New Theatre Comique

Defunct building in New York City

New Theatre Comique

1868 drawing of a street scene in front of the altered but recognizable exterior of the church

General information
Location| 728–30 Broadway, Manhattan, New York City
Completed| 1839
Opened| 1864
Demolished| 1884
As the Globe Theatre

The Church of the Messiah at 728–30 Broadway, near Waverly Place in Greenwich Village, Manhattan, New York City, was dedicated in 1839[1] and operated as a church until 1864. In January 1865 it was sold to department store magnate Alexander Turney Stewart and converted into a theater, which subsequently operated under a series of names,[2] including Globe Theatre, and ending with New Theatre Comique. It burned down in 1884.[3]

## Theater names and managers

[edit]

The following information comes from Brown (page numbers in parentheses):

* 1865, January 23 – Broadway Athenaeum (A. T. Stewart, owner; James H. Hackett, manager) (376–77)
* 1865, December 23 – Lucy Rushton's Theatre (Lucy Rushton, proprietor and manager) (377)
* 1866, September 5 – New York Theatre (Lewis Baker and Mark Smith, managers) (379)
* 1867, May 6 – The Worrell Sisters' New York Theatre (M. L. Finch, manager) (383)
* 1868, August 3 – New York Theatre (Alvin Lloyd, manager) (386)
* 1868, November 4 – The Worrell Sisters' Theatre (387)
* 1870, October 3 – Globe Theatre (Josh Hart, manager) (388)
* 1879 – Globe Theatre (Edward Eddy, manager) (389)
* 1871 – Nixon's Amphitheatre (James M. Nixon, manager) (389)
* 1872, April 7 – Broadway Theatre (Jean Burnside, manager) (390)
* 1873, January 21 – Daly's Fifth Avenue Theatre (Augustin Daly, manager) (390)
* 1873, August 25 – Daly's Broadway Theatre (Augustin Daly, manager) (391)
* 1874, April 6 – Fox's Broadway Theatre (G. A. Swalm, proprietor; George H. Tyler, manager) (393)
* 1874, August 3 – Globe Theatre (Robert W. Butler, manager) (393)
* 1874, November 2 – Globe Theatre (James Campbell and Frank Murtha, managers) (393)
* 1876, January 25 – Globe Theatre (Charles Shay, manager) (394)
* 1876, August 25 – Globe Theatre (Robert Butler, manager) (394)
* 1876, October 25 – Globe Theatre (Tallmadge & Scofield, proprietors; Robert W. Butler and C. W. Shafer, managers) (394)
* 1876, November 15 – Heller's Wonder Theatre (Robert Heller, manager) (394)
* 1877, July 30 – Wood's Theatre (George Wood, manager) (394)
* 1877, September 10 – Neil Bryant's Opera House (Andrew Bleakley, manager) (394)
* 1877, December 24 – National Theatre (394–95)
* 1878, September 9 – Globe Theatre (Harry Weston, manager) (396)
* 1878, December 14 – Globe Theatre (Frank B. Murtha, manager) (396)
* 1879, October 20 – New York Circus (Lewis B. Lent, manager) (397)
* 1879, October [?] – Broadway Novelty Theatre (Professor Nelson and J. Z. Little, manager) (397)
* 1881, October 29 – New Theatre Comique (Harrigan and Hart, proprietors; John E. Cannon, manager) (397)
* 1884, December 23 [Destroyed by fire] (398)

## References

[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Globe Theatre (728 Broadway).

Notes

1. ^ Greenleaf 1846, pp. 375–76.
2. ^ Dunlap 2004, p. 48.
3. ^ Brown 1903, pp. 376–98.

Sources

* Brown, Thomas Allston (1903). A History of the New York Stage: From the First Performance in 1732 to 1901. Vol. 2\. New York: Dodd, Mead and Company.
* Dunlap, David W. (2004). From Abyssinian to Zion: A Guide to Manhattan's Houses of Worship. New York: Columbia University Press. ISBN 9780231125437.
* Greenleaf, Jonathan (1846). A History of the Churches, of All Denominations, in the City of New York. New York: E. French.

