Protective laws

Laws enacted to protect women from hazards or difficulties of paid work

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources in this article. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.
Find sources: "Protective laws" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2010) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

|

The examples and perspective in this article may not represent a worldwide view of the subject. You may improve this article, discuss the issue on the talk page, or create a new article, as appropriate. (October 2024) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

|

Protective laws were enacted to protect women from certain hazards or difficulties of paid work. These laws had the effect of reducing the employment available to women, saving it for men. These were enacted in many jurisdictions in the United States, and some were in effect until the mid or late 20th century. The landmark case Muller v. Oregon set a precedent to use sex differences as a basis for separate legislation.[1]

The name is not a formal one but is a widely used colloquial term, as was the term protective legislation.[2]

Part of a series on

Feminism

History

* Feminist history
* Women's history
* American
* British
* Canadian
* German

Waves

* First
* Second
* Third
* Fourth

Timelines

* Women's suffrage
* Muslim countries
* US

* Other women's rights

Women's suffrage by country

* Austria
* Australia
* Canada
* Colombia
* India
* Japan
* Kuwait
* Liechtenstein
* New Zealand
* Spain
* Second Republic
* Francoist
* Switzerland
* United Kingdom
* Cayman Islands
* Wales
* United States
* states

Intersectional variants

* Fat
* Lesbian
* Lesbian of color
* Radical lesbianism
* Separatist
* Sex-positive
* Transfeminism
* Postgenderism
* Vegetarian ecofeminism

Socialist

* Anarchist
* Queer
* Jineology
* Marxist
* Critical theory
* Standpoint
* Materialist
* Ecofeminist
* Postcolonial
* Global
* Transnational
* Xenofeminism
* Jineoloji

Multicultural

* Africana womanism
* Black
* Hip hop
* Lesbian
* Ratchet
* Chicana
* Lesbian
* Indigenous
* Native American
* Multiracial
* Romani
* Womanism

Other variants

* Anti-abortion
* Conservative
* Equity
* Femonationalism
* Liberal
* Maternal
* Postfeminism
* Reactionary
* State
* Carceral
* Imperial
* Embedded
* Gender-critical or trans-exclusionary
* Victim
* White

Religious variants

* Atheist
* Buddhist
* Christian
* Mormon
* New
* Womanist
* Asian
* Neopagan
* Dianic Wicca
* Reclaiming
* Ecofeminist
* Hindu
* Islamic
* Jewish
* Orthodox
* Sikh

Movements and ideologies

* 4B movement

* White Feather Campaign
* Analytical
* Anti-fascist
* Anti-pornography
* Cyber
* HCI
* Networked
* Xeno
* Difference
* Cultural
* Neo
* Ecofeminism
* Eugenic
* Individualist
* Liberal
* Equality
* Social
* Labor
* Libertarian
* Lipstick
* Stiletto
* Post-structural
* Postmodern
* Radical
* Political lesbianism
* Separatist
* Technofeminism
* Women's liberation

Concepts

* Antinaturalism
* Choice feminism
* Cognitive labor
* Conscription
* Complementarianism
* Literature
* Children's literature
* Diversity (politics)
* Diversity, equity, and inclusion
* Effects on society
* Equality
* Female education
* Female genital mutilation
* Femicide
* Femonationalism
* Feminism in culture
* Feminist movement
* African-American women's suffrage movement
* Art movement
* In hip hop
* Feminist stripper
* Formal equality
* Gender equality
* Gender quota
* Gender role
* Girl power
* Honor killing
* Ideal womanhood
* Invisible labor
* Internalized sexism
* International Girl's Day and Women's Day
* Language reform
* Feminist capitalism
* Gender-blind
* Likeability trap
* Male privilege
* Matriarchal religion
* Media
* Men in feminism
* Misogyny
* Trans
* Oedipus complex
* Opposition to feminism
* Pro-feminism
* Protofeminism
* Purplewashing
* Racism
* Reproductive justice
* Sentencing disparity
* Sex workers' rights
* Sexual harassment
* Sexual objectification
* Substantive equality
* Toxic masculinity
* Transmisogyny
* Triple oppression
* Violence against women
* War on women
* Women's empowerment
* Women-only space
* Women's health
* Women's rights
* Women in the workforce

Outlooks

* Abortion-rights
* Bicycling and feminism
* Bodily integrity
* Criticism of marriage
* Views on BDSM
* Views on pornography
* Views on prostitution
* Views on sexual orientation
* Views on sexuality
* Views on transgender topics
* Reproductive rights
* Sexual and reproductive health and rights
* SCUM Manifesto

