Open society

Political term coined by Henri Bergson in 1932

For the non-profit foundation, see Open Society Foundations.

Part of a series on

Liberalism

Schools

* Classical
* Conservative
* Cultural
* Economic
* Green
* Muscular
* National
* Neo
* Neoclassical
* New
* Ordo
* Radical
* Religious
* Christian
* Catholic
* Islamic
* Jewish
* Secular
* Social
* Techno

Principles

* Consent of the governed
* Due process
* Democracy
* Economic globalization
* Equality
* Gender
* Legal
* Federalism
* Freedom
* Economic
* Market
* Trade
* Press
* Religion
* Speech
* Harm principle
* Internationalism
* Invisible hand
* Labor theory of property
* Laissez-faire
* Liberty
* Negative
* Positive
* Limited government
* Market economy
* Natural monopoly
* Open society
* Permissive society
* Popular sovereignty
* Property
* Private
* Public
* Rights
* Civil and political
* Minority
* Natural and legal
* To own property
* To bear arms
* Rule of law
* Secularism
* Secular humanism
* Separation of church and state
* Separation of powers
* Social contract
* Social justice
* Social services
* Welfare state
* Whig history

History

* Glorious Revolution
* Age of Enlightenment
* Atlantic Revolutions
* American Revolution
* French Revolution
* Revolutions of 1848
* Vormärz
* Prague Spring
* Revolutions of 1989
* Arab Spring

Intellectuals

* Milton
* Locke
* Spinoza
* Montesquieu
* Voltaire
* Rousseau
* Smith
* Kant
* Turgot
* Burke
* Priestley
* Paine
* Beccaria
* Condorcet
* Bentham
* Korais
* De Gouges
* Robespierre
* Wollstonecraft
* Staël
* Say
* Humboldt
* Constant
* Ricardo
* Guizot
* Lamennais
* List
* Bastiat
* Martineau
* Emerson
* Tocqueville
* Mill
* Spencer
* Arnold
* Acton
* Weber
* Hobhouse
* Croce
* Cassirer
* Mises
* Ortega
* Keynes
* Collingwood
* Čapek
* Hu
* Hayek
* Popper
* Aron
* Berlin
* Friedman
* Rawls
* Sen
* Nozick
* Kymlicka
* Badawi

Politicians

* Jefferson
* Kołłątaj
* Madison
* Artigas
* Bolívar
* Broglie
* Lamartine
* Macaulay
* Kossuth
* Deák
* Cobden
* Mazzini
* Juárez
* Lincoln
* Gladstone
* Cavour
* Sarmiento
* Mommsen
* Naoroji
* Itagaki
* Levski
* Kemal
* Deakin
* Milyukov
* Lloyd George
* Venizelos
* Ståhlberg
* Gokhale
* Rathenau
* Madero
* Einaudi
* King
* Roosevelt
* Pearson
* Ohlin
* Kennedy
* Jenkins
* Balcerowicz
* Verhofstadt
* Obama
* Macron

Organizations

* Africa Liberal Network
* Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe
* Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe Party
* Arab Liberal Federation
* Council of Asian Liberals and Democrats
* European Democratic Party
* European Liberal Youth
* International Alliance of Libertarian Parties
* International Federation of Liberal Youth
* Liberal International
* Liberal Network for Latin America
* Liberal parties
* Liberal South East European Network
* Renew Europe

