High Court of Tuvalu

Court in Tuvalu

High Court of Tuvalu

Established| 1978
Jurisdiction| Tuvalu
Location| Funafuti
Authorised by| Constitution of Tuvalu
Appeals to| Court of Appeal of Tuvalu
Number of positions| 3
Chief Justice
Currently| The Hon Sir Gordon Ward OBE (Acting)
Since| 2019

Politics of Tuvalu

Government

* Constitution of Tuvalu

* Law
* Human rights

Legislature

* Parliament of Tuvalu

* Speaker Samuelu Teo

* Natano
* Kofe
* Laafai
* Taupo
* Tehulu
* Melei
* Laoi
* Teo
* Boreham
* Kiritome
* Sopoaga
* Talama
* Paeniu
* Sualiki
* Taape
* Meisake

Executive

* Monarch

* Charles III

* Governor-General

* Sir Tofiga Vaevalu Falani

* Prime Minister

* Feleti Teo (I)

* * *

* Cabinet

Judiciary

* Judicial Committee of the Privy Council

* President Robert Reed

* High Court of Tuvalu

* Chief Justice Charles Sweeney

Elections

* 1977 general elections
* 1981 general elections
* 1985 general elections
* 1989 general elections
* September 1993 general elections
* November 1993 general elections
* 1998 general elections
* 2002 general elections
* 2006 general elections
* 2010 general elections
* 2015 general elections
* 2019 general elections
* 2024 general elections

Foreign relations

* Visa policy

Tuvalu portal

* Other countries

* v
* t
* e

The High Court of Tuvalu is the superior court of Tuvalu. It has unlimited original jurisdiction to determine the Law of Tuvalu and hears appeals from the lower courts.[1]

## General jurisdiction of the High Court

[edit]

The High Court of Tuvalu has general jurisdiction and responsibility, as authorised by sections 122 to 136 of the Constitution of Tuvalu.[2] The jurisdiction of the High Court extends over both criminal and civil matters, and deals with cases at first instance or on appeal from the lower courts. The administration of the court is set out in Superior Courts Act (1987) and the admiralty jurisdiction is addressed in the Admiralty Jurisdiction (Tuvalu) Order (1975).

## Lower courts

[edit]

There are eight Island Courts and Lands Courts; appeals in relation to land disputes are made to the Lands Courts Appeal Panel. Appeals from the Island Courts and the Lands Courts Appeal Panel are made to the Magistrates Court, which has jurisdiction to hear civil cases involving up to $10,000.

## Jurisdiction of the High Court in constitutional matters

[edit]

Section 5 of the Constitution establishes the jurisdiction of the High Court in constitutional matters; with sections 40 to 42 confirming the jurisdiction of the High Court to determine questions in relation to the Bill of Rights is set out in Part II of the Constitution.

Amasone v. Attorney General was a judgment of Ward CJ delivered on 6 August 2003. Amasone Kilei, the leader of the opposition, requested an order regarding the calling of parliament. The Chief Justice delivered directions as to how the governor-general should proceed to take any action he considers to be appropriate under Section 116(1) of the Constitution, acting in his own deliberate judgment, rather than as advised by the cabinet.[3] That is, the governor-general could consider whether it was appropriate to exercise his reserve powers in calling parliament.

Teonea v. Pule o Kaupule of Nanumaga was a judgment of Ward CJ given delivered 11 October 2005.[4] The case raised issues in relation to the balancing the freedoms of religion, expression and association that are set out in the Constitution of Tuvalu against the values of Tuvaluan culture and social stability that are also referred to in the Constitution. This matter went on appeal to the Court of Appeal of Tuvalu.[5]

## Chief Justice of Tuvalu

[edit]

Sir (Dermot) Renn Davis (1928-1997), who had previously served in Kenya and then as the British Judge in the New Hebrides Condominium (now Vanuatu) 1973-1976, and as the first Chief Justice of Solomon Islands in 1976 and as Chief Justice of Gibraltar (1980-1986), was Chief Justice of Tuvalu from 1978 to 1980 and then Chief Justice of the Falkland Islands and a Judge of Appeal of Gibraltar. He died, on his way to a Mozart festival in Leipzig, Germany aged 68 in 1997.

The Hon Sir Gaven Donne KBE, (1914-2010) was Chief Justice 1985-2001, retired at the age of 85 and died aged 95 in 2010.

