Subsidiarity

Principle of social organization

Not to be confused with Subsidiary or Subsidy.

For the Catholic social teaching, see Subsidiarity (Catholicism). For the principle in European Union law, see Subsidiarity (European Union).

Subsidiarity is a principle of social organization that holds that social and political issues should be dealt with at the most immediate or local level that is consistent with their resolution. The Oxford English Dictionary defines subsidiarity as "the principle that a central authority should have a subsidiary function, performing only those tasks which cannot be performed at a more local level".[1] The concept is applicable in the fields of government, political science, neuropsychology, cybernetics, management and in military command (mission command). The OED adds that the term "subsidiarity" in English follows the early German usage of "Subsidiarität".[2] More distantly, it is derived from the Latin verb subsidio (to aid or help), and the related noun subsidium (aid or assistance).

The development of the concept of subsidiarity has roots in the natural law philosophy of Thomas Aquinas and was mediated by the social scientific theories of Luigi Taparelli, SJ, in his 1840–43 natural law treatise on the human person in society.[3] In that work, Taparelli established the criteria of just social order, which he referred to as "hypotactical right" and which came to be termed subsidiarity following German influences.[4]

Another origin of the concept is in the writings of Calvinist law-philosopher Johannes Althaus who used the word "subsidia" in 1603.[5][6] As a principle of just social order, it became one of the pillars of modern Catholic social teaching.[3][7] Subsidiarity is a general principle of European Union law. In the United States of America, Article VI, Paragraph 2 of the constitution of the United States is known as the Supremacy Clause. This establishes that the federal constitution, and federal law generally, take precedence over state laws, and even state constitutions.[8] The principle of States' Rights is sometimes interpreted as being established by the Tenth Amendment, which says that "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

## Political theory

[edit]

Alexis de Tocqueville's classic study, Democracy in America, may be viewed as an examination of the operation of the principle of subsidiarity in early 19th century America. Tocqueville noted that the French Revolution began with "a push towards decentralization… in the end, an extension of centralization".[9] He wrote that "Decentralization has, not only an administrative value, but also a civic dimension, since it increases the opportunities for citizens to take interest in public affairs; it makes them get accustomed to using freedom. And from the accumulation of these local, active, persnickety freedoms, is born the most efficient counterweight against the claims of the central government, even if it were supported by an impersonal, collective will."[10]

Part of a series on

Christian democracy

Principles

* Catholic social teaching
* Christian corporatism
* Christian ethics
* Christian humanism
* Common good
* Communitarianism
* Conservatism
* Christian
* Compassionate
* Liberal
* Progressive
* Social
* Consistent life ethic
* Cultural mandate
* Culture of life
* Dignity of labor
* Distributism
* Economic progressivism
* Familialism
* Human dignity
* Just war theory
* Liberalism
* Christian
* Catholicism
* Conservative
* Ordo
* Social
* Mixed economy
* Multiculturalism
* Neo-Calvinism
* Neo-Thomism
* Option for the poor
* Pan-European identity
* Person Dignity Theory
* Popularism
* Public morality
* Religious liberty
* Friendly separation of church and state
* Religious pluralism
* Social Gospel
* Social justice
* Social market economy
* Solidarity
* Sphere sovereignty
* Stewardship
* Environmentalism
* Environmental protection
* Subsidiarity
* in Catholicism
* Welfare
* State

Philosophers

* Arizmendiarrieta
* Baader
* Barth
* Belloc
* Benedict XV
* Berggrav
* Blond
* Bonhoeffer
* Brague
* Cardijn
* Chesterton
* Day
* Dooyeweerd
* Escrivá
* Gebhardt
* Gilson
* Görres
* Groen
* Guardini
* Habsburg
* John XXIII
* John Paul II
* Ketteler
* De Koninck
* Korfanty
* Lamennais
* Leo XIII
* Lewis
* Manning
* Maritain
* Merton
* Milani
* Mounier
* Müller-Armack
* Murray
* Nell-Breuning
* Newman
* Ozanam
* Paul VI
* Pesch
* Pieper
* Pius XI
* Pottier
* Röpke
* Sheen
* Spaemann
* Stein
* Stomma
* Sturzo
* Tawney
* Tischner
* Toniolo
* Vogelsang
* Weigel
* Williams

Politicians

* Adenauer
* Andreotti
* Antall
* Aznar
* Bayrou
* Beel
* Bidault
* Biden
* Bondevik
* Busch
* Buzek
* Caldera
* Clerides
* Cosgrave
* Daul
* De Gasperi
* Dehaene
* Donnelly
* Dzurinda
* Erhard
* Erzberger
* Fenech Adami
* Field
* Frei
* Gemayel
* Groen
* Haller
* Joseph
* Juncker
* Kaas
* Ketteler
* Klausener
* Kohl
* Komorowski
* Korfanty
* Kramp-Karrenbauer
* Kurz
* Kuyper
* Lacalle Pou
* Laschet
* Letta
* Leuger
* Lipinski
* Lubbers
* Martens
* Mattarella
* Mazowiecki
* Merkel
* Merz
* Metsola
* Mikołajczyk
* Moro
* Nile
* Quadros
* Pastrana
* Peterle
* Pethrus
* Popiel
* Portas
* Pöttering
* Prodi
* Raab
* Schäffer
* Schuman
* Schüssel
* Seipel
* Söder
* Stegerwald
* Stomma
* Strauss
* Sturzo
* Tajani
* Tindemans
* Vogelsang
* von der Leyen
* Wałęsa
* Weber
* Werner
* Windthorst

