Hamburg Uprising

1923 communist insurrection in Germany

Hamburg Uprising

Part of the Revolutions of 1917–1923 and
Political violence in Germany (1918–1933)

Reichswehr soldiers searching passersby near a barricade
| Date| 23–24 October 1923

|

Location|

Hamburg, Germany

Result|  Government victory
Belligerents
Weimar Republic|  Communist Party of Germany
Commanders and leaders
|  Ernst Thälmann
Strength
6,000 police officers and soldiers|  5,000
Casualties and losses
17 dead
69 wounded|  21 dead
175 wounded
102 captured
61 civilians dead
1,400 people arrested

* v
* t
* e

Political violence in Germany (1918–1933)

1918-1923

* German strike of January 1918
* Collapse of the Imperial German Army
* German Revolution of 1918–1919
* Greater Poland uprising (1918–1919)
* Occupation of the Rhineland
* Silesian Uprisings
* Feme murders
* 1920 East Prussian plebiscite
* Reichstag Bloodbath
* Kapp Putsch
* Ruhr uprising
* French occupation of Frankfurt
* March Action
* Klaipėda Revolt
* Occupation of the Ruhr
* Cuno strikes
* Küstrin Putsch
* German October
* Hamburg Uprising
* Beer Hall Putsch

1929-1933

* Blutmai
* Stennes revolt
* Murder of Paul Anlauf and Franz Lenck
* Altona Bloody Sunday
* 1932 Prussian coup d'état
* Potempa murder of 1932
* Kwami Affair
* 1932 Berlin transport strike
* Reichstag fire
* Nazi boycott of Jewish businesses

Related

* Röhm purge
* July Putsch
* Kristallnacht

* v
* t
* e

Revolutions of
1917–1923

1917

* Russian Revolution
* Pistolerismo
* French Army mutinies
* Potato riots
* Conscription disturbance at the Brisbane School of Arts
* Australian general strike
* Étaples mutiny
* Brazil strike movement

1918

* Austro-Hungarian strike
* German strike of January
* Finnish Civil War
* Cattaro mutiny
* Arab Revolt
* Rice riots
* British police strikes
* Canadian Labour Revolt
* German Revolution
* Revolutions and interventions in Hungary
* Red Week
* Egyptian Revolution
* Swiss general strike
* 1918 protest in Zagreb
* Darwin rebellion
* Greater Poland uprising

1919

* Biennio Rosso
* Tragic Week
* Southampton mutiny
* Irish War of Independence
* First Red Scare
* La Canadenca strike
* Kinmel Park mutiny
* March First Movement
* May Fourth Movement
* Turkish War of Independence
* Sette Giugno
* Epsom riot
* Luton Peace Day Riots

1920

* Ruhr uprising
* Iraqi Revolt
* Patagonia Rebelde

1921

* Mongolian Revolution
* March Action
* Uprising in West Hungary
* Rand Rebellion

1923

* September Uprising
* German October
* Hamburg Uprising
* Kraków riot

Part of a series on the

History of Hamburg
by timeline

Prehistory and Antiquity

* Hamburg culture (15 ka)
* Treva (1st CE)
* Tangendorf disc brooch (3rd CE)

Middle Ages

* Hammaburg (810)
* Archbishops (832–1072)
* Cathedral (1035)
* Bornhöved (1227)
* Hanseatic League (1321–1669)
* Victual Brothers (1389–1401)
* Constitution (1410)

Early Modern

* Free Imperial city (1510–1806)
* All Saints' Flood (1570)
* Barbary pirates (1578–1751)
* Greenland whaling (1644–1806)

Continental Blockade

* Bouches-de-l'Elbe (1811–14)
* Siege of Hamburg (1813)
* Hanseatic Legion (1813)

Modern

* Great Fire (1842)
* Speicherstadt (1888)
* Cholera Epidemic (1892)
* Dockers' Strike (1896)
* Greater Hamburg Act (1937)
* Neuengamme concentration camp (1938–45)
* Bombing in World War II (1940–45)

Contemporary

* Hamburg Ravensbrück trials (1947)
* North Sea flood (1962)
* Hamburg cell (2001)

by other topic

Political and economic history

*     * Port history (1189–)
* Constitutional history (1410–)
* Diplomatic history (1648–1918)
* Postal history (1649–1868)

Jewish history

*     * Sephardic Jews (1590–1942)
* Hamburg Temple (1818–1938)
* Israelitisches Familienblatt (1898–1938)

* Other Hamburg topics

* Culture
* Demographics
* Economy
* Education
* Geography
* Politics

* * *

* Hamburg portal

* v
* t
* e

The Hamburg Uprising (‹See Tfd›German: Hamburger Aufstand) was a communist insurrection that occurred in Hamburg in Weimar Germany on 23 October 1923. A militant section of the Hamburg Communist Party of Germany launched an uprising as part of the so-called German October. Rebels stormed 24 police stations, 17 in Hamburg and seven in Schleswig-Holstein Province in Prussia, and established barricades around the city. The communist insurgency in Hamburg was futile, lacking support from the rest of Germany or from the Soviet Union, and disintegrated within a day. Around 100 people died during the Hamburg Uprising and the exact details of the event, as well as the assessment of its impact, remain controversial.