* v
* t
* e

Broadway theatres

List

Active, by owner

| The Shubert Organization (17)|

* Ambassador Theatre
* Belasco Theatre
* Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre
* Booth Theatre
* Broadhurst Theatre
* Broadway Theatre
* Ethel Barrymore Theatre
* Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre
* Imperial Theatre
* James Earl Jones Theatre
* John Golden Theatre
* Longacre Theatre
* Lyceum Theatre
* Majestic Theatre
* Music Box Theatre
* Shubert Theatre
* Winter Garden Theatre

|

Nederlander Organization (9)|

* Gershwin Theatre
* Lena Horne Theatre
* Lunt-Fontanne Theatre
* Marquis Theatre
* Minskoff Theatre
* Nederlander Theatre
* Neil Simon Theatre
* Palace Theatre
* Richard Rodgers Theatre

ATG Entertainment (7)|

* Al Hirschfeld Theatre
* August Wilson Theatre
* Eugene O'Neill Theatre
* Hudson Theatre
* Lyric Theatre
* St. James Theatre
* Walter Kerr Theatre

Roundabout Theatre Company (3)|

* Stephen Sondheim Theatre
* Studio 54
* Todd Haimes Theatre

Other (5)|

* Circle in the Square Theatre (independent)
* Hayes Theater (Second Stage)
* New Amsterdam Theatre (Disney)
* Samuel J. Friedman Theatre (MTC)
* Vivian Beaumont Theater (Lincoln Center)

Extant former
Broadway theatres|

* Ed Sullivan Theater (CBS)
* Edison Theatre (Hotel Edison)
* Empire Theatre (AMC Theatres)
* Liberty Theatre
* Mark Hellinger Theatre (Times Square Church)
* New Victory Theater (New 42nd Street)
* Sony Hall (Blue Note Entertainment Group)
* Times Square Theater (New 42nd Street)

Defunct and/or demolished

| Post-1949|

* 48th Street Theatre
* Adelphi Theatre
* Apollo Theatre
* Bijou Theatre
* Center Theatre
* Colonial Theatre
* Empire Theatre
* Fulton Theatre
* International Theatre
* Latin Quarter
* Metropolitan Opera House
* Morosco Theatre
* New Century Theatre
* Playhouse Theatre
* President Theatre
* Rialto Theatre
* Vanderbilt Theatre
* Ziegfeld Theatre

|

Post-1919|

* 39th Street Theatre
* 44th Street Theatre
* 49th Street Theatre
* American Music Hall
* Anco Cinema
* Astor Theatre
* Belmont Theatre
* Bowery Theatre
* Broadway Theatre
* Casino de Paris
* Casino Theatre
* Century Theatre
* Charles Hopkins Theatre
* Civic Repertory Theatre
* Comedy Theatre
* Concert Theatre
* Criterion Theatre
* Daly's 63rd Street Theatre
* Earl Carroll Theatre
* Fifth Avenue Theatre
* Gaiety Theatre
* Garrick Theatre
* George M. Cohan's Theatre
* Hippodrome Theatre
* Knickerbocker Theatre
* Klaw Theatre
* Lewisohn Stadium of City College of New York
* Lyric Theatre (1903)
* Maxine Elliott's Theatre
* Nora Bayes Theatre
* Princess Theatre
* Sam H. Harris Theatre
* Waldorf Theatre

Post-1866|

* Abbey's Park Theatre
* Academy of Music
* Bandbox Theatre
* Barnum's New American Museum
* Bijou Theatre
* Broadway Theatre
* Central Theatre
* Circle Theatre
* Daly's Theatre
* Garden Theatre
* Grand Opera House
* Herald Square Theatre
* Hoyt's Theatre
* Koster and Bial's Music Hall
* Lyceum Theatre
* Madison Square Roof Garden
* Manhattan Theatre
* Murray Hill Theatre
* New Bowery Theatre
* New Theatre Comique
* New York Theatre
* Niblo's Garden
* Olympic Theatre
* Paradise Roof Garden
* Princess Theatre
* Savoy Theatre
* Star Theatre
* Theatre Comique
* Victoria Theatre
* Wallack's Theatre
* Weber's Music Hall
* Winter Garden Theatre

Pre-musical|

* American Theatre
* Anthony Street Theatre
* Barnum's American Museum
* Booth's Theatre
* Broadway Theatre
* Burton's Chambers Street Theatre
* John Street Theatre
* Nassau Street Theatre
* National Theatre
* Olympic Theatre
* Park Theatre
* Richmond Hill Theatre

