The Dead Christ with Angels

1864 oil painting by Édouard Manet

Le Christ mort et les anges

English: The Dead Christ with Angels
Artist| Édouard Manet
Year| 1864
Medium| Oil on canvas
Dimensions| 179.4 cm × 149.9 cm (70 5/8 in × 59 in)
Location| Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

The Dead Christ with Angels is an 1864 oil painting by French painter Édouard Manet. The painting depicts the biblical story (John 20:12) of Mary Magdalene entering the tomb of Jesus and seeing two angels but finding Jesus's body missing.[1][2] It is now in the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City.

Manet seldom chose to paint images with religious meaning, and he tended to focus on contemporary subjects. John Hunisak speculates that Manet may have wanted to display a religious work in the 1864 Salon because of the negative reaction he had received for his recent paintings of modern subjects.[3] Manet may have hoped, Hunisak suggests, that the more traditional topic, with a contemporary twist, would please his supporters and critics alike.

## Description

[edit]

This work sparked controversy and confusion among viewers due to certain stylistic choices Manet made in representing the story.

Most notably, Manet shows the two angels with the body of the dead Christ still visible.[4] The Bible verses referenced describe the angels dressed in white, however Manet's choice was to depict them dressed in bright red and orange colors. Vladimir Gurewich suggests that this decision was most likely meant to heighten the drama of the scene.[4]

A stone in the lower right section of the painting is inscribed with the chapter in the Gospel of John that the work is based upon. The direct verse reference is debated due to the style that the lowercase v is written in: it either refers to the Roman numeral V, or as an abbreviation for vers ("verse").[2] Depending on this interpretation, the painting is a depiction of either John 20:5-12 or John 20:12.[citation needed]

Jesus's spear wound is also shown on the wrong side of his body, which Manet realized only after he had submitted the painting to the Salon.[2] Art historians have drawn attention to the shifted wound as a mirrored image of Christ, however historical accounts note that this change was completely unintentional on the artist's part.[5] Therefore, the reading of the wound as a deeper, "mirrored" meaning is merely speculative interpretation.

## Critical reaction

[edit]

Critics and many of Manet's supporters were confused by the new artistic direction that he took in the painting. The contradictions within The Dead Christ with Angels are characteristic of Manet's earlier exploration of discordances: the brightly colored angels contrast with the neutral background; the angels are not aligned; and the cloth is variously realistic and abstract.[3]: 271 The technique used to paint Jesus, most notably the blurring seen in his hand and feet, also shows movement typical of Manet's work.[3] Despite the similarities in technique, the scene attracted attention due to its lack of alignment with Manet's previous works.[citation needed]

The Dead Christ with Angels (1866-1867), copperplate etching and aquatint. Art Institute of Chicago. The Dead Christ with Angels (1866–1867), etching and aquatint. Cleveland Museum of Art

## Related works

[edit]

In 1866 or 1867 Manet produced an etching with aquatint of the painting. Impressions are in many collections, including the Art Institute of Chicago and the Cleveland Museum of Art.

The Dead Christ with Angels is often associated with the book Vie de Jésus by Ernest Renan, published in 1863, a year before Manet's painting was first exhibited. In the book, Renan denies Christ's resurrection from the dead, and emphasizes the idea that miracles do not exist.[6] Renan's work is credited as a potential influence for Manet because the inscribed verse, John 20:12, served as the book's main argument in the denial of Christ's resurrection. The painting also shows the angels grieving over death instead of happily announcing a resurrection, which is often used as proof to demonstrate the artistic influence Renan had on Manet.[6]

## See also

[edit]

* List of paintings by Édouard Manet
* 1864 in art

## References

[edit]

