Jan Tinbergen

Dutch economist (1903–1994)

Jan Tinbergen

Jan Tinbergen in 1982

Born| (1903-04-12)12 April 1903

The Hague, Netherlands

Died| 9 June 1994(1994-06-09) (aged 91)

The Hague, Netherlands

Nationality| Dutch
Alma mater| Leiden University
Known for| First national macroeconomic model
Awards| Erasmus Prize (1967)
Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences (1969)
Scientific career
Fields| Economics, Econometrics
Institutions| Erasmus University
Doctoral advisor| Paul Ehrenfest
Doctoral students| Tjalling Koopmans
Hans van den Doel
Supachai Panitchpakdi
Ashok Mitra

Jan Tinbergen (/ˈtɪnbɜːrɡən/; Dutch: [ˈtɪnˌbɛrɣə(n)]; 12 April 1903 - 9 June 1994) was a Dutch economist who was awarded the first Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 1969, which he shared with Ragnar Frisch for having developed and applied dynamic models for the analysis of economic processes. He is widely considered to be one of the most influential economists of the 20th century and one of the founding fathers of econometrics.[1][2][3][4]

His important contributions to econometrics include the development of the first macroeconometric models, the solution of the identification problem, and the understanding of dynamic models.[3] Tinbergen was a founding trustee of Economists for Peace and Security. In 1945, he founded the Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis (CPB) and was the agency's first director.

## Biography[edit]

Tinbergen was the eldest of five children of Dirk Cornelis Tinbergen and Jeannette van Eek. His brother Nikolaas "Niko" Tinbergen would also win a Nobel Prize (for physiology, during 1973) for his work in ethology, while his youngest brother Luuk would become a famous ornithologist. Jan and Nikolaas Tinbergen are the only siblings to have both won Nobel Prizes.[5]

Between 1921 and 1925, Tinbergen studied mathematics and physics at the University of Leiden under Paul Ehrenfest. During those years at Leiden, he had numerous discussions with Ehrenfest, Kamerlingh Onnes, Hendrik Lorentz, Pieter Zeeman, and Albert Einstein.[6][7]

After graduating, Tinbergen fulfilled his community service in the administration of a prison in Rotterdam and at the Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS) in The Hague. He then returned to the University of Leiden and in 1929 defended his PhD thesis titled "Minimumproblemen in de natuurkunde en de economie" (Minimisation problems in Physics and Economics).[8] This topic was suggested by Ehrenfest and allowed Tinbergen to combine his interests in mathematics, physics, economics and politics. At that time, CBS established a new department of business surveys and mathematical statistics, and Tinbergen became its first chairman, working at CBS until 1945. Access to the vast CBS data helped Tinbergen in testing his theoretical models. In parallel, starting from 1931, he was professor of statistics at the University of Amsterdam, and in 1933 he was appointed associate professor of mathematics and statistics at The Netherlands School of Economics, Rotterdam, where he stayed until 1973.[6][7]

From 1929 to 1945 he worked for the Dutch statistical office and served as consultant at the Economic and Financial Organization of the League of Nations (1936–1938). In 1945 he became the first director of the Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis and left this position in 1955 to focus on education. He spent one year as a visiting professor at the Harvard University and then returned to the Dutch Economic Institute (the successor of the Netherlands School of Economics). In parallel, he provided consulting services to international organizations and governments of various developing countries, such as United Arab Republic, Turkey, Venezuela, Surinam, Indonesia and Pakistan.[6][7][9]

Tinbergen became a member of the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences in 1946.[10] He was also a member of the International Academy of Science, Munich. In 1956 he founded the Econometric Institute at the Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam together with Henri Theil, who also was his successor in Rotterdam. In 1960, he was elected as a Fellow of the American Statistical Association and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences.[11][12] The Tinbergen Institute was named in his honour. The International Institute of Social Studies (ISS) awarded its Honorary Fellowship to Jan Tinbergen in 1962.[6][7] He was elected to the American Philosophical Society in 1963.[13] In 1968, he received an honorary doctorate from Sir George Williams University, which later became Concordia University.[14] He was elected to the United States National Academy of Sciences in 1974.[15]

## Work[edit]

Minister Pronk, Tinbergen and De Seynes at an economy symposium in The Hague, 23 May 1975

For many, Jan Tinbergen became known for the so-called 'Tinbergen Norm' often discussed long after his death. There is no written work of Tinbergen in which he himself states it formally.[16] It is generally believed to be the principle that, if the ratio between the greatest and least income exceeds 5, it becomes disadvantageous for the societal unit involved. Tinbergen himself discussed some technicalities of a five-to-one income distribution ratio in an article published in 1981.[17] Apart from specifics about a five-to-one ratio, it is true in general that Tinbergen's grand theme was income distribution and the search for an optimal social order.