Regional variants

* Europe
* Latin America
* Albania
* Armenia
* Australia
* Austria
* Bangladesh
* Belgium
* Bolivia
* Brazil
* Bulgaria
* Canada
* Chile
* China
* Hong Kong
* Colombia
* Costa Rica
* Croatia
* Cuba
* Cyprus
* Czech Republic
* Denmark
* Ecuador
* Egypt
* Estonia
* Finland
* France
* Georgia
* Germany
* Greece
* Venizelism
* Honduras
* Hungary
* India
* Iran
* Israel
* Italy
* Liberism
* Japan
* Latvia
* Lithuania
* Luxembourg
* Mexico
* Moldova
* Montenegro
* Netherlands
* New Zealand
* Nicaragua
* Nigeria
* North Macedonia
* Norway
* Panama
* Paraguay
* Peru
* Philippines
* Poland
* Cracovian
* Portugal
* Romania
* Russia
* Senegal
* Serbia
* Slovakia
* Slovenia
* South Africa
* South Korea
* Spain
* Sweden
* Switzerland
* Taiwan
* Thailand
* Tunisia
* Turkey
* Ukraine
* United Kingdom
* Cobdenism
* Gladstonian
* Manchester
* Whiggism
* United States
* Arizona School
* Classical
* Jeffersonian
* Modern
* Uruguay
* Venezuela
* Zimbabwe

Related topics

* Abortion debate
* Pro-Choice
* Anti-authoritarianism
* Anti-communism
* Bias in American academia
* Bias in the media
* Capitalism
* Democratic
* Centrism
* Radical centrism
* Economic freedom
* Egalitarianism
* Empiricism
* Humanism
* Individualism
* Anarchist
* Land value tax
* Liberal autocracy
* Liberal conservatism
* Feminist
* Equity
* Internationalist
* Libertarianism
* Left
* Right
* Pirate Party
* Progressivism
* Sexually liberal feminism
* Utilitarianism

* Liberalism portal
* Politics portal

* v
* t
* e

Open society (French: société ouverte) is a term coined by French-Jewish philosopher Henri Bergson in 1932,[1][2] and describes a dynamic system inclined to moral universalism.[3] Bergson contrasted an open society with what he called a closed society, a closed system of law, morality or religion. Bergson suggests that if all traces of civilization were to disappear, the instincts of the closed society for including or excluding others would remain.[4]

The idea of an open society was further developed during World War II by the Austrian-born Jewish philosopher Karl Popper.[5][6] Popper saw it as part of a historical continuum reaching from the organic, tribal, or closed society, through the open society (marked by a critical attitude to tradition) to the abstract or depersonalized society lacking all face-to-face interaction transactions.[7]

## History

[edit]

Popper saw the classical Greeks as initiating the slow transition from tribalism towards the open society, and as facing for the first time the strain imposed by the less personal group relations entailed thereby.[8]

Whereas tribalistic and collectivist societies do not distinguish between natural laws and social customs, so that individuals are unlikely to challenge traditions they believe to have a sacred or magical basis, the beginnings of an open society are marked by a distinction between natural and man-made law, and an increase in personal responsibility and accountability for moral choices (not incompatible with religious belief).[9]

Popper argued that the ideas of individuality, criticism, and humanitarianism cannot be suppressed once people have become aware of them, and therefore that it is impossible to return to the closed society,[10] but at the same time recognized the continuing emotional pull of what he called "the lost group spirit of tribalism", as manifested for example in the totalitarianisms of the 20th century.[11]

While the period since Popper's study has undoubtedly been marked by the spread of the open society, this may be attributed less to Popper's advocacy and more to the role of the economic advances of late modernity.[12] Growth-based industrial societies require literacy, anonymity and social mobility from their members[13] — elements incompatible with much tradition-based behavior but demanding the ever-wider spread of the abstract social relations Georg Simmel saw as characterizing the metropolitan mental stance.[14]

## Definition

[edit]

Karl Popper defined the open society as one "in which an individual is confronted with personal decisions" as opposed to a "magical or tribal or collectivist society."[15]

He considered that only democracy provides an institutional mechanism for reform and leadership change without the need for bloodshed, revolution or coup d'état.[16]

## Critical knowledge

[edit]

Popper's concept of the open society is epistemological rather than political.[17] When Popper wrote The Open Society and Its Enemies, he believed that the social sciences had failed to grasp the significance and the nature of fascism and communism because these sciences were based on what he saw to be faulty epistemology.[18] Totalitarianism forced knowledge to become political which made critical thinking impossible and led to the destruction of knowledge in totalitarian countries.[18]

