Paul Shanley

Laicized American priest

Paul Richard Shanley

Born| (1931-01-25)January 25, 1931

Boston, Massachusetts, USA

Died| October 28, 2020(2020-10-28) (aged 89)

Ware, Massachusetts, USA

Nationality| American
Occupation| Roman Catholic priest
Known for| Boston clergy sex abuse scandal
Criminal charge(s)| Indecent assault and child rape
Criminal penalty| 12 to 15 years in prison (served 12)
Ecclesiastical career
Church| Roman Catholic Church
Laicized| 2004

Paul Richard Shanley (January 25, 1931[1] – October 28, 2020) was an American Roman Catholic priest who became the center of a massive sexual abuse scandal in the Archdiocese of Boston in Massachusetts. Beginning in 1967, the archdiocese covered up numerous allegations of child sexual assault against Shanley and facilitated his transfers to other states.

Shanley was convicted of child rape and removed from the priesthood in 2004. Shanley appealed his conviction in 2007 based on questions about the validity of repressed memories, but his conviction was upheld. Shanley was incarcerated from 2005 until his release from state prison in 2017. He died in 2020.

## Biography

[edit]

### Early life

[edit]

Paul Shanley was born on January 25, 1931, in Boston, Massachusetts. His father owned a bowling alley and pool room and his mother worked as a legal secretary. Shanley attended Huntington School for Boys, working in the summer as a camp counselor. Shanley would later claim that he was sexually abused by a priest when he was 12 years old.[2] After graduating from high school in 1950, Shanley entered Boston University. However, after two years, he entered St. John's Seminary in Boston to study for the priesthood.[3]

### Priesthood

[edit]

#### 1960s

[edit]

Shanley was ordained a priest for the Archdiocese of Boston in 1960.[4] After his ordination, Shanley was assigned as an assistant pastor at St. Patrick's Parish in Stoneham, Massachusetts. The next year, a parent in Stoneham complained to the police that Shanley had sexually abused his 11-year-old son. The police were ready to prosecute Shanley, but the father backed off. The mother wrote a complaint letter to Cardinal Richard Cushing, the archbishop, but heard nothing back. There were other complaints about Shanley in Stoneham.[3]

In 1967, a priest at the National Shrine of our Lady of La Salette in Attleboro, Massachusetts wrote a complaint letter to the archdiocese about Shanley. The priest relayed allegations from two boys that Shanley sexually abused them during a weekend visit to a cabin in the Blue Hills.[5]

In 1969, Shanley started his Youth Apostolate in the Roxbury section of Boston, ministering to people suffering from drug addiction and young runaways struggling with their sexuality. He gained "the nickname the hippie priest for his long hair and outspoken views, including his public rejection of the church's condemnation of homosexuality." Shanley's writings included Changing Norms of Sexuality.[6] His work with youth inspired three nuns to start a similar social agency in Boston.[3]

#### 1970s and 1980s

[edit]

At a church meeting in Rochester, New York, in 1977, Shanley said that when an adult and a child have sex, ''the adult is not the seducer—the kid is the seducer.'' In addition, he said that punishing the adult only hurts the child. An attendee at that meeting noted his remarks and sent them to the Archdiocese of Boston.[3]

In 1979, Shanley attended a conference in Boston on sexuality as a representative of the archdiocese. The February 12, 1979 issue of Gaysweek contained an article about the conference titled "Men & Boys". The article stated that Shanley defended the value of relationships between men and boys. Although he was not part of it, a number of conference attendants decided to form the North American Man-Boy Love Association (NAMBLA)[5][7][8] During the 1980s, Shanley served as pastor for several years at St. Jean the Evangelist Parish in Newton, Massachusetts.[9]

#### 1990s

[edit]

In 1990, the archdiocese arranged for Shanley to minister temporarily in the Diocese of San Bernardino in Southern California. While working in California, Shanley was to be on paid sick leave from the archdiocese. Bishop Robert J. Banks wrote a letter in January 1990 to the bishop of San Bernardino stating that Shanley had a clean record. Shanley also signed an affidavit for the Diocese of San Bernardino saying that he did not have any allegations of wrongdoing in Massachusetts.