Tinbergen developed the first national comprehensive macroeconomic model, which he first developed in 1936 for the Netherlands, and later applied to the United States and the United Kingdom.[18]

In his work on macroeconomic modelling and economic policy making, Tinbergen classified some economic quantities as targets and others as instruments.[19] Targets are those macroeconomic variables the policy maker wishes to influence, whereas instruments are the variables that the policy maker can control directly. Tinbergen emphasized that achieving the desired values of a certain number of targets requires the policy maker to control an equal number of instruments. This is known as the Tinbergen Rule.[20]

Tinbergen's classification remains influential today, underlying the theory of monetary policy used by central banks. Many central banks today regard the inflation rate as their target; the policy instrument they use to control inflation is the short-term interest rate.[21]

Tinbergen's work on macroeconomic models was later continued by Lawrence Klein, contributing to another Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences. For his cultural contributions, he was given the Gouden Ganzenveer in 1985.[22]

Tinbergen's econometric modelling lead to a lively debate with several known participants including J.M. Keynes, Ragnar Frisch and Milton Friedman. The debate is sometime referred to as the Tinbergen debate. (see Keynes–Tinbergen debate.)[23][24]</ref>[25]

## Selected publications[edit]

* World security and equity. Aldershot, 1990. ISBN 1-85278-187-4.
* Production, income and welfare: the search for an optimal social order. Brighton, 1985 ISBN 0-7450-0014-2.
* Economic policy: Principles and Design. Amsterdam, 1978. ISBN 0-7204-3129-8.
* Der Dialog Nord-Süd: Informationen zur Entwicklungspolitik. Frankfurt am Main: Europ. Verlagsanstalt, 1977.
* Income distribution: analysis and policies. New York, 1975. ISBN 0-444-10832-7.
* The Dynamics of Business Cycles: A Study in Economic Fluctuations. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1974. ISBN 0-226-80418-6.
* The Element of Space in Development Planning (together with L.B.M. Mennes and J.G. Waardenburg), Amsterdam, 1969
* Development planning. London, 1967.
* Central planning. Studies in comparative economics, 4. New Haven, 1964.
* Shaping the world economy, suggestions for an international economic policy. New York, 1962.
* Selected papers. Amsterdam, 1959
* Economic Policy: Principles and Design, Amsterdam, 1956
* Centralization and Decentralization in Economic Policy, Amsterdam, 1954 ISBN 0-313-23077-3.
* Econometrics. London, 1953.
* On the Theory of Economic Policy. Second edition (1952) is Volume 1 of Contributions to Economic Analysis, Amsterdam: North-Holland.
* Business Cycles in the United Kingdom, 1870–1914, Amsterdam, 1951
* International economic co-operation. Amsterdam, 1945.
* Business Cycles in the United States, 1919–1932, Geneva, 1939 and New York, 1968.
* An econometric approach to business cycle problems. In: Impasses économiques ; 2; Actualités scientifiques et industrielles, ISSN 0365-6861 ; 525. Paris, 1937.

About Tinbergen

* Acocella, Nicola, Di Bartolomeo, Giovanni (2006), ‘Tinbergen and Theil meet Nash: controllability in policy games’, in: ‘Economics Letters’, 90(2): 213–218.
* Acocella, Nicola, Di Bartolomeo, Giovanni and Hughes Hallett, A. [2010], ‘Policy games, policy neutrality and Tinbergen controllability under rational expectations’, in: ‘Journal of Macroeconomics’, 32(1): 55–67.
* Acocella, Nicola Di Bartolomeo, Giovanni and Hughes Hallett, A. [2011], ‘Tinbergen controllability and n-player LQ-games’, in: ‘Economics Letters’, 113: 32–4.
* Murshed, SM. 2021. "Reformulating Jan Tinbergen’s normative vision on welfare and security." Journal of Peace Research.

