Gravity battery

Type of electrical storage device

Energy from a source such as sunlight is used to lift a mass such as water upward against the force of gravity, giving it potential energy. The stored potential energy is later converted to electricity that is added to the power grid, even when the original energy source is not available.

A gravity battery is a type of energy storage device that stores gravitational energy—the potential energy E given to an object with a mass m when it is raised against the force of gravity of Earth (g, 9.8 m/s²) into a height difference h.

In a common application, when renewable energy sources such as wind and solar provide more energy than is immediately required, the excess energy is used to move a mass upward against the force of gravity to generate gravitational potential energy. When customers eventually require more energy than the sources can provide, the mass is lowered to convert the potential energy into electricity using an electric generator. Though solid masses such as concrete blocks can be used, more commonly, pumped-storage hydroelectricity generation involves pumping water to higher elevations and later guiding it through water turbines to generate electricity.[1]

## Technical background

[edit]

Pendulum clock driven by three weights as "gravity battery"

An old and simple application is the pendulum clock driven by a weight, which at 1 kg and 1 m travel can store nearly 10 newton-meters [Nm], joules [J] or watt-seconds [Ws], thus 1/3600 of a watt-hour [Wh], while a typical Lithium-ion battery 18650 cell[2] can hold about 7 Wh, thus 2500 times more at 1/20 of the weight. A 100 kg human would have to climb stairs of ten floors (25 m) to match the little battery cell. A 10 ton King Kong climbing a 250m building, and falling down, equals 7 kWh of gravity battery, the size of a small electric motorcycle battery, or the first series of Tesla Powerwall home storage battery.

Using a weight the size of a bus[3] made of scrap iron, at 700 tons, lowered into a 1000 m deep mine shaft, would provide 1900 kWh, but at over US$ 100[4] per ton of scrap iron, would cost US$ 70000, which in 2023 already could buy over 500 kWh of lithium-ion battery packs at US$ 139 per kWh.[5][dubious - discuss]

To challenge chemical batteries on planet Earth, with g around 9.8 m/s², and height differences limited to those of mountains or ocean sea beds, only the mass can be scaled, using water in at least two lakes for pumped-storage hydroelectricity. For example, up to 4 Gigawatthours (GWh) of energy can be stored at Markersbach plant in Germany, which operates since 1979, using two water reservoirs of over 6 million m3 capacity (6 million tons of mass) with an height difference (hydraulic head) of 288 m (945 ft). The turbines can pump, or generate, at up to 1045 MW, for several hours, and usually two full pump-generate cycles within 24 hours. In Germany as of June 2024, pumped storage can hold a total energy of 39 GWh[6] while battery storage is over 14 GWh, with installed power[7] at just under 10 GW for each. The capacity of the 1,4 million battery electric cars in Germany is estimated at around 102 GWh[8] as of June 2024; only few of them can feed back energy into a house, or the grid.

## Development

[edit]

The earliest form of a device that used gravity to power mechanical movement was the pendulum clock, invented in 1656 by Christiaan Huygens. The clock was powered by the force of gravity using an escapement mechanism, that made a pendulum move back and forth. Since then, gravity batteries have advanced into systems that can utilize the force due to gravity, and turn it into electricity for large scale energy storage.

The first gravity based pumped-storage hydroelectricity (PSH) system was developed in 1907 in Switzerland. In 1930, pumped-storage came to the United States by the Connecticut Electric and Power Company. As of 2019, the total world capacity for PSH is 168 GW (gigawatts).[9] The United States has 23 GW capacity from PSH, accounting for nearly 2% of the energy supply system and 95% of utility-scale energy storage in the US. Gravity based pumped-storage electricity is currently the largest form of grid energy storage in the world.[10][11][12][13]

In 2012, Martin Riddiford and Jim Reeves developed the first functioning prototype of GravityLight, a small-scale gravity battery that is now commercially available in certain countries.[14]