## Background

[edit]

Main article: German October

See also: Occupation of the Ruhr, Cuno strikes, and Küstrin Putsch

Between 1919 and 1923, the Weimar Republic was in crisis and there were many violent conflicts between left-wing and right-wing elements. The economic situation of the population was rapidly deteriorating and by autumn 1923 hyperinflation was at its peak, which brought gains in popularity to the Communist Party (KPD). The Occupation of the Ruhr region further radicalized the political disputes. In August 1923, there was a wave of nationwide strikes against Chancellor Wilhelm Cuno, which led to a vote of no-confidence in the Reichstag and his subsequent resignation.[1] At the end of September, the government declared a state of emergency. On 1 October, the Black Reichswehr attempted the Küstrin Putsch. Two weeks later, on 13 October, the Reichstag adopted an enabling act under Article 48 of the Weimar Constitution that, with the stipulation that any decree made under it could be rejected by the Reichstag, was to facilitate a de jure dictatorship by Chancellor Gustav Stresemann until either a change of government or 31 March 1924.[2] A demonstration of several thousand unemployed stormed the "no-protest zone" (Bannmeile) around the Hamburg city hall, an action which, during this period, risked death at the hands of the police and right-wing paramilitaries.[citation needed] In Saxony and Thuringia, coalition governments were formed that included the KPD, which saw this as an opportunity to take over.

Within the international Communist movement, there was discussion of an attempted armed rebellion in Germany. Leon Trotsky and other influential members of the Soviet Politburo and the Comintern advanced the idea, but Heinrich Brandler, head of the KPD, felt it was premature. The exact motives of the small Hamburg group led by Hugo Urbahns and Hans Kippenberger, who planned the uprising, remain unknown.

According to Russian historian Vadim Rogovin, the leadership of the German Communist party had requested that Moscow send Leon Trotsky to Germany to direct the 1923 insurrection. However, this proposal was rejected by the Politburo which was controlled by Stalin, Zinoviev and Kamenev who decided to send a commission of lower-ranking Russian Communist party members.[3]

## Uprising

[edit]

Late on 22 October 1923, the military leader of the KP Wasserkante, one of the most militant sections of the Hamburg KPD, received orders via the regional party leadership to begin the rebellion. Only 1,300 took an active part in the rebellion from the beginning, although the Hamburg KPD numbered some 14,000 members.[4] No more than 5,000 workers had participated by the end of it.[5] On 23 October at 5:00 a.m., they stormed 26 police precincts and took weapons from 17 of them.[6]

There was also activity in Altona and the urban district of Stormarn, where the police stations in Schiffbek[7] and Bramfeld were attacked and weapons taken. In Bad Oldesloe, Ahrensburg and Rahlstedt, train tracks and streets were blockaded. In the town of Bargteheide, insurgents arrested local government leaders and proclaimed the "Soviet Republic of Stormarn". In Schiffbek, where the KPD had support, placards were posted to calm residents and to urge support for the uprising, declaring "Long live Soviet Germany! Long live the Federation of Soviet states of the world! Long live the world revolution!"[7]

Most of the uprising was quelled in a few hours. In Schiffbek, it lasted till just past noon.[7] Only in Barmbek, where the KPD had received some 20% of the vote in the previous election, the insurgents were supported by residents, who helped them build barricades and brought them food. The rebels were able to maintain their position during the entire day, despite the continuous exchange of gunfire. At night, however, convinced of the hopelessness of their situation, they snuck away. The next day, the police launched a major offensive against empty barricades.

## Aftermath

[edit]

The Uprising claimed the lives of 17 police officers, 21 rebels and 61 innocent bystanders.[5] Sixty-nine police officers were wounded, along with 175 rebels.[5] There were 1,400 people arrested, with 443 tried in a special court.[5] In Schiffbek alone, 191 people were arrested and later, in February 1925, had to be tried at the Altona Landgericht because of unrest in Schiffbeck, where the KPD had garnered 32.4% of the vote in the May 1924 election.[7] This was the largest of the trials against the Uprising insurgents.

The Hamburger Werftarbeiter
('Hamburg wharf worker'), 1928 painting by Heinrich Vogeler

The Uprising contributed to the deteriorating relationship between the two working class political parties. After the Uprising, the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) refused to work with the KPD and even intensified the repression of the KPD by reinforcing the government's positions. Rejection by both the Republic and the SPD strengthened the Communists. Within the KPD, the Uprising became a heroic legend[8] about the courageous few rebels facing a hopeless fight. The defeat of the Uprising was interpreted as the consequence of weak centralization and a lack of obedience to party-oriented structures and evidence that these must be increased.