1. ^ "MoMA.org | Interactives | Exhibitions | 2006 | Manet and the Execution of Maximilian | The Dead Christ". www.moma.org. Retrieved 2019-08-28.
2. ^ a b c Sheppard, Jennifer M. (1981-01-01). "The Inscription in Manet's "The Dead Christ, with Angels"". Metropolitan Museum Journal. 16: 199–200. doi:10.2307/1512778. ISSN 0077-8958. JSTOR 1512778. S2CID 192998653.
3. ^ a b c Hunisak, John (2015-09-01), "Manet's Dead Christ with Angels", Engaging the Passion, 1517 Media, pp. 267–276, doi:10.2307/j.ctt13wwwjn.23, retrieved 2022-11-21
4. ^ a b Gurewich, Vladimir (1957). "Observations on the Iconography of the Wound in Christ's Side, with Special Reference to Its Position". Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes. 20 (3/4): 358–362. doi:10.2307/750787. ISSN 0075-4390. JSTOR 750787. S2CID 192284546.
5. ^ Rubin, James Henry (1994). Manet's Silence and the Poetics of Bouquets. Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0-674-54802-2.
6. ^ a b Sheppard, Jennifer M. (1981). "The Inscription in Manet's "The Dead Christ, with Angels"". Metropolitan Museum Journal. 16: 199–200. doi:10.2307/1512778. ISSN 0077-8958. JSTOR 1512778. S2CID 192998653.

* v
* t
* e

Édouard Manet

Paintings|

* List of paintings
* The Barque of Dante (1854–1858)
* Christ the Gardener (1856–1859)
* The Absinthe Drinker (1859)
* Spanish Cavaliers (1859)
* Portrait of Madame Brunet (1860)
* Portrait of Monsieur and Madame Manet (1860)
* The Spanish Singer (1860)
* Boy Carrying a Sword (1861)
* La Nymphe surprise (1861)
* The Street Singer (1862)
* Music in the Tuileries (1862)
* The Old Musician (1862)
* Portrait of Victorine Meurent (1862)
* Mademoiselle V. in the Costume of an Espada (1862)
* Little Lange (1862)
* The Luncheon on the Grass (1863)
* La Négresse (1863)
* Olympia (1863)
* Young Man Dressed as a Majo (1863)
* The Dead Man (1864))
* The Bullfight (1864–65)
* The Dead Christ with Angels (1864)
* The Kearsarge at Boulogne (1864)
* The Battle of the Kearsarge and the Alabama (1864)
* The Races at Longchamp (1865)
* Jesus Insulted by the Soldiers (1865)
* Bullfight (1865–66)
* Bullfight – Death of the Bull (1865)
* The Matador Saluting (1866)
* The Fifer (1866)
* A Young Lady in 1866 (1866)
* The Execution of Emperor Maximilian (1867)
* Portrait of Emile Zola (1868)
* Boy Blowing Bubbles (1868)
* Madame Manet at the Piano (1867–68)
* The Balcony (1868)
* Luncheon in the Studio (1868)
* The Reading (1868)
* The Port of Boulogne by Moonlight (1868)
* Departure of the Folkestone Steamer (1869)
* The Brioche (1870)
* Repose (1870)
* The Funeral (1870)
* Effect of Snow on Petit-Montrouge (1870)
* Berthe Morisot with a Bouquet of Violets (1872)
* Tarring a Boat (1873)
* The Railway (1873)
* The Croquet Game (1873)
* Masked Ball at the Opera House (1873)
* Argenteuil (1874)
* Berthe Morisot with a Fan (1874)
* Claude Monet Painting in his Studio (1874)
* Boating (1874)
* Portrait of Marguerite de Conflans (c. 1876)
* Portrait of Stéphane Mallarmé (1876)
* Le Suicidé (1877–1881)
* Nana (1877)
* Plum Brandy (c. 1877)
* The Rue Mosnier Dressed with Flags (1878)
* Blonde Woman with Bare Breasts (c. 1878)
* Chez Tortoni (c. 1878–1880)
* Georges Clemenceau (Fort Worth) (1879)
* Georges Clemenceau (Paris) (1879)
* Chez le Père Lathuille (1879)
* Portrait of Marguerite Gauthier-Lathuille (1879)
* In the Conservatory (1879)
* Madame Manet in the Conservatory (1879)
* The Waitress (1879)
* Corner of a Café-Concert (1879)
* The Café-Concert (1879)
* Self-Portrait with Palette (1879)
* A Bundle of Asparagus (1880)
* A Sprig of Asparagus (1880)
* Portrait of Countess Albazzi (1880)
* Portrait of Monsieur Pertuiset the Lion-Hunter (1881)
* Dead Eagle Owl (1881)
* The Rabbit (1881)
* Rochefort's Escape (1881)
* Spring (1881)
* Autumn (1882)
* A Bar at the Folies-Bergère (1882)
* The House at Rueil (1882)
* Flowers in a Crystal Vase (1882)
* White Lilacs in a Glass Vase (1882)