## See also[edit]

* List of economists

## References[edit]

1. ^ Dekker, Erwin (2021). Jan Tinbergen (1903–1994) and the Rise of Economic Expertise. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-108-85320-0.
2. ^ Dekker, Erwin (2022). "An "Ordo-Thinker" on the Left: Jan Tinbergen on the National and International Economic Order". History of Political Economy. 54 (4): 689–718. doi:10.1215/00182702-9895888. ISSN 0018-2702. S2CID 248839847.
3. ^ a b Magnus, Jan & Mary S. Morgan (1987) The ET Interview: Professor J. Tinbergen in: 'Econometric Theory 3, 1987, 117-142.
4. ^ Willlekens, Frans (2008) International Migration in Europe: Data, Models and Estimates. New Jersey. John Wiley & Sons: 117.
5. ^ "Nobel Prize Facts".
6. ^ a b c d Jan Tinbergen (1903–1994) Koninklijke Bibliotheek (in Dutch)
7. ^ a b c d O'Connor, John J.; Robertson, Edmund F., "Jan Tinbergen", MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive, University of St Andrews
8. ^ Jan Tinbergen (1929). "Minimumproblemen in de natuurkunde en de economie" (PDF).
9. ^ Curriculum Vitae. nobelprize.org
10. ^ "Jan Tinbergen (1903 - 1994)". Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences. Archived from the original on 18 September 2020.
11. ^ View/Search Fellows of the ASA Archived 2016-06-16 at the Wayback Machine, accessed 2016-07-23.
12. ^ "Jan Tinbergen". American Academy of Arts & Sciences. Retrieved 2022-11-10.
13. ^ "APS Member History". search.amphilsoc.org. Retrieved 2022-11-10.
14. ^ "Honorary Degree Citation - Jan Tinbergen* | Concordia University Archives". archives.concordia.ca. Retrieved 2016-03-30.
15. ^ "J. Tinbergen". www.nasonline.org. Retrieved 2022-11-10.
16. ^ Akkerboom, Broer. "De Tinbergennorm bestaat niet". Me Judice, 14 Mei 2015.
17. ^ Tinbergen, Jan (1981). "Misunderstandings concerning income distribution policies" (PDF). De Economist. 129 (1): 13. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.1030.5758. doi:10.1007/BF01705865. S2CID 154797347.
18. ^ Dhaene, G.; Barten, A. P. (1989). "When it all began". Economic Modelling. 6 (2): 203. doi:10.1016/0264-9993(89)90005-9.
19. ^ Klein, Lawrence (2004). "The Contribution of Jan Tinbergen to Economic Science". De Economist. 152 (2): 155–157. doi:10.1023/B:ECOT.0000023251.14849.4f. S2CID 154689887.
20. ^ Del Rio, Pablo; Howlett, Michael P. (2013). "Beyond the'Tinbergen Rule'in Policy Design: Matching Tools and Goals in Policy Portfolios". Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy Research Paper (13–01). Retrieved 21 December 2020.
21. ^ Blinder, Alan (1999), Central Banking in Theory and Practice. MIT Press, ISBN 0262522608.
22. ^ "Laureaten De Gouden Ganzenveer vanaf 1955". Stichting De Gouden Ganzenveer. 2009. Archived from the original on 2009-02-25. Retrieved 2009-07-28.
23. ^ Leeson, R. (1998). "The Ghosts I Called I Can't Get Rid of Now: the Keynes-Tinbergen-Friedman-Phillips Critique of Keynesian Macroeconometrics" (PDF). History of Political Economy. 30 (1): 51–94. doi:10.1215/00182702-30-1-51.
24. ^ Louçã, F. (1999). "The econometric challenge to Keynes: Arguments and contradictions in the early debates about a late issue" (PDF). The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought. 6 (3): 404–438. doi:10.1080/10427719900000074. hdl:10400.5/25984.[permanent dead link]
25. ^ Peden, W. (2022). "Probability and Statistics in the Tinbergen-Keynes Debates". Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics. 15 (2): 100–119. doi:10.23941/ejpe.v15i2.710.