The Hon Sir Gordon Ward OBE, Chief Justice of Tuvalu (2000-2016), was a President of the Court of Appeal of Fiji, and Chief Justice of Tonga and of Trinidad and Tobago.[6] In May 2013 Sir Gordon Ward ruled on the application of the Tuvaluan Opposition regarding the calling of a by-election for the vacant seat in Nukufetau,[7] which led to the 2013 Nukufetau by-election.[8]

The Hon Charles Sweeney QC was appointed Chief Justice in early 2016.[9] Following the election of Kausea Natano as prime minister following the 2019 Tuvaluan general election, the justice minister, Simon Kofe, announced a two-member tribunal to investigate Mr Sweeney on allegations of judicial misconduct.[10][11]

The Hon Sir Gordon Ward was appointed as acting Chief Justice,[12] pending the appeal by the Hon Charles Sweeney QC against the termination of his appointment by a resolution of the Parliament.[13]

## Judges of the High Court of Tuvalu

[edit]

The Hon. Robin Millhouse QC, a Chief Justice of Kiribati for 16 years and before that (1982-1999) a judge of the Supreme Court of South Australia and eventually its senior puisne judge, an Attorney General of South Australia and a member of its Parliament for more than 25 years, served as a Judge of the High Court of Tuvalu from 2014. He died, aged 87, on 27 April 2017. Plenus annis, plenus honoribus.

The Hon Justice Michael Finnane RFD QC served as a Judge of the High Court of Tuvalu in 2017.

In 2021, Sir John Baptist Muria was appointed as a judge of the High Court of Tuvalu.[12]

## Court of Appeal of Tuvalu

[edit]

Most rulings of the High Court can be appealed to the Court of Appeal of Tuvalu.

## References

[edit]

1. ^ "Tuvalu Courts System Information". PacLII. Retrieved 10 March 2014.
2. ^ "Constitution of Tuvalu" (PDF). Government of Tuvalu. 1 October 2023. Archived from the original (PDF) on 3 December 2023. Retrieved 27 November 2023.
3. ^ "Amasone v Attorney General [2003] TVHC 4; Case No 24 of 2003 (6 August 2003)". PACLII. Retrieved 5 April 2015.
4. ^ "Teonea v Kaupule [2005] TVHC 2; HC CC No 23 of 2003 (11 October 2005)". PACLII. Retrieved 10 March 2014.
5. ^ "Teonea v Pule o Kaupule of Nanumaga [2009] TVCA 2; Court of Appeal Civil Appeal No. 1 of 2005 (4 November 2009)". PACLII. Retrieved 10 March 2014.
6. ^ "Tuvalu govt yet to address Fiji travel ban on Chief Justice". Radio New Zealand International. 14 August 2013. Retrieved 14 August 2013.
7. ^ "Attorney General, In re Application under Section 131(1) of the Constitution of Tuvalu [2014] TVHC 15; Civil Case 1.2013 (24 May 2013)". PACLII. Retrieved 5 April 2015.
8. ^ Matau, Robert (June 2013). "Tuvalu's high court orders by-election to be held". Island Business. Archived from the original on 21 September 2013. Retrieved 23 January 2014.
9. ^ "The Hon Charles Sweeney QC". Michael Kirby Chambers. 2016. Retrieved 21 June 2016.
10. ^ "Climate advocacy, Taiwan to remain priorities for new Tuvalu government". Radio New Zealand. 23 September 2019. Retrieved 23 September 2019.
11. ^ "New Tuvalu Government suspends Chief Justice". Pacific Islands News Association (PINA). 23 September 2019. Retrieved 16 October 2019.
12. ^ a b "Government Appoints First High Court Judge". Tuvalu Paradise - Issue No. 01/2021. 11 January 2021. Archived from the original on 20 April 2021. Retrieved 31 January 2021.
13. ^ "Government Appoints First High Court Judge". Tuvalu Paradise - Issue No. 01/2021. 11 January 2021. Archived from the original on 20 April 2021. Retrieved 31 January 2021.

## Further reading

[edit]

* Jennifer Corrin-Care, Tess Newton and Don Paterson (1999), Introduction to South Pacific Law, London: Cavendish Publishing

## External links

[edit]

* "High Court of Tuvalu (reported cases)". PACLII. Retrieved 10 March 2014.

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template