and distribution of wealth", adding: "I have sometimes thought that here may be the rock on which Western civilization will finally shatter itself. Economism can build a society which is rich, prosperous, powerful, even one which has a reasonably wide diffusion of material well-being. It can not build one which is lovely, one which has savor and depth, and which exercises the irresistible power of attraction that loveliness wields. Perhaps by the time economism has run its course the society it has built may be tired of itself, bored of its own hideousness, and may despairingly consent to annihilation, aware that it is too ugly to be let live any longer."[11]

## See also

[edit]

* Class reductionism
* Economic determinism
* Gross national happiness
* Vulgar Marxism – Label for a Marxist philosophy of history

## References

[edit]

1. ^ s:ru:МСЭ2/«Экономизм»
2. ^ Policy Futures in Education, Volume 3, Number 1, 2005. Transmodernism, Marxism and Social Change: some implications for teacher education Mike Cole, Bishop Grosseteste College, Lincoln, United Kingdom
3. ^ a b c d Wu, Yiching (2014). The cultural revolution at the margins : Chinese socialism in crisis. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press. p. 98\. ISBN 978-0-674-41985-8. OCLC 881183403.
4. ^ a b c Russo, Alessandro (2020). Cultural Revolution and revolutionary culture. Durham: Duke University Press. p. 180\. ISBN 978-1-4780-1218-4. OCLC 1156439609.
5. ^ Lenin, Vladimir (1902). "What Is To Be Done?". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 5 October 2023.
6. ^ "ЭКОНОМИСТЫ • Большая российская энциклопедия - электронная версия". bigenc.ru. Archived from the original on 8 May 2020. Retrieved 14 April 2021.
7. ^ Karl, Rebecca E. (2010). Mao Zedong and China in the twentieth-century world : a concise history. Durham [NC]: Duke University Press. p. 137\. ISBN 978-0-8223-4780-4. OCLC 503828045.
8. ^ a b Wu, Yiching (2014). The cultural revolution at the margins : Chinese socialism in crisis. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press. pp. 98–99\. ISBN 978-0-674-41985-8. OCLC 881183403.
9. ^ Wu, Yiching (2014). The cultural revolution at the margins : Chinese socialism in crisis. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press. pp. 99–101\. ISBN 978-0-674-41985-8. OCLC 881183403.
10. ^ a b c d U.C. Mandal, Dictionary Of Public Administration (2007), p. 149, ISBN 9788176257848, Sarup & Sons publishing
11. ^ Nock, Albert Jay. Memoirs Of A Superfluous Man. p. 147.

## Bibliography

[edit]

* John Ralston Saul (2005). The Collapse of Globalism.
* Richard Norgaard (2015). "The Church of Economism and Its Discontents". In Great Transition Initiative.

## External links

[edit]

Wikiquote has quotations related to Economism.

* May God Save Us From Economists at The New Republic

* v
* t
* e

Economics

Theoretical|

* Microeconomics
* Decision theory
* Price theory
* Game theory
* Contract theory
* Mechanism design
* Macroeconomics
* Mathematical economics
* Complexity economics
* Computational economics
* Agent-based computational economics
* Behavioral economics
* Pluralism in economics

Empirical|

* Econometrics
* Economic statistics
* Experimental economics
* Economic history

Applied|

* Agriculture
* Business
* Cultural
* Demographic
* Development
* Ecological
* Education
* Engineering
* Environmental
* Evolutionary
* Financial
* Geographic
* Happiness
* Health
* History
* Information
* Infrastructure
* Institutions
* Labour
* Law
* Management
* Non-monetary
* Organization
* Participation
* Personnel
* Planning
* Policy
* Public sector
* Public choice
* Social choice
* Regional
* Regulatory
* Resources
* Rural
* Service
* Transport
* Urban
* Welfare

Schools
(history)

* Attention
* Mainstream
* Heterodox
* American (National)
* Ancient thought
* Austrian
* Behavioral
* Buddhist
* Chartalism
* Modern monetary theory
* Chicago
* Classical
* Critique of political economy
* Democratic
* Disequilibrium
* Ecological
* Evolutionary
* Feminist
* Freiwirtschaft
* Georgism
* Happiness
* Historical
* Humanistic
* Institutional
* Keynesian
* Neo- (neoclassical–Keynesian synthesis)
* New
* Post-
* Circuitism
* Malthusianism
* Marginalism
* Marxian
* Neo-
* Mercantilism
* Mixed
* Mutualism
* Neoclassical
* Lausanne
* New classical
* Real business-cycle theory
* New institutional
* Physiocracy
* Socialist
* Stockholm
* Supply-side
* Thermo

Economists

* de Mandeville
* Quesnay
* Smith
* Malthus
* Say
* Ricardo
* von Thünen
* List
* Bastiat
* Cournot
* Mill
* Gossen
* Marx
* Walras
* Jevons
* George
* Menger
* Marshall
* Edgeworth
* Clark
* Pareto
* von Böhm-Bawerk
* von Wieser
* Veblen
* Gesell
* Fisher
* Pigou
* Heckscher
* von Mises
* Schumpeter
* Keynes
* Knight
* Polanyi
* Frisch
* Sraffa
* Myrdal
* Hayek
* Kalecki
* Röpke
* Kuznets
* Tinbergen
* Robinson
* von Neumann
* Hicks
* Lange
* Leontief
* Galbraith
* Koopmans
* Schumacher
* Friedman
* Samuelson
* Simon
* Buchanan
* Arrow
* Baumol
* Solow
* Rothbard
* Greenspan
* Sowell
* Becker
* Ostrom
* Sen
* Lucas
* Stiglitz
* Thaler
* Hoppe
* Krugman
* Piketty
* more

Lists|

* Glossary
* Economists
* Publications (journals)
* Schools

* Category
* Index
* Lists
* Outline
* Publications
* Business portal

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template