## External links[edit]

Wikiquote has quotations related to Jan Tinbergen.

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Jan Tinbergen.

* Jan Tinbergen at the Mathematics Genealogy Project
* TINBERGEN, Jan in: Biografisch Woordenboek van het Socialisme en de Arbeidersbeweging in Nederland
* Jan Tinbergen College (Dutch website)
* IDEAS/RePEc
* Profile at The International Institute of Social Studies (ISS)
* "Jan Tinbergen (1903–1994)". The Concise Encyclopedia of Economics. Library of Economics and Liberty (2nd ed.). Liberty Fund. 2008.
* Newspaper clippings about Jan Tinbergen in the 20th Century Press Archives of the ZBW
* Jan Tinbergen on Nobelprize.org

Awards

New creation |  Laureate of the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economics
1969
Served alongside: Ragnar Frisch | Succeeded by

Paul A. Samuelson

* v
* t
* e

Laureates of the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences

1969–1975|

* 1969: Ragnar Frisch / Jan Tinbergen
* 1970: Paul A. Samuelson
* 1971: Simon Kuznets
* 1972: John R. Hicks / Kenneth J. Arrow
* 1973: Wassily Leontief
* 1974: Gunnar Myrdal / Friedrich August von Hayek
* 1975: Leonid Vitaliyevich Kantorovich / Tjalling C. Koopmans

1976–2000|

* 1976: Milton Friedman
* 1977: Bertil Ohlin / James E. Meade
* 1978: Herbert A. Simon
* 1979: Theodore W. Schultz / Sir Arthur Lewis
* 1980: Lawrence R. Klein
* 1981: James Tobin
* 1982: George J. Stigler
* 1983: Gérard Debreu
* 1984: Richard Stone
* 1985: Franco Modigliani
* 1986: James M. Buchanan Jr.
* 1987: Robert M. Solow
* 1988: Maurice Allais
* 1989: Trygve Haavelmo
* 1990: Harry M. Markowitz / Merton H. Miller / William F. Sharpe
* 1991: Ronald H. Coase
* 1992: Gary S. Becker
* 1993: Robert W. Fogel / Douglass C. North
* 1994: John C. Harsanyi / John F. Nash Jr. / Reinhard Selten
* 1995: Robert E. Lucas Jr.
* 1996: James A. Mirrlees / William Vickrey
* 1997: Robert C. Merton / Myron S. Scholes
* 1998: Amartya Sen
* 1999: Robert A. Mundell
* 2000: James J. Heckman / Daniel L. McFadden

2001–present|

* 2001: George A. Akerlof / A. Michael Spence / Joseph E. Stiglitz
* 2002: Daniel Kahneman / Vernon L. Smith
* 2003: Robert F. Engle III / Clive W.J. Granger
* 2004: Finn E. Kydland / Edward C. Prescott
* 2005: Robert J. Aumann / Thomas C. Schelling
* 2006: Edmund S. Phelps
* 2007: Leonid Hurwicz / Eric S. Maskin / Roger B. Myerson
* 2008: Paul Krugman
* 2009: Elinor Ostrom / Oliver E. Williamson
* 2010: Peter A. Diamond / Dale T. Mortensen / Christopher A. Pissarides
* 2011: Thomas J. Sargent / Christopher A. Sims
* 2012: Alvin E. Roth / Lloyd S. Shapley
* 2013: Eugene F. Fama / Lars Peter Hansen / Robert J. Shiller
* 2014: Jean Tirole
* 2015: Angus Deaton
* 2016: Oliver Hart / Bengt Holmström
* 2017: Richard H. Thaler
* 2018: William Nordhaus / Paul Romer
* 2019: Abhijit Banerjee / Esther Duflo / Michael Kremer
* 2020: Paul Milgrom / Robert B. Wilson
* 2021: David Card / Joshua Angrist / Guido Imbens
* 2022: Ben Bernanke / Douglas Diamond / Philip H. Dybvig
* 2023: Claudia Goldin

* v
* t
* e

1969 Nobel Prize laureates

Chemistry|

* Derek Barton (Great Britain)
* Odd Hassel (Norway)

Literature (1969)|

* Samuel Beckett (Ireland)