Models|

* Méry Laurent
* Victorine Meurent
* Laure
* Suzanne Manet (wife)
* Berthe Morisot

Portrayals|

* A Studio at Les Batignolles (1870 painting)
* Bazille's Studio (1870 painting)
* The Impressionists (2006 series)

Related|

* Eugène Manet (brother)

* v
* t
* e

Metropolitan Museum of Art

Places|

| The Met Fifth Avenue|

* Anna Wintour Costume Center
* Astor Court
* Robert Goldwater Library
* Temple of Dendur
* Thomas J. Watson Library

|

Other sites|

* The Cloisters
* Met Breuer

Directors|

* Luigi Palma di Cesnola
* Caspar Purdon Clarke
* Edward Robinson
* Herbert Eustis Winlock
* Francis Henry Taylor
* James Rorimer
* Thomas Hoving
* Philippe de Montebello
* Thomas P. Campbell

Miscellaneous|

* Met Gala
* Museum Mile
* Metropolitan Museum of Art Guide

Antiquities|

* Amathus sarcophagus
* Bajaur casket
* Burke Jizō
* Pratt Ivories
* Coffin of Nedjemankh
* Cesnola Sphinx Funerary Stele
* Dipylon krater
* Magdeburg Ivories
* Armenian Gospel with Silver Cover
* Calligraphic Galleon
* Carp and Pine
* Chair of Reniseneb
* Fieschi Morgan Staurotheke
* Hounds and Jackals
* The Hunt of the Unicorn
* Hunting of Birds with a Hawk and a Bow
* Kettle Drums
* Kneeling Bull with Vessel
* Miniature Altarpiece with the Crucifixion
* Modern Gothic cabinet
* Morgan Casket
* Pair of Incense Boxes in the Shape of Mandarin Ducks
* Pomegranate carved in the round
* Rectangular Octave Virginal
* Studiolo from the Ducal Palace in Gubbio
* Intan Jizō
* The Triumph of Fame
* Vase with lid
* Woman Seen from the Back
* Statuette of Mercury
* Statuette of the lady Tiye
* Phoenician metal bowls

