Toxic colonialism

This article is written like a personal reflection, personal essay, or argumentative essay that states a Wikipedia editor's personal feelings or presents an original argument about a topic. Please help improve it by rewriting it in an encyclopedic style. (August 2014) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

|

Drums with dangerous waste

Toxic colonialism, or toxic waste colonialism, is the practice of exporting hazardous waste from developed countries to underdeveloped ones for disposal.[1]

## Background

[edit]

In 1992, 'toxic colonialism' was a phrase coined by Jim Puckett of Greenpeace for the dumping of the industrial wastes of the West on territories of the Third World.[2] The term refers to practices of developed nations who rid themselves of toxic or hazardous waste by shipping it to less developed areas of the world. The affected communities typically lack the resources, knowledge, political organization, or capital to resist the practice.[3] In the US, the term may also be applied to exploitation of Native American reservations, where differing environment regulations allow the land to be more easily used for dump sites.

According to The Diplomat:

> In the 1980s, developed nations began tightening legislation surrounding waste disposal and health standards. As a result, in order to avoid their own environmental regulations and the high cost associated with them, wealthy nations began to export their rubbish to developing nations. Rather than managing and containing their own plastic and hazardous waste, developed nations exported it by the container load to developing nations, which lacked adequate facilities to store or dispose of it. In the 1980s a new term was coined to describe this practice: "Waste colonialism."[4]

## Significance

[edit]

There have been numerous adverse effects of toxic colonialism on both people and the environment, although a reported positive of toxic colonialism includes economic gains to developing nations. History shows that the overall impact of the toxic waste dumping in these nations has been devastating and has severely compromised all aspects of human health. In a case study for the 2010 Geneva Convention, Bashir Mohamed Hussein, PhD details one account of toxic and radioactive waste dumping in Somalia and its effects, "UNEP...reported that the people were complaining of unusual health problems including "acute respiratory infections, heavy dry coughing, mouth bleeding, abdominal hemorrhage and unusual chemical skin reaction...Likewise, both Somali and non-Somali medical doctors working in Somalia have reported an excessive incidence of cancer, unknown diseases, spontaneous miscarriages of the pregnant women and child malformation."[5] The significance of toxic waste on humans is made evident by the research along with the fact that those nations and their people that suffer from the effects of said colonialist behavior are those of those in developing nations without the resources, knowledge or capital to both understand the effects and tackle the treatment they have been subject to.

### Socioeconomic aspects

[edit]

Despite the many health effects of toxic colonialism, these effects are reportedly often overshadowed by the economic interests of both the developing and developed nations. One of the leading socioeconomic aspects of toxic colonialism is capital gain and money. Jennifer Kitt states "developed countries want to save it, and developing countries want to earn it."[6] There is little report of regard for the health concerns developing countries subject their people to as long as there is a monetary or economical gain and the developed world takes full advantage of this in order to save money, and "the wealth and income gaps between developing nations and developed nations have continually grown throughout the past century. As developing nations seek to boost economic growth, the enforcement of the few hazardous waste regulations in place often fall by the wayside. Many agencies in these developing countries do not have the resources to give approvals or enforce their regulations".[6] Despite this, "developed countries generally have increasingly stringent environmental regulations governing the domestic disposal of hazardous wastes. When compliance costs are coupled with an increased quantity of waste and local opposition to disposal, they generally produce drastically increased disposal costs for hazardous waste."[6] It is effective for developed countries to seek those less developed and offer them the idea of economic relief at a seemingly minor, but substantial environment cost. In some instances, monetary funds are not the only thing exchanged between developed and developing nations. For example, "Somali warring parties used to accept hazardous and highly toxic wastes in exchange of army and ammunition".[5] The need for developed nations to remove themselves from handling excessive toxic waste commitments is also a reported driving force behind toxic colonialism.

## Progress

[edit]

Over the past few decades there have been improvements in environmental protection that have tried to end the illegal dumping of toxic waste worldwide. The Basel Convention in 1989 was a treaty signed by 105 countries and was intended to regulate the international shipping of toxic substances. Despite the treaty, millions of tons of toxic and hazardous materials continue to move both legally and illegally from richer countries to poorer countries each year.[7] The history of suburbanization reveals that although many forces contributed to decentralization, it has largely been an exclusionary undertaking.[8]

In 1992 the US established the US Environmental Act in an attempt to identify areas threatened by the highest levels of toxic chemicals and ensure that groups of individuals residing within those areas have opportunities and resources to participate in public discussions concerning siting and cleanup of industrial facilities.[citation needed] One organization fighting toxic colonialism is the Basel Action Network (BAN).[9] BAN is focused on confronting the impacts of global environmental injustice and economic inefficiency of toxic trade (toxic wastes, products and technologies).[9]

## See also

[edit]