Energy Vault, a Swiss company founded in 2017, stores electricity using a crane that raises and lowers blocks of concrete.[15][16][17] In late 2020, a prototype built in Arbedo-Castione used six cranes on a 110-meter-high tower to move 35-ton concrete blocks with a capacity of 80 megawatt hours.[18][19]

Gravitricity, founded in 2011 by Peter Fraenkel, built a 15-meter 250-kilowatt gravity battery prototype near Edinburgh, Scotland that started trial operations and grid-connection in April 2021.[20][21][22]

## Mechanisms and parts

[edit]

Gravity batteries can have different designs and structures, but all gravity batteries use the same properties of physics to generate energy. Gravitational potential energy is the work required to move an object in the opposite direction of Earth's gravity, expressed by the equation

U = m g h {\displaystyle U=mgh}

where  U {\displaystyle U} is gravitational potential energy,  m {\displaystyle m} is the mass of the object,  g {\displaystyle g} is the acceleration due to gravity (9.8 m/s2 on earth), and  h {\displaystyle h} is the height of the object. Using the work-energy principle, the total amount of energy generated can be expressed by the equation

Δ E = m g ( h 1 − h 2 ) {\displaystyle \Delta E=mg(h_{1}-h_{2})}

where  E {\displaystyle E} is the total amount of energy generated and  h 1 {\displaystyle h_{1}} and  h 2 {\displaystyle h_{2}} represent the initial and final heights of an object. The change of energy directly correlates to the vertical displacement of a mass; the higher a mass is lifted, the more gravitational potential energy is stored. The change in energy also directly correlates to the mass of an object; the heavier the mass, the bigger the change in energy.

For example, a weight with the mass of 1,000 kg (1 metric ton) must be elevated to the height of around 367 m (1,200 ft) to store the energy of 1 kWh.

In a gravity battery, a mass is displaced, or lifted, to generate gravitational potential energy that is transformed into electricity. Gravity batteries store gravitational potential energy by lifting a mass to a certain height using a pump, crane, or motor. After the mass is lifted, it now stores a certain gravitational potential energy based on the mass of the object and how high it was lifted. The stored gravitational potential energy is then transferred into electricity. The mass is lowered to fall back to its original height, which causes a generator to spin and create electricity.

## Types of gravity batteries

[edit]

### Large scale

[edit]

Pumped-storage hydroelectricity (PSH) is the most widely used and highest-capacity form of grid-energy storage. In PSH, water is pumped from a lower reservoir to a higher reservoir, which can then be released through turbines to produce energy. An alternative PSH proposal uses a proprietary high-density liquid, 2+1⁄2 times denser than water, which requires a smaller head (elevation) and thus decreases the size and cost of the necessary infrastructure.[23][24]

Energy-storage-by-rail is a concept where excess renewable energy is used to run heavy train cars uphill during times of low energy demand. The potential energy is released later by using regenerative braking as they roll downhill, acting as a gravity battery.[25] A utility-scale (50 MW) facility called GravityLine began construction in October 2020 by Advanced Rail Energy Storage, located at the Gamebird Pit gravel mine in the Pahrump Valley, Nevada, and is planned to deliver up to 15 minutes of service at full capacity.[26]

Lift Renewable Energy uses a form of gravity battery. To store energy, buoyant gas containers are pulled down into water by a winch, water is in effect lifted hundreds of meters. The cycle is then reversed and electricity is generated as the gas containers rise. Relatively little infrastructure is required, the batteries can be sited near major population centers, round trip efficiency is 85+%, and the system can be built at a GWh scale.[citation needed]

Lifted Weight Storage (LWS) technology uses surplus energy to mechanically lift solid weights vertically, typically on a pulley system. When extra energy is needed, the mass is lowered, and the pulley turns a generator.[27]

Energy Vault 60 meter prototype in Arbedo-Castione, Switzerland, in 2021

EnergyVault is designing a LWS system using a tower built from 32-ton concrete blocks, stacked with 120-meter cranes. One commercial unit is expected to store 20 MWh of energy, or enough to power 2,000 Swiss homes a day.[16]

