Victor Bruce, 9th Earl of Elgin

British noble, 9th Earl of Elgin, 13th Earl of Kincardine (1849–1917)

His Excellency The Right Honourable

The Earl of Elgin

KG GCSI GCIE PC

Victor Bruce, c. 1897

Secretary of State for the Colonies
In office
10 December 1905 – 12 April 1908
Monarch| Edward VII
Prime Minister| Henry Campbell-Bannerman
Preceded by| Alfred Lyttelton
Succeeded by| The Earl of Crewe
Viceroy and Governor-General of India
In office
11 October 1894 – 6 January 1899
Monarch| Victoria
Preceded by| The Marquess of Lansdowne
Succeeded by| The Lord Curzon of Kedleston
Personal details
Born| (1849-05-16)16 May 1849
Montreal, Canada East,
Province of Canada
Died| 18 January 1917(1917-01-18) (aged 67)
Dunfermline, Fife,
United Kingdom
Nationality| British
Political party| Liberal
Spouse|

Lady Constance Carnegie

(m. 1876; died 1909)​

Gertrude Sherbrooke

(m. 1913)​

Children| 12, including Edward
Parent(s)| James Bruce, 8th Earl of Elgin
Lady Mary Louisa Lambton
Alma mater| Balliol College, Oxford

Victor Alexander Bruce, 9th Earl of Elgin, 13th Earl of Kincardine, KG, GCSI, GCIE, PC (16 May 1849 - 18 January 1917), known as Lord Bruce until 1863, was a right-wing British Liberal politician who served as Viceroy of India from 1894 to 1899. He was appointed by Prime Minister Arthur Balfour to hold an investigative enquiry into the conduct of the Boer War in 1902 to 1903. The Elgin Commission was the first of its kind in the British Empire, and it travelled to South Africa and took oral evidence from men who had actually fought in the battles. It was the first to value the lives of the dead and to consider the feelings of mourning relatives left behind, and it was the first occasion in the history of the British Army that recognised the testimony of ordinary soldiery as well as that of the officers.[1]

## Background and education

[edit]

Elgin was born in Montreal, Canada East (now Montreal, Quebec), the son of James Bruce, 8th Earl of Elgin, who served as Governor-General of Canada at the time, and his wife, Lady May Louisa, daughter of John Lambton, 1st Earl of Durham. He was educated at Glenalmond, Eton and Balliol College, Oxford.[1] He owned 2,895 acres.[2]

## Political career

[edit]

Elgin entered politics as a Liberal, serving as Treasurer of the Household and as First Commissioner of Works under William Ewart Gladstone in 1886.

### Viceroy of India

[edit]

Lord Elgin. Coats of Arms of Victor Bruce.

Following in his father's footsteps, Elgin was made Viceroy of India in 1894. His viceroyalty was not a particularly notable one. Elgin himself did not enjoy the pomp and ceremony associated with the viceroyalty, and his conservative instincts were not well suited to a time of economic and social unrest. He said, "India is the pivot of our Empire... If the Empire loses any other part of its Dominion we can survive, but if we lose India, the sun of our Empire will have set."

During his time as Viceroy, famine broke out in India, in which Elgin reportedly admitted that up to 4.5 million people died.[3] Other estimates have put the death toll at 11 million people.[3] His administration in India was otherwise notable for the Afridi frontier risings of 1897–1898.[4]

### Elgin Commission

[edit]

Elgin returned to England in 1899 and was made a Knight of the Garter. From 1902 to 1903, Elgin was made chairman of the commission that investigated the conduct of the Second Boer War. He was appointed Honorary Colonel of the 1st Fifeshire Volunteer Artillery Corps on 26 March 1902.[5]

The Elgin Committee discussed cavalry in spring 1903. Many mounted infantry units had been raised during the Boer War, some from scratch and some by converting infantry units. All were agreed that cavalry should be trained to fight dismounted with firearms, but traditionalists wanted cavalry still to be trained as the arme blanche, charging with lance and sabre. Although the traditional view appears absurd with hindsight, at the time matters were less clearcut. General French stressed the importance of morale, after the success of his cavalry charges at Elandslaagte and Kimberley. That view was by no means extreme: Maj-Gen J.P. Brabazon thought sword and lance were suitable only for "Latin" cavalry, and that "Anglo-Saxons" should instead be equipped with "a light battleaxe or tomahawk". After Wolseley, Evelyn Wood and Roberts (all of whom had seen the future of cavalry as being for use as mounted infantry only) had retired, the traditional view was reestablished as French and his protégé Major-General Haig rose to the top of the Army.[6] The recommendations of the Commission were never fully implemented. The Esher Report into the future of the Army overshadowed its findings, and the Army came to be dominated by the High Tory reorganisation of the War Office.