* v
* t
* e

Structures on Broadway in Manhattan and the Bronx

Buildings (The Battery – Houston Street)

* U.S. Custom House
* One
* Two
* 11 (Bowling Green Offices)
* 25 (Cunard)
* 26 (Standard Oil)
* 52
* 61 (Adams Express)
* 65 (American Express)
* 1 Wall Street
* 71 (Empire)
* 75 (Trinity Church)
* 100 (American Surety)
* 111, 115 (Trinity and United States Realty)
* 120 (Equitable)
* 140 (Marine Midland)
* 165 (One Liberty Plaza)
* 195
* 200 (Fulton Center)
* Corbin Building
* 209
* St. Paul's Chapel
* Trinity Church Cemetery
* Transportation (225)
* 233 (Woolworth)
* 253, 256 (Home Life)
* 258 (Rogers Peet)
* City Hall
* 270 (Tower 270)
* 277 (Broadway–Chambers)
* 280
* 287
* 290 (Ted Weiss Federal)
* 291
* 305 (Mutual Reserve)
* 319
* 346 (Former New York Life)
* 359
* 361
* 395 (Pearl River Mart)
* 457–459 (A. J. Dittenhofer Warehouse)
* 462 (Mills & Gibb)
* 488 (E. V. Haughwout)
* 495 (New Era)
* 561 (Scholastic)

Buildings (Houston Street – Times Square)

* 611 (Cable)
* 640
* 721 (Tisch School)
* 770
* 800 (Grace Church)
* 828 (Strand Bookstore)
* 889 (Gorham)
* 900 (Goelet)
* 935–939
* Flatiron Building
* Madison Green
* 1181 (Baudouine)
* 1200 (Gilsey)
* 1232 (Grand Hotel)
* 1260 (Martinique Hotel)
* 1300 (Hotel McAlpin)
* 1313
* Macy's
* 1328 (Marbridge)
* 1352 (Greenwich Savings Bank)
* Holy Innocents Church
* Times Square Tower
* 1466 (Knickerbocker Hotel)

Buildings (Times Square – Columbus Circle)

* 1472 (4 Times Square)
* 1475 (One Times Square)
* 1500
* 1501 (Paramount)
* 1515 (One Astor Plaza and Minskoff Theatre)
* 1535 (Marriott Marquis)
* 1540 (Bertelsmann)
* 1552 (I. Miller)
* 1560 (Embassy Theatre)
* 1564 (Palace Theatre)
* 1566 (TSX Broadway)`
* 1585 (Morgan Stanley)
* 1605 (Crowne Plaza Hotel)
* 1619 (Brill)
* 1634 (Winter Garden Theatre)
* 1650 (Ellen's Stardust Diner)
* 1633 (Paramount Plaza)
* 1681 (Broadway Theatre)
* 1697 (Ed Sullivan Theatre)
* 1717
* 1740
* 1745 (Random House Tower)
* 1764 (224 West 57th Street)
* 1780 (Central Park Tower)
* 1790 (5 Columbus Circle)
* 240 Central Park South

Buildings (Columbus Circle – The Bronx)

* Deutsche Bank Center
* Trump International Hotel and Tower
* 1865
* Empire Hotel
* The Dorilton
* 2100 (Apple Bank)
* 2109 (Ansonia)
* 2124 (Beacon Theatre)
* Hotel Beacon
* The Astor
* 2175 (Hotel Belleclaire)
* 2201 (Apthorp)
* First Baptist Church
* 2350 (Bretton Hall)
* The Belnord
* 2429 (Murray's Sturgeon Shop)
* Astor Court
* The Cornwall
* 2626 (Metro Theater)
* 2689–2693 (Hotel Marseilles)
* School at Columbia
* 2880 (Goddard Institute)
* Broadway Hall
* 3009 (Barnard College)
* 3333 (Riverside Park Community)
* Intercession Church
* 3939 (Children's Hospital)
* 3940
* Audubon Ballroom
* Shabazz Center
* 4140 (United Palace)
* 4881 (Dyckman House)
* 4967 (Good Shepherd Church)
* 5069 (Seaman-Drake Arch)
* 5141 (Allen Hospital)

