Great Plains wolf

Subspecies of gray wolf

"Lobo wolf" redirects here. For the Mexican subspecies, see Mexican wolf.

Great Plains wolf

Scientific classification
Kingdom:  | Animalia
Phylum:  | Chordata
Class:  | Mammalia
Order:  | Carnivora
Suborder:  | Caniformia
Family:  | Canidae
Subfamily:  | Caninae
Genus:  | Canis
Species:  |

C. lupus

Subspecies:  |

C. l. nubilus

Trinomial name
Canis lupus nubilus

Say, 1823[1]

Synonyms[3]

variabilis (Wied-Neuwied, 1841)[2]

The Great Plains wolf (Canis lupus nubilus), also known as the buffalo wolf, lobo wolf or loafer, is a subspecies of gray wolf that once extended throughout the Great Plains, from southern Manitoba and Saskatchewan in Canada southward to northern Texas in the United States.[4] The subspecies was thought to be extinct in the wild in 1926, until studies declared that its descendants were found in Minnesota, Wisconsin and Michigan.[5] In addition, 20 wolves were bought by Dr. Edward Heber McCleery, whose descendants are now located in Bridger, Montana. They were described as a large, light-colored wolf but with black and white varying between individual wolves, with some all white or all black. The Native Americans of North Dakota told of how only three Great Plains wolves could bring down any sized bison.[6]

## Taxonomy

[edit]

Two Great Plains wolves cuddling

This wolf was first recorded in 1823 by the naturalist Thomas Say in his writings on Major Stephen Long's expedition to the Great Plains. Say was the first person to document the difference between a "prairie wolf" (coyote) and on the next page of his journal a wolf which he named Canis nubilus. He described one of these wolves that had been caught in a trap:

> Canis nubilus. Dusky, the hair cinereous at base, then brownish-black then gray, then black; the proportion of black upon the hairs, is so considerable, as to give to the whole animal a much darker colour, than the darkest of the latrans, but the gray of the hairs combining with the black tips, in the general effect produce a mottled appearance; the gray colour predominates on the lower part of the sides; ears short, deep brownish-black, with a patch of gray hair on the anterior side within; muzzle blackish above; superior lifjs, anterior to the canine teeth, gray; inferior jaw at tip and extending in a narrowed line backwards, nearly to the origin of the neck, gray; beneath dusky ferruginous, greyish with long hair between the hind thighs, and with a large white spot on the breast; the ferruginous colour is very much narrowed on the neck, but is dilated on the lower part of the cheeks; legs brownish- black, with but a slight admixture of gray hairs, excepting on the anterior edge of the hind thighs, and the lower edgings of the toes, where the gray predominates; the tail is short, fusiform, a little tinged with ferruginous, black above near the base and at tip, the tip of the trunk hardly attaining to the os calcis; the longer hairs of the back, particularly over the shoulders, resemble a short sparse mane.....The aspect of this animal is far more fierce and formidable than either the common red wolf, or the prairie wolf, and is of a more robust form.[1]

In 1995, the American mammalogist Robert M. Nowak analyzed data on the skull morphology of wolf specimens from around the world. For North America, he proposed that there were only five subspecies of gray wolf. One of these he described as a moderate-sized wolf that was originally found from Texas to Hudson Bay and from Oregon to Newfoundland which he named C. l. nubilus.[7][8] This proposal was not recognized in the taxonomic authority Mammal Species of the World (2005), which classified this wolf as one of the 27 subspecies of Canis lupus in North America.[3]

### Lineage

[edit]

"Roping gray wolf" - John C. H. Grabill photograph 1887

Gray wolves (Canis lupus) migrated from Eurasia into North America 70,000–23,000 years ago[9][10] and gave rise to at least two morphologically and genetically distinct groups. One group is represented by the extinct Beringian wolf[9][11] and the other by the modern populations.[9]

A haplotype is a group of genes found in an organism that are inherited together from one of their parents.[12][13] Mitochondrial DNA (mDNA) passes along the maternal line and can date back thousands of years.[14] A 2005 study compared the mitochondrial DNA sequences of modern wolves from across North America with those from thirty-four specimens dated between 1856 and 1915 collected from the western United States, Mexico and the Labrador Peninsula. The historic population was found to possess twice the genetic diversity of modern wolves,[15][16] which suggests that the mDNA diversity of the wolves eradicated from the western US was more than twice that of the modern population. Some haplotypes possessed by the Mexican wolf, the extinct Southern Rocky Mountain wolf and the Great Plains wolf were found to form a unique "southern clade". All North American wolves group together with those from Eurasia, except for the southern clade which form a group exclusive to North America. The wide distribution area of the southern clade indicates that gene flow was extensive across the recognized limits of its subspecies.[16]