### Colonial Secretary

[edit]

When the Liberals returned to power in 1905, Elgin became Secretary of State for the Colonies (with Winston Churchill as his Under-Secretary). As colonial secretary, he pursued a conservative policy and opposed the generous settlement of the South African question proposed by Prime Minister Campbell-Bannerman, which was enacted more in spite of the Colonial Secretary's opposition than because of his efforts. After being dropped from the next government by the next prime minister, Asquith, Elgin retired from public life in 1908.[7]

## Honours

[edit]

Lord Elgin was appointed Knight Grand Commander of the Order of the Star of India (GCSI) and Knight Grand Commander of the Order of the Indian Empire (GCIE) on his appointment as Viceroy in 1894. He was appointed a Knight of the Order of the Garter (KG) on his return to the United Kingdom in 1899.

In July 1902, he received the freedom of the city of St Andrews "in recognition of his devotion to the public service, whether holding the exalted position of Viceroy of India, where he watched over the interests of a vast Empire with remarkable skill, prudence, and success, or discharging the duties connected with county government and giving his time and wide experience as Chairman of the Carnegie Trust for the advancement of education in Scotland".[8]

## Family

[edit]

Constance, Countess of Elgin (1876), daughter of Sir James Carnegie, 9th Earl of Southesk The Earl of Elgin at his private estate in Scotland, 1889.

Lord Elgin married Lady Constance Mary Carnegie, daughter of James Carnegie, 9th Earl of Southesk, in 1876. They had six sons and five daughters:

* Lady Elizabeth Mary Bruce (11 September 1877 - 13 May 1944)
* Lady Christina Augusta Bruce (25 January 1879 - 12 September 1940)
* Lady Constance Veronica Bruce (24 February 1880 - 7 July 1969)
* Edward James Bruce, 10th Earl of Elgin, 14th Earl of Kincardine (9 June 1881 - 27 November 1968)
* Hon. Robert Bruce (18 November 1882 - 31 October 1959)
* Hon. Alexander Bruce (29 July 1884 - October 1917)
* Lady Marjorie Bruce (12 December 1885 - 23 May 1901)
* Colonel Hon. David Bruce (11 June 1888 - 26 August 1964)
* Lady Rachel Catherine Bruce (23 February 1890 - 17 December 1964)
* Captain Hon. John Bernard Bruce (9 April 1892 - 3 August 1971)
* Hon. Victor Alexander Bruce (13 February 1897 - 19 December 1930).

After Lady Elgin's death in 1909, he married Gertrude Lilian, daughter of William Sherbrooke and widow of Frederick Charles Ashley Ogilvy, in 1913. They had one posthumous son:

* Hon. Bernard Bruce (12 June 1917 - 17 June 1983)

## Death

[edit]

Lord Elgin died at the family estate in Dunfermline in January 1917, at 67. He was succeeded in his titles by his eldest son from his first marriage, Edward.

His widow, Gertrude, later remarried and died in February 1971.

## Kincardine whisky

[edit]

Kincardine whisky was released in November 2016 by Fusion Whisky Ltd, in partnership with independent bottler and distillery Adelphi.[9]

It was made to honour his achievements, particularly his time in India when he served as Viceroy and Governor-Consul. It featured photography from the Bruce family's archive.

The Kincardine was a blend, or fusion, of seven-year-old India single malt whisky from Amrut distillery in Bangalore and mature single malt Scotch whisky from Glen Elgin and Macallan distilleries in Speyside. Only 800 bottles were produced, with a price of about £135 and ABV of 52.9%. It was the fourth international blend from Fusion Whisky and followed from the highly acclaimed Glover whiskies.[10]

Adelphi's Alex Bruce is the great-grandson of Victor Bruce.

## See also

[edit]

* Famine in India

## References

[edit]

1. ^ a b "Victor Bruce, 9th Earl of Elgin". Encyclopædia Britannica. 29 February 2024.
2. ^ The great landowners of Great Britain and Ireland
3. ^ a b Davis, Mike. Late Victorian Holocausts; 1. Verso, 2000. ISBN 1-85984-739-0 pg. 158
4. ^ Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). "Elgin and Kincardine, Earls of" . Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 9 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 268.
5. ^ "No. 27419". The London Gazette. 25 March 1902. p. 2081.
6. ^ Reid 2006, p107-8, 112
7. ^ Elizabeth Lane Furdell. (1996). "Bruce, Victor Alexander". In James Stuart Olson, Robert Shadle (ed.). Historical Dictionary of the British Empire: A-J. Greenwood Press. pp. 204–205. ISBN 0-313-29366-X.
8. ^ "The Freedom of St Andrews". The Times. No. 36824\. London. 19 July 1902. p. 14.
9. ^ "Scotch-Indian whisky hybrid launches". www.scotchwhisky.com. 8 November 2016.
10. ^ "The Glover 18 year old". www.malt-review.com. 25 August 2016.