Popper's theory that knowledge is provisional and fallible implies that society must be open to alternative points of view. An open society is associated with cultural and religious pluralism; it is always open to improvement because knowledge is never completed but always ongoing: "if we wish to remain human, then there is only one way, the way into the open society ... into the unknown, the uncertain and insecure".[19]

In the closed society, claims to certain knowledge and ultimate truth lead to the attempted imposition of one version of reality. Such a society is closed to freedom of thought. In contrast, in an open society each citizen needs to engage in critical thinking, which requires freedom of thought and expression and the cultural and legal institutions that can facilitate this.[17]

## Further characteristics

[edit]

Humanitarianism, equality and political freedom are ideally fundamental characteristics of an open society. This was recognized by Pericles, a statesman of the Athenian democracy, in his laudatory funeral oration: "advancement in public life falls to reputation for capacity, class considerations not being allowed to interfere with merit; nor again does poverty bar the way, if a man is able to serve the state, he is not hindered by the obscurity of his condition. The freedom which we enjoy in our government extends also to our ordinary life."[20]

Arguably however it was the tension between a traditional society and the new, more open space of the emerging polis which most fully marked classical Athens,[21] and Popper was very aware of the continuing emotional appeal of what he called "holism...longing for the lost unity of tribal life"[22] into the modern world.

## Caveats

[edit]

Investor and philanthropist George Soros, a self-described follower of Karl Popper,[23] argued that sophisticated use of powerful techniques of subtle deception borrowed from modern advertising and cognitive science by conservative political operatives such as Frank Luntz and Karl Rove casts doubt on Popper's view of open society.[24] Because the electorate's perception of reality can easily be manipulated, democratic political discourse does not necessarily lead to a better understanding of reality.[24] Soros argues that in addition to the need for separation of powers, free speech, and free elections, an explicit commitment to the pursuit of truth is imperative.[24] "Politicians will respect, rather than manipulate, reality only if the public cares about the truth and punishes politicians when it catches them in deliberate deception."[24]

Popper however, did not identify the open society either with democracy or with capitalism or a laissez-faire economy, but rather with a critical frame of mind on the part of the individual, in the face of communal group think of whatever kind.[25] An important aspect in Popper's thinking is the notion that the truth can be lost. Critical attitude does not mean that the truth is found.

## See also

[edit]

* Freedom of speech portal
* Liberalism portal
* Libertarianism portal

* Civil inattention
* Freedom of information
* Liberal democracy
* Open–closed political spectrum
* Open business
* Open government
* Open Society Institute
* Open source governance
* Social equilibrium
* The Transparent Society
* The Wealth of Networks

## References

[edit]

