Greyfriars Bobby

Skye Terrier

For the novel, see Greyfriars Bobby (novel). For the film, see Greyfriars Bobby (film).

Greyfriars Bobby

This statue of Bobby sits at the corner of Edinburgh's Candlemaker Row and George IV Bridge, and is a Category A listed building

Breed| Skye Terrier or Dandie Dinmont Terrier[1]
Born| 4 May 1855
Edinburgh, Scotland [citation needed]
Died| 14 January 1872 (aged 16)
Edinburgh, Scotland
Resting place| Greyfriars Kirkyard
Known for| Guarding the grave of his owner until he died himself on 14 January 1872
Owner| John Gray
Awards| Key to the City of Edinburgh

Greyfriars Bobby (4 May 1855 – 14 January 1872) was a Skye Terrier or Dandie Dinmont Terrier[1] who became known in 19th-century Edinburgh for spending 14 years guarding the grave of his owner until he died on 14 January 1872. The story continues to be well known in Scotland, through several books and films. A prominent commemorative statue and nearby graves are a tourist attraction.

## Traditional view

[edit]

Albumen print (c. 1865) thought to be of Greyfriars Bobby Greyfriars Bobby's collar

The best-known version of the story is that Bobby belonged to John Gray, who worked for the Edinburgh City Police as a nightwatchman. When John Gray died he was buried in Greyfriars Kirkyard, the kirkyard surrounding Greyfriars Kirk in the Old Town of Edinburgh. Bobby then became known locally, spending the rest of his life sitting on his master's grave.[2][3]

In 1867 the lord provost of Edinburgh, Sir William Chambers, who was also a director of the Scottish Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, paid for Bobby's licence and gave the dog a collar, now in the Museum of Edinburgh.[3][4]

Bobby is said to have sat by the grave for 14 years.[2][3][4][5] He died in 1872[4][5] and a necropsy by Prof Thomas Walley of the Edinburgh Veterinary College concluded he had died from cancer of the jaw.[6]

He was buried just inside the gate of Greyfriars Kirkyard, not far from John Gray's grave.[3]

A year later, the English philanthropist Lady Burdett-Coutts was charmed by the story and had a drinking fountain topped with Bobby's statue (commissioned from the sculptor William Brodie) erected at the junction of George IV Bridge and Candlemaker Row (opposite the entrance to the churchyard) to commemorate him.[5][7]

### John Gray

[edit]

Not to be confused with John Auld (disambiguation), Old Jock, or Old John.

John Gray (died 15 February 1858) commonly known in popular culture as Auld Jock, was a gardener who came to Edinburgh in 1850 with his wife Jess and son John.[8] He avoided working in a workhouse by joining the Edinburgh City Police as a nightwatchman.[9] Around this time he looked after Greyfriars Bobby.[10] Bobby would follow John Gray whilst he was at work. According to records, policemen were obliged to have watchdogs with them.[11] John Traill claimed that John Gray was a farmer who regularly visited his coffee house at the one o'clock gun, though this might have been embellished as Traill didn't own the coffee house until four years after John Gray died.[11] Gray reportedly died of tuberculosis on 15 February 1858 and was buried in Greyfriars Kirkyard.[12] For 14 years, the dog stayed at his master's graveside.[13]

In January 2018, his grave was toppled by vandals.[14] George Robinson of the One O'Clock Gun Association said "There are guys wandering around there totally out of their mind. You can't control that."[15]

## Alternative views

[edit]

Greyfriars Bobby with John Traill and his family, 1868

The accuracy of stories of Greyfriars Bobby has been challenged many times: for instance, in Forbes Macgregor's Greyfriars Bobby: The Real Story at Last,[16] Jan Bondeson's Greyfriars Bobby: The Most Faithful Dog in the World,[17] and Richard Brassey's "Greyfriars Bobby The Most Famous Dog in Scotland".[18]