Paintings|

* 1476 Altarpiece
* A Cavalryman
* A Vase of Flowers (1716)
* The Abduction of Rebecca
* The Accommodations of Desire
* The Actor (painting)
* Adoration of the Magi (Bosch, New York)
* Adoration of the Shepherds (Mantegna)
* The Aegean Sea
* The Afternoon Meal (Luis Meléndez)
* Alexander Hamilton (Trumbull)
* The Allegory of Faith
* Allegory of the Planets and Continents
* Alpine Pool
* Altman Madonna
* America Today
* Ancient Rome (painting)
* Annunciation (Memling)
* Annunziata Polyptych
* Anthony van Dyck self portrait
* Approaching Thunder Storm
* Arab Woman (watercolor)
* Arcadia (painting)
* Ariadne (Giorgio de Chirico)
* Aristotle with a Bust of Homer
* Artillery (Roger de la Fresnaye)
* The Artist's Wife and His Setter Dog
* At the Seaside
* Au Lapin Agile
* Autumn Ivy (Ogata Kenzan)
* Autumn Rhythm (Number 30)
* Bamboo in the Four Seasons
* Bache Madonna
* Bain à la Grenouillère
* The Baker's Cart
* The Banks of the Bièvre near Bicêtre
* Banquet in Silence (Marsden Hartley)
* Bashi-Bazouk (Jean-Léon Gérôme)
* A Basket of Clams (Winslow Homer)
* Beauty Revealed
* Black Iris (painting)
* Black Stork in a Landscape
* Boating (Édouard Manet)
* Annunciation (Botticelli, New York)
* Bouquet of Small Chrysanthemums (Léon Bonvin)
* Boy Carrying a Sword
* The Bridge at Villeneuve-la-Garenne
* Brigand and His Wife in Prayer
* Bringing Down Marble from the Quarries to Carrara
* The Brioche
* Broadway and 42nd Street
* Broken Eggs
* Burg Weiler Altarpiece
* Butler Madonna
* By the Seashore
* Ca' Dolfin Tiepolos
* The Calm Sea (painting)
* Camouflage Self-Portrait
* Cannon Rock (painting)
* The Card Players
* Catania and Mount Etna
* Cemetery, New Mexico (Marsden Hartley)
* Cervara Altarpiece
* The Chess Players (Eakins painting)
* Children Playing with a Goat
* Christ Carrying the Cross (El Greco, New York)
* Christ Presented to the People (Il Sodoma)
* Christ with a Staff
* Claes Duyst van Voorhout
* Cloudy Mountains
* Coast Guard Station, Two Lights, Maine
* Coast Scene, Isles of Shoals
* The Collector of Prints (Edgar Degas)
* Comtesse de la Châtre
* Captain George K. H. Coussmaker
* Cow's Skull: Red, White, and Blue
* A Cowherd at Valhermeil, Auvers-sur-Oise
* Cows Crossing a Ford
* Crucifixion (Corpus Hypercubus)
* Crucifixion and Last Judgement diptych
* Crucifixion with the Virgin and St John
* The Cup of Tea
* Cypresses (Metropolitan Museum of Art)
* The Dance Class (Degas, Metropolitan Museum of Art)
* The Dancing Class
* The Dead Christ with Angels
* The Death of Harmonia
* The Death of Socrates
* The Defense of Champigny
* Delirious Hem
* The Denial of Saint Peter (Caravaggio)
* Diana and Cupid
* The Dream of Aeneas (Salvator Rosa)
* Dressing for the Carnival
* Madonna and Child (Duccio)
* Egyptian Woman with Earrings
* Egyptians Raising Water from the Nile
* The Empress Elizabeth of Russia on Horseback, Attended by a Page
* Entrance to a Dutch Port
* Equestrian Portrait of Cornelis and Michiel Pompe van Meerdervoort with Their Tutor and Coachman
* Esther before Ahasuerus (Artemisia Gentileschi)
* Ethel Scull 36 Times
* The Experts (painting)
* The Falls of Niagara
* The Farm at Les Collettes, Cagnes
* Femme Lisant
* Ferry near Gorinchem
* The Fingernail Test
* Fish Market (Joachim Beuckelaer)
* The Fishing Boat
* Fishing Boats, Key West
* The Five Points (Metropolitan Museum of Art)
* Florinda (painting)
* The Forest in Winter at Sunset (painting)
* The Fortune Teller (de La Tour)
* Fruit Dish and Glass
* The Funeral (painting)
* Fur Traders Descending the Missouri
* Garden at Sainte-Adresse
* George Washington (Trumbull)
* Gilbert Stuart (Goodridge)
* A Girl Asleep
