Progressive Party (United States, 1924–1934)

This article is about the 1924 Progressive Party. For other uses, see Progressive Party (disambiguation).

Political party in the United States

Progressive Party

Chair| Robert M. La Follette
Founded| 1924
Dissolved| 1927
Split from| Republican Party
Democratic Party
Succeeded by| Wisconsin Progressive Party
Headquarters| Washington, D.C.
Ideology| Agrarianism
Populism
Progressivism
Political position| Left-wing[1]

* Politics of the United States
* Political parties
* Elections

The Progressive Party was a political party created as a vehicle for Robert M. La Follette, Sr. to run for president in the 1924 election. It did not run candidates for other offices, and it disappeared after the election. The party advocated progressive positions such as government ownership of railroads and electric utilities, cheap credit for farmers, the outlawing of child labor, stronger laws to help labor unions, more protection of civil liberties, an end to American imperialism in Latin America, and a referendum before any president could lead the nation into war.

After winning election to the United States Senate in 1905, La Follette had emerged as a leader of progressives. He sought the Republican presidential nomination in the 1912 election, but many of his backers switched to Theodore Roosevelt after the former president entered the race. La Follette refused to join Roosevelt's Progressive Party, and that party collapsed after 1916. However, the progressives remained a potent force within both major parties. In 1924, La Follette and his followers created their own Progressive Party which challenged the conservative major party nominees, Calvin Coolidge of the Republican Party and John W. Davis of the Democratic Party.

The Progressive Party was composed of La Follette supporters, who were distinguished from the earlier Roosevelt supporters by being generally more agrarian, populist, and midwestern in perspective, as opposed to urban, elite, and eastern. The party held a national convention in July 1924 that nominated a ticket consisting of La Follette for president, and La Follete later selected Democratic Senator Burton K. Wheeler of Montana as his running mate. The ticket enjoyed support among many farmers and laborers and was endorsed by the Socialist Party of America and the American Federation of Labor.

In the 1924 election, the party carried only La Follette's home state of Wisconsin. The ticket won 16.6% of the national popular vote and carried many counties in the Midwest and West with large German American elements or strong labor union movements. Kenneth McKay estimates that about 52 percent of the LaFollette's support (2,530,000 votes) came from farmers; 20 percent (1,000,000) from socialists; another 20 percent from union members of the American Federation of Labor; and about 8 percent from railroad workers.[2]

The party's share of the vote represents one of the best performances by a third party in presidential election history.

The Progressive Party's National Committee held its last meeting in 1927.[3] In 1934, nine years after his death, Follette's sons created the Wisconsin Progressive Party and briefly dominate Wisconsin politics.

## Wisconsin Progressives

[edit]

1924 Presidential election results by county.

Calvin Coolidge

John W. Davis

Robert M. La Follette

— light = plurality, green = over 50%

Years before, La Follette had created the "Progressive" faction inside the Republican Party of Wisconsin in 1900. In 1912 he attempted to create a Progressive Party but lost control to Theodore Roosevelt, who became his bitter enemy.[4]

In 1924 his new party (using the old 1912 name) called for public ownership of railroads, which catered to the Railroad brotherhoods. La Follette ran with Senator Burton K. Wheeler, Democratic Senator from Montana. The party represented a farmer/labor coalition and was endorsed by the Socialist Party of America, the American Federation of Labor and many railroad brotherhoods. The party did not run candidates for other offices, and only carried one state, Wisconsin. La Follette continued to serve in the Senate as a Republican until his death the following year, and was succeeded in a special election in 1925 by his son, Robert M. La Follette, Jr.[5]

The La Follette family continued his political legacy in Wisconsin, publishing The Progressive magazine and pushing for liberal reforms. In 1934, La Follette's two sons began the Wisconsin Progressive Party, which briefly held power in the state and was for some time one of the state's major parties, often ahead of the Democrats.[6]

## California Progressives

[edit]