Parties

* American Solidarity Party
* Austrian People's Party
* Christian Democracy
* Christian Democratic Appeal
* Christian Democratic and Flemish
* Christian Democratic Party
* Christian Democratic Party of Uruguay
* Christian Democratic People's Party
* Christian-Democratic Rebirth Party
* Christian Democratic Union of Germany
* Christian Social People's Party
* Christian Social Union in Bavaria
* Christian Union
* Centre Party
* Centrists for Europe
* Civic Platform
* Croatian Democratic Union
* Democratic Rally
* Democrats
* Fianna Fáil
* Fine Gael
* Kataeb Party
* National Action Party
* National Party
* Nationalist Party
* New Democracy
* Patriotic Union
* People's Party
* Polish People's Party
* Popular Republican Movement
* Prohibition Party
* VMRO-DPMNE

Organizations

* Catholic Action
* Centrist Democrat International
* Christian Democrat Organization of America
* European People's Party
* European Christian Political Party
* Konrad Adenauer Foundation
* Conservative Christian Fellowship
* Centre for European Studies
* European Ideas Network
* Schuman Foundation
* Center for Public Justice
* Paneuropean Union
* World Movement of Christian Workers
* SIPDIC

Documents

* Rerum novarum
* Populorum progressio
* Graves de communi re
* Quadragesimo anno
* Laborem exercens
* Sollicitudo rei socialis
* Centesimus annus
* Laudato si'

Related topics

* Catholic Church and politics
* Christian left
* Christian anarchism
* Christian communism
* Christian socialism
* Christian right
* Christian libertarianism
* Christian nationalism
* Theoconservatism
* Clerical philosophers
* Ethical socialism
* Integralism
* Illiberal democracy
* Progressive Christianity
* Religious democracy
* Buddhist
* Islamic
* Jewish
* Mormon
* Social democracy
* Traditionalist Catholicism

* Christianity portal
* Politics portal

* v
* t
* e

As Christian Democratic political parties were formed, they adopted the Catholic social teaching of subsidiarity, as well as the neo-Calvinist theological teaching of sphere sovereignty, with both Catholics and Protestants agreeing "that the principles of sphere sovereignty and subsidiarity boiled down to the same thing".[11]

The term "subsidiarity" is also used to refer to a tenet of some forms of conservative or libertarian thought in the United States. For example, conservative author Reid Buckley writes:

> Will the American people never learn that, as a principle, to expect swift response and efficiency from government is fatuous? Will we never heed the principle of subsidiarity (in which our fathers were bred), namely that no public agency should do what a private agency can do better, and that no higher-level public agency should attempt to do what a lower-level agency can do better – that to the degree the principle of subsidiarity is violated, first local government, the state government, and then federal government wax in inefficiency? Moreover, the more powers that are invested in government, and the more powers that are wielded by government, the less well does government discharge its primary responsibilities, which are (1) defence of the commonwealth, (2) protection of the rights of citizens, and (3) support of just order.[12]

The United Nations Development Programme's 1999 report on decentralisation noted that subsidiarity was an important principle. It quoted one definition:

> Decentralization, or decentralising governance, refers to the restructuring or reorganisation of authority so that there is a system of co-responsibility between institutions of governance at the central, regional and local levels according to the principle of subsidiarity, thus increasing the overall quality and effectiveness of the system of governance, while increasing the authority and capacities of sub-national levels.[13]

According to Richard Macrory, the positive effects of a political/economic system governed by the principle of subsidiarity include:[14]

* Systemic failures of the type seen in the crash of 2007/08 can largely be avoided, since diverse solutions to common problems avoid common mode failure.
* Individual and group initiative is given maximum scope to solve problems.
* The systemic problem of moral hazard is largely avoided. In particular, the vexing problem of atrophied local initiative/responsibility is avoided.

He writes that the negative effects of a political/economic system governed by the principle of subsidiarity include:

* When a genuine principle of liberty is recognised by a higher political entity but not all subsidiary entities, implementation of that principle can be delayed at the more local level.
* When a genuinely efficacious economic principle is recognised by a higher political entity, but not all subsidiary entities, implementation of that principle can be delayed at the more local level.
* In areas where the local use of common resources has a broad regional, or even global, impact, higher levels of authority may have a natural mandate to supersede local authority.[14]

## General principle of European Union law

[edit]

Main article: Subsidiarity (European Union)

This article is part of a series on

Politics of the European Union

Member states (27)

*  Austria
*  Belgium
*  Bulgaria
*  Croatia
*  Cyprus
*  Czech Republic
*  Denmark
*  Estonia
*  Finland
*  France
*  Germany
*  Greece
*  Hungary
*  Ireland
*  Italy
*  Latvia
*  Lithuania
*  Luxembourg
*  Malta
*  Netherlands
*  Poland
*  Portugal
*  Romania
*  Slovakia
*  Slovenia
*  Spain
*  Sweden

* * *

Candidate countries

* Albania
* Bosnia and Herzegovina
* Georgia
* Moldova
* Montenegro
* North Macedonia
* Serbia
* Ukraine

* * *

Countries with suspended accession negotiations

* Turkey

* * *

Applicant countries

* Kosovo

* * *

States not on the agenda

* Armenia
* Azerbaijan
* Belarus
* Iceland
* Kazakhstan
* Norway
* Russia
* Switzerland
* United Kingdom

* * *

Microstates and the European Union

* Andorra
* Liechtenstein
* Monaco
* San Marino
* Vatican City

* * *

* Special territories
* EU 3 (EU founding states)
* Enlargement of the European Union
* Withdrawal from the European Union