Shanley was assigned to assist the pastor at St. Anne's Parish in San Bernardino, California. While posted at St. Anne's, Shanley and Reverend John J. White opened a small bed and breakfast property in Palm Springs, California, that catered to gay men.[10] In October 1993, the Diocese of San Bernardino received a letter from Reverend John B. McCormack, a deputy of Cardinal Law, that said the archdiocese had received records of past child sexual abuse allegations against Shanley. The Diocese of San Bernardino suspended Shanley immediately.[10]

The archdiocese in late 1993 sent Shanley to the Institute of Living, a psychiatric facility in Hartford, Connecticut, for evaluation. While at the institute, Shanley admitted to sexually abusing four boys and admitted an attraction to adolescent males. The Institute diagnosed Shanley as being 'narcissistic' and 'histrionic'.[11]

Shanley moved to New York City in 1995 to serve as assistant director of Leo House, a Catholic residence facility in Manhattan. In 1997, Cardinal John O'Connor of the Archdiocese of New York was considering Shanley's promotion to director. However, Cardinal Law dissuaded him from doing it, citing potential embarrassment to the church from Shanley's past.[5]

### Conviction and appeal

[edit]

In May 2002, Shanley was arrested in San Diego, California, on three counts of child rape from Massachusetts. The allegations dated to when he was a pastor at St. Jean's. The victim had filed charges against Shanley only a few days earlier, saying the attacks occurred for several years between ages six and 15.

In February 2005, Shanley was convicted in Massachusetts of indecent assaults and statutory rape; he received a sentence of 12 to 15 years in state prison. Shanley was laicized in 2004.[8]

The Shanley case was based on recovered memories of abuse that happened 20 years earlier when the plaintiff was a young child. The validity of recovered memory and the alleged prejudice against Shanley due to heavy media coverage formed the basis for his legal appeal.[7][12][13]

In 2007, Shanley's new attorney, Robert F. Shaw Jr., filed a motion for a new trial, challenging his convictions as unjust.[14] During a May 2008 hearing, Shaw argued that repressed memories of childhood rape and sexual assault by family and clergy were without general acceptance in the scientific community and were so-called "junk science". Shaw claimed that the court had not received accurate information about the scientific status of repressed memories before Shanley's trial.[15][16]

On November 26, 2008, Superior Court Judge Stephen Neel denied Shaw's motion for a new trial.[17] Shaw then filed a petition for review in the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, arguing that Neel had erred, and that "repressed memory" is an unproven, hypothesized phenomenon that has not been accepted in the scientific community and should not be admitted as evidence in Massachusetts courts. In January 2009, the Supreme Judicial Court granted the petition and ordered the case transferred from the intermediate appellate court for review by the state's highest court.[18]

On September 10, 2009, the Supreme Judicial Court heard arguments in the Shanley case.[19] Shaw argued that Shanley was prosecuted, convicted and imprisoned based upon inadmissible evidence.[20][21][22] The case was closely watched throughout the United States and abroad.[23][24][25][26] On January 10, 2010, the Supreme Judicial Court unanimously affirmed Shanley's conviction. It concluded:

> "In sum, the judge's finding that the lack of scientific testing did not make unreliable the theory that an individual may experience dissociative amnesia was supported in the record, not only by expert testimony but by a wide collection of clinical observations and a survey of academic literature. ... There was no abuse of discretion in the admission of expert testimony on the subject of dissociative amnesia."[27]

### Prison release and death

[edit]

Shanley was released on parole from Old Colony Correctional Center in Bridgewater, Massachusetts on July 28, 2017, after serving 12 years. His sentence required him to be on supervised probation until 2027.[2][28]

Paul Shanley died of heart failure in Ware, Massachusetts, on October 28, 2020, at age 89.[2][4]

## See also

[edit]

* Roman Catholic sex abuse cases
* Roman Catholic priests accused of sex offenses
* Crimen sollicitationis

## References

[edit]