Sections of the middle class saw in the Uprising their fears of a Bolshevik Revolution confirmed and became more attracted to anti-communist politics. As a result, in the 1924 Hamburg Reichstag election, the German National People's Party saw their share of the votes rise from 12% to about 20%, though it quickly dropped back to around 12% in 1928.[9]

## Films

[edit]

* Der Hamburger Aufstand Oktober 1923. Dokumentary, Federal Republic of Germany, (1971) 41 Min., Written by Reiner Etz, Gisela Tuchtenhagen, Klaus Wildenhahn; Director: Klaus Wildenhahn. Produced by the German Film and Television Academy Berlin and NDR (Hamburg)[10]
* Ernst Thälmann – Sohn seiner Klasse. Drama, German Democratic Republic (1954) Director: Kurt Maetzig

## Citations

[edit]

1. ^ Michaelis, Andreas (14 September 2014). "Wilhelm Cuno 1876–1933". Deutsches Historisches Museum (in German). Retrieved 17 May 2023.
2. ^ Ermächtigungsgesetz. Vom 13. Oktober 1923 - via Wikisource.
3. ^ Rogovin, Vadim Zakharovich (2021). Was There an Alternative? Trotskyism: a Look Back Through the Years. Mehring Books. p. 272\. ISBN 978-1-893638-97-6.
4. ^ Lemmons 2013, p. 35.
5. ^ a b c d Lemmons 2013, p. 36.
6. ^ Stadtteilkollektiv Rotes Winterhude (2003), p. 11
7. ^ a b c d "Schiffbek im Hamburger Aufstand" Archived 2016-07-14 at the Wayback Machine Geschichtswerkstatt Billstedt (in German)
8. ^ Erich Wollenberg, "Der Hamburger Aufstand und die Thälmann-Legende" (1964) (PDF) Papiertiger–Kollektiv. Republished in Schwarze Protokolle, No. 6 (1973), p. 10\. Retrieved 28 July 2023 (in German)
9. ^ Hamburg election results Die Freie und Hansestadt Hamburg Reichstagswahlen 1919–1933. Retrieved 25 July 2011 (in German)
10. ^ Der Hamburger Aufstand Oktober 1923 A Wochenschau broadcast produced in Hamburg, March–August 1971, filmportal.de (in German)

## Bibliography

[edit]

* Bernhard H. Bayerlein, Leonid G. Babicenko (Eds.): Deutscher Oktober 1923. Ein Revolutionsplan und sein Scheitern, Berlin (2003). (Archive des Kommunismus – Pfade des XX. Jahrhunderts. 3) ISBN 3-351-02557-2 (in German)
* Sergej Tretjakow: Hörst Du, Moskau. Drama about the Hamburg Uprising. Moscow (1923) (in German)
* Angelika Voß: Der „Hamburger Aufstand“ im Oktober 1923. In: Angelika Voß, Ursula Büttner, Hermann Weber: Vom Hamburger Aufstand zur politischen Isolierung. Kommunistische Politik 1923–1933 in Hamburg und im Deutschen Reich, Hamburg (1983), pp. 9–54 (in German)
* Louis Biester (postum): Der Kommunistenputsch 1923. In: Jahrbuch für den Kreis Stormarn (1985), pp. 73–76 (in German)
* Stadtteilkollektiv Rotes Winterhude: Der Hamburger Aufstand – Verlauf – Mythos – Lehren. Hamburg (2003) (in German)[1]
* Berlin, Jörg: "Staatshüter und Revolutionsverfechter. Arbeiterparteien in der Nachkriegszeit"; in: Ulrich Bauche (Ed.): Wir sind die Kraft. Arbeiterbewegung in Hamburg von den Anfängen bis 1945; Exhibition catalogue, Museum für Hamburgische Geschichte, VSA Hamburg (1983) pp. 103–131. ISBN 3-87975-355-5 (in German)
* Lothar Danner: Ordnungspolizei Hamburg. Betrachtungen zu ihrer Geschichte 1918–1933, Hamburg (1958) (in German)
* Lemmons, Russel (2013). Hitler's Rival: Ernst Thälmann in Myth and Memory. Lexington, Kentucky: The University Press of Kentucky. ISBN 978-0-8131-4090-2.

## See also

[edit]

* Ernst Thälmann
* Spartacist uprising 1919
* Ruhr Uprising 1920
* Beer Hall Putsch
* Hamburgische Bürgerschaft
* 1923 in Germany

## External links

[edit]

* Literature about Hamburg Uprising in the German National Library catalogue
* Ernst Thälmann's interpretation (in German)
* Larissa Reissner, Hamburger Oktober 1923 Berlin (1924) (in German)

Authority control databases: National |

* Germany
* United States
* Israel

|

1. ^ Der Hamburger Aufstand - Verlauf - Mythos - Lehren pp. 1-32 (PDF) and pp. 33-64 (PDF) Rotes Winterhude (in German)

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template