## Further reading

[edit]

* Elgin Papers, India Office Records, British Library
* Queen Victoria – "Journals"
* Queen Victoria – "Our Life in the Highlands"
* Hyam, Ronald. Elgin and Churchill at the Colonial Office 1905-1908: The Watershed of the Empire-Commonwealth. Macmillan & Co., London, 1968.
* Bence-Jones, Mark. The Viceroys of India. Constable, London, 1982.
* Reid, Walter (2006). Architect of Victory: Douglas Haig. Birlinn Ltd, Edinburgh, 2006. ISBN 1-84158-517-3.

## External links

[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Victor Bruce, 9th Earl of Elgin.

* Hansard 1803–2005: contributions in Parliament by the Earl of Elgin
* Kidd, Charles, ed. (1903). Debrett's peerage, baronetage, knightage, and companionage. London: Dean and son. p. 352.

Political offices

Preceded by

Viscount Folkestone

|  Treasurer of the Household
1886  | Succeeded by

Viscount Folkestone

Preceded by

Albert Morley

|  First Commissioner of Works
1886  | Succeeded by

David Plunkett

Preceded by

Alfred Lyttelton

|  Secretary of State for the Colonies
1905–1908  | Succeeded by

The Earl of Crewe

Government offices
Preceded by

The Marquess of Lansdowne

|  Viceroy of India
1894–1899  | Succeeded by

The Lord Curzon of Kedleston

Honorary titles
Preceded by

Sir Robert Anstruther

|  Lord Lieutenant of Fife
1886–1917  | Succeeded by

Sir William Robertson

Peerage of Scotland
Preceded by

James Bruce

|  Earl of Elgin
Earl of Kincardine
1863–1917  | Succeeded by

Edward James Bruce

* v
* t
* e

Viceroys of India

East India
Company
(1773-1858)|

* Warren Hastings (1774-85)
* The Earl Cornwallis (1786-93)
* The Lord Teignmouth (1793-98)
* The Marquess Wellesley (1798-1805)
* The Marquess Cornwallis (1805)
* The Earl of Minto (1807-13)
* The Marquess of Hastings (1813-23)
* The Earl Amherst (1823-28)
* Lord William Bentinck (1828-35)
* The Earl of Auckland (1836-42)
* The Earl of Ellenborough (1842-44)
* The Viscount Hardinge (1844-48)
* The Marquess of Dalhousie (1848-56)
* The Viscount Canning (1856-58)

British Government1
(1858-1947)|

* The Earl Canning (1858-62)
* The Earl of Elgin (1862-63)
* The Lord Lawrence (1864-69)
* The Earl of Mayo (1869-72)
* The Earl of Northbrook (1872-76)
* The Earl of Lytton (1876-80)
* The Marquess of Ripon (1880-84)
* The Marquess of Dufferin and Ava (1884-88)
* The Marquess of Lansdowne (1888-94)
* The Earl of Elgin (1894-99)
* The Lord Curzon of Kedleston (1899-1905)
* The Earl of Minto (1905-10)
* The Lord Hardinge of Penshurst (1910-16)
* The Lord Chelmsford (1916-21)
* The Earl of Reading (1921-26)
* The Lord Irwin (1926-31)
* The Earl of Willingdon (1931-36)
* The Marquess of Linlithgow (1936-43)
* The Viscount Wavell (1943-47)
* The Viscount Mountbatten of Burma (1947)

Governors General after Indian
independence2|

* The Earl Mountbatten of Burma (1947-48)
* Chakravarthi Rajagopalachari (1948-50)

Governors General after Pakistani
independence3|

* Muhammad Ali Jinnah (1947-48)
* Sir Khawaja Nazimuddin (1948-51)
* Ghulam Muhammad (1951-55)
* Iskander Mirza (1955-56)

1 Following the 1857 Sepoy Mutiny. 2 As representatives of George VI in his role as King of India (1947-50). 3 As representatives of George VI and then Elizabeth II in their roles as King and Queen of Pakistan, respectively.

Authority control databases

International|

* ISNI
* VIAF
* FAST

National|

* Germany
* United States
* France
* BnF data
* Netherlands
* Israel

Other|

* IdRef
* SNAC

*[c.]: circa
*[m.]: married
*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template