* * *

Treaties and Declarations

* Schuman Declaration (1950)
* Treaty of Paris (1951)
* Europe Declaration (1951)
* Spaak Report (1956)
* Treaty of Rome (1957)
* Euratom Treaty (1957)
* Merger Treaty (1965)
* Solemn Declaration (1983)
* Single European Act (1986)
* Maastricht Treaty (1992)
* Treaty of Amsterdam (1997)
* Treaty of Nice (2001)
* Berlin Declaration (2007)
* Treaty of Lisbon (2007)
* Article 7
* Article 50

* * *

Opt-outs

* * *

Treaties of accession

1972, 1979, 1985, 1994, 2003, 2005, 2011

* * *

Treaties of withdrawal

1984, 2020

* * *

Other treaties

* Schengen Agreement (1985)
* European Economic Area Agreement (1992)

* * *

Abandoned treaties and agreements

* European Constitution (2004)
* UK membership renegotiation (2015–2016)

Executive institutions

European Council

* President: Costa (PES)
* Parties
* List of meetings

* * *

European Commission

* Von der Leyen Commission
* President: Von der Leyen (EPP)
* Vice Presidents
* College of Commissioners
* Civil Service
* Secretary-General:  Juhansone

Legislative institutions

* Legislative procedure

* * *

Council of the EU

Presidency

Denmark

(July–December 2025)

* * *

Configurations

* GAC
* FAC
* ECOFIN
* Eurogroup
* AGRIFISH
* EPSCO
* COMPET
* TTE
* ENVI
* JHA
* EYC

* * *

* Voting
* Secretariat
* Secretary-General: Thérèse Blanchet
* Directorates-general
* Council preparatory bodies
* COREPER
* Council Working Parties

* * *

European Parliament
(Members)

* President: Metsola
* Largest groups
* EPP (Manfred Weber)
* S&D (Iratxe García)
* Member of the European Parliament
* 10th session (2024–2029)
* Bureau
* Vice Presidents
* Quaestor
* Conference

* * *

National parliaments

Judicial institutions

Court of Justice of the EU

* European Court of Justice
* Members
* Advocates General
* Rulings
* General Court

Auditory institutions

European Court of Auditors

* European Court of Auditors

* * *

Other auditory bodies

* Internal Audit Service of the Commission
* Committee on Budgetary Control of the Parliament
* Economic and Financial Affairs configuration of the Council
* Anti-Fraud Office
* Public Prosecutor's Office

European Central Bank

* President Lagarde
* ESCB
* EMU
* Euro banknotes
* Euro coins

Other bodies

European Investment Bank Group

* Investment Bank
* Investment Fund
* EIB Institute

* * *

European Stability Mechanism

* European Stability Mechanism

* * *

European University Institute

* European University Institute

* * *

Unified Patent Court

* Unified Patent Court

* * *

Agencies, decentralised independent bodies and joint undertakings

* Decentralised agencies of the EU
* Single market agencies
* CFSP agencies
* AFSC agencies
* ESFS European Supervisory Authorities
* SRM bodies
* Executive agencies of the EU
* Euratom agencies
* Decentralised independent bodies of the EU
* European Institute of Innovation and Technology
* European Public Prosecutor's Office
* Corporate bodies of the EU
* European Data Protection Board
* Authority for European Political Parties and European Political Foundations
* Joint undertakings
* of the EU
* of the Euratom

* * *

Other independent bodies

* European Data Protection Supervisor
* European Ombudsman

* * *

Advisory bodies

* European Committee of the Regions
* European Economic and Social Committee
* Political and Security Committee
* European Union Military Committee
* EU/ESA Space Council

* * *

Inter-institutional bodies

* Publications Office of the European Union
* European External Action Service
* European Personnel Selection Office
* Anti-Fraud Office
* European Administrative School

Euratom

Euratom members

*  Austria
*  Belgium
*  Bulgaria
*  Croatia
*  Cyprus
*  Czech Republic
*  Denmark
*  Estonia
*  Finland
*  France
*  Germany
*  Greece
*  Hungary
*  Ireland
*  Italy
*  Latvia
*  Lithuania
*  Luxembourg
*  Malta
*  Netherlands
*  Poland
*  Portugal
*  Romania
*  Slovakia
*  Slovenia
*  Spain
*  Sweden

* * *

Associated states

*  Switzerland
*  United Kingdom

* * *

* Nuclear power in the European Union

Euratom since 1 January 2021

Economic and Monetary Union

Eurozone members

* Austria
* Belgium
* Croatia
* Cyprus
* Estonia
* Finland
* France
* Germany
* Greece
* Ireland
* Italy
* Latvia
* Lithuania
* Luxembourg
* Malta
* Netherlands
* Portugal
* Slovakia
* Slovenia
* Spain

* * *

Eurogroup

* President
* Paschal Donohoe

* * *

Other currencies in use

* Bulgarian lev
* Czech koruna
* Danish krone
* Hungarian forint
* Polish złoty
* Romanian leu
* Swedish krona

* * *

* ERM II
* Enlargement of the eurozone

* * *

Non Euro countries relationship to Euro

* Bulgaria
* Czechia
* Denmark
* Hungary
* Poland
* Sweden
* Romania

Eurozone since 2015

Schengen Area

*  Austria
*  Belgium
*  Bulgaria
*  Croatia
*  Czech Republic
*  Denmark
*  Estonia
*  Finland
*  France
*  Germany
*  Greece
*  Hungary
*  Italy
*  Latvia
*  Lithuania
*  Luxembourg
*  Malta
*  Netherlands
*  Poland
*  Portugal
*  Romania
*  Slovakia
*  Slovenia
*  Spain
*  Sweden

* * *

Non-EU members

*  Iceland
*  Liechtenstein
*  Norway
*  Switzerland

* * *

Non-Schengen area EU member states

*  Cyprus
*  Ireland (Opt-out)

* * *

* ETIAS
* Prüm Convention
* Schengen Information System
* Visa Information System
* Visa policy of the Schengen Area