A study published in 2018 looked at the limb morphology of modern and fossil North American wolves. The major limb bones of the dire wolf, Beringian wolf, and most modern North American gray wolves can be clearly distinguished from one another. Late Pleistocene wolves on both sides of the Laurentide Ice Sheet — Cordilleran Ice Sheet possessed shorter legs when compared with most modern wolves. The Late Pleistocene wolves from the Natural Trap Cave, Wyoming and Rancho La Brea, southern California were similar in limb morphology to the Beringian wolves of Alaska. Modern wolves in the Midwestern USA and northwestern North America possess longer legs that evolved during the Holocene, possibly driven by the loss of slower prey. However, shorter legs survived well into the Holocene after the extinction of much of the Pleistocene megafauna, including the Beringian wolf. Holocene wolves from Middle Butte Cave (dated less than 7,600 YBP) and Moonshiner Cave (dated over 3,000 YBP) in Bingham County, Idaho were similar to the Beringian wolves. The Mexican wolf (C. l. baileyi) and pre-1900 samples of the Great Plains wolf (Canis lupus nubilus) resembled the Late Pleistocene and Holocene fossil gray wolves due to their shorter legs.[9]

### Ancestor

[edit]

In 2021, a mitochondrial DNA analysis of North American wolf-like canines indicates that the extinct Late Pleistocene Beringian wolf was the ancestor of the southern wolf clade, which includes the Mexican wolf and the Great Plains wolf. The Mexican wolf is the most ancestral of the gray wolves that live in North America today.[17]

## Description

[edit]

Buffalo Hunt, White Wolves Attacking Buffalo Bull \- George Catlin 1844

The Great Plains wolf's distribution once extended throughout the Great Plains from southern Manitoba and Saskatchewan southward to northern Texas.[4]

They are described as a large, light-colored wolf but with black and white varying between individual wolves, with some all white or all black. The average body length ranges from 1.4 m (4.6 ft) to 1.96 m (6.4 ft) [18][19] with a weight of the male averaging 100 lb (45 kg) and the heaviest recorded at 150 lb (68 kg). The Native Americans of North Dakota told of how only three of these wolves could bring down a buffalo, including a large old bull.[6]

## Decline and resurgence

[edit]

Early records indicate C. l. nubilus being very abundant throughout the Great Plains. After the mass extirpations of the American bison (Bison bison), they were poisoned and trapped for their pelts until few remained. The pioneer Alexander Henry wrote about these wolves several times during his trips to North Dakota, noting how they fed extensively on buffalo carcasses. They were bold around humans, sometimes approaching people and entering their tents while they slept. He recorded that Indians occasionally dug up wolf pups from their prairie dens and dug large pitfalls to capture wolves and foxes. Members of his group dug up wolf pups and found them very tame and easy to train. In 1833 Maximilian of Wied-Neuwied recorded that these wolves were common in the upper Missouri, where the Indians operated wolf pits and traded wolves to him in exchange for two rolls of tobacco each. He found the Indian's dogs to be more of a personal danger than the wolves.[6]

In 1856, Lt. G. K. Warren gathered together a collection of this wolf's skulls which now reside in the National Museum of Natural History.[6] He noted that some wolf skull specimens appeared not to be full-blooded wolves as their molars indicated a hybrid. There have been many stories in this region about ferocious hybrid wolf-dogs, and it is possible that the wolf's tameness and lack of fear of humans might be due admixture with domestic dogs. In North Dakota, by 1875 sightings of the wolf became rare, by 1887 they were almost gone.[6] On the Canadian Prairies, bounty payments for wolves commenced in 1878 in Manitoba, and 1899 in Saskatchewan and Alberta.[20] In North Dakota, two were sighted in 1915 by Remington Kellogg. The last known wolf was shot in 1922.[6] The Great Plains wolf was declared extinct in the wild in 1926.