1. ^ • Henri Bergson ([1932] 1937). Les Deux Sources de la morale et de la religion, ch. I, pp. 1–103 and ch. IV, pp. 287–343. Félix Alcan.
• Translated as ([1935] 1977), The Two Sources of Morality and Religion Internet Archive (left or right arrow buttons select succeeding pages), pp. 18–27, 45–65, 229–234., trs., R. A. Audra and C. Brereton, with assistance of W. H. Carter. Macmillan press, Notre Dame.
2. ^ Leszek Kołakowski, Modernity on Endless Trial (1997), p. 162
3. ^ Thomas Mautner (2005), 2nd ed. The Penguin Dictionary of Philosophy ["Open society" entry], p. 443.
4. ^ Henri Bergson,  The Two Sources of Morality and Religion, Macmillan, 1935, pp. 20–21.
5. ^ K. R. Popper, The Open Society and Its Enemies, 2 vols. ([1945] 1966), 5th ed.
6. ^ A. N. Wilson, Our Times (2008), pp. 17–18
7. ^ K. R. Popper, The Open Society and Its Enemies, Volume One (1945), 1 and 174–175.
8. ^ K. R. Popper, 1945:175–176
9. ^ Popper, K., The Open Society and Its Enemies, Volume One (Routledge, 1945, reprint 2006), chapter 5, part III.
10. ^ Popper, K., The Open Society and Its Enemies, Volume One (Routledge, 1945, reprint 2006), chapter 10, part VIII.
11. ^ K. R. Popper, 1945:199–200
12. ^ Wilson, p. 403
13. ^ Ernest Gellner, Nationalism (1997), pp. 25–29
14. ^ M. Hardt/K. Weeks, The Jameson Reader (2000), pp. 260–266
15. ^ Popper, K., The Open Society and Its Enemies, Volume One (Routledge, 1945, reprint 2006), chapter 10, part I.
16. ^ K. R. Popper, 1945:4
17. ^ a b Soros, George, "The Age of Fallibility," Public Affairs (2006).
18. ^ a b Popper, K., The Open Society and Its Enemies, Volume Two (Routledge, 1945, reprint 2006), chapters 23 and 24.
19. ^ K. R. Popper, 1945:201
20. ^ Thucydides, The History of the Peloponnesian War, Book II: Pericles' Funeral Oration Archived 2015-10-22 at the Wayback Machine.
21. ^ J. Boardman et al., The Oxford History of the Classical World (1991), p. 232
22. ^ K. R. Popper, 1945:80
23. ^ Soros, George, Soros on Soros (John Wiley and Sons, 1995), page 33.
24. ^ a b c d Soros, George, "From Karl Popper to Karl Rove – and Back", Project Syndicate (November 8, 2007).
25. ^ I. C. Jarvie et al. eds., Popper's Open Society after fifty years (1999), pp. 43–46

## Further reading

[edit]

* R. B. Levinson, In Defence of Plato (1953)
* Liberalism as threat to the open society: Charles Arthur Willard. Liberalism and the Problem of Knowledge: A New Rhetoric for Modern Democracy, University of Chicago Press, 1996.
* Maurice Cornforth: The Open Philosophy and the Open Society: A Reply to Dr Karl Popper's Refutations of Marxism. New York: International Publishers (1968).

## External links

[edit]

* Media related to Open Society at Wikimedia Commons

* v
* t
* e

Political philosophy

Terms|

* Authority
* Citizenship‎
* Duty
* Elite
* Emancipation
* Freedom
* Government
* Hegemony
* Hierarchy
* Justice
* Law
* Legitimacy
* Liberty
* Monopoly
* Nation
* Obedience
* Peace
* People
* Pluralism
* Power
* Progress
* Propaganda
* Property
* Regime
* Revolution
* Rights
* Ruling class
* Society
* Sovereignty‎
* State
* Utopia
* War

Government|

* Aristocracy
* Oligarchy
* Autocracy
* Bureaucracy
* Dictatorship
* Democracy
* Ochlocracy
* Gerontocracy
* Meritocracy
* Monarchy
* Tyranny
* Plutocracy
* Technocracy
* Theocracy

Ideologies|

* Agrarianism
* Anarchism
* Capitalism
* Christian democracy
* Colonialism
* Communism
* Communitarianism
* Confucianism
* Conservatism
* Corporatism
* Distributism
* Environmentalism
* Fascism
* Feminism
* Feudalism
* Imperialism
* Islamism
* Liberalism
* Libertarianism
* Localism
* Marxism
* Monarchism
* Multiculturalism
* Nationalism
* Nazism
* Populism
* Republicanism
* Social Darwinism
* Social democracy
* Socialism
* Third Way

Concepts|

* Balance of power
* Bellum omnium contra omnes
* Body politic
* Clash of civilizations
* Common good
* Consent of the governed
* Divine right of kings
* Family as a model for the state
* Monopoly on violence
* Natural law
* Negative and positive rights
* Night-watchman state
* Noble lie
* Noblesse oblige
* Open society
* Ordered liberty
* Original position
* Overton window
* Separation of powers
* Social contract
* State of nature
* Statolatry
* Supermajority
* Tyranny of the majority

