Kaliwa Low Dam

Cancelled dam project

This article is about the 600 MLD dam proposed by the Philippine government in 2012 and shelved in 2019. For other proposed dam projects in the same watershed, see Proposed dams in the Kaliwa River watershed.

The Kaliwa Low Dam was proposed by the Philippine Government in 2012, was one of several bulk water supply projects on the upper portion of the Kaliwa River Watershed that have been proposed but ultimately shelved by the Philippine Government since the 1970s.[1]

The proposed Kaliwa Low Dam design had a 600 million-liters-a-day (MLD) capacity, and the water supply tunnel has a 2,400-MLD capacity. Had it been built, the Kaliwa Low Dam was expected to ease the demand on the Angat Dam, Manila's sole water storage facility.[2] It was the main component of the New Centennial Water Source-Kaliwa Dam Project in Tanay, Rizal, which also called for the construction of a water supply tunnel and various attendant infrastructure.[1]

The project had originally been proposed as a bigger, integrated system that included a plan for a second dam, named Laiban dam further upstream. But the government decided on a proposal that would have built the system in stages, and only stage one, involving Kaliwa Low Dam and the water supply tunnel, was approved under the administration of Benigno Aquino III.[3] When the project did not move forward by the time Aquino administration ended, the succeeding Duterte administration decided not to pursue the Japanese-proposed Kaliwa Low Dam plan in 2019, deciding to instead pursue a bigger, China-funded dam project.[4][5]

## Earlier projects at the Laiban Watershed[edit]

Various plans for the construction of a dam in Tanay, Rizal, have been proposed since the 1970s, when the Marcos government first decided that the location was a more viable location for a dam than the Marikina River. However, protests against the construction of the dam, called Laiban because Barangay Laiban was chosen as the exact project site, very quickly led to protests from various groups. Foremost among these were Indigenous peoples from Central and Southern Luzon, notably the local Remontado Dumagat people, whose ancestral lands would specifically be affected.[6][7] Environmental and activist groups later also raised concerns. As a result, construction of the dam has been approved, deferred, stopped, and restarted a number of times in the decades since.[8]

## Project approval process[edit]

### Original proposal, including Laiban Dam and Power Plant[edit]

The roots of the current "New Centennial Water Source Project" can be traced to the Water Security Legacy (WSL) Roadmap proposed by the Metropolitan Waterworks and Sewerage System (MWSS) in 2012–2016. Based on this document, the MWSS developed plans for "the development of a dam at the Kaliwa River (Laiban Dam), and/or a smaller dam downstream (Kaliwa Low Dam) to maximize water supply, ensure short - and long - term redundancy, and optimize power generation capacities," and in February 2013, the Public Private Partnership Center released a document "sounding out" interested parties.[9]

In that initial market sounding, this proposal was already thought likely to comprise:[9]

1. ) Laiban Dam and/or Kaliwa Low Dam;
2. ) Head works and its appurtenant facilities;
3. ) Conveyance structure from the diversion point to the water treatment facility(s);
4. ) Water treatment facility(s); and
5. ) Hydropower facility(s).

In report by Philippine Daily Inquirer reporter Niña Calleja in that same month, MWSS senior deputy administrator Nathaniel Santos indicated that the main difference of the NCWSP from previous plans was that it would involve the construction of two smaller dams at the Kaliwa watershed instead of just the one. A main dam (Laiban Dam) would be built at the upper Kaliwa River in Barangay Laiban, and another regulating dam (Kaliwa Low Dam) further downstream.[10]

When the National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA) Investment Coordination Committee (ICC) had their October 4, 2013, Joint Cabinet Committee and Technical Board Meeting, however, they suggested that the MWSS to develop the project in stages, allowing for construction on the Kaliwa Low Dam to begin sooner, and for the Laiban Dam components of the project to be funded under a different financial mechanism.[3][11]

### Project financing[edit]

The original integrated project had been proposed by the MWSS under a build-operate-transfer (BOT) financing scheme. When the Joint Cabinet Committee and Technical Board Meeting of the National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA) Investment Coordination Committee (ICC) discussed the project on 4 October 2013, however, they recommended that the MWSS resubmit its proposal with only the Kaliwa Low Dam and water supply tunnel components, and that it be funded using the MWSS' funds or though overseas development assistance.[11]