Schengen Area from January 2023

European Economic Area

EEA members

* Austria
* Belgium
* Bulgaria
* Croatia
* Cyprus
* Czech Republic
* Denmark
* Estonia
* Finland
* France
* Germany
* Greece
* Hungary
* Ireland
* Italy
* Latvia
* Lithuania
* Luxembourg
* Malta
* Netherlands
* Poland
* Portugal
* Romania
* Slovakia
* Slovenia
* Spain
* Sweden

* * *

Non-EU members

*  Iceland
*  Liechtenstein
*  Norway

* * *

Topics

* EEA Joint Committee
* EEA National Identity cards
* Microstates and the European Union

European Economic Area

Elections

* Elections to the European Parliament
* European parties
* European foundations
* Political groups of the European Parliament
* Spitzenkandidat
* Constituencies
* Apportionment
* Referendums related to the EU

* * *

European elections

* 1979
* 1984
* 1989
* 1994
* 1999
* 2004
* 2009
* 2014
* 2019
* 2024 (latest election)

* * *

Elections in EU member states

* Austria
* Belgium
* Bulgaria
* Croatia
* Cyprus
* Czech Republic
* Denmark
* Estonia
* Finland
* France
* Germany
* Greece
* Hungary
* Ireland
* Italy
* Latvia
* Lithuania
* Luxembourg
* Malta
* Netherlands
* Poland
* Portugal
* Romania
* Slovakia
* Slovenia
* Spain
* Sweden

Law

* Acquis
* Conferral
* Primacy (ECJ Case 6/64)
* Subsidiarity
* Regulation
* Democratic legitimacy
* Directive
* Decision
* Recommendation
* Fundamental Rights

Policies and issues

* Budget
* Customs Union
* Free Trade Agreements
* European Single Market
* Area of FS&J
* Policies
* Agricultural
* Energy
* Fisheries
* Regional
* Citizenship
* Passports of the European Union
* Identity
* Pro-Europeanism
* Euroscepticism
* European banking union
* European Banking Supervision
* Single Resolution Mechanism
* Capital Markets Union
* European System of Financial Supervision
* Institutional seats of the European Union
* Integration
* Supranationalism
* European Federation
* Multi-speed Europe
* Enhanced cooperation

Foreign relations

High Representative

* Kaja Kallas

* * *

* Ext. Action Service
* Foreign Policy
* Defence Policy

* * *

Foreign relations of EU member states

* Austria
* Belgium
* Bulgaria
* Croatia
* Cyprus
* Czech Republic
* Denmark
* Estonia
* Finland
* France
* Germany
* Greece
* Hungary
* Ireland
* Italy
* Latvia
* Lithuania
* Luxembourg
* Malta
* Netherlands
* Poland
* Portugal
* Romania
* Slovakia
* Slovenia
* Spain
* Sweden

* * *

* Argentina–European Union relations
* Armenia–European Union relations
* Australia–European Union relations
* Brazil–European Union relations
* Canada–European Union relations
* China–European Union relations
* European Union–NATO relations
* Georgia–European Union relations
* Iceland–European Union relations
* Iran–European Union relations
* Israel–European Union relations
* Japan–European Union relations
* Kazakhstan–European Union relations
* Mexico–European Union relations
* Moldova–European Union relations
* Norway–European Union relations
* Russia–European Union relations
* Switzerland–European Union relations
* Turkey–European Union relations
* Ukraine–European Union relations
* United Kingdom–European Union relations (History)
* Post-Brexit United Kingdom relations with the European Union
* Brexit
* United States–European Union relations

* * *

* Common Travel Area (Ireland)
* Microstates and the European Union
* European Union and the United Nations
* European Union Association Agreement
* European Neighbourhood Policy
* Eastern Partnership
* Euronest Parliamentary Assembly

* * *

* G7
* G20

Defunct bodies

* European Communities (1958–1993)

European Coal and Steel Community
European Economic Community
* European Community
* Western European Union
* Convention on the Future of Europe

European Union portal

* Other countries

* v
* t
* e

English Wikisource has original text related to this article:

Protocol on the Application of Principles of Subsidiarity and Proportionality

Subsidiarity is perhaps presently best known as a general principle of European Union law. According to this principle, the Union may only act (i.e. make laws) collectively where independent action of individual countries is insufficient without equal action by other members. The principle was established in the 1992 Treaty of Maastricht.[15] However, at the local level it was already a key element of the European Charter of Local Self-Government, an instrument of the Council of Europe promulgated in 1985 (see Article 4, Paragraph 3 of the Charter) (which states that the exercise of public responsibilities should be decentralised). Subsidiarity is related in essence to, but should not be confused with, the concept of a margin of appreciation.

Subsidiarity was established in EU law by the Treaty of Maastricht, which was signed on 7 February 1992 and entered into force on 1 November 1993. The present formulation is contained in Article 5(3) of the Treaty on European Union (consolidated version following the Treaty of Lisbon, which entered into force on 1 December 2009):

> Under the principle of subsidiarity, in areas which do not fall within its exclusive competence, the Union shall act only if and in so far as the objectives of the proposed action cannot be sufficiently achieved by the Member States, either at central level or at regional and local level, but can rather, by reason of the scale or effects of the proposed action, be better achieved at Union level.