Theory

* Feminist method
* Gender studies
* Gender mainstreaming
* Gynocentrism
* Kyriarchy
* Male gaze
* Matriarchy
* Women's studies
* Men's studies
* Patriarchy
* Écriture féminine

Areas of study

* Anthropology
* Archaeology
* Architecture
* Art
* Art criticism
* Literary criticism
* Film theory
* Science fiction
* Biology
* Composition studies
* Criminology
* Pathways perspective
* Economics
* FDPA
* Geography
* International relations
* Constructivism
* Legal theory
* Pedagogy
* Philosophy
* Aesthetics
* Empiricism
* Epistemology
* Ethics
* Justice ethics
* Existentialism
* Metaphysics
* science
* Political ecology
* Political theory
* Pornography
* Psychology
* Therapy
* Revisionist mythology
* Sex wars
* Sexology
* Sociology
* Technoscience
* Theology
* womanist theology

By continent/country

* Africa
* Democratic Republic of the Congo
* Egypt
* Ethiopia
* Ghana
* Mali
* Nigeria
* Senegal
* South Africa
* Albania
* Australia
* Bangladesh
* Canada
* China
* Denmark
* Finland
* France
* Germany
* Greece
* Hong Kong
* India
* Indonesia
* Iran
* Iraq
* Republic of Ireland
* Israel
* Italy
* Japan
* Latin America
* Argentina
* Brazil
* Chile
* Haiti
* Honduras
* Mexico
* Paraguay
* Trinidad and Tobago
* Lebanon
* Malaysia
* Nepal
* Netherlands
* New Zealand
* Northern Cyprus
* Norway
* Pakistan
* Philippines
* Poland
* Russia
* Saudi Arabia
* South Korea
* Sweden
* Syria
* Taiwan
* Thailand
* Turkey
* Vietnam
* Ukraine
* United Kingdom
* United States
* History of women

Lists and categories

|  Lists

* Articles
* Feminists
* by nationality
* Literature
* American feminist literature
* Feminist comic books
* Feminist songs

* Conservative feminisms
* Ecofeminist authors
* Feminist art critics
* Feminist economists
* Feminist philosophers
* Feminist poets
* Feminist rhetoricians
* Jewish feminists
* Muslim feminists
* Feminist parties
* Suffragists and suffragettes
* Women's rights activists
* Women's studies journals
* Women's suffrage organizations

Categories

* Women's rights by country
* Feminists by nationality

Feminism portal

* v
* t
* e

## Range of laws

[edit]

Over laws affected work hours, wages, occupational choice, mandatory seating, homework, and rights to do business and make contracts.[3] Specifically, various laws required a minimum wage for women and children[4] (criticized because women allegedly did not need the money, the minimum wage was opposed for men and ruled unlawful in 1923)[4] and forbade or regulated lifting heavy loads, working at night or for long hours, or tending bar[5] and required some safety and breaks from work for rest, lunch, and bathroom use.[6] The ban on long hours often denied the possibility of earning overtime pay.[5] Some of the laws were irrelevant to work but were intended to protect women's ability to become mothers and not be subject to sexual issues that were often categorized as moral issues.[5]

## Rationale for passage

[edit]

Protection of women was a rationale for the enactment of the laws. Women were considered more vulnerable than men in factories and sweatshops, and one supporter of the laws was the Amalgamated Clothing Workers, a labor organization, which supported the laws for nonmembers of unions.[5] Some supporters in unions and women's organizations, concerned that courts in the 1950s would oppose pro-labor legislation generally, wanted to preserve whatever such laws were already in place.[7] By 1972, however, the year the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) to the U.S. Constitution passed the Congress and was proposed to the states for ratification, unions supported the ERA and considered female-only protective laws as against women's interests.[8]

Another rationale was put forth by an organization which, in 1836, adopted a resolution that said, "Whereas, Labor is a physical and moral injury to women and a competitive menace to men, we recommend legislation to restrict women in industry."[9]

The minimum wage was supported except for men because of "widespread agreement that the labor market did not function effectively where women and the family were concerned"[10] and among feminists because women needed to support their own dependents.[10]

## Criticisms

[edit]

They were criticized on several grounds.