Questions about the story's accuracy are not new. In a newspaper article in The Scotsman, "Greyfriars Bobby A Dog's Devotion" (11 August 1934), Councillor Wilson McLaren responds to contemporary questions about the accuracy of the stories by describing his own conversation, in 1871, with "Mr Traill" of "Traill's Coffee House" in relation to the dog he himself was then feeding, reassuring readers about the story Mr Traill had given him, and describing responses in 1889 to questions about the story's accuracy.[19] A sense of the difficulty of determining accuracy is gained from two opposing letters to The Scotsman newspaper on 8 February 1889 (part of the debate referred to by McLaren), both from people claiming close links to Greyfriars Kirk, both claiming to have known of the dog personally but with opposing views over the accuracy of stories.[20]

A common discussion is over which of two people named John Gray was the real owner of Bobby (one being a night watchman and the other a farmer).[4] In Councillor McLaren's account, Mr Traill in 1871 had spoken about John Gray the farmer.[19]

Jan Bondeson's book advances the view that fundamental facts about the dog and its loyalty are wrong. Bondeson states as background that in 19th-century Europe, there are over 60 documented accounts of graveyard or cemetery dogs. They were stray dogs, fed by visitors and curators to the point that the dogs made the graveyards their home. People began to believe that they were waiting by a grave and so the dog was looked after. Bondeson claims that after an article about Bobby appeared in The Scotsman, visitor numbers to the graveyard increased, which supposedly created a commercial benefit for the local community.[17] Bondeson also speculates that in 1867, the original Bobby died and was replaced with a younger dog, which explains Bobby's supposed longevity.[17]

According to a book published in 2022,[21] Bobby was more likely to have been a dandie dinmont terrier than a Skye terrier as is generally supposed. The claim was made by Mike Macbeth, president of the Dandie Dinmont Terrier Club of Canada. Macbeth pointed out that the dandie dinmont terrier was extremely popular in Scotland at the time, with some 60 breeders in the Edinburgh area, whereas skye terriers tended to be confined to the Isle of Skye.[22]

## Memorials

[edit]

Bobby's headstone in Greyfriars Kirkyard

* Greyfriars Bobby Fountain, the fountain includes a life-size statue of Greyfriars Bobby created by William Brodie in 1872, financed by Baroness Burdett-Coutts of the Coutts banking family. The monument is Edinburgh's smallest listed structure.
* Greyfriars Bobby's Bar, a pub located on the ground floor of the Candlemaker Row's houses.[23]
* Greyfriars Bobby's headstone, the headstone was erected by The Dog Aid Society of Scotland and unveiled by the Duke of Gloucester on 13 May 1981.[24] The monument reads, "Greyfriars Bobby – Died 14 January 1872 – Aged 16 years – Let his loyalty and devotion be a lesson to us all".
* In 2021 a new monument to mark the 150th anniversary of the dog’s death was placed close to the east wall of Greyfriars Kirk. This was ordered by Robbie Beattie, a senior manager with Edinburgh City Council's Bereavement Service.[25] No consultation or conventional commissioning process was undertaken, despite the Kirkyard lying within a UNESCO World Heritage site.[26]

Memorial to Bobby in Greyfriars Kirkyard, erected in 2021

## Books and films directly about Bobby

[edit]

* The 1902 historical account, "The True Story of Greyfriars Bobby" by Henry T. Hutton, Publisher: Edinburgh
* The 1912 novel Greyfriars Bobby by Eleanor Atkinson embellished the story and made John Gray a shepherd, known as "Auld Jock".[27] The 1961 Walt Disney film Greyfriars Bobby: The True Story of a Dog was based on the book.[28]
* The Adventures of Greyfriars Bobby, another film, was released in the UK in February 2006 starring James Cosmo and Christopher Lee (released elsewhere in 2005 under the alternative title Greyfriars Bobby).[29] The Edinburgh Castle scenes in this film were actually shot at Stirling Castle. Many expressed reservations that a West Highland Terrier was cast as Bobby, and that new characters were added while one of the major characters in Bobby's life, John Traill, was omitted.[30]