Parks and plazas

* Bowling Green
* Zuccotti Park
* City Hall Park
* Union Square
* Madison Square
* Greeley Square
* Herald Square
* Times Square
* Columbus Circle
* Verdi Square
* Van Cortlandt Park

Subway stations

* 103rd Street
* 116th Street–Columbia University
* 125th Street
* 137th Street–City College
* 145th Street
* 14th Street
* 157th Street
* 168th Street
* 231st Street
* 238th Street
* 23rd Street
* 28th Street
* 34th Street–Herald Square
* 50th Street
* 59th Street–Columbus Circle
* 66th Street–Lincoln Center
* 72nd Street
* 79th Street
* 86th Street
* 96th Street
* Bowling Green
* Canal Street
* Cathedral Parkway–110th Street
* City Hall
* Dyckman Street
* Eighth Street–New York University
* Fulton Street
* Inwood–207th Street
* Marble Hill–225th Street
* Prince Street
* Times Square–42nd Street
* Van Cortlandt Park–242nd Street
* Wall Street

Former

* New York Produce Exchange
* Government House
* 39 (Macomb House)
* 50 (Tower)
* 64-70 (Manhattan Life Insurance)
* 113–119 (City Hotel)
* 120 (Equitable Life)
* 149 (Singer)
* 165 (City Investing)
* 169–171 (Gilsey)
* 176 (Howard Hotel)
* 195 (Western Union)
* 220 (St. Paul)
* 222 (Barnum's American Museum)
* Astor House
* Rogers Peet
* 346 (Appleton)
* 472 (Mechanics' Hall)
* Theatre Comique
* Church of the Divine Unity
* 507 (St. Nicholas Hotel)
* Metropolitan Hotel
* 663 (Canterbury Hall)
* 673 (Grand Central Hotel)
* 728 (Church of the Messiah)
* 728 (New Theatre Comique)
* 881 (Arnold Constable)
* 1101 (Albemarle Hotel)
* 1107 (McCrory Stores)
* 1115 (Legnam Corporation)
* Hotel Victoria
* 1185 (Fifth Avenue Theatre)
* 1372 (Fair Waist Company)
* 1392 (Knickerbocker Theatre)
* 1411 (Metropolitan Opera House)
* 1469 (Pabst)
* 1481 (Rialto Theatre)
* 1500 (Hotel Claridge)
* 1537 (Astor Theatre)
* 1567 (Central Theatre)
* 1579 (Strand Theatre)
* 1600 (Studebaker)
* Jack Dempsey's Restaurant
* 1645 (Capitol Theatre)
* 1650
* Beltone Studios
* Iridium Jazz Club
* 1678 (Birdland)
* 1865 (Museum of Biblical Art)
* 1981 (Dauphin Hotel)
* 4260 (Coliseum Theatre)
* St. Teresa of Avila Church

* v
* t
* e

East Village and NoHo

Manhattan, New York City

Green spaces

* Abe Lebewohl Park
* Carmen Pabón del Amanecer Jardín
* Chico Mendez Mural Garden (former)
* Esperanza Garden (former)
* La Plaza Cultural de Armando Perez
* Liz Christy Garden
* New York Marble Cemetery
* New York City Marble Cemetery
* Open Road Park
* Tompkins Square Park

Education

* Cooper Union
* 41 Cooper Square
* East Side Community High School
* Grace Church School
* Harvey Milk High School
* High School for Health Professions and Human Services
* Ottendorfer Library
* Third Street Music School Settlement

Religion

* Church of the Immaculate Conception and Clergy Houses
* Church of the Most Holy Redeemer
* Church of the Nativity
* German Evangelical Lutheran Church of St. Mark
* Grace Church
* Middle Collegiate Church
* Mission of Our Lady of Loreto (Sheen Center, Barat Settlement House)
* San Isidoro y San Leandro Western Orthodox Catholic Church of the Hispanic Mozarabic Rite
* Slovenian Church of St. Cyril in New York
* St. Ann's Armenian Catholic Cathedral
* St. Ann Church
* St. Brigid Roman Catholic Church
* St. Emeric Church
* St. George's Church
* St. Mark's Church in-the-Bowery
* St. Nicholas Kirche
* St. Nicholas of Myra Church
* St. Stanislaus Bishop and Martyr Church
* Tabernacle Baptist Church