* Ecocide
* Environmental crime
* Environmental dumping
* Environmental justice
* Environmental racism
* Global environmental inequality
* Global waste trade
* Sacrifice zone
* Pollution is Colonialism

## References

[edit]

1. ^ Pratt, Laura A. (February 2011). "Decreasing Dirty Dumping? A Reevaluation of Toxic Waste Colonialism and the Global Management of Transboundary Hazardous Waste". William & Mary Environmental Law and Policy Review. 35 (2): 581.
2. ^ Dalyell, Tam (July 2, 1992). "Thistle Diary: Toxic wastes and other ethical issues". New Scientist: 50.
3. ^ Reed, T.V. (Summer 2009). "Toxic Colonialism, Environmental Justice and Native Resistance in Silko's Almanac of the Dead". MELUS. 34 (2): 25–42\. doi:10.1353/mel.0.0023. JSTOR 20532677.
4. ^ "Asia Stands up to 'Waste Colonialism'". The Diplomat. 20 June 2019.
5. ^ a b Hussein, Bashir (8 June 2010). "The Evidence of Toxic And Radioactive Wastes Dumping In Somalia And Its Impact On The Enjoyment Of Human Rights: A Case Study" (PDF). Geneva: Somacent Development Research Foundation. Retrieved 30 January 2013.
6. ^ a b c Kitt, Jennifer R. (1995). "Waste Exports to the Developing World: A Global Response". Georgetown International Environmental Law Review. 7: 485.
7. ^ Cunningham, William; Cunningham, Mary (2010). Environmental Science: A Global Concern. New York: McGraw-Hill.
8. ^ Pulido, Laura (2000-03-01). "Rethinking Environmental Racism: White Privilege and Urban Development in Southern California". Annals of the Association of American Geographers. 90 (1): 12–40\. doi:10.1111/0004-5608.00182. hdl:10214/1833. ISSN 1467-8306.
9. ^ a b "About the Basel Action Network". Basel Action Network. 2011. Retrieved 18 April 2013.

## Further reading

[edit]

* Lipman, Zada (Winter 2002). "A Dirty Dilemma: The Hazardous Waste Trade". Harvard International Review: 67–71.

* v
* t
* e

Biosolids, waste, and waste management

Major types|

* Agricultural wastewater
* Biodegradable waste
* Biomedical waste
* Brown waste
* Chemical waste
* Construction waste
* Demolition waste
* Electronic waste
* by country
* Food waste
* Green waste
* Hazardous waste
* Heat waste
* Industrial waste
* Industrial wastewater
* Litter
* Marine debris
* Mining waste
* Municipal solid waste
* Open defecation
* Packaging waste
* Post-consumer waste
* Radioactive waste
* Scrap metal
* Sewage
* Sharps waste
* Surface runoff
* Toxic waste

Processes|

* Anaerobic digestion
* Balefill
* Biodegradation
* Composting
* Durable good
* Ecological design
* Garden waste dumping
* Illegal dumping
* Incineration
* Landfill
* Landfill mining
* Mechanical biological treatment
* Mechanical sorting
* Photodegradation
* Reclaimed lumber
* Recycling
* appliance recycling
* battery recycling
* bottle recycling
* fluorescent lamp recycling
* land recycling
* plastic recycling
* textile recycling
* timber recycling
* tire recycling
* water heat recycling
* water recycling shower
* Repurposing
* Resource recovery
* Reusable packaging
* Right to repair
* Sewage treatment
* Urban mining
* Waste collection
* Waste sorting
* Waste trade
* Waste treatment
* Waste-to-energy

Countries|

* Afghanistan
* Albania
* Armenia
* Australia
* Belgium
* Bangladesh
* Brazil
* Bosnia and Herzegovina
* Egypt
* Georgia
* Hong Kong
* India
* Israel
* Japan
* Kazakhstan
* New Zealand
* Russia
* South Korea
* Sri Lanka
* Switzerland
* Syria
* Tanzania
* Taiwan
* Thailand
* Turkey
* United Kingdom
* United States

Agreements|

* Bamako Convention
* Basel Convention
* EU directives
* batteries
* Recycling
* framework
* incineration
* landfills
* RoHS
* vehicles
* waste water
* WEEE
* London Convention
* Oslo Convention
* OSPAR Convention

Occupations|

* Sanitation worker
* Street sweeper
* Waste collector
* Waste picker

Other topics|

* Blue Ribbon Commission on America's Nuclear Future
* China's waste import ban
* Cleaner production
* Downcycling
* Eco-industrial park
* Extended producer responsibility
* High-level radioactive waste management
* History of waste management
* Landfill fire
* Sewage regulation and administration
* Supervised injection site
* Toxic colonialism
* Upcycling
* Waste hierarchy
* Waste legislation
* Waste minimisation
* Zero waste

* Environment portal
* Category: Waste
* Index
* Journals
* Lists
* Organizations

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template