Hiram W. Johnson, backed by women's suffrage activist and early feminist Katherine Philips Edson,[7] was a candidate for California governor in 1910, the Progressive Party vice presidential nominee in 1912, and was reelected as Governor of California on the Progressive ticket in 1914. In 1916, he was elected as a Progressive to the U.S. Senate and continued his affiliation with the state party throughout his decades in the Senate, while simultaneously winning the Republican nomination. While Johnson was personally close to Theodore Roosevelt, he was much closer ideologically to Robert La Follette. Johnson sat out the general election in 1924 after unsuccessfully challenging President Calvin Coolidge for the Republican nomination. Johnson personally disliked La Follette but grudgingly admired his quixotic third-party bid and generally agreed with his 1924 platform.[8]

In 1934, when the La Follettes founded the Wisconsin Progressive Party, the California Progressive Party obtained a ballot line in California and ran seven candidates (all unsuccessful, although Raymond L. Haight got 13% of the vote for Governor of California, running as a moderate against socialist and Democratic nominee Upton Sinclair). In 1936 they elected Franck R. Havenner as Congressman for California's 4th congressional district, and garnered a significant portion of the votes in some other races.

Havenner became a Democrat before the 1938 race; Haight defeated eventual winner Culbert Olson in the Progressive primary election, but received only 2.43% of the vote in the general election as a Progressive; and by the time of the 1942 gubernatorial election, the Progressives were no longer on the California ballot. By 1944, Haight was again a Republican, a delegate to the Republican National Convention.[9]

## Presidential candidate performance

[edit]

Year  | Presidential nominee  | Vice-Presidential nominee  | Popular votes  | Percentage  | Electoral votes

|
|
|
|
|

1924 |
Robert M. La Follette |
Burton K. Wheeler | 4,831,706 #3 | 16.6% | 13

## Footnotes

[edit]

1. ^ "La Follette lost 100 years ago, but his progressivism lives on" (in English and US). The Cap Times. 2024-11-05. Archived from the original on 11 December 2024. Retrieved 2025-01-14. "He won 5 million votes nationwide — the highest total in the 20th century for a third-party candidate on the left... In fact, the program that La Follette ran on — taxing the rich, cracking down on Wall Street abuses, empowering workers to organize unions, defending small farmers, breaking up corporate trusts, strengthening public utilities — fueled a resurgence of left-wing populist movements across the upper Midwest: the Non-Partisan League of North Dakota, the Farmer-Labor Party of Minnesota and the Progressive Party of Wisconsin."`{{cite web}}`: CS1 maint: unrecognized language (link)
2. ^ K.C. MacKay, The Progressive Movement of 1924. (Columbia University Press, 1947) pp 188-204..
3. ^ Shideler, James (Spring 1951). "The Disintegration of the Progressive Party Movement of 1924". The Historian. 13 (2). Taylor & Francis: 189–201\. doi:10.1111/j.1540-6563.1951.tb00121.x. JSTOR 24436116.189-201&rft.date=1951&rft_id=info:doi/10.1111/j.1540-6563.1951.tb00121.x&rft_id=https://www.jstor.org/stable/24436116#id-name=JSTOR&rft.aulast=Shideler&rft.aufirst=James&rft_id=https://www.jstor.org/stable/24436116&rfr_id=info:sid/en.wikipedia.org:Progressive+Party+(United+States,+1924–1934)" class="Z3988">
4. ^ Nancy Unger, Fighting Bob La Follette: The Righteous Reformer. Second edition. Madison: Wisconsin Historical Society Press, 2008; pp. 221-238.
5. ^ Unger, Fighting Bob La Follette, pp. 281-303.
6. ^ Herbert F. Margulies; The Decline of the Progressive Movement in Wisconsin, 1890-1920. (State Historical Society of Wisconsin, 1968.)
7. ^ Braitman, Jacqueline R. (June 1986). "A California Stateswoman: The Public Career of Katherine Philips Edson". California History. 65 (2): 82–95\. doi:10.2307/25158366. JSTOR 25158366.82-95&rft.date=1986-06&rft_id=info:doi/10.2307/25158366&rft_id=https://www.jstor.org/stable/25158366#id-name=JSTOR&rft.aulast=Braitman&rft.aufirst=Jacqueline+R.&rfr_id=info:sid/en.wikipedia.org:Progressive+Party+(United+States,+1924–1934)" class="Z3988">
8. ^ See: George E. Mowry, The California Progressives. (1963).
9. ^ Kevin Starr, Endangered Dreams: The Great Depression in California. New York: Oxford University Press, 1996; pg. 152-154.