The national parliaments of EU member states have an "early warning mechanism" whereby if one third raise an objection – a "yellow card" – on the basis that the principle of subsidiarity has been violated, then the proposal must be reviewed. If a majority do so – an "orange card" – then the council or parliament can vote it down immediately. If the logistical problems of putting this into practice are overcome, then the power of the national parliaments could be deemed an extra legislature, without a common debate or physical location: dubbed by EUObserver a "virtual third chamber".[16]

A more descriptive analysis of the principle can be found in Protocol 2 to the European Treaties.[17]

### Court of Justice

[edit]

The Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg is the authority that has to decide whether a regulation falls within the exclusive competence[a] of the Union, as defined by the Treaty on European Union and its predecessors. As the concept of subsidiarity has a political as well as a legal dimension, the Court of Justice has a reserved attitude toward judging whether EU legislation is consistent with the concept. The Court will examine only marginally whether the principle is fulfilled. A detailed explanation of the legislation is not required; it is enough that the EU institutions explain why national legislation seems inadequate and that Union law has an added value.

An example is the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union in a legal action taken by the Federal Republic of Germany against the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union concerning a Directive on deposit guarantee schemes (13 May 1997). Germany argued that the Directive did not explain how it was compatible with the principle of subsidiarity. The Court answered:

> In the present case, the Parliament and the Council stated in the second recital in the preamble to the Directive that "consideration should be given to the situation which might arise if deposits in a credit institution that has branches in other Member States became unavailable" and that it was "indispensable to ensure a harmonised minimum level of deposit protection wherever deposits are located in the Community". This shows that, in the Community legislature's view, the aim of its action could, because of the dimensions of the intended action, be best achieved at Community level....

> Furthermore, in the fifth recital the Parliament and the Council stated that the action taken by the Member States in response to the Commission's Recommendation has not fully achieved the desired result. The Community legislature therefore found that the objective of its action could not be achieved sufficiently by the Member States.

> Consequently, it is apparent that, on any view, the Parliament and the Council did explain why they considered that their action was in conformity with the principle of subsidiarity and, accordingly, that they complied with the obligation to give reasons as required under Article 190 of the Treaty. An express reference to that principle cannot be required.

> On those grounds, the plea of infringement of the obligation to state reasons is unfounded in fact and must therefore be rejected. (Case C-233/94[18])

## See also

[edit]

* Anti-Federalism – 1780s political movement in the U.S.Pages displaying short descriptions of redirect targets
* Cellular democracy
* Decentralization – Organizational theory
* Devolution – Granting of some competences of central government to local government
* Distributism – Economic theory promoting local control
* Federalism – Political concept
* Foundation for subsidiarity – Italian cultural organizationPages displaying short descriptions of redirect targets
* Grassroots democracy – Type that favors individual activism
* Local government – Lowest in the administration pyramid
* Localism (politics) – Political philosophy
* Margin of appreciation – Doctrine in international human rights law
* Parochialism – Focus on small sections of an issue
* Primary and secondary legislation – Two forms of law in democracies
* Principle of conferral – EU acts at the behest of its members
* Public choice – Economic theory applied to political science
* Oswald von Nell-Breuning – German Catholic theologian
* Staatenverbund – Potent union of sovereign states
* States' rights – Political powers reserved for U.S. states
* Urban secession – City becomes independent political unit

## References

[edit]

1. ^ "subsidiarity". Oxford English Dictionary. Archived from the original on 10 April 2019. "[mass noun] (in politics) the principle that a central authority should have a subsidiary function, performing only those tasks which cannot be performed at a more local level"
2. ^ Early German usage: Subsidiarität(1809 or earlier in legal use; 1931 in the context of Catholic social doctrine, in §80 of Rundschreiben über die gesellschaftliche Ordnung ("Encyclical concerning the societal order"), the German version of Pope Pius XI's encyclical Quadragesimo anno (1931))".
3. ^ a b Behr, Thomas. Social Justice and Subsidiarity: Luigi Taparelli and the Origins of Modern Catholic Social Thought (Washington DC: Catholic University of American Press, December 2019).
4. ^ Behr, Thomas. Social Justice and Subsidiarity: Luigi Taparelli and the Origins of Modern Catholic Social Thought (Washington DC: Catholic University of American Press, December 2019). See in particular the Appendix, Taparelli's "Treatise on Subsidiarity" translated in this work.
5. ^ Endo, Ken (31 May 1994). "The Principle of Subsidiarity: From Johannes Althusius to Jacques Delors". 北大法学論集. 44 (6): 652-553. "It is reasonable however to also identify Althusius as the first proponent of subsidiarity and federalism (he uses, in fact, the word "subsidia" in the text). He was a Calvinist theoretician of the laical State at the beginning of the 17th century."
6. ^ Frederik H. Kistenkas (1 January 2000). "European and domestic subsidiarity. An Althusian conceptionalist view". Tilburg Law Review. 8 (3): 247–254\. doi:10.1163/221125900X00044. Archived from the original on 9 December 2019. Retrieved 9 December 2019.
7. ^ "Das Subsidiaritätsprinzip als wirtschaftliches Ordnungsprinzip", Wirtschaftliche Entwicklung und soziale Ordnung. Degenfeld-Festschrift, Vienna: von Lagler and J. Messner, 1952, pp. 81–92, cited in Helmut Zenz, DE, archived from the original on 31 October 2007, retrieved 9 November 2009.
8. ^ "Supremacy Clause". LII / Legal Information Institute. Archived from the original on 1 February 2018. Retrieved 10 September 2021.
9. ^ Schmidt, Vivien A (23 March 2007), Democratizing France: The Political and Administrative History of Decentralization, Cambridge University Press, p. 10, ISBN 978-0-52103605-4.
10. ^ A History of Decentralization Archived 11 May 2013 at the Wayback Machine, Earth Institute of Columbia University, retrieved 4 February 2013
11. ^ Segell, Glen (2000). Is There a Third Way?. Glen Segell Publishers. p. 80\. ISBN 978-1-90141418-9. "When the Dutch Protestant and Catholic parties combined, to form the Christian Democrats, the two parties agreed that the principles of sphere sovereignty and subsidiarity boiled down to the same thing."
12. ^ Reid Buckley, An American Family – The Buckleys, Simon & Schuster, 2008, p. 177.
13. ^ Decentralization: A Sampling of Definitions Archived 12 May 2013 at the Wayback Machine, Joint UNDP (United Nations Development Programme)-Government of Germany evaluation of the UNDP role in decentralization and local governance, the United Nations Development Programme, October 1999, pp. 2, 16, 26.
14. ^ a b Macrory, Richard, 2008, Regulation, Enforcement and Governance in Environmental Law, Cameron May, London, p. 657.
15. ^ Shelton, Dinah (2003). "The Boundaries of Human Rights Jurisdiction in Europe". Duke Journal of Comparative and International Law. 13 (1). Duke University School of Law: 95–154\. Archived from the original on 20 June 2017. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
16. ^ Cooper, Ian (16 October 2009) Comment: Will national parliaments use their new powers? Archived 25 October 2009 at the Wayback Machine, EUObserver
17. ^ Protocol 2 to the European Treaties Archived 6 August 2010 at the Wayback Machine.
18. ^ "Judgment Of The Court in Case C-233/94". Archived from the original on 11 May 2013. Retrieved 27 December 2011.

