Voree plates

Set of three metal plates associated with Mormonism

This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages)

The neutrality of this article is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. (February 2024) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

|

This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources.
Find sources: "Voree plates" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (February 2024) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

|

(Learn how and when to remove this message)

1845 broadside depicting the Voree Plates

The Voree plates, also called The Record of Rajah Manchou of Vorito,[pronunciation?] or the Voree Record, were a set of three tiny metal plates allegedly discovered by James J. Strang, a leader of the Latter Day Saint movement, in Voree, Wisconsin, United States, in 1845.

Purportedly the final testament of an ancient American ruler named "Rajah Manchou of Vorito", Strang asserted that this discovery vindicated his claims to be the true successor of Joseph Smith, founder of the Latter Day Saint movement—as opposed to Brigham Young, whom most Latter Day Saints accepted as Smith's successor in 1844. The plates also lent credence to Strang's claim that Voree, not the Salt Lake Valley, was to be the new "gathering place" of the Latter Day Saints. His purported translation of this text is accepted as scripture by his church and some other bodies descending from it, but not by any other Latter Day Saint organization.

Unlike the golden plates used by Smith to produce the Book of Mormon, the existence of Strang's plates was verified by independent, non-Mormon witnesses, including Christopher Latham Sholes, inventor of the first practical typewriter. Strang was accused of having fabricated the plates from a brass tea kettle, a claim which he and his partisans vigorously denied. The plates disappeared around 1900 and their current whereabouts are unknown.

## Discovery

[edit]

1856 daguerreotype of James Strang, taken on Beaver Island, Lake Michigan, by J. Atkyn, itinerant photographer and later one of Strang's assassins. A map of old Voree, engraved on a monument at the townsite.

According to Latter Day Saint beliefs, many ancient inhabitants of the Americas engraved records on metal plates. Joseph Smith, the movement's founding prophet, claimed that he translated the Book of Mormon from a set of golden plates which he was shown the location of by an angel named Moroni.

Following Smith's murder in 1844, a number of claimants came forward to lead his nascent church, including Strang. As a recent convert to Mormonism, Strang did not possess the name recognition among rank-and-file Latter Day Saints enjoyed by Brigham Young and Sidney Rigdon, the two principal contenders for church leadership. Hence, Strang faced an uphill battle in his quest to be recognized as the heir to Smith's prophetic mantle.

To advance his cause, Strang asserted that unlike Rigdon and Young, he had hard evidence of his prophetic calling. One of Smith's titles had been "Prophet, Seer, Revelator, and Translator", and Strang wished to substantiate his claim to succession by following in Smith's footsteps. So, while Young and Rigdon never offered their followers any newly revealed ancient records, Strang announced on January 17, 1845, that God had promised to lead him to a hitherto-undiscovered chronicle of a long-lost American people.[1] This, said Strang, would prove that he was Smith's true successor.

Strang next testified that on September 1, 1845, an angel of God appeared to him and showed him the location of "the record of my people in whose possession thou dwellest."[2] Accordingly, he went on September 13 to the indicated site, located in Voree, Wisconsin, south of the White River on what is now referred to as the "Hill of Promise." Strang led four witnesses to a large oak on the hillside, inviting them to examine the ground around the tree carefully before digging for the plates. All four later testified that they could discern no evidence of digging or other disturbance of the ground.

After removing the tree, Strang's companions dug down approximately three feet, where they discovered three small brass plates in a case of baked clay. Strang subsequently claimed to have deciphered this record, which he said was authored by an ancient Native American named "Rajah Manchou of Vorito."[3]

## Appearance and dimensions

[edit]

The Voree plates measured approximately 2.5 inches long, and between 1.25 and 1.5 inches wide.[4] According to one anonymous witness, they were "about the thickness of a piece of tin, fastened together in one corner by a ring passing through them."[5] A second witness described them as being "thickly covered with ancient characters of curious workmanship."[6] Stephen Post, the brother of Strangite apostle Warren Post, visited Strang in 1850 and examined the plates for himself, noting that "they were not polished very smooth before engraving, by appearance."[4]

Unlike his brother, Stephen Post had trouble believing Strang's account of the plates' origin and discovery: "With all the faith & confidence that I could exercise," he later wrote, "all that I could realize was that Strang made the plates himself, or at least that it was possible that he made them." Post equally observed that the brass used in the Voree plates seemed indistinguishable to him from the French brass used in ordinary tea kettles.[7]

Four of the six sides of the Voree plates contained text written in an unknown script. The fifth side contained a map showing the area where the plates were found,[8] while side one contained engravings of the "all-seeing eye" and a man holding a scepter, with the sun, moon, and stars beneath him.[9] These images were said to represent God, the president of the church, his two counselors, the high council of the church, the apostles, and the seventies.[4]

## Translation and testimony

[edit]

Strang's published translation of the Voree plates reads as follows:

> My people are no more. The mighty are fallen, and the young slain in battle. Their bones bleached on the plain by the noonday shadow. The houses are leveled to the dust, and in the moat are the walls. They shall be inhabited.

