Ordination of women in the Church of Scotland

Lady Grisell Baillie (1822–1891), the first deaconess in the Church of Scotland

The Church of Scotland was one of the first national churches to accept the ordination of women. In Presbyterianism, ordination is understood to be an ordinance rather than a sacrament; ministers and elders are ordained; until recently deacons were "commissioned" but now they too are ordained to their office in the Church of Scotland.

## Background

[edit]

Women were commissioned as deacons (or "deaconesses") from 1888,[1] and allowed to preach from 1949. Serious debate on the ordination of women as ministers began when Mary Levison petitioned the General Assembly for ordination in 1963. She was eventually ordained as a Minister of Word and Sacrament in 1978, and in 1991 became the first woman to be appointed as Queen's Chaplain.[2]

In a Presbyterian Church, elders (who together with the minister form the kirk session and fulfill some of the functions of a parish council in other denominations) are ordained for life (ad vitam aut culpam) though in some cases without the laying-on of hands. The minister ("minister of Word and Sacrament", to use the full title) is a "teaching elder", the other kirk session members are "ruling elders", and the difference is understood to lie in the authority of the appointment rather than the spiritual nature of the ordinance. Consequently, the theological arguments for and against the ordination of women as elders were identical to those concerning women ministers, and the two debates ran in parallel and were settled more or less simultaneously. The General Assembly changed its legislation to allow the ordination of women as elders in 1966 and as ministers in 1968.[3]

## First women

[edit]

Part of a series on

Christianity and gender
"Adam and Eve" by Albrecht Dürer (1504)

Theology

* Proverbs 31
* 1 Timothy 2:12
* Biblical womanhood
* Christian views on marriage
* Deaconess
* Jesus's interactions with women
* List of women in the Bible
* Ordination of women
* Paul the Apostle and women
* Rape in the Hebrew Bible
* Stay-at-home daughter
* Women as theological figures
* Women in the Bible
* Women in Christianity

Major positions

* Christian egalitarianism
* Complementarianism

Other positions

* Asian feminist theology
* Biblical patriarchy
* New feminism
* Womanist theology

Ordination of women in Christianity

* Ordination of women in Catholicism
* Ordination of women in Protestantism (Anglican • Methodist • Church of Scotland)

Church and society

* African and African-American women in Christianity
* Christianity and homosexuality
* Fallen woman
* Transgender people and Christianity
* Women in Church history

Organizations

|  Feminist

* Evangelical and Ecumenical
Women's Caucus

Egalitarian

* Christians for Biblical Equality

Complementarian

* Council on Biblical
Manhood and Womanhood

Patriarchal

* Vision Forum (defunct)

Theologians and authors (by view)

|  Feminist

* Anne Eggebroten
* Grace Jantzen
* Virginia Ramey Mollenkott
* Letha Dawson Scanzoni

Egalitarian

* Gilbert Bilezikian
* Greg Boyd
* Gordon Fee
* Kevin Giles
* Stanley Grenz
* Kenneth E. Hagin
* Paul Jewett
* Roger Nicole
* Frank Stagg
* William J. Webb

Complementarian

* Don Carson
* John MacArthur
* Susan Foh
* John Frame
* Wayne Grudem
* George W. Knight III
* Albert Mohler
* Douglas Moo
* Jennifer Morse
* Raymond C. Ortlund Jr.
* Dorothy Patterson
* Paige Patterson
* John Piper
* Vern Poythress
* Owen Strachan

Theologians and authors (by branch)

|  Roman Catholic

* Hildegard of Bingen
* Julian of Norwich
* Catherine of Siena
* Christine de Pizan
* Juana Inés de la Cruz
* Edith Stein
* Pope John Paul II
* Phyllis Zagano

Eastern Orthodox

* Frederica Mathewes-Green

Protestant

* April Ulring Larson
* Catherine Booth
* Lise-Lotte Rebel
* Katharine Jefferts Schori

* v
* t
* e

Lady Grisell Baillie (1822–1891) became the first deaconess in the Church of Scotland on 9 December 1888 in a service conducted by Dr James Mackenzie Allardyce at Bowden Kirk in Bowden, Scottish Borders.[4]

The first woman to be ordained as a minister in the Church of Scotland was the Revd Catherine McConnachie by the Presbytery of Aberdeen in 1969.[5] She served as assistant minister at St George's Tillydrone, in Aberdeen. In 1972 the Revd Euphemia H C. Irvine was the first to be ordained and inducted as a parish minister - at Milton of Campsie Parish Church, near Glasgow. She retired in 1988. In 2014, 204 women were serving ministers in the Church of Scotland within Scotland, representing 25.1% of the active Ministers of Word and Sacrament in the country. There were also 61 women serving as Ministries Development Staff.[6]

Women have also played an increasingly prominent role in the Church's administration. In 1996, the Revd Dr Marjory MacLean - then minister at Stromness, Orkney - was appointed as the first women to be Depute Clerk to the General Assembly and later served as acting Principal Clerk in 2002-2003 (and again in 2009). In 2022, the Rev Fiona Smith, previously minister of Ness Bank, Inverness, became the first woman to serve as full-time Principal Clerk.[7] A number of other senior administrators in the Church are women. Women have also been taking an increasing role in important non-pastoral functions in the church: in 2000 Rosemary Goring became the first female editor of Life and Work.

## Female Moderators of the General Assembly

[edit]

The first female Moderator of the General Assembly was Dr Alison Elliot in 2004, who was also the first elder to hold the post since the 16th century.[8] In May 2007 the Revd Sheilagh M. Kesting became the first female minister to be elected as Moderator of the General Assembly.

### List of Female Moderators of the General Assembly

[edit]

* 2004 Alison Elliot OBE LLD DD (Elder, Session Clerk at Edinburgh: Greyfriars Tolbooth & Highland Kirk, Associate Secretary of the Centre for Theology & Public Issues at the University of Edinburgh)
* 2007 Sheilagh M. Kesting DD (Secretary of the Committee on Ecumenical Relations)
* 2013 Lorna Hood DD (Renfrew: North)
* 2018 Susan Brown, Dornoch Cathedral
* 2023 Sally Foster-Fulton

## References

[edit]

1. ^ Warfield, Benjamin (1899). "Presbyterian Deaconesses" (PDF). The Presbyterian Review. 10 (38): 283–289. Retrieved 22 October 2015.
2. ^ Mackay, Johnston. "Obituary: Rev. Mary Levison, minister of the Church of Scotland". Scotsman. Retrieved 22 October 2015.
3. ^ Cashdollar, Charles D. (1 November 2010). Spiritual Home: Life in British and American Reformed Congregations, 1830-1915. Penn State Press. ISBN 978-0-271-04355-5.
4. ^ "Scotland's First Deaconess", by D.P. Thompson M.A., A Walker & Son Ltd, Galashiels 1946
5. ^ Macdonald, Lesley Orr (1999). In Good Company: Women in the Ministry. Wild Goose Publications. ISBN 978-1-901557-15-2.
6. ^ The Church of Scotland General Assembly 2015 (PDF) (2015 ed.). The Church of Scotland Assembly Arrangements Committee. p. 6/14. Retrieved 22 October 2015.
7. ^ "Former Inverness Church of Scotland Minister confirmed as first woman to take up key role with General Assembly on permanent basis". Inverness Courier. 26 May 2022. Retrieved 25 June 2022.
8. ^ Abrams, Lynn (2006). Gender in Scottish History Since 1700. Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 978-0-7486-1761-6.

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template