* They failed to require protection from the hazards or difficulties for all workers who needed those protections.
* They denied jobs to women who did not need the protections at all or needed the jobs more than the protections and could make that choice.
* Many denied jobs rather than required changes, either at the workplaces or elsewhere, that would have reduced any reason for protection.
* Few, if any, of these laws applied to women's unpaid work at home or with families, which could be more hazardous or difficult than some of the restricted employments.
* Some women may have advocated for such laws, but many were put into effect when women did not have the vote or the right to hold electoral office,[3] so the people ultimately responsible for legislating them were almost exclusively men, and they were responding to voters who were men.
* The laws disincentivized employers from hiring women.

Protective labor laws were criticized because they excluded women from prestigious well-paid male-dominated occupations, and they confined women's work to the home, thus reinforcing Separate Spheres ideology and the Cult of Domesticity.[1]

An opponent of these laws was the National Woman's Party (NWP), which led support for the Equal Rights Amendment. It opposed the laws as interfering with women's right to make contracts and as preventing them from offering their full capabilities at work, objecting, for example, to a 20-pound limit on lifting, if a woman wanted that job and could lift the weight.[5]

## Modernity

[edit]

Eventually, most or all were amended, repealed, ruled unconstitutional (i.e., in violation of the US Constitution and thus invalid), or not enforced anymore because they singled women out for unequal treatment. (Laws in the US may not be enforced if they are unconstitutional or otherwise unauthorized in law.) Had the Equal Rights Amendment to the Constitution been enacted in the 1970s or the 1980s, it was believed the laws would have been invalidated by the amendment and subsequent litigation[5] and, as a result, most liberal organizations opposed the amendment.[5] The laws had earlier been supported by social feminists for decades.[5]

Some of the laws have been replaced by laws that apply to both genders, such as the Occupational Safety and Health Act.

An argument for protective laws still sometimes arises, as with debates over the US military's continuing legal ban on women in certain combat positions, when it is argued that the ban should remain in effect because women might be killed or raped.

## Worldwide

[edit]

Besides the United States, many others may have laws with comparable intent or effect and that constrain employment of women or of other groups of adults defined by characteristics at birth, although the laws may not be called by the same name.

In Egypt, around the 1920s, the Egyptian Feminist Union advocated for protective legislation.[11]

## See also

[edit]

* Mothers' pensions
* Muller v. Oregon
* Potty parity
* Right to sit
* Sheppard–Towner Act

## Footnotes

[edit]

1. ^ a b Baron, Ava (1981). "Protective Labor Legislation and the Cult of Domesticity". Journal of Family Issues. 2 (1). SAGE Publications: 25–38\. doi:10.1177/0192513X8100200103. S2CID 145776998.
2. ^ Stansell, Christine, The Feminist Promise: 1792 to the Present (N.Y.; Modern Library, 1st ed. 2010 (ISBN 978-0-679-64314-2)), p. 197 (protective legislation as term).
3. ^ a b Grant, Jane, Confession of a Feminist, in The American Mercury, vol. LVII, no. 240, December , 1943, pp. 684–691, esp. pp. 688–690.
4. ^ a b Folbre, Nancy, Greed, Lust and Gender: A History of Economic Ideas (Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press, 2009 (ISBN 978-0-19-923842-2)), p. 276 & n. 37 (author prof. economics, Univ. of Mass. Amherst).
5. ^ a b c d e f g h Stansell, Christine, The Feminist Promise, op. cit., p. 197.
6. ^ Stansell, Christine, The Feminist Promise, op. cit., p. 197 & n. 51, citing Cobble, Dorothy Sue, The Other Women's Movement: Workplace Justice and Social Rights in Modern America (Princeton, N.J., 2004), p. 184.
7. ^ Stansell, Christine, The Feminist Promise, op. cit., p. 197 n. 52, citing Peterson, The Kennedy Commission, in Tinker, Irene, ed., Women in Washington: Advocates for Public Policy (Beverly Hills, Calif., 1983).
8. ^ Stansell, Christine, The Feminist Promise, op. cit., p. 287.
9. ^ Grant, Jane, Confession of a Feminist, in The American Mercury, vol. LVII, no. 240, December , 1943, pp. 684–691, esp. pp. 688–690 (quotations per p. 689 (italics in Jane Grant's article)).
10. ^ a b Folbre, Nancy, Greed, Lust and Gender, op. cit., p. 276.
11. ^ Badran, Margot, Feminism in Islam: Secular and Religious Convergences (Oxford, Eng.: Oneworld, 2009 (ISBN 978-1-85168-556-1)), p. 124 (author sr. fellow, Ctr. for Muslim Christian Understanding, Georgetown Univ., U.S., & fellow, Woodrow Wilson International Ctr. for Scholars, Washington, D.C.).