1. ^ "Paul Shanley, notorious pedophile priest, dies at 89". The Washington Post. November 6, 2020. Retrieved March 15, 2025.
2. ^ a b c "Paul Shanley, Ex-Priest in Child Sex-Abuse Scandal, Dies at 89". The New York Times. Associated Press. November 9, 2020. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved June 19, 2022.
3. ^ a b c d Butterfield, Fox; Hontz, Jenny (May 19, 2002). "A Priest's 2 Faces: Protector, Predator". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved June 19, 2022.
4. ^ a b Papadopoulos, Maria (November 6, 2020). "Former priest Paul Shanley, key figure in Boston clergy sex abuse scandal, dies". WFXT. Retrieved November 7, 2020.
5. ^ a b c "Shanley Attended NAMBLA Meeting". Fox News. May 2, 2002. Retrieved April 9, 2011.
6. ^ Jacobs, Sally (July 10, 2002). "'If they knew the madness in me'. A search for the real Rev. Paul Shanley..." The Boston Globe. Retrieved October 9, 2006.
7. ^ a b Wypijewski, JoAnn (September–October 2004). "The Passion of Father Shanley". Legal Affairs. New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University. Archived from the original on January 18, 2022. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
8. ^ a b "Ex-priest leaves prison after serving his sentence for child sex abuse". National Catholic Reporter. 31 July 2017. Retrieved 7 June 2019.
9. ^ Orth, Maureen (April 18, 2008). "Unholy Communion". Vanity Fair. Retrieved March 30, 2019.
10. ^ a b Rezendes, Michael; Carroll, Matt (April 8, 2002). "Boston diocese gave letter of assurance about Shanley". The Boston Globe. Boston, Massachusetts: Boston Globe Partners, L.P. Retrieved October 9, 2006.
11. ^ Podles, Leon J. (2008). Sacrilege: Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church. Crossland Press. ISBN 978-0-9790279-9-4.
12. ^ Lyons, Daniel (June 9, 2003). "Sex, God & Greed". Forbes. Archived from the original on June 6, 2003. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
13. ^ Rauch, Jonathan (March 14, 2005). "Is Paul Shanley Guilty? If Paul Shanley is a monster, the state didn't prove it". Reason Magazine. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
14. ^ D'Entremonte, Jim (March 2008). "Any Prayer for Shanley?". The Guide Magazine. Archived from the original on 2011-07-27.
15. ^ Lavoie, Denise (May 29, 2008). "A former priest seeks new trial". The Boston Globe. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
16. ^ Roche, Kerri (May 29, 2008). "Lawyer for Ex-Priest Questions Repressed Memory Science" (PDF). Daily News Tribune. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
17. ^ "Priest in Boston clergy scandal denied new trial". Necn.com. November 26, 2008. Archived from the original on September 5, 2012. Retrieved April 4, 2011.
18. ^ Murphy, Shelley (January 27, 2009). "SJC to hear appeal by ex-priest in abuse case". The Boston Globe. Boston, Massachusetts: Boston Globe Media Partners. Retrieved April 9, 2011.
19. ^ "Brief of The Leadership Council for Child Abuse and Interpersonal Violence as Amicus Curiae" (PDF). Commonwealth of Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court. 2009. Archived from the original (PDF) on March 3, 2016. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
20. ^ "Disgraced priest Paul Shanley seeks new trial, challenges repressed memories". NECN. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
21. ^ "Convicted ex-priest challenges repressed memories". WHDH-TV. Archived from the original on July 19, 2011. Retrieved April 9, 2011.
22. ^ Paul Shanley appeal [dead link]
23. ^ Zezima, Katie (September 16, 2009). "Ex-Priest Challenges Abuse Conviction on Repressed Memories". The New York Times. New York City. Retrieved April 9, 2011.
24. ^ "Ex-Priest Questions Repressed Memories". ABC News. New York City: ABC. September 14, 2009. Retrieved April 9, 2011.
25. ^ Saltzman, Jonathan (September 10, 2009). "'Repressed memory' is at issue in defrocked priest's appeal". The Boston Globe. Boston, Massachusetts: Boston Globe Media Partners. Retrieved April 9, 2011.
26. ^ Williamson, Dianne (September 13, 2009). "Repressed memory: Issue still argued". Telegram & Gazette. Worcester, Massachusetts: Gannett. Retrieved April 9, 2011.
27. ^ Commonwealth v. Paul Shanley, 752 U.S. 455 (Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, Middlessex 2010), archived from the original.
28. ^ Wamsley, Laura (July 28, 2017). "Former Priest And Convicted Child Abuser Paul Shanley Released From Prison". NPR. Retrieved July 28, 2017.