## Notes

[edit]

1. ^ Exclusive competencies are those matters that the member states have agreed with each other by treaty are those that they should achieve jointly (typically through the European Commission). All other matters remain as "national competences" (each member decides its own policy independently). International trade agreements are an example of the former, taxation is an example of the latter.

## External links

[edit]

Look up subsidiarity in Wiktionary, the free dictionary.

* Treaty establishing the European Community
* The Assembly of European Regions' Subsidiarity is a word movement, demanding recognition in dictionaries worldwide
* "Subsidiaritaet" in the Lexikon der sozialoekologischen Marktwirtschaft

* v
* t
* e

Autonomous types of first-tier subdivision administration

Federalism|

* Asymmetric federalism
* Confederation
* Cooperative federalism
* Corporative federalism
* Dual federalism
* Ethnic federalism
* Federacy
* Federal monarchy
* Federal republic
* Federated state
* Federation
* Fiscal federalism
* Symmetric federalism
* List of federal countries

Unitary state|

* Devolution
* Regional state

Unions|

* Composite monarchy
* Dual monarchy
* Dynastic union
* Empire
* Colonial empire
* Multinational state
* Personal union
* Political union
* Real union
* Superstate
* Supranational union
* Continental union

Subordinacy|

* Associated state
* Client state
* Colony
* Dependent territory
* Direct rule
* Dominion
* Indirect rule
* Mandate
* Protectorate
* Puppet state
* Satellite state
* Trusteeship
* Tributary state
* Vassal state

Development|

* Annexation
* Cession
* Detachment
* Irredentism
* Military occupation
* Partition
* Secession
* Separatism
* Territorial dispute

See also|

* Autonomy
* Autonomous area
* Decentralization
* Hegemony
* Home rule
* Stateless nation
* Subsidiarity
* Suzerainty
* Tribal sovereignty

* v
* t
* e

Conservatism

Schools
by region|

| International|

* Authoritarian
* Corporatist
* Cultural
* Fiscal
* Green
* Liberal
* Moderate
* National
* Paternalistic
* Populist
* Pragmatic
* Progressive
* Reactionary
* Religious
* Social
* Traditionalist
* Ultra

|

Asia|

| China|

* Chiangism
* Confucianism
* Neo
* New
* Dai Jitao Thought
* Neoauthoritarianism

|

Iran|

* Khomeinism
* Monarchist
* Principlist

Israel|

* Fundamentalist
* Jewish
* Kahanism
* Zionism
* Neo
* Religious
* Revisionist

Japan|

* Minzoku
* Neo
* Nippon Kaigi
* Shōwa Statism
* State Shinto

South Korea|

* Ilminism
* New Right

Turkey|

* Democratic
* Erdoğanism
* Neo-Ottomanism

Other|

* Bangladesh
* Hong Kong
* India
* Malaysia
* Pakistan
* Ziaism
* Singapore
* Taiwan
* Chiangism

Europe|

| France|

* Action Française
* Bonapartism
* Gaullism
* Integral nationalism
* Legitimism
* Maurrassisme
* Nouvelle Droite
* Orléanism
* Révolution nationale
* Sarkozysm
* Ultra-royalism

|

Germany|

* Agrarian
* Hegelian
* Historical School
* Neue Rechte
* Ordoliberalism
* Prussianism
* Cameralistic
* Socialist
* Revolutionary
* Young
* Ritter School
* Romanticism
* State Socialism
* Völkisch

Italy|

* Berlusconism
* Historical Right
* Italian school of elitism
* Neo-Bourbonism
* Sanfedismo

Poland|

* Golden Liberty
* Kaczyzm
* Monarchist
* National Democracy
* Sarmatism

Russia|

* Duginism
* Eurasianism
* Monarchist
* Black-hundredism
* Tsarism
* Putinism
* Slavophilia
* Pochvennichestvo

Spain|

* Alfonsism
* Carlism
* Carloctavismo
* Carlo-francoism
* Francoism
* National Catholicism
* Integrism
* Mellismo
* Maurism
* Neocatholicism
* Noucentisme

United
Kingdom|

* Cameronism
* Civic
* Compassionate
* Muscular liberalism
* Jacobitism
* Neo-Jacobite Revival
* Neo
* One-nationism
* Powellism
* Thatcherism
* Toryism
* High
* Red
* Social