Five wolf pups from McCleery's backyard

Pennsylvania-based physician Dr. Edward Heber McCleery purchased 20 wolves between 1921 and 1930 through several Canadian and American dealers, authorities and zoos. In 1930, the U.S. Biological Survey informed McCleery that these were the last Great Plains wolves. Currently, the wolves are cared for by Wolf Haven International in Bridger, Montana.[21]

Later studies found wolves in Minnesota, Wisconsin and Upper Michigan that were descendants of Canis lupus nubilus. The Great Plains wolf had migrated eastward during the early 1970s to Minnesota, resulting in a change of wolf skull sizes (when compared to the bordering eastern wolf).[22] Even then, their number became fewer and fewer until they were federally protected as an endangered species in 1974. Since then, their population became larger in the Great Lakes region and by 2009, their estimate grew to 2,992 wolves in Minnesota, 580 in Michigan and 626 in Wisconsin. A R [18][19][5]

## See also

[edit]

* Three Toes of Harding County

## References

[edit]

1. ^ a b Say, T. et al. (1823) Account of an expedition from Pittsburgh to the Rocky Mountains, performed in the years 1819 and '20 : by order of the Hon. J.C. Calhoun, sec'y of war: under the command of Major Stephen H. Long. From the notes of Major Long, Mr. T. Say, and other gentlemen of the exploring party. Philadelphia : H.C. Carey and I. Lea ... p. 169-173.
2. ^ Prince Maximilian of Wied-Neuwied (1841). Reise in das innere Nord-Amerika in den Jahren 1832 bis 1834. Vol. 2\. Coblenz. p. 95.[Trip to the interior of North America 1832 to 1834]
3. ^ a b Wozencraft, W. C. (2005). "Order Carnivora". In Wilson, D. E.; Reeder, D. M. (eds.). Mammal Species of the World: A Taxonomic and Geographic Reference (3rd ed.). Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 575–577\. ISBN 978-0-8018-8221-0. OCLC 62265494. url=https://books.google.com/books?id=JgAMbNSt8ikC&pg=PA576
4. ^ a b Mech, L. (1970). "Appendix A – Subspecies of wolves – North American". The Wolf: The Ecology and Behavior of an Endangered Species. Doubleday. ISBN 978-0-307-81913-0. "Great Plains wolf; buffalo wolf; loafer. This is another extinct subspecies. It once extended throughout the Great Plains from southern Manitoba and Saskatchewan southward to northern Texas."
5. ^ a b Wydeven, Adrian P; Van Deelen, Timothy R; Heske, Edward J, eds. (2009). Recovery of Gray wolves in the Great Lakes Region of the United States, An Endangered Subpecies Success Story. link.springer.com. doi:10.1007/978-0-387-85952-1. ISBN 978-0-387-85951-4. S2CID 132793403.
6. ^ a b c d e f A Biological Survey of North Dakota, Vernon, B., (1926), North American Fauna: Number 49: pp. 150–156.
7. ^ Nowak, R. (2003). "9-Wolf Evolution and Taxonomy". In Mech, L. David; Boitani, Luigi (eds.). Wolves: Behaviour, Ecology and Conservation. University of Chicago Press. p. 245\. ISBN 0-226-51696-2.
8. ^ Another look at wolf taxonomy Nowak, R.M. 1995. Pp. 375–397 in L.N. Carbyn, S.H. Fritts and D.R. Seip, eds. Ecology and conservation of wolves in a changing world: proceedings of the second North American symposium on wolves. Canadian Circumpolar Institute, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
9. ^ a b c d Tomiya, Susumu; Meachen, Julie A (2018). "Postcranial diversity and recent ecomorphic impoverishment of North American gray wolves". Biology Letters. 14 (1): 20170613. doi:10.1098/rsbl.2017.0613. PMC 5803591. PMID 29343558.
10. ^ Koblmüller, Stephan; Vilà, Carles; Lorente-Galdos, Belen; Dabad, Marc; Ramirez, Oscar; Marques-Bonet, Tomas; Wayne, Robert K.; Leonard, Jennifer A. (2016). "Whole mitochondrial genomes illuminate ancient intercontinental dispersals of grey wolves (Canis lupus)". Journal of Biogeography. 43 (9): 1728–1738\. Bibcode:2016JBiog..43.1728K. doi:10.1111/jbi.12765. S2CID 88740690.
11. ^ Leonard, J. A.; Vilà, C; Fox-Dobbs, K; Koch, P. L.; Wayne, R. K.; Van Valkenburgh, B (2007). "Megafaunal extinctions and the disappearance of a specialized wolf ecomorph" (PDF). Current Biology. 17 (13): 1146–50\. Bibcode:2007CBio...17.1146L. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2007.05.072. hdl:10261/61282. PMID 17583509. S2CID 14039133. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2016-12-28. Retrieved 2018-01-27.
12. ^ Cox, C. B.; Moore, Peter D.; Ladle, Richard (2016). Biogeography: An Ecological and Evolutionary Approach. Wiley-Blackwell. p. 106\. ISBN 978-1-118-96858-1.
13. ^ Editorial Board (April 2012). Concise Dictionary of Science. V&s Publishers. ISBN 978-93-81588-64-2.
14. ^ Arora, Devender; Singh, Ajeet; Sharma, Vikrant; Bhaduria, Harvendra Singh; Patel, Ram Bahadur (2015). "Hgs Db: Haplogroups Database to understand migration and molecular risk assessment". Bioinformation. 11 (6): 272–5\. doi:10.6026/97320630011272. PMC 4512000. PMID 26229286.
15. ^ Miklosi, Adam (2015). Dog Behaviour, Evolution, and Cognition. Oxford Biology (2 ed.). Oxford University Press. pp. 106–107\. ISBN 978-0199545667.
16. ^ a b Leonard, Jennifer A.; Vilà, Carles; Wayne, Robert K. (2004). "FAST TRACK: Legacy lost: Genetic variability and population size of extirpated US grey wolves (Canis lupus)". Molecular Ecology. 14 (1): 9–17\. doi:10.1111/j.1365-294X.2004.02389.x. PMID 15643947. S2CID 11343074.
17. ^ Wilson, Paul J.; Rutledge, Linda Y. (2021). "Considering Pleistocene North American wolves and coyotes in the eastern Canis origin story". Ecology and Evolution. 11 (13): 9137–9147\. Bibcode:2021EcoEv..11.9137W. doi:10.1002/ece3.7757. PMC 8258226. PMID 34257949.
18. ^ a b "Great Plains Wolf". www.wolfquest.org.
19. ^ a b "Great Plains Wolf". wolf-stuff.com.
20. ^ Proulx, Gilbert; Rodtka, Dwight (2015). "Predator Bounties in Western Canada Cause Animal Suffering and Compromise Wildlife Conservation Efforts". Animals. 5 (4): 1034–1046\. doi:10.3390/ani5040397. PMC 4693201. PMID 26479482.
21. ^ "Welcome to the Dr. McCleery Lobo Wolves Digital Archive! · Dr. McCleery Lobo Wolves Digital Archive". McCleery Wolves. Retrieved 2025-03-18.
22. ^ Mech, L. David; Nowak, Ronald M.; Weisberg, Sanford (2011-11-22). "Use of cranial characters in taxonomy of the Minnesota wolf (Canis sp.)". Canadian Journal of Zoology. 89 (12): 1188–1194\. doi:10.1139/z11-097. ISSN 0008-4301.