## External links

[edit]

* www.googleadservices.com
* CourtTV's Paul Shanley trial coverage
* Church documents related to the case
* Vanity Fair Feature: Unholy Communion
* Sacrilege: Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church

* v
* t
* e

Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston

Ordinaries|

Bishops
Jean-Louis Lefebvre de Cheverus
Benedict Joseph Fenwick
John Bernard Fitzpatrick

Archbishops
John Joseph Williams
William Henry O'Connell
Richard Cushing
Humberto Sousa Medeiros
Bernard Francis Law
Seán Patrick O'Malley
Richard Henning

Auxiliary bishops
Cristiano Borro Barbosa
Robert Francis Hennessey
Mark William O'Connell
Robert Philip Reed
Peter J. Uglietto

Emeriti bishops
John Anthony Dooher
Arthur L. Kennedy

Deceased
Joseph Gaudentius Anderson
Thomas Francis Markham
Emilio S. Allué
Francis Xavier Irwin
Walter James Edyvean

Churches|

List
List of churches in the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston

Cathedral
Cathedral of the Holy Cross

Basilicas and shrines
Basilica and Shrine of Our Lady of Perpetual Help, Boston
St. Anthony Shrine, Boston
St. Clement Eucharistic Shrine, Boston
Our Lady of Good Voyage, the Seaport Shrine

Parishes
Holy Name, West Roxbury
Holy Trinity, Lowell
Our Lady of Czestochowa, Boston
Our Lady of Good Voyage, Gloucester
Our Lady Help of Christians, Newton
Sacred Heart, Cambridge
St. Albert the Great, Weymouth
St. Charles Borromeo, Waltham
St. John the Baptist, Salem
St. John the Evangelist, Cambridge
St. Joseph, Boston
St. Leonard, Boston
St. Mary, Dedham (History)
St. Mary, Milton
St. Mary, Newton
St. Mary, Waltham
St. Mary, Winchester
St. Mary - St. Catherine of Siena, Charlestown
St. Paul, Cambridge
St. Stanislaus Bishop & Martyr, Chelsea
St. Susanna, Dedham

Former parishes
Holy Cross, Boston
Our Lady of Mount Carmel, East Boston
St. Aidan, Brookline
St. Catherine of Sienna, Charlestown
St. Joseph, Roxbury
St. Mary, Charlestown
St. Stephen, Boston

Education|

Seminaries
Pope St. John XXIII National Seminary
St. John's Seminary

Colleges
Boston College
Emmanuel College
Labouré College
Merrimack College
Regis College
St. John's Seminary

Closed
Marian Court College

High schools
Academy of Notre Dame, Tyngsboro
Arlington Catholic High School, Arlington
Austin Preparatory School, Reading
Bishop Fenwick High School, Peabody
Boston College High School, Dorchester
Cathedral High School, Boston
Catholic Memorial School, West Roxbury
Central Catholic High School, Lawrence
Cristo Rey Boston High School, Dorchester
Fontbonne Academy, Milton
Lowell Catholic High School, Lowell
Malden Catholic High School, Malden
Newton Country Day School, Newton
Notre Dame Academy, Hingham
Notre Dame High School, Lawrence
St. John's Preparatory School, Danvers
St. Mary's High School, Lynn
Saint Sebastian's School, Needham
Ursuline Academy, Dedham
Xaverian Brothers High School, Westwood

Closed
Cambridge Matignon School, Cambridge
Don Bosco Technical High School, Boston
Elizabeth Seton Academy, Boston
Hudson Catholic High School, Hudson
Marian High School, Framingham
Mount Alvernia High School, Newton
Nazareth Academy, Wakefield
Our Lady of Nazareth Academy, Wakefield
Pope John XXIII High School, Everett
Presentation of Mary Academy, Methuen
Sacred Heart High School, Kingston
Saint Clement High School, Medford
Saint Joseph Preparatory High School, Boston
St. Dominic Savio Preparatory High School, Boston
Trinity Catholic High School, Newton

Former
Archbishop Williams High School, Braintree
Cardinal Spellman High School, Brockton

Priests|

John P. Brennan
Charles A. Finn
Gerald Fitzgerald
John Geoghan
George Kerr
Philip King
Mimie Pitaro
Patrick O'Beirne
Dennis J. O'Donovan
Paul Fitzpatrick Russell
Paul Shanley
Henry A. Walsh

Other|

The Pilot (archdiocese newspaper)
CatholicTV
Regina Cleri
Catholic Archdiocese of Boston sex abuse scandal