Peace (1969)|

* International Labour Organization

Physics|

* Murray Gell-Mann (United States)

Physiology or Medicine|

* Max Delbrück (United States)
* Alfred Hershey (United States)
* Salvador Luria (United States)

Economic Sciences|

* Ragnar Frisch (Norway)
* Jan Tinbergen (Netherlands)

Nobel Prize recipients
1964
1965
1966
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
1973
1974

* v
* t
* e

Presidents of the Econometric Society

1931–1950|

* Irving Fisher (1931–1934)
* François Divisia (1935)
* Harold Hotelling (1936–1937)
* Arthur Bowley (1938–1939)
* Joseph Schumpeter (1940–1941)
* Wesley Mitchell (1942–1943)
* John Maynard Keynes (1944–1945)
* Jacob Marschak (1946)
* Jan Tinbergen (1947)
* Charles Roos (1948)
* Ragnar Frisch (1949)
* Tjalling Koopmans (1950)

1951–1975|

* R. G. D. Allen (1951)
* Paul Samuelson (1952)
* René Roy (1953)
* Wassily Leontief (1954)
* Richard Stone (1955)
* Kenneth Arrow (1956)
* Trygve Haavelmo (1957)
* James Tobin (1958)
* Marcel Boiteux (1959)
* Lawrence Klein (1960)
* Henri Theil (1961)
* Franco Modigliani (1962)
* Edmond Malinvaud (1963)
* Robert Solow (1964)
* Michio Morishima (1965)
* Herman Wold (1966)
* Hendrik Houthakker (1967)
* Frank Hahn (1968)
* Leonid Hurwicz (1969)
* Jacques Drèze (1970)
* Gérard Debreu (1971)
* W. M. Gorman (1972)
* Roy Radner (1973)
* Don Patinkin (1974)
* Zvi Griliches (1975)

1976–2000|

* Hirofumi Uzawa (1976)
* Lionel McKenzie (1977)
* János Kornai (1978)
* Franklin M. Fisher (1979)
* J. Denis Sargan (1980)
* Marc Nerlove (1981)
* James A. Mirrlees (1982)
* Herbert Scarf (1983)
* Amartya K. Sen (1984)
* Daniel McFadden (1985)
* Michael Bruno (1986)
* Dale Jorgenson (1987)
* Anthony B. Atkinson (1988)
* Hugo Sonnenschein (1989)
* Jean-Michel Grandmont [de] (1990)
* Peter Diamond (1991)
* Jean-Jacques Laffont (1992)
* Andreu Mas-Colell (1993)
* Takashi Negishi (1994)
* Christopher Sims (1995)
* Roger Guesnerie (1996)
* Robert E. Lucas, Jr. (1997)
* Jean Tirole (1998)
* Robert B. Wilson (1999)
* Elhanan Helpman (2000)

2001–present|

* Avinash Dixit (2001)
* Guy Laroque [fr] (2002)
* Eric Maskin (2003)
* Ariel Rubinstein (2004)
* Thomas J. Sargent (2005)
* Richard Blundell (2006)
* Lars Peter Hansen (2007)
* Torsten Persson (2008)
* Roger B. Myerson (2009)
* John H. Moore (2010)
* Bengt Holmström (2011)
* Jean-Charles Rochet [ru] (2012)
* James J. Heckman (2013)
* Manuel Arellano (2014)
* Robert Porter (2015)
* Eddie Dekel (2016)
* Drew Fudenberg (2017)
* Tim Besley (2018)
* Stephen Morris (2019)
* Orazio Attanasio (2020)
* Pinelopi Koujianou Goldberg (2021)
* Guido Tabellini (2022)
* Rosa Matzkin (2023)

Authority control databases

International|

* FAST
* ISNI
* VIAF

National|

* Norway
* Chile
* Spain
* France
* BnF data
* Catalonia
* Germany
* Israel
* Belgium
* United States
* Latvia
* Japan
* Czech Republic
* Australia
* Greece
* Korea
* Croatia
* Netherlands
* Poland
* Portugal
* Vatican

Academics|

* CiNii
* MathSciNet
* Mathematics Genealogy Project
* zbMATH

People|

* Netherlands
* Deutsche Biographie
* Trove

Other|

* SNAC
* IdRef

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template