## External links

[edit]

Data related to Canis lupus nubilus at Wikispecies

* International Wolf Center

Wikimedia Commons has media related to
Canis lupus nubilus
(Great Plains wolf).

* v
* t
* e

Extinct Canidae

* Kingdom Animalia
* Phylum Chordata
* Class Mammalia
* Order: Carnivora
* Suborder: Caniformia

Canidae

Canidae

* †Prohesperocyon

†Hesperocyoninae|

* Hesperocyon
* Mesocyon
* Cynodesmus
* Sunkahetanka
* Philotrox
* Enhydrocyon
* Paraenhydrocyon
* Caedocyon
* Ectopocynus

Osbornodon|

* O. brachypus
* O. fricki
* O. iamonensis
* O. renjiei
* O. sesnoni
* O. scitulus
* O. wangi

†Borophaginae

* Archaeocyon
* Oxetocyon
* Otarocyon
* Rhizocyon

| Phlaocyonini|

* Cynarctoides

Phlaocyon|

* P. achoros
* P. annectens
* P. latidens
* P. leucosteus
* P. mariae
* P. marslandensis
* P. minor
* P. multicuspus
* P. taylori
* P. yatkolai

Borophagini

* Cormocyon
* Desmocyon
* Metatomarctus
* Euoplocyon
* Psalidocyon
* Microtomarctus
* Protomarctus
* Tephrocyon