## Further reading

[edit]

* Hesseltine, William B. The Rise and Fall of Third Parties: From Anti-Masonry to Wallace. Washington, DC: Public Affairs Press, 1948.
* La Follette, Philip. Adventure in Politics: The Memoirs of Philip La Follette. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1970.
* MacKay, K. C. The Progressive Movement of 1924. New York: Columbia University Press, 1947. online
* Margulies, Herbert F. The Decline of the Progressive Movement in Wisconsin, 1890-1920. Madison, WI: State Historical Society of Wisconsin, 1968. online
* Nye, Russel B., Midwestern Progressive Politics: A Historical Study of Its Origins and Development, 1870-1958. Lansing: Michigan State College Press, 1951.
* Unger, Nancy C. Fighting Bob La Follette: The Righteous Reformer. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2000.

## See also

[edit]

* Progressive Party (United States, 1912)
* Progressive Party (United States, 1948)
* Wisconsin Progressive Party
* Minnesota Progressive Party
* California Progressive Party
* Oregon Progressive Party
* Vermont Progressive Party
* Nomination of Robert M. La Follette for President, 1924
* A.J. Barnes, California Progressive candidate

## External links

[edit]

* Progressive Party 1924 platform from UC Santa Barbara's The American Presidency Project

* v
* t
* e

(<- 1920) 1924 United States presidential election (-> 1928)

Republican Party
(Convention · Primaries)|

| Nominees|

* President: Calvin Coolidge (incumbent)
* Vice President: Charles G. Dawes

|

Other candidates|

* Hiram Johnson
* Robert M. La Follette

Democratic Party
(Convention · Primaries)|

| Nominees|

* President: John W. Davis
* Vice President: Charles W. Bryan

|

Other candidates|

* William Gibbs McAdoo
* Al Smith
* campaign
* Oscar Underwood

Progressive Party|

| Nominees|

* President: Robert M. La Follette
* Vice President: Burton K. Wheeler

|

Other Third-party and independent candidates

Communist Party|

* Nominee: William Z. Foster
* VP nominee: Benjamin Gitlow

Prohibition Party|

* Nominee: Herman P. Faris
* VP nominee: Marie C. Brehm

American Party|

* Nominee: Gilbert Nations
* VP nominee: Charles Hiram Randall

* Other 1924 elections: House
* Senate

* v
* t
* e

Socialist Party of America

Presidential tickets|

* 1904, Debs/Hanford
* 1908, Debs/Hanford
* 1912, Debs/Seidel
* 1916, Benson/Kirkpatrick
* 1920, Debs/Stedman
* 1924, Endorsed Progressive Party ticket
* 1928, Thomas/Maurer
* 1932, Thomas/Maurer
* 1936, Thomas/Nelson
* 1940, Thomas/Krueger
* 1944, Thomas/Hoopes
* 1948, Thomas/Smith
* 1952, Hoopes/Friedman
* 1956, Hoopes/Friedman

Parties by state
and territory|

| State|

* California
* Colorado
* Connecticut
* Florida
* Kansas
* Louisiana
* Maine
* Massachusetts
* Michigan
* Minnesota
* Missouri
* New Jersey
* New York
* North Carolina
* North Dakota
* Ohio
* Oklahoma
* Oregon
* Pennsylvania
* Texas
* Washington (state)
* Wisconsin

|

Related topics|

* History of the socialist movement in the United States
* Social Democratic Federation
* Social Democratic Party of America
* Socialist Party USA
* Committee for the Preservation of the Socialist Party
* Democratic Socialist Organizing Committee
* Social Democrats, USA
* Young People's Socialist League
* English-language press of the Socialist Party of America
* Non-English press of the Socialist Party of America
* Democratic socialism
* Social democracy