* United States portal
* Catholicism portal

* v
* t
* e

Catholic Church sexual abuse cases

Cases|

| By context|

* In confession

|

By country|

* Argentina
* Austria
* Australia
* Belgium
* Canada
* Chile
* El Salvador
* Germany
* Ireland
* Italy
* Poland
* Mexico
* New Zealand
* United Kingdom
* United States
* Venezuela

By religious
institute|

* English Benedictine Congregation
* Brothers Hospitallers of Saint John of God
* Christian Brothers
* Legion of Christ
* Salesian order
* Sisters of Mercy
* Society of Jesus

By clerical
rank|

| Cardinals|

* Hans Hermann Groër (1998)
* Stanisław Dziwisz (1998)
* Bernard Francis Law (2002)
* Angelo Sodano (2010)
* Keith O'Brien (2015)
* Edward Egan (2018)
* Theodore McCarrick (2019)
* Ricardo Ezzati (2019)

|

Bishops|

* Joseph Keith Symons (1998)
* Anthony O'Connell (2002)
* Juliusz Paetz (2002)
* Georg Müller (2009)
* Raymond Lahey (2012)
* Józef Wesołowski (2013)
* Marco Órdenes Fernández (2018)
* Francisco José Cox (2018)
* Gonzalo Duarte García de Cortázar (2018)
* Cristián Caro Cordero (2018)
* Franco Mulakkal (2018)
* Juan Barros Madrid (2018)
* Philip Wilson (2018)
* Edward Joseph Adams (2019)

Priests|

* Category:Catholic priests convicted of sexual abuse

Responses|

| Catholic
Church|

| Holy See|

* Roman Curia
* Crimen sollicitationis (1962)
* The Role of the Church in the Causation, Treatment and Prevention of the Crisis in the Priesthood (1971)
* Instruction Concerning the Criteria for the Discernment of Vocations (2005)
* Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors (2014)
* Vatican sexual abuse summit (2019)
* Vos estis lux mundi [2019]

|

US Conference of
Catholic Bishops|

* Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People (2002)
* John Jay Report (2004)

Other|

* Settlements and bankruptcies (since 1994)
* Virtus (1998)
* Hussey Commission (2002)

See also|

* Parish transfers of abusive Catholic priests (c. 1956–2011)

Governments|

* Hughes Inquiry
* Ferns Report
* Ryan Commission
* McCoy Report
* McCullough Report
* Murphy Report
* Pennsylvania Grand Jury Report
* Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse

Activists|

* Duplessis Orphans
* Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests
* Voice of the Faithful
* Barbara Blaine
* David Clohessy
* Mitchell Garabedian
* Eric MacLeish
* Richard Sipe
* Phil Saviano

Pre-modern|

* Liber Gomorrhianus
* Katharina von Zimmern

Popular
culture|

* Judgment (1990 film)
* The Boys of St. Vincent (1992 miniseries)
* Sinéad O'Connor on Saturday Night Live (1992)
* Primal Fear (1996 film)
* Sex in a Cold Climate (1998 documentary)
* States of Fear (1999 documentary)
* "Red Hot Catholic Love" (2002 South Park episode)
* Suing the Pope (2002 documentary)
* The Magdalene Sisters (2002 film)
* Cardinal Secrets (2002 documentary)
* Song for a Raggy Boy (2004 film)
* Holy Water-Gate (2004 documentary)
* Twist of Faith (2004 documentary)
* Bad Education (2004 film)
* Our Fathers (2005 film)
* Sex Crimes and the Vatican (2006 documentary)
* Deliver Us from Evil (2006 film)
* Hand of God (2006 documentary)
* Doubt (2008 film)
* Brendan Smyth: Betrayal of Trust (2011 documentary)
* In the Name of the Son (2012 film)
* Mea Maxima Culpa: Silence in the House of God (2012 documentary)
* Secrets of the Vatican (2014 documentary)
* Perfect Obedience (2014 film)
* Spotlight (2015 film)
* The Club (2015 film)
* The Keepers (2017 documentary miniseries)
* Romans (2017 film)
* Clergy (2018 film)
* By the Grace of God (2019 film)
* Prey (2019 film)
* Tell No One (2019 documentary)
* Procession (2021 documentary)

Related|

* Debate on the causes of clerical child abuse
* Media coverage of Catholic sexual abuse cases
* Clericalism
* Homosexual clergy in the Catholic Church
* Anti-Catholicism
* Criticism of the Catholic Church
* In literature and media

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template
*[c.]: circa