## Other references in popular culture

[edit]

* A British Rail class 47 number 47711 was named "Greyfriars Bobby" in 1981. One of the original nameplates now sits above the sales counter at Harburn Hobbies model shop in Edinburgh.[31]
* Challenge to Lassie (1949), is an earlier film based on Atkinson's book, replacing Bobby with Lassie.[32]
* The 1945 film The Body Snatcher, has an oblique reference to Bobby. The title character John Gray, played by Boris Karloff, while seeking to dig up a corpse in Greyfriars Kirkyard, encounters a dog (named "Robbie") guarding the grave. The dog is killed.[33]
* In 1964, popular Scottish duo The Alexander Brothers recorded a song 'Greyfriars Bobby' on Pye Records which refers to Bobby being loyal to a shepherd.[34]
* Gaspode, a talking dog in the Discworld fantasy novels of Terry Pratchett, claims to be named after a famous dog named Gaspode with a similar story to Greyfriars Bobby, though he says it was later discovered that the reason this Gaspode stayed howling by his master's grave was that his tail was trapped under the gravestone.[35]
* In 2019, the Royal Lyceum Theatre in Edinburgh did a production of A Christmas Carol[36] that relocated the events of the tale to Edinburgh a year after Auld Jock's death, attributing the old man's death to his being evicted by Scrooge. Bobby is depicted in the play by a puppet, and is shown to be friends with Tiny Tim (also portrayed by a puppet); Scrooge's vision of the future sees Bobby being taken by the dog-catcher after Tiny Tim's death means there is nobody to warn Bobby. The play concludes with Scrooge using a gift left behind by the Spirit of Christmas Nooadays (the Scots equivalent of the Ghost of Christmas Present) to provide Bobby's licence, thus protecting him from the dog-catcher.[37][38]
* The music video for Scottish musician Lewis Capaldi's song "Wish You the Best" features a storyline based on Greyfriars Bobby.[39]
* In the 2013 video game Grand Theft Auto V, developed by Edinburgh-based studio Rockstar North, a dog (either a Skye Terrier or West Highland Terrier) can be seen visiting a headstone at the Vinewood cemetery on a daily basis.[40]

## See also

[edit]

* Bobbie the Wonder Dog
* Dog on the Tuckerbox
* Fido (Italian dog)
* Hachikō
* Kostya
* List of individual dogs

## References

[edit]