Other|

* Austria
* Belgium
* Rexism
* Denmark
* Finland
* Georgia
* Monarchist
* Greece
* Metaxism
* Populist
* Hungary
* Iceland
* Luxembourg
* Netherlands
* Norway
* Portugal
* Miguelist
* Integralismo Lusitano
* Romania
* Monarchist
* Serbia
* Monarchist
* Sweden
* Switzerland
* Ukraine

Latin America|

| Argentina|

* Federal Peronism
* Maurrasismo
* Menemism
* Nacionalismo
* Orthodox Peronism

|

Brazil|

* Bolsonarism
* Coronelism
* Integralism
* Janismo
* Monarchist
* Patrianovism
* Populism

Chile|

* Gremialismo
* Pinochetism

Other|

* Belize
* Colombia
* Rojismo
* Uribism
* Cuba
* Guatemala
* Mexico
* Cristero
* Panama
* Peru
* Fujimorism
*  Odriismo
* Uruguay
* Herrerism
* Riverism
* Ruralismo
* Venezuela
* Perezjimenismo

North America|

| Canada|

* Populism
* Trumpism
* Clerico-nationalism
* Social
* Toryism
* Blue
* Red
* Pink

|

United
States|

* Compassionate
* Libertarian
* Fusionism
* Paleo
* Tea Party
* Movement
* Neo
* Old Right
* Paleo
* Reaganism
* Social
* Traditionalist
* Trumpism

Oceania|

* Australia
* Centre Right
* National Right
* New Zealand

Philosophy|

| Principles|

* Ancestral worship
* Authority
* Traditional
* Class collaboration
* Consociationalism
* Clericalism
* Collective identity
* Confessionalism
* Cultural assimilation
* Cultural heritage
* Cultural values
* Culture of life
* Pro-Life
* Discipline
* Duty
* Elitism
* Aristocracy
* Meritocracy
* Noblesse oblige
* Ethical order
* Familialism
* Family values
* Fundamentalism
* Gender role
* Complementarianism
* Honour
* Imperialism
* Loyalty
* Monarchism
* Royalist
* Natural law
* Natural Order
* Norms
* Conventions
* Customs
* Mores
* Ordered liberty
* Organicism
* Organized religion
* Orthodoxy
* Patriotism
* Nationalism
* Personalism
* Philosophical realism
* Moral realism
* Private property
* Protectionism
* Public morality
* Rule of law
* Social hierarchy
* Social institutions
* Social order
* Solidarity
* Sovereignty
* State religion
* Stewardship
* Subsidiarity
* Tradition

|

Intellectuals|

* Bainville
* Barruel
* Belloc
* Bonald
* Buckley Jr.
* Burke
* Burnham
* Carlyle
* Chateaubriand
* Chesterton
* Coleridge
* Comte
* Cortés
* Dávila
* Dostoevsky
* Eliot
* Evola
* Fardid
* Gentz
* Haller
* Hitchens
* Hume
* Iorga
* Johnson
* Jünger
* Karamzin
* Kirk
* Kuehnelt-Leddihn
* La Mennais
* Le Bon
* Le Play
* Leontiev
* Lewis
* Maistre
* Mansfield
* Maurras
* Menéndez
* More
* Müller
* Newman
* Nisbet
* Novalis
* Oakeshott
* Corrêa de Oliveira
* Peterson
* Ranke
* Renan
* Rivarol
* Röpke
* Santayana
* Savigny
* Schlegel
* Schmitt
* Scruton
* Solzhenitsyn
* Sowell
* Spann
* Spengler
* Stahl
* Strauss
* Taine
* Tocqueville
* Uvarov
* Voegelin

Politics|

| Organisations|

* European Conservatives and Reformists Party
* European People's Party
* Identity and Democracy
* International Democrat Union
* International Monarchist League
* Muslim Brotherhood
* Tradition, Family, Property

|

Politicians|

* Abe
* Adams
* Adenauer
* Andreotti
* Berlusconi
* Bismarck
* Bolsonaro
* GW Bush
* Canning
* Chiang
* Churchill
* Diefenbaker
* Disraeli
* Dmowski
* Dollfuss
* Erdoğan
* Franco
* Fujimori
* de Gaulle
* Harper
* Horthy
* John Paul II
* Kaczyński
* Khamenei
* Khomeini
* Kohl
* Le Pen
* Lee
* Macdonald
* Mannerheim
* Marcos
* Maurras
* Menzies
* Metaxas
* Metternich
* Mobutu
* Modi
* Netanyahu
* Orbán
* Park
* Pérez Jiménez
* Pinochet
* Pitt
* Powell
* Prat de la Riba
* Putin
* Reagan
* Salazar
* Salisbury
* Smith
* Stolypin
* Suharto
* Thatcher
* Trujillo
* Trump
* Vajpayee
* de Valera
* Zia
* Zemmour

Religion|

* Christian democracy
* Christian politics
* Theonomy
* Christian right
* Theoconservatism
* Confucianism
* Hindutva
* Jewish conservatism
* Religious Zionism
* Islamism
* Islamic economics
* Theravada
* Buddhist economics
* Traditionalist Catholicism
* Catholic social teaching
* Distributism
* Integralism
* Ultramontanism
* Traditionalist School

Historical
background|

* Ancien régime
* Bourbon Restauration
* Congress of Vienna
* Concert of Europe
* Conservative Order
* Counter-Enlightenment
* German Romanticism
* Holy Alliance
* Ultra-royalism