### Approval of Kaliwa Low Dam proposal[edit]

The project, with its revised scope, was approved at the May 29, 2014, meeting of the NEDA Board, which is chaired by President Benigno Aquino III.[12]

On July 28, 2014, President Aquino cited Kaliwa dam in his 5th State of the Nation Address as one of the infrastructure projects approved by his administration as part of its drought prevention efforts.[13]

In 2015, two consortia were pre-qualified to bid for the undertaking of the Kaliwa Dam project[14] — the SMC-K Water Consortium, which is a partnership between San Miguel Holdings Corp. and Korea Water Resources Corp.; and the Abeima-Datem Consortium, which is a partnership between Albeinsa Infraestructura Medio Ambiento S.A and Datem Inc.[14]

### Government shift to Chinese proposal[edit]

In 2019, under the administration of President Rodrigo Duterte, the government revealed that it would not continue with the project under a public–private partnership agreement as proposed during the Aquino administration, but would instead pursue the project using Official Development Assistance loan from China.[5]

Some lawyers noted that the interest rate of the Chinese deal was 2%, while the Japanese deal that was sidelined by the government only had a 1.25% interest.[15] The Japanese have since renewed their call for the Philippine government to reconsider their proposal.[16][17]

## Social and environmental concerns[edit]

### Social issues[edit]

Ancestral lands belonging to Indigenous Dumagats and Remontados will be affected by the Kaliwa Dam project.[18] The coalition Sectors Opposed to the Kaliwa Dam (STOP Kaliwa Dam) estimate that 1,000 households from Barangay Daraitan in Tanay, Rizal, and 500 households in Pagsangahan, General Nakar, Quezon, will be inundated by the construction.[19] The Samahan ng mga Katutubong Agta/Dumagat (Organization of Indigenous Agta/Dumagat) estimate that the project would displace 10,000 members of the Dumagat tribe.[20] Protesters have maintained that Indigenous communities that will be affected by the project were not consulted.[20][21][22] Philippine law requires that such projects acquire free, prior, and informed consent (FPIC) from Indigenous communities.[23]

### Environmental issues[edit]

Sierra Madre is one of the most biodiverse areas in the Philippines and the largest remaining rainforest in the country.[24] An estimated 12,147 hectares of residual forests, home to 172 recorded plant or flora species will be affected by the dam construction.[24]

The project site is part of the Kaliwa Watershed Forest Reserve, which is supposedly protected by virtue of Proclamation No. 573 on June 22, 1968.[25] Proclamation 1636 declared a portion of the area a National Park and Wildlife Sanctuary.[19]

Environmental groups have protested the project, as the dam will destroy a great portion of the Sierra Madre range. The dam will ultimately destroy numerous habitats of many endangered species living in the mountains once construction begins.[26] Among the thousands of plant and animal life whose home will be destroyed by the project is the critically endangered Philippine eagle.[24][25] Other species that will be affected by the project are the endangered north Philippine hawk-eagle, the Philippine brown deer, the Philippine warty pig, and the vulnerable northern rufous hornbill.[24]

## See also[edit]

* Proposed Dams in the Kaliwa River watershed
* Manila Water Supply III project
* Angat Dam
* Wawa Dam
* Chico River Dam Project
* Metropolitan Waterworks and Sewerage System