## Further reading

[edit]

* Nancy Woloch, A Class by Herself: Protective Laws for Women Workers, 1890s-1990s. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2015.

* v
* t
* e

Law

Core subjects|

* Administrative law
* Civil law
* Constitutional law
* Contract
* Criminal law
* Crime
* Deed
* Doctrine
* Equity
* Evidence
* International law
* Law of obligations
* Private law
* Procedure
* Civil
* Criminal
* Property law
* Public law
* Punishment
* Corporal
* Restitution and unjust enrichment
* Statutory law
* Tort

Disciplines|

* Abortion law
* Agricultural law
* Animal law
* Aviation law
* Amnesty law
* Banking law
* Bankruptcy
* Commercial law
* Competition law
* Conflict of laws
* Construction law
* Consumer protection
* Corporate law
* Cyberlaw
* Drugs law
* Election law
* Energy law
* Entertainment law (Media law)
* Environmental law
* Family law
* Financial law
* Financial regulation
* Health law
* Immigration law
* Intellectual property
* International criminal law
* International labour law
* International human rights
* International slavery laws
* International trade law
* Jurimetrics
* Labour
* Landlord–tenant law
* Law of war
* Legal archaeology
* Legal fiction
* Maritime law
* Marriage law
* Military law
* Music law
* Nationality law
* Probate
* Estate
* Will and testament
* Product liability
* Public international law
* Refugee law
* Space law
* Sports law
* State of emergency
* Tax law
* Transport law
* Trust law
* Unenforced law

Sources of law|

* Charter
* Legal code / Statutory law
* Constitution
* Custom
* Divine law
* Divine right
* Human rights
* Legitimacy
* Letters patent
* Man-made law
* Natural law
* Natural and legal rights
* Case law
* Precedent
* Law reports
* Legal treatise
* Regulations

Law making|

* Ballot measure
* Codification
* Decree
* Edict
* Executive order
* Proclamation
* Legislation
* Delegated legislation
* Regulation
* Rulemaking
* Promulgation
* Ratification
* Repeal
* Treaty
* Concordat
* Statutory law
* Statute
* Act of parliament
* Act of Congress
* Basic structure doctrine

Legal systems|

* Civil law
* Common law
* Chinese law
* Legal pluralism
* Religious law
* Canon law
* Catholic canon law
* Hindu law
* Jain law
* Jewish law
* Parsi law
* Sharia
* Roman law
* Byzantine law
* Socialist law
* Statutory law
* Xeer
* Yassa

Legal theory|

* Anarchist
* Contract theory
* Comparative law
* Expressive function
* Feminist
* Law and economics
* Legal ethics
* Legal formalism
* History
* Libertarian
* International legal theory
* Principle of legality
* Principle of typicality
* Pseudolaw
* Rule of law
* Rule of man
* Sociology

Jurisprudence|

* Adjudication
* Administration of justice
* Admission to practice law
* Constitutionalism
* Criminal justice
* Court-martial
* Disbarment
* Dispute resolution
* Fiqh
* Lawsuit/Litigation
* Legal opinion
* Legal remedy
* Damages
* Deterrence (penology)
* Proportionality
* Reparations
* Legal status
* Judge
* Justice of the peace
* Magistrate
* Judgment
* Judicial activism
* Judicial interpretation
* Judicial misconduct
* Kangaroo court
* Judicial review
* Jurisdiction
* Jury
* Justice
* Practice of law
* Attorney
* Barrister
* Counsel
* Lawyer
* Legal representation
* Prosecutor
* Solicitor
* Question of fact
* Question of law
* Trial
* Trial advocacy
* Trier of fact
* Ultra vires
* Verdict

Legal institutions|

* Barristers' chambers
* Bureaucracy
* The bar
* The bench
* Civil society
* Court
* Ecclesiastical
* Court of equity
* Election commission
* Executive
* Judiciary
* Law enforcement
* Agency
* Legal education
* Law school
* Legal industry by country
* Legislature
* Military
* Police
* Political party
* Tribunal

History|

* History of the legal profession
* History of the American legal profession
* Women in law

* Law portal
* Category
* Index
* Outline

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template