Gravitricity's LWS system in an underground shaft uses an electric winch to lift a 500-to-5000-tonne weight, which when lowered turns the winch motor as a generator. The system generates 10 MWh, enough to power 13,000 homes for two hours. The weight can also be dropped quickly for a small burst of power.[28][29]

### Small scale

[edit]

GravityLight is a small gravity-powered light that operates by manually lifting a bag of rocks or sand up and then letting it fall by itself to generate energy. It is designed as an alternative for those who do not have access to electricity and typically rely on kerosene lamps, which are expensive, dangerous, and polluting.[14][30][31]

## Economics and efficiency

[edit]

Cost of gravity batteries varies by design.

Pumped storage hydropower costs $165/MWh to operate, with a levelized cost of storage (LCOS), of $0.17/kWh.[32][33] The pumps and turbines of PSH systems operate at up to 90% efficiency.[34]

Gravitricity's 250 kW demonstrator is expected to be $1.25 million, promising a 50-year lifespan and efficiency of 80–90%.[citation needed] A 2018 comparative review of the proposition was favorable considering the extended lifespan and power-to-energy cost ratio.[35]

Gravity batteries can make solar and wind more viable as they can store the excess energy they make during peak hours and distribute it later when needed.[27][36]

## Environmental impacts

[edit]

Gravity batteries are designed to be paired with renewable energy solutions whose sources (sunlight, wind, etc) are frequently variable and do not necessarily coincide with demand. It is hoped that they will have a better long term cost than chemical batteries, while having fewer environmental issues than other traditional storage solutions such as pumped-water storage. It is anticipated that gravity battery systems will be able to quickly provide power during peak consumption which may allow them to supplement or replace fossil fuel peaking power plants. Single weight systems are expected to be able to achieve full power generation in less than a second.[20]

Among low-carbon long-duration energy storage methods, pumped storage hydropower had the lowest current energy cost, though lithium-ion batteries are expected to overtake it in the future.[37]: 38 Pumped storage hydropower and other long-duration storage methods are considered to have low environmental and security risks compared to battery technology, with the only limiting factor being geology.[37]: 45–47

## Gravity (chemical) battery

[edit]

Further information: Daniell cell § Gravity cell

From 1870 to 1930,[38] the term "gravity battery" was used to describe a collection of popular battery types where gravity was used to keep the chemical constituents separate based on their respective densities.[39]

## See also

[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Gravity battery.

* Flywheel energy storage
* Grid energy storage
* Pumped-storage hydroelectricity

## References

[edit]