## References[edit]

1. ^ a b "China will make Philippines dam a reality, after four decades of protest". South China Morning Post. 2018-12-09. Retrieved 2018-12-10.
2. ^ Smith, Sandy (June 23, 2014). "New Starts: Closing 6 Blocks in D.C., Planning K.C. Streetcars From Afar, Manila's New Water Supply". nextcity.org. Next City. Retrieved June 30, 2014.
3. ^ a b Añonuevo, Euan Paulo C. (June 11, 2014), Laiban Dam Project next on MWSS' PPP list, InterAksyon.com
4. ^ "Why borrow from China? Japanese dam is free, safe". Retrieved 2019-08-20.
5. ^ a b "Gov't targets construction of China-funded Kaliwa Dam by July". CNN. March 18, 2019. Archived from the original on 19 July 2019. Retrieved 19 July 2019.
6. ^ Mallari, Delfin T. Jr. (July 12, 2013). "Sierra Madre tribe asks Congress to stop Laiban dam". Philippine Daily Inquirer. Makati City: Philippine Daily Inquirer, Inc. Retrieved July 2, 2014.
7. ^ "Tribes oppose dams for MM folk's water". Inquirer News. 5 May 2013.
8. ^ "Laiban Dam Project Chronology of Events" (PDF). Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism. July 2009. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2013-08-20. Retrieved July 1, 2014.
9. ^ a b Market Sounding for the New Centennial Water Source Project (NCWP) (PDF), Public-Private Partnership Center, February 2013, retrieved January 30, 2014
10. ^ Calleja, Niña (February 25, 2013). "P85B MWSS project: Same river in Tanay but different plan: Gov't to undertake project to head off possible water shortage in NCR". Philippine Daily Inquirer. Makati: Philippine Daily Inquirer, Inc. Retrieved July 1, 2014.
11. ^ a b New Centennial Water Supply Source Project, For Policy Decision by NEDA ICC Cabinet Committee, Metropolitan Waterworks and Sewerage System, December 3, 2013, archived from the original on May 28, 2014, retrieved June 30, 2014
12. ^ "NEDA approves nine projects worth P62 billion - Solar News". www.solarnews.ph. Archived from the original on 2014-05-31.
13. ^ "SONA Fact Check: Dike, dam pose environmental threats". 30 July 2014.
14. ^ a b "Integrated PPP vs Hybrid PPP: The case of Kaliwa Dam". BusinessWorld. 7 November 2018.
15. ^ "Diokno questions several provisions in P12.2-B loan agreement for Kaliwa Dam project". Manila Bulletin. 25 March 2019. Archived from the original on 21 April 2019. Retrieved 21 April 2019.
16. ^ Raymundo, Jr., Perfecto (18 March 2019). "Japanese firm renews proposal on Kaliwa Dam project". Philippine News Agency. Retrieved 2 July 2022.
17. ^ "EXECUTIVE SUMMARY FOR THE PUBLIC (ESP) New Centennial Water Source (NCWS) - Kaliwa Dam Project" (PDF). Environmental Management Bureau. Philippines. 2014. Retrieved 2 July 2022.
18. ^ Luci-Atienza, Charissa; Cahiles-Magkilat, Bernie (March 20, 2019). "Weirs, instead of dams, for our water problem". Manila Bulletin News. Retrieved 22 April 2019.
19. ^ a b "Coalition rejects China-funded Kaliwa Dam project". Philstar. April 2, 2019. Retrieved 22 April 2019.
20. ^ a b Vergara, Robert (March 21, 2019). "Dumagat leader laments alleged lack of tribe consent for Kaliwa dam: 'Binabraso nila kami'". CNN. Archived from the original on 19 July 2019. Retrieved 19 July 2019.
21. ^ "The big sacrifice". Philippine Daily Inquirer. April 17, 2019. Retrieved 19 July 2019.
22. ^ Punongbayan, J. C. (July 18, 2019). "[ANALYSIS] The poor quality of economic growth under Duterte". Rappler. Retrieved 19 July 2019.
23. ^ Ramos, Mariejo S. (April 11, 2019). "Kaliwa Dam opponets [sic] cite lack of indigenous people's consent". Inquirer. Retrieved 19 July 2019.
24. ^ a b c d "Kaliwa Dam will destroy Sierra Madre biodiversity". Philstar. November 29, 2018. Retrieved 22 April 2019.
25. ^ a b Madarang, Catalina Ricci S. (14 March 2019). "Why China-funded Kaliwa Dam, a possible alternate water source, is heavily opposed". Interaksyon. Retrieved 22 April 2019.
26. ^ Archived at Ghostarchive and the Wayback Machine: Brigada: Ano-ano ang magiging epekto ng Kaliwa Dam Project? [Brigada: What will be the impact of the Left Dam Project?]. YouTube (in Filipino).