Philosophers|

| Antiquity|

* Aristotle
* Chanakya
* Cicero
* Confucius
* Han Fei
* Lactantius
* Mencius
* Mozi
* Plato
* political philosophy
* Polybius
* Shang
* Sun Tzu
* Thucydides
* Xenophon

|

Middle Ages|

* Al-Farabi
* Aquinas
* Averroes
* Bruni
* Dante
* Gelasius
* al-Ghazali
* Ibn Khaldun
* Marsilius
* Muhammad
* Nizam al-Mulk
* Ockham
* Plethon
* Wang

Early modern
period|

* Boétie
* Bodin
* Bossuet
* Calvin
* Campanella
* Filmer
* Grotius
* Guicciardini
* Hobbes
* political philosophy
* James
* Leibniz
* Locke
* Luther
* Machiavelli
* Milton
* More
* Müntzer
* Pufendorf
* Spinoza
* Suárez

18th and 19th
centuries|

* Bakunin
* Bastiat
* Beccaria
* Bentham
* Bolingbroke
* Bonald
* Burke
* Carlyle
* Comte
* Condorcet
* Constant
* Cortés
* Engels
* Fichte
* Fourier
* Franklin
* Godwin
* Haller
* Hegel
* Herder
* Hume
* Iqbal
* Jefferson
* Kant
* political philosophy
* Le Bon
* Le Play
* Madison
* Maistre
* Marx
* Mazzini
* Mill
* Montesquieu
* Nietzsche
* Owen
* Paine
* Renan
* Rousseau
* Sade
* Saint-Simon
* Smith
* Spencer
* de Staël
* Stirner
* Taine
* Thoreau
* Tocqueville
* Tucker
* Voltaire

20th and 21st
centuries|

* Agamben
* Ambedkar
* Arendt
* Aron
* Badiou
* Bauman
* Benoist
* Berlin
* Bernstein
* Burnham
* Chomsky
* Dmowski
* Du Bois
* Dugin
* Dworkin
* Evola
* Foucault
* Fromm
* Fukuyama
* Gandhi
* Gentile
* Gramsci
* Guénon
* Habermas
* Hayek
* Hoppe
* Huntington
* Kautsky
* Khomeini
* Kirk
* Kropotkin
* Laclau
* Lenin
* Luxemburg
* Mansfield
* Mao
* Marcuse
* Maurras
* Michels
* Mises
* Mosca
* Mouffe
* Negri
* Nozick
* Nussbaum
* Oakeshott
* Ortega
* Pareto
* Popper
* Qutb
* Rand
* Rawls
* Röpke
* Rothbard
* Russell
* Sartre
* Schmitt
* Scruton
* Shariati
* Sorel
* Spann
* Spengler
* Strauss
* Sun
* Taylor
* Voegelin
* Walzer
* Weber

Works|

* Republic (c. 375 BC)
* Politics (c. 350 BC)
* On the Republic (51 BC)
* Treatise on Law (c. 1274)
* Monarchy (1313)
* The Prince (1532)
* Leviathan (1651)
* Two Treatises of Government (1689)
* The Spirit of Law (1748)
* The Social Contract (1762)
* Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790)
* Rights of Man (1791)
* Elements of the Philosophy of Right (1820)
* Democracy in America (1835–1840)
* The Communist Manifesto (1848)
* On Liberty (1859)
* The Revolt of the Masses (1929)
* The Road to Serfdom (1944)
* The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945)
* The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951)
* A Theory of Justice (1971)
* The End of History and the Last Man (1992)

Related|

* Authoritarianism
* Collectivism and individualism
* Conflict theories
* Contractualism
* Critique of political economy
* Egalitarianism
* Elite theory
* Elitism
* History of political thought
* Institutional discrimination
* Jurisprudence
* Justification for the state
* Political ethics
* Political spectrum
* Left-wing politics
* Centrism
* Right-wing politics
* Political theology
* Political violence
* Separation of church and state
* Separatism
* Social justice
* Statism
* Totalitarianism

* Category:Political philosophy

Authority control databases

National|

* Germany
* Czech Republic

Other|

* Encyclopedia of Modern Ukraine

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template