Culture

| Restaurants/
nightlife|

* B&H Dairy
* Bungalow
* Burp Castle
* CheLi
* Club Cumming
* Death & Co.
* Foul Witch
* Foxface Natural
* HAGS
* Joe's Pub
* Kanoyama
* KGB
* Lucien
* McSorley's
* Nuyorican Poets Café
* Penny
* Please Don't Tell
* Pommes Frites
* Pyramid Club
* Somtum Der
* Superiority Burger
* The Cock
* The Talking Band
* Torien
* Tuome
* Veniero's
* Veselka
* Webster Hall

|

Theater|

* Astor Place Theatre
* Classic Stage Company
* Connelly Theater
* La MaMa Experimental Theatre Club
* Metropolitan Playhouse
* Nublu Club
* Orpheum Theatre
* Performance Space New York
* Playwrights Horizons Theater School
* The Public Theater
* Joe's Pub
* Theatre 80
* Theater for the New City
* Village East by Angelika
* WOW Café

Stores|

* Barbara Feinman Millinery
* Ray's Candy Store
* Strand Bookstore
* Trash and Vaudeville

Museums and galleries|

* Anthology Film Archives
* Brant Foundation
* Merchant's House Museum
* Swiss Institute Contemporary Art New York

Other|

* 4th Street Food Co-op
* Alamo
* C-Squat
* The Houston Bowery Wall
* Museum of Broken Windows
* Russian & Turkish Baths
* The Standard, East Village

Former|

* 8BC
* A7
* Angel's Share
* Astor Opera House
* Cagen
* Charas/El Bohio
* Club 57
* Dos Blockos
* Fez
* Five Spot Café
* Gem Spa
* Ground Zero Gallery
* Heartbreak
* Harry & Ida's Meat and Supply Co.
* Jewel Bako
* Kiev Restaurant
* Kim's Video and Music
* King Tut's Wah Wah Hut
* Kyo Ya
* Lanza's
* Limbo
* Lit Lounge
* Lucy's
* Lynn Redgrave Theater
* New St. Marks Baths
* New Theatre Comique
* New York Vauxhall Gardens
* Now Gallery
* Old Reliable Theatre Tavern
* Other Music
* Paresis Hall
* The Ritz
* The Saint
* SideWalk Cafe
* Sin-é
* St. Mark's Bookshop
* St. Mark's Playhouse
* Ukiyo
* Upright Citizens Brigade Theatre

Other buildings

* 51 Astor Place
* 339 Lafayette Street
* 640 Broadway
* 770 Broadway
* Astor Place Tower
* Bayard–Condict Building
* Bracetti Plaza
* Christodora House
* Colonnade Row
* De Vinne Press Building
* Firehouse, Engine Company 33 and Ladder Company 9
* First Houses
* Hamilton Fish House
* Hamilton-Holly House
* Isaac T. Hopper House
* Metropolitan Savings Bank Building
* Riis Houses
* Robbins & Appleton Building
* Schermerhorn Building
* Silk Building
* Tompkins Square Lodging House for Boys and Industrial School
* Stuyvesant Polyclinic Hospital
* Van Tassell and Kearney Horse Auction Mart
* Village View

Transportation

| Subway stations|

* First Avenue
* Second Avenue
* Third Avenue
* Astor Place
* Broadway–Lafayette Street/Bleecker Street
* Eighth Street–New York University

|

Streets|

* First Avenue
* Second Avenue
* Third Avenue
* 4th Street
* 6th Street (Curry Row)
* 8th Street and St. Mark's Place
* 14th Street
* Astor Place
* Avenue A
* Avenue B
* Avenue C
* Avenue D
* Bleecker Street
* Bond Street
* Bowery
* Broadway
* Cooper Square
* Great Jones Street
* Houston Street
* Lafayette Street
* Taras Shevchenko Place

Regions

* Alphabet City
* Book Row
* East 10th Street Historic District
* East Village/Lower East Side Historic District
* Little Germany
* St. Mark's Historic District
* Yiddish Theatre District

See also: Manhattan Community Board 2, Manhattan Community Board 3, 9th Precinct

40°43′46″N 73°59′35″W﻿ / ﻿40.72939°N 73.99317°W﻿ / 40.72939; -73.99317
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template