Cynarctina|

* Paracynarctus
* Cynarctus

Aelurodontina|

* Tomarctus
* Aelurodon

Borophagina|

* Paratomarctus
* Carpocyon
* Protepicyon
* Epicyon

Borophagus|

* B. diversidens
* B. dudleyi
* B. hilli
* B. littoralis
* B. orc
* B. parvus
* B. pugnator
* B. secundus

| Caninae|

*     * see below↓

|

Caninae

Caninae

* †Leptocyon
* †Metalopex

| Urocyon|

* †U. citrinus
* †U. galushai
* †U. minicephalus
* †U. progressus
* †U. webbi

|

Vulpini

* †Ferrucyon
* †Prototocyon

Nyctereutes
(raccoon dogs)|

* †N. abdeslami
* †N. donnezani
* †N. lockwoodi
* †N. megamastoides
* †N. sinensis
* †N. tingi
* †N. vinetorum

Vulpes
(true foxes)|

* †V. hassani
* †V. odessana
* †V. praeglacialis
* †V. qiuzhudingi
* †V. riffautae
* †V. rooki
* †V. skinneri
* †V. stenognathus

Canini (true dogs)

* †Canis gezi
* †Nurocyon

Cerdocyonina
(zorro)|

* †Protocyon
* †Theriodictis

Speothos|

* †Pleistocene bush dog (S. pacivorus)

†Dusicyon|

* Falkland Islands wolf (D. australis)
* D. avus
* D. cultridens

Lycalopex
(South American foxes)|

* †L. cultridens (?)
* †L. ensenadensis

| Canina (wolf-like canids)|

*     * see below↓

|

Canina (wolf-like canids)

Canina

* †Dire wolf (Aenocyon)
* †Sardinian dhole (Cynotherium)
* †Trinil dog (Mececyon)
* †Merriam's dog (Megacyon)
* †Xenocyon

| †Eucyon|

* E. davisi
* E. debonisi
* E. ferox
* E. intrepidus
* E. khoikhoi
* E. kuta
* E. marinae
* E. minor
* E. monticinensis
* E. skinneri
* E. wokari
* E. zhoui

|

Lycaon|

* †L. magnus
* †L. sekowei

Dhole (Cuon alpinus)|

* †C. a. antiquus
* †C. a. caucasicus
* †European dhole (C. a. europaeus)
* †Tien Shan dhole (C. a. hesperius)

Canis

* †C. adoxus
* †C. antonii
* †C. apolloniensis
* †Armbruster's wolf (C. armbrusteri)
* †C. arnensis
* †C. borjgali
* †C. cedazoensis
* †C. chihliensis
* †Edward's wolf (C. edwardii)
* †Etruscan wolf (C. etruscus)
* †C. lepophagus
* †Mosbach wolf (C. mosbachensis)
* †C. nehringi
* †C. palmidens
* †C. variabilis

| Coyote (C. latrans)|

* †Pleistocene coyote (C. l. orcutti)

|

Red wolf (C. rufus)|

* †Florida black wolf (C. r. floridanus)
* †Texas red wolf (C. r. rufus)

Wolf (C. lupus)

| †Prehistoric|

* C. l. bohemica
* C. l. lunellensis
* C. l. maximus
* C. l. santenaisiensis
* Cave wolf (C. l. spelaeus)
* Beringian wolf

|

†Recently
extinct|

* Sicilian wolf (C. l. cristaldii)
* Hokkaido wolf (C. l. hattai)
* Japanese wolf (C. l. hodophilax)
* Austro-Hungarian wolf

* Synonymized under C. l. arctos: Bernard's wolf (C. l. bernardi)

* Synonymized under C. l. occidentalis: Kenai Peninsula wolf (C. l. alces)
* Manitoba wolf (C. l. griseoalbus)

* Synonymized under C. l. nubilus: Newfoundland wolf (C. l. beothucus)
* Cascade mountain wolf (C. l. fuscus)
* Mogollon mountain wolf (C. l. mogollonensis)
* Texas wolf (C. l. monstrabilis)
* Southern Rocky Mountain wolf (C. l. youngi)

* See also: Evolution of the wolf
* Category:Extinct canids

Taxon identifiers

Canis lupus nubilus|

* Wikidata: Q718688
* Wikispecies: Canis lupus nubilus
* CoL: 5G724
* EoL: 1267233
* GBIF: 6164217
* iNaturalist: 201561
* ITIS: 726836
* MSW: 14000768
* NatureServe: 2.741244
* NCBI: 2841922

Canis nubilus|

* Wikidata: Q122930284
* GBIF: 8585515
* Paleobiology Database: 44868

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template
*[†]: Extinct