* v
* t
* e

National political parties in the United States

List of political parties in the United States

Major parties|

* Democratic
* Republican

Third parties|

| Larger|

* Green
* Libertarian

|

Smaller|

* African People's Socialist
* Alliance
* American Freedom
* American Solidarity
* Black Socialists of America
* Christian Liberty
* Citizens
* Communist
* Constitution
* Freedom Party
* Freedom Road Socialist Organization
* Freedom Socialist
* Forward Party
* Green Mountain Peace and Justice Party
* Legal Marijuana Now
* Liberal
* National Progressive Party
* Progressive Dane
* Marijuana
* Pirate
* Peace and Freedom Party
* People's
* Progressive Labor Party
* Prohibition
* Reform
* Socialism and Liberation
* Socialist (1973)
* Socialist Action
* Socialist Alternative
* South Carolina Workers Party
* Social Democrats, USA
* Socialist Equality
* Socialist Labor
* Socialist Workers
* Transhumanist
* Unity
* Working Class
* Working Families
* Workers World
* World Socialist

Defunct parties|

| Major parties|

* Democratic-Republican
* Federalist
* National Republican
* Whig
* National Union

|

Third parties|

* American (Know Nothing)
* Americans Elect
* Anti-Masonic
* American Nazi
* American (1924)
* American (1969)
* American Vegetarian
* Black Panther
* Boston Tea
* Citizens
* Communist Workers'
* Constitution (1952)
* Constitutional Union
* Democratic-Republican (1844)
* Farmer–Labor
* Free Soil
* Gold Democrats
* Greenback
* Human Rights Party
* Independence (1906)
* Independence (2007)
* Justice
* Labor (1919)
* Labor (1996)
* Liberal Republican
* Liberty (1840)
* National Equal Rights Party
* National (1917)
* National Renaissance
* National Socialist
* National States' Rights
* Natural Law
* New Alliance
* New Party
* New Union
* Nullifier
* Opposition
* Patriot Party
* People's Party
* Populist (People's)
* Personal Choice
* Populist
* Progressive (1912)
* Progressive (1924)
* Progressive (1948)
* Proletarian Party
* Radical Democracy
* Raza Unida
* Readjuster
* Red Guards
* Red Guard Party
* Renew America Movement
* Serve America Movement
* Silver
* Silver Republican
* Social Democratic
* Socialist (1901)
* States Rights (Dixiecrat)
* Traditionalist Worker
* Unconditional Union
* Union (1850)
* Union (1861)
* Union (1936)
* U.S. Labor
* White Panthers
* White Patriot
* Young Patriots
* Workers
* Young Lords
* Youth International

|

*     * State and local political parties (without national body)
* Presidential nominating convention (List)
* Politics of the United States
* Politics portal

* v
* t
* e

Historical left-wing third-party U.S. presidential tickets

This group includes only pre-1996 parties that fielded a candidate that won greater 0.1% of the popular vote in at least one presidential election

Presidential
tickets that
won at least
one percent of
the national
popular vote
(candidate(s) /
running mate(s))|

| Greenback|

* Peter Cooper/Samuel F. Cary (1876)
* James B. Weaver/Barzillai J. Chambers (1880)
* Benjamin Butler/Absolom M. West (1884)

|

Union Labor|

* Alson Streeter/Charles E. Cunningham (1888)

Populist|

* James B. Weaver/James G. Field (1892)
* William Jennings Bryan/Thomas E. Watson (1896)

Socialist|

* Eugene V. Debs/Ben Hanford (1904 and 1908)
* Eugene V. Debs/Emil Seidel (1912)
* Allan L. Benson/George R. Kirkpatrick (1916)
* Eugene V. Debs/Seymour Stedman (1920)
* Norman Thomas/James H. Maurer (1932)

Bull Moose|

* Theodore Roosevelt/Hiram Johnson (1912)

Progressive (1924)|

* Robert M. La Follette/Burton K. Wheeler (1924)

Progressive (1948)|

* Henry A. Wallace/Glen H. Taylor (1948)

Other notable
left-wing parties|

* Socialist Labor Party of America
* Social Democratic Party of America
* Independence Party
* Farmer–Labor Party
* Communist Party USA
* Socialist Workers Party
* Liberty Party
* People's Party
* Citizens Party
* New Alliance Party

* Third-party performances in presidential elections
* Labor history of the United States
* Liberalism in the United States
* Progressivism in the United States
* Socialism in the United States

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template