The Sing-song Girls of Shanghai

Novel by Han Bangqing

For the film adapted from the novel, see Flowers of Shanghai.

The Sing-song Girls of Shanghai

Traditional Chinese| 海上花列傳
Simplified Chinese| 海上花列传
| Transcriptions

Standard Mandarin
Hanyu Pinyin| Hǎishàng Huā Lièzhuàn
Wade–Giles| Hai-shang Hua Lieh-chuan

Romanization| he2 zaan3 ho1 lih4 zoe3

The Sing-song Girls of Shanghai, also translated as Shanghai Flowers[1] or Biographies of Flowers by the Seashore,[2] is an 1892 novel by Han Bangqing.[2]

The novel, the first such novel to be serially published,[2] chronicles lives of prostitutes in Shanghai in the late 19th century.[1] Unlike most prostitution-oriented novels in Wu Chinese, specifically the Suzhou dialect, all dialog in this novel is in Wu.[3][4]

The writer Eileen Chang translated the book into Mandarin, published in two parts under the titles "海上花開" and "海上花落" (lit. The Flowers of the Sea Bloom / Fade" or "The Flowers of Shanghai Bloom / Fade"). She also translated the book into English,[5] which was not discovered until after her death.[6] Eva Hung revised and edited the English translation before its publication.

Wilt L. Idema, who wrote a book review of The Chinese Novel at the Turn of the Century in T'oung Pao, wrote that the novel Shanghai Flowers included the use of Wu in dialogs, a "doomed to failure" protagonist, and a consciously crafted plot, therefore the book "already showed many of the characteristics of a typical Late Ch'ing novel".[2]

A film adaptation called Flowers of Shanghai was made in 1998.[6]

## Reception

[edit]

Hu Shih, Lu Xun, and other Chinese literary figures critically acclaimed Shanghai Flowers. However, the novel did not sell very well.[3] Lesley Downer of The New York Times wrote that few people read the novel in China as of 2005.[6]

Hu Shih's thesis is that because the novel had such a strong usage of Wu, readers had difficulty understanding it.[3] Donald B. Snow, author of Cantonese as Written Language: The Growth of a Written Chinese Vernacular, wrote that generally the sales of other novels outperformed Shanghai Flowers because their limited usage of the Wu made them easier to read.[3] David Der-wei Wang argued that the main usage of Wu in the novel was only by the prostitute characters and therefore the original novel would be fairly understood by other Chinese speakers. Wang concluded that the language would not be the reason for the novel's continued unpopularity since Chang had written her Mandarin translation. Instead, Wang argued that Han Bangqing's "matter-of-fact" way of describing things, which opposes opulent descriptions of events and food; and the general lack of sensationalism and "sentimental narcissism" contribute to "the fact that it does not read like the prostitute novel we generally know."[5][7]

## English translation

[edit]

* Han Bangqing (2005) [1892]. The Sing-song Girls of Shanghai. Translated by Eileen Chang and Eva Hung. Columbia University Press. ISBN 9780231122689.

## See also

[edit]

* China portal
* Novels portal

* Nine-tailed Turtles

## References

[edit]

* Forbes, Andrew. Shanghai (National Geographic Traveler Beijing & Shanghai). National Geographic Books, 2007. ISBN 1426201486, 9781426201486.
* Idema, W. L. "The Chinese Novel at the Turn of the Century" (book review). T'oung Pao, ISSN 0082-5433, 01/1982, Volume 68, Issue 4/5, pp. 352 – 355
* Snow, Donald B. Cantonese as Written Language: The Growth of a Written Chinese Vernacular. Hong Kong University Press, 2004. ISBN 962209709X, 9789622097094.
* Wang, David Der-wei. "Foreword." In: Han Bangqing (2005). The Sing-song Girls of Shanghai. Columbia University Press. ISBN 9780231122689.

## Notes

[edit]

1. ^ a b Forbes, p. 240.
2. ^ a b c d Idema, p. 355
3. ^ a b c d Snow, p. 34.
4. ^ 张爱玲诞辰百年｜细读《海上花》①：从长三书寓到香港大宅
5. ^ a b Wang, David Der-wei, Google Books PT10.
6. ^ a b c Downer, Lesley. "Pleasure Houses." The New York Times. November 20, 2005. Retrieved on March 27, 2015.
7. ^ 张爱玲诞辰百年｜细读《海上花》①：从长三书寓到香港大宅

## Further reading

[edit]

* Cheng, Stephen (Spring–Autumn 1982). "Sing-song Girls of Shanghai and Its Narrative Methods" (PDF). Renditions. Vol. 17–18\. pp. 111–136 - via Chinese University of Hong Kong. \- See profile page

## External links

[edit]

* Han, Pang-ch'ing (Spring–Autumn 1982). "The Sing-song Girls of Shanghai" (PDF). Renditions. Vol. 17–18\. Translated by Eileen Chang. pp. 95–110 - via Chinese University of Hong Kong. \- See profile page
* (in Chinese) 海上花列傳 \- Wikisource
* (in Chinese) 海上花列傳