1. ^ Chaturvedi, D.K.; Yadav, Shubham; Srivastava, Tamanna; Kumari, Tanvi (July 27, 2020). "Electricity storage system: A Gravity Battery". 2020 Fourth World Conference on Smart Trends in Systems, Security and Sustainability (WorldS4). London, United Kingdom: IEEE. pp. 412–416\. doi:10.1109/WorldS450073.2020.9210321. ISBN 978-1-7281-6823-4. S2CID 222137266.
2. ^ 3,6 V and 2000 mAh, size 18 by 65 mm, weight under 50 g
3. ^ 2,5 m wide, 4 m high, 10 m long, thus 100 m³
4. ^ "Scrap Metal Prices". October 20, 2020.
5. ^ "Lithium-Ion Battery Pack Prices Hit Record Low of $139/KWH". November 26, 2023.
6. ^ "Main Page".
7. ^ "Energy-Charts".
8. ^ "Main Page-eng".
9. ^ "International - U.S. Energy Information Administration". Energy Information Administration. Retrieved October 30, 2020.
10. ^ "Most pumped storage electricity generators in the U.S. were built in the 1970s - Today in Energy - U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)". www.eia.gov. Retrieved November 16, 2020.
11. ^ "Pumped Hydropower". Energy Storage Association. Archived from the original on January 24, 2022. Retrieved November 16, 2020.
12. ^ "Pumped-Storage Hydropower". Energy.gov. Retrieved November 16, 2020.
13. ^ "2018 Pumped Storage Report" (PDF). National Hydropower Association. January 1, 2018. Retrieved November 3, 2020.
14. ^ a b "When Gravity Equals Light". July 3, 2018. Retrieved October 28, 2020.
15. ^ Spector, Julian (April 3, 2020). "The 5 Most Promising Long-Duration Storage Technologies Left Standing". Greentech Media. Retrieved October 28, 2020.
16. ^ a b "EnergyVault". EnergyVault: Enabling a Renewable World. EnergyVault. 2020.
17. ^ Kelly-Detwiler, Peter (October 14, 2019). "Energy Vault Receives $110 Million From SoftBank For Gravity-Assisted Power Storage". Forbes. Retrieved October 30, 2020.
18. ^ "Revolutionary idea to store green power for the grid". swissinfo.ch. January 3, 2020.
19. ^ "What is the 'gravity energy storage system' that is attracting attention as a low-cost energy storage means?". gigazine.net. January 7, 2021.
20. ^ a b Moore, Samuel K. (January 5, 2021). "Gravity Energy Storage Will Show Its Potential in 2021". IEEE Spectrum. Retrieved February 9, 2021.
21. ^ "Gravitricity celebrates success of 250kW energy storage demonstrator". Solar Power Portal. April 23, 2021.
22. ^ "Gravitricity battery generates first power at Edinburgh site". BBC. April 21, 2021.
23. ^ Ambrose, Jillian (February 8, 2021). "Powering up: UK hills could be used as energy 'batteries'". the Guardian.
24. ^ "RheEnergise Home Page". www.rheenergise.com. Retrieved February 8, 2021.
25. ^ Massey, Nathanael. "Energy Storage Hits the Rails Out West". Scientific American. Archived from the original on December 4, 2017. Retrieved December 31, 2017.
26. ^ Hebrock, Robin (October 16, 2020). "Energy storage project breaks ground in Pahrump". Pahrump Valley Times. Retrieved March 18, 2021.
27. ^ a b says, Len Gardiner (February 20, 2020). "What Are Gravity Batteries?". TheGreenAge. Retrieved October 29, 2020.
28. ^ "Fast, long-life energy storage". Gravitricity. Retrieved October 28, 2020.
29. ^ Kropotin, P. (November 20, 2023), "Gravity Energy Storage Systems with Weight Lifting", Thermopedia, Begel House Inc., ISBN 978-1-56700-456-4, retrieved June 24, 2024
30. ^ "GravityLight - light from the lift of a weight". deciwatt.global. Retrieved October 29, 2020.
31. ^ "GravityLight". Deciwatt. Retrieved November 1, 2020.
32. ^ "Energy Storage Technology and Cost Characterization Report" (PDF). U.S. Department of Energy. July 1, 2019. Retrieved November 1, 2020.
33. ^ "Pumped-hydro energy storage – cost estimates for a feasible system". Brave New Climate. April 5, 2010. Retrieved November 16, 2020.
34. ^ "Pump Up the Storage | Do the Math". November 15, 2011. Retrieved November 16, 2020.
35. ^ O'Neill, Neasan (April 23, 2018). "Is gravity and old mineshafts the next breakthrough in energy storage?". Imperial College News. Imperial College London.
36. ^ Ong, Sandy (December 6, 2019). "Mix Mountains and Gravity for Long-Term Energy Storage". IEEE Spectrum. Retrieved November 16, 2020.
37. ^ a b Mann, Margaret; Putsche, Vicky; Shrager, Benjamin (February 24, 2022). Grid Energy Storage: Supply Chain Deep Assessment (PDF) (Report). United States Department of Energy. Retrieved August 6, 2022.
38. ^ "Google Ngram search for popularity of the term Gravity Battery". Archived from the original on April 8, 2020.
39. ^ "Gravity Batteries by Robert Murray-Smith". YouTube. April 7, 2020.