* Girl with a Cat (Gwen John)
* Glass Blowers of Murano
* Golden Cock and Hen
* A Goldsmith in His Shop, Possibly Saint Eligius
* The Great Sirens
* The Gulf Stream (painting)
* Harlequin with a Guitar
* The Harvest, Pontoise
* The Harvesters (painting)
* Haystacks:Autumn
* Head of Christ (Rembrandt, New York)
* The Heart of the Andes
* The Hermit (Il solitario)
* The Horse Fair
* Houses on the Achterzaan
* I Saw the Figure 5 in Gold
* In a Courtyard, Tangier
* The Interior of an Atelier of a Woman Painter (Lemoine)
* Interior with a Young Couple and a Dog
* Irises screen
* Isaac Blessing Jacob (Gerbrand van den Eeckhout)
* Isle of the Dead (painting)
* Italian Hill Town (Arthur B. Davies)
* Jingo-ji Tripiṭaka
* Jo, the Beautiful Irishwoman
* Joy of Life (Valadon)
* Juan Legua
* July Fourteenth, Rue Daunou, 1910
* The Kearsarge at Boulogne
* The Lacemaker (Maes)
* Lachrymae (Frederic Leighton)
* Lady at the Tea Table
* Lady with the Rose (Charlotte Louise Burckhardt)
* Lake George (John Frederick Kensett)
* Landscape with Sky
* The Last Communion of Saint Jerome (Botticelli)
* Lehman Madonna
* Lilacs in a Window
* Lobster Fishermen (Marsden Hartley)
* The Lovesick Maiden
* Lukas Spielhausen
* Lydia Crocheting in the Garden at Marly (Mary Cassatt)
* Madame Élisabeth de France
* Madame Grand (Louise Élisabeth Vigée Le Brun)
* Madonna and Child (Bellini, New York, 1485–1490)
* Madonna and Child Enthroned with Saints (Raphael)
* Magdalene with Two Flames
* The Maidservant
* Maine Coast
* Majas on a Balcony
* Manuel Osorio Manrique de Zúñiga
* The Marriage of the Virgin (Michelino da Besozzo)
* The Martyrdom of Saint Barbara (Lucas Cranach the Elder)
* The Masquerade Dress
* The Matador Saluting
* Max Schmitt in a Single Scull
* Mérode Altarpiece
* Merry company with two men and two women
* Mezzetino (painting)
* The Midnight Ride of Paul Revere (painting)
* Miss V Dressed as a Bullfighter
* Model by the Wicker Chair
* Mont Sainte-Victoire and the Viaduct of the Arc River Valley
* Moonlight, Wood Island Light
* Morning, An Overcast Day, Rouen
* Moses Striking the Rock
* Mother and Child (Cassatt)
* Mountain Stream (John Singer Sargent)
* Mountain with Red House
* Movement No. 5, Provincetown Houses
* Mr. and Mrs. I. N. Phelps Stokes
* Mrs. Atkinson (Gwen John)
* Mrs. Beckington (Alice Beckington)
* Mrs. Hugh Hammersley
* The Musician (Bartholomeus van der Helst painting)
* A Musician and His Daughter
* The Musicians (Caravaggio)
* Mystic Marriage of St. Catherine (Memling)
* Nativity scenes attributed to Zanobi Strozzi
* Night-Shining White
* Northeaster (painting)
* Nude Before a Mirror
* Oedipus and the Sphinx
* Old Trees, Level Distance
* Pity (William Blake)
* Portrait of Madame Jacques-Louis Leblanc

Exhibitions|

* Alexander McQueen: Savage Beauty
* American Woman: Fashioning a National Identity
* AngloMania: Tradition and Transgression in British Fashion
* Before Yesterday We Could Fly
* Camp: Notes on Fashion
* China: Through the Looking Glass
* Death Becomes Her: A Century of Mourning Attire
* Fashion and History: A Dialogue
* Glitter and Doom
* Heavenly Bodies: Fashion and the Catholic Imagination
* In America: A Lexicon of Fashion
* In America: An Anthology of Fashion
* Jacqueline Kennedy: The White House Years
* Manus x Machina: Fashion in an Age of Technology
* The Metropolitan Museum of Art Centennial
* The Model as Muse: Embodying Fashion
* The Pictures Generation
* Rei Kawakubo/Comme des Garçons Art of the In-Between
* Superheroes: Fashion and Fantasy
* Te Maori
* Vessel Orchestra

Commons *  Category
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template
*[c.]: circa