1. ^ a b Khan, Aina J (24 July 2022). "Faithful terrier Greyfriars Bobby may have been a different breed, book claims". The Guardian. Retrieved 23 August 2022.
2. ^ a b greyfriarsbobby.co.uk "Greyfriars Bobby - Greyfriars". Archived from the original on 6 March 2013. Retrieved 11 February 2013. (11 February 2013).
3. ^ a b c d Education Scotland website "Greyfriars Bobby - Making of industrial and urban Scotland - Scotlands History". Archived from the original on 21 February 2013. Retrieved 11 February 2013. (11 February 2013).
4. ^ a b c d Edinburgh Museums and Galleries website [1] (11 February 2013).
5. ^ a b c Edinburgh Museums (monuments) website [2] Archived 7 January 2014 at the Wayback Machine (11 February 2013)
6. ^ Greyfriars Bobby: The Most Faithful Dog in the World, J Bondeson
7. ^ "Story of Greyfriars Bobby: A Heartwarming Tale". scotlandwelcomesyou.com. 16 February 2018. Retrieved 2 March 2021.
8. ^ "Greyfriars Bobby". Historic UK. Retrieved 3 August 2021.
9. ^ "Touching tribute to Greyfriars Bobby and Edinburgh watchman John Gray hosted at Greyfriars Kirkyard". Edinburgh Evening News. 15 January 2020. Retrieved 2 August 2021.
10. ^ Robert Petterson, The One Year Book of Amazing Stories 365 Days of Seeing God’s Hand in Unlikely Places, Tyndale House Publishers, 2018 ISBN 978-1496424037
11. ^ a b "Greyfriars Bobby – separating facts from fiction". Must See Scotland. 20 November 2020. Retrieved 29 July 2021.
12. ^ "The story behind Greyfriars Bobby – Scotland's most famous dog". Daily Record. 4 August 2020. Retrieved 3 August 2021.
13. ^ "Story of Greyfriars Bobby: A Truly Heartwarming And Inspiring Tale". Scotland Welcomes You. 16 February 2018. Retrieved 4 August 2021.
14. ^ "Grave of Greyfriars Bobby's master is vandalised". BBC News. 11 January 2018. Retrieved 2 August 2021.
15. ^ "Brazen vandals topple famous headstone of Greyfriars Bobby owner 'Auld Jock' amid complaints about drug users in kirkyard". Daily Record. 11 January 2018. Retrieved 3 August 2021.
16. ^ Macgregor, Forbes "Greyfriars Bobby: The Real Story at Last" Steve Savage Publishers Limited, 2nd Revised edition, (2002), ISBN 978-1904246008
17. ^ a b c Jan Bondeson, Greyfriars Bobby: The Most Faithful Dog in the World, Amberley Publishing, 2011, ISBN 978-1445607627
18. ^ Brassey, Richard "Greyfriars Bobby" Orion Childrens, (2010), ISBN 978-1444000573
19. ^ a b The Scotsman, 11 August 1934
20. ^ The Scotsman, 8 February 1889
21. ^ Macbeth, Mike (2022). The Dandie Dinmont Terrier, the True Story of Scotland's Forgotten Breed.
22. ^ "Faithful terrier Greyfriars Bobby may have been a different breed, book claims". The Guardian. 24 July 2022.
23. ^ "Greyfriars Bobby's Bar in Edinburgh - Nicholson's Pubs".
24. ^ "Remember when: we've got no grave concerns", The Scotsman, 26 March 2016
25. ^ "36651 Correspondence" (PDF). edinburgh.axlr8.uk.
26. ^ beta.edinburgh.gov.uk. "Freedom of information (FOI) disclosure log – The City of Edinburgh Council". Edinburgh.gov.uk. Retrieved 11 August 2022.
27. ^ Eleanor Atkinson. Greyfriars Bobby at Project Gutenberg
28. ^ Douglas Brode (2004). From Walt to Woodstock: How Disney Created the Counterculture. University of Texas Press. pp. 194–196. ISBN 0-292-70273-6.
29. ^ The Adventures of Greyfriars Bobby: IMDB.com website.
30. ^ Stirling Castle location, The Adventures of Greyfriars Bobby: BBC.co.uk website.
31. ^ Thunderbuck Ram. "Names". Class47.co.uk. Retrieved 11 August 2022.
32. ^ Hanson, Patricia King, ed. (1999). AFI Catalog of Motion Pictures Produced in the United States. University of California Press. p. 400. ISBN 0-520-21521-4.
33. ^ Gregory W. Mank (2009). Bela Lugosi and Boris Karloff: The Expanded Story of a Haunting Collaboration. McFarland. pp. 481, 504. ISBN 978-0-78645-472-3.
34. ^ "The Alexander Brothers - Greyfriar's Bobby". Discogs.
35. ^ Pratchett, Terry; Simpson, Jacqueline (2008). The Folklore of Discworld. Doubleday. pp. 250–251. ISBN 9780385611008.
36. ^ "An Edinburgh Christmas Carol". Royal Lyceum Theatre Edinburgh. Retrieved 1 May 2021.
37. ^ Kelly, Paul (28 November 2022). "REVIEW: An Edinburgh Christmas Carol". thesouthernreporter.co.uk. The Southern Reporter. Retrieved 5 April 2023.
38. ^ O'Donoghue, Natalie (27 November 2022). "Review: AN EDINBURGH CHRISTMAS CAROL, Lyceum Theatre". broadwayworld.com. Broadway World. Retrieved 5 April 2023.
39. ^ Cook, Allen; McDonald, Toni (18 April 2023). "Lewis Capaldi music video stars terrier from Worcester". BBC. Retrieved 22 April 2023.
40. ^ Cooper, Dalton (23 April 2021). "Grand Theft Auto 5 Dog Visits Its Owner's Grave Every Day". Game Rant. Retrieved 21 July 2023.