Related|

| Ideologies|

* Agrarianism
* Clerical fascism
* Communitarianism
* Conservative liberalism
* Corporatism
* Localism

|

* Anti-communism
* Anti-gender movement
* Anti-Masonry
* Aristocracy
* Black conservatism
* United States
* Desecularization
* Postsecularism
* Conservative feminism
* Conservative wave
* Counter-revolutionary
* Elite theory
* Ethnopluralism
* Hispanic and Latino conservatism in the United States
* LGBTQ conservatism
* Neo-feudalism
* Neo-medievalism
* Opposition to LGBTQ rights
* Para-fascism
* Political Evangelicalism in Latin America
* Political theology
* Radical right
* Europe
* United States
* Reactionary
* Neo-
* Right realism
* Right-wing politics
* Authoritarianism
* New
* European
* Small-c conservatives

* Conservatism portal
* Politics portal

* v
* t
* e

Judiciary and law of the European Union

Judiciary|

* Court of Justice of the European Union
* European Court of Justice
* members
* Advocates General
* General Court
* Civil Service Tribunal
* European lawyer
* Relationship with ECHR
* Public Prosecutor
* European civil code

Treaties|

* Rome Treaty
* Merger Treaty
* Single European Act
* Maastricht Treaty
* Amsterdam Treaty
* Nice Treaty
* Lisbon Treaty
* Charter of Fundamental Rights
* Opt-outs

Acts|

* Acquis: Regulation
* Directive
* Framework Directive
* Decision
* Recommendation
* Digital Services Act

Procedures|

* Ordinary legislative procedure
* Consultation procedure
* Consent procedure
* Commission and Council acting alone
* Commission acting alone

Principles
and terms

* Acquis communautaire
* EUR-Lex
* Direct applicability
* Direct effect
* European labour law
* European Enforcement Order
* Gold-plating
* Four freedoms
* Home state regulation
* Indirect effect
* Incidental effect
* Minimum harmonisation
* Maximum harmonisation
* Preliminary ruling
* Precautionary principle
* Principle of legal certainty
* Recasting
* Principle of conferral
* Proportionality
* Staatenverbund
* State liability
* Subsidiarity
* Supremacy

Regulations|

* Council Regulation (EC) No. 1206/2001
* Council Regulation (EC) No. 1348/2000
* Customs Regulation 1383/2003
* Regulation (EC) No 261/2004
* EU-Eco-regulation
* Commission Regulation (EC) No. 2257/94
* Commission Regulation (EU) No. 1170/2011
* Customs Regulation 3295/94
* Regulation on roaming charges
* Brussels Regime
* CLP Regulation
* Regulation on Community designs
* Societas Europaea
* European Union System for the Evaluation of Substances
* Commission Regulation (EC) No 474/2006
* REACH
* Rome II Regulation
* Rule of Law Conditionality Regulation

Directives|

* Good Clinical Practice Directive
* Data Protection Directive
* ATEX directive
* Battery Directive
* Best available technology
* Biocidal Products Directive
* Birds Directive
* Capital Requirements Directives
* Clinical Trials Directive
* Computer Programs Directive
* Conditional Access Directive
* Copyright Duration Directive (93/98/EEC)
* Copyright Term Directive (2006/116/EC)
* Cosmetics Directive
* Dangerous Substances Directive (67/548/EEC)
* Dangerous Preparations Directive
* Data Retention Directive
* Database Directive
* Database right
* Directive 2000/43/EC on Anti-discrimination
* Directive establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation
* Information Society Directive (first Copyright directive)
* Directive on Privacy and Electronic Communications
* Directive on the Promotion of the use of biofuels and other renewable fuels for transport
* Directive on the re-use of public sector information
* Directive on Electricity Production from Renewable Energy Sources
* End of Life Vehicles Directive
* CHP Directive
* Directive on the energy performance of buildings
* Directive on the enforcement of intellectual property rights
* Directive 2004/38/EC on the right to move and reside freely
* Environmental liability directive
* European SEA Directive 2001/42/EC
* European units of measurement directives
* Habitats Directive
* Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control
* Internal Market in Electricity Directive
* Landfill Directive
* Directive on the legal protection of biotechnological inventions
* Directive on the legal protection of designs
* Markets in Financial Instruments Directive
* Measuring Instruments Directive
* Medical Devices Directive
* Posted Workers Directive
* Pressure Equipment Directive
* Rental Directive
* Resale Rights Directive
* Restriction of Hazardous Substances Directive
* Satellite and Cable Directive
* Directive on services in the internal market
* Temporary and Agency Work Directive
* Trade Marks Directive
* European Directive on Traditional Herbal Medicinal Products
* Unfair Commercial Practices Directive
* Universal Service Directive
* Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive
* Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Directive
* Waste Incineration Directive
* Waste framework directive
* Water Framework Directive
* Working Time Directive

Cases|

* ECJ Rulings (Caselex): Allonby v Accrington and Rossendale College
* Apostolides v Orams
* Bosman
* Cassis de Dijon
* Chacón Navas v Eurest Colectividades SA
* Chen
* Ciarán Tobin
* Coleman v Attridge Law
* Costa v ENEL
* Factortame
* Francovich
* Kamer van Koophandel en Fabrieken voor Amsterdam v Inspire Art Ltd
* Kolpak
* Microsoft Corp. v. Commission
* Marleasing SA v La Comercial Internacional de Alimentacion SA
* Metock
* Nordsee
* Palacios de la Villa v Cortefiel Servicios SA
* Peter Paul and Others v Bundesrepublik Deutschland
* Procureur du Roi v Dassonville
* Ralf Sieckmann v Deutsches Patent und Markenamt
* Tanja Kreil
* Van Duyn v Home Office
* Van Gend en Loos

Fraud|

* Court of Auditors
* European Anti-Fraud Office
* Accountability in the European Union

* European Union portal
* Law portal

Authority control databases

National|

* Germany
* United States
* Czech Republic
* Israel

Other|

* Historical Dictionary of Switzerland
* Yale LUX

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template