## External links

[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Greyfriars Bobby.

* Greyfriars Kirkyard Trust
* The Adventures of Greyfriars Bobby (2005) Film website.
* Greyfriars Bobby Statue Location at Waymarking.com website.

* v
* t
* e

Edinburgh

History|

* Etymology
* Burning of Edinburgh
* Mary, Queen of Scots
* Greyfriars Kirk
* Burke and Hare
* Kingdom of Scotland
* Act of Union 1707
* Parliament of Scotland
* David Hume
* Edinburgh Review
* Holyrood Abbey
* Treaty of Edinburgh
* Edinburgh town walls
* Old Town
* New Town
* Robert Adam
* James Craig
* Church of Scotland
* Disruption of 1843
* Thomas Aikenhead
* Deacon Brodie
* North British Railway
* Visit of King George IV
* Sir Walter Scott
* Edwin of Northumbria
* Devolution
* Burgh
* Lothian
* Edinburgh Stock Exchange
* Porteous Riots
* Silvermills
* Tron riot
* Greyfriars Bobby
* Great Fire of Edinburgh

Governance|

* City of Edinburgh Council
* Lord Provost of Edinburgh
* Scottish Parliament

Buildings and
landmarks|

* Arthur's Seat
* Balmoral Hotel
* Brass Founders' Pillar
* Bute House
* Calton Hill
* Craiglockhart Castle
* Edinburgh Castle
* Edinburgh International Conference Centre
* Forth Rail Bridge
* Forth Road Bridge
* Governor's House
* Holyrood Palace
* National Monument
* New College
* Old College
* Parliament House
* Princes Street Gardens
* Ross Fountain
* Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh
* Scott Monument
* Scottish Parliament Building
* St Andrew's House
* St Giles' Cathedral
* Victoria Quay

Museums
and galleries|

* Fruitmarket Gallery
* The Georgian House
* Museum of Edinburgh
* National Museum of Scotland
* National War Museum
* Dynamic Earth
* Public art
* Royal Scottish Academy
* Scottish National Gallery
* Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art

Theatres and
concert halls|

* Bedlam Theatre
* Edinburgh Arena (proposed)
* Edinburgh Playhouse
* Festival Theatre
* King's Theatre
* Queen's Hall
* Reid Concert Hall
* Royal Lyceum Theatre
* St Cecilia's Hall
* Traverse Theatre
* Usher Hall

Economy|

* Bank of Scotland
* Caledonian Brewery
* Edinburgh Park
* Edinburgh BioQuarter
* Fort Kinnaird
* Ocean Terminal
* Royal Bank of Scotland
* Scottish Widows
* Standard Life

Transport|

* A1 road
* Airport
* Edinburgh Airport Rail Link
* Edinburgh City Bypass
* Edinburgh Crossrail
* Edinburgh Waverley railway station
* Haymarket railway station
* Lothian Buses
* Trams

Health and
education|

* Edinburgh College
* Edinburgh College of Art
* Heriot-Watt University
* Hospitals
* Moray House School of Education
* Napier University
* Queen Margaret University
* Schools
* Scotland's Rural College
* University of Edinburgh

Festivals|

* Edinburgh Festival Fringe
* Edinburgh International Book Festival
* Edinburgh International Film Festival
* Edinburgh International Festival
* Edinburgh International Television Festival
* Hogmanay
* Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo

Other topics|

* Demographics of Edinburgh
* Geography of Edinburgh
* Beer in Edinburgh
* Graveyards and cemeteries in Edinburgh

* Category
* Commons
* Outline
* Portal

Authority control databases

International|

* ISNI
* VIAF
* FAST

National|

* United States
* Israel

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template