> I have in the burial served them, and their bones in the Death-shade, towards the sun's rising, are covered. They sleep with the mighty dead, and they rest with their fathers. They have fallen in transgression and are not, but the elect and faithful there shall dwell.

> The word hath revealed it. God hath sworn to give an inheritance to his people where transgressors perished. The word of God came to me while I mourned in the Death-shade, saying, I will avenge me on the destroyer. He shall be driven out. Other strangers shall inhabit thy land. I an ensign there will set up. The escaped of my people there shall dwell when the flock disown the Shepherd and build not on the Rock.

> The forerunner men shall kill, but a mighty prophet there shall dwell. I will be his strength, and he shall bring forth thy record. Record my words, and bury it in the Hill of Promise.[10]

Strang published facsimiles of the Voree plates, and his translations of them, in his church's newspaper, The Voree Herald.[11] Many Latter Day Saints found this new discovery compelling and believed it to be a sure sign that Strang was indeed Smith's true successor. For those who remained skeptical or merely curious, Mormon or non-Mormon, Strang readily produced the plates themselves for personal examination.

One such investigator was the non-Mormon Christopher Sholes, inventor of the first practical typewriter, and a later inspiration to Thomas Edison. As the editor of the Southport Telegraph, Sholes called upon Strang and perused his discovery. Sholes offered no opinion on the plates, but described Strang as "honest and earnest" and opined that his followers ranked "among the most honest and intelligent men in the neighborhood."[12]

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and the Community of Christ, the two largest factions of the Latter Day Saint movement, both reject Strang's claims to prophetic leadership and the purported authenticity of the Voree plates.

## Possible additional text

[edit]

According to one source, there may have been text translated from the Voree plates that Strang never made public. Strang himself had indicated more than once that he had released to his followers only "part of the record of Rajah Manchou of Vorito."[4] H. V. Reed, who had visited Strang and read his translation, published a possible addition to Strang's text in the Chicago Illustrated Journal in January 1873:

> It shall come to pass in the latter days, that my people shall hear my voice, and the truth shall speak from the earth, and my people shall hear, and shall come and build the Temple of the Lord. My prophet, unto whom I send my word, shall lead them, and guide them in the ways of peace and salvation. In Voree the name of the Mighty One shall be heard, and the nations shall obey my law, and hear the words of my servant, whom I shall raise up unto them in the latter days.[4]

No official determination has been made by the Strangite church as to whether these words should be considered part of Strang's translation or not.[4]

## Allegations of forgery

[edit]

Some members of competing restoration churches have insisted that the Voree plates were forged by Strang. Isaac Scott, an ex-Strangite, wrote to Joseph Smith III alleging that he learned from Caleb Barnes, Strang's former law partner, that he and Strang had fabricated the plates from a tea kettle belonging to Strang's father-in-law as part of a land speculation scheme.[13]

According to Scott, Barnes and Strang "made the 'plates' out of Ben [Perce]'s old kettle and engraved them with an old saw file, and ... when completed they put acid on them to corrode them and give them an ancient appearance; and that to deposit them under the tree, where they were found, they took a large auger ... which Ben [Perce] owned, put a fork handle on the auger and with it bored a long slanting hole under a tree on 'The Hill of Promise,' as they called it, laying the earth in a trail on a cloth as taken out, then put the 'plates' in, tamping in all the earth again, leaving no trace of their work visible.”[13]

Wingfield W. Watson, a high priest in the Strangite sect who knew Strang, vigorously challenged these allegations in an 1889 publication entitled The Prophetic Controversy #3.[14] Among other things, Watson points out that the theory advanced fails to explain how the 12"x12"x3" stone covering block was placed above the case containing the plates.

Strang was assassinated in 1856. The Voree plates remained with his family until they disappeared sometime around 1900.[4] Their current whereabouts are unknown.

## Script used on the plates

[edit]

The Voree plates are written in an unknown alphabet. Strang authored a personal diary during his youth, parts of which were written in a secret code which was not deciphered until over one hundred years later by his grandson. Comparison of the script used in the coded portions of Strang's diary[15] and the script used on the Voree plates[4] shows remarkable similarities between the two.

Keith Thompson alleges that the text on the plates matches Strang's published translation. Although he did not identify the values of specific characters, he claimed to have shown how words such as "and", "in", and "are" appear in multiple places.[16] According to a Strangite website, Derek J. Masson, a non-Mormon scholar, reportedly argued in an unpublished 1977 paper that Strang's translation was sound.[4] This same site alleges that a second scholar, Robert Madison,[17] concluded in 1990 that the text on the plates appears to represent a genuine, albeit unknown, language, and that Strang's translation appeared to be "a superb (if poetic) rendition of that text into English."[4]

Independent scholarly assessment of Masson's and Madison's conclusions does not exist.

## See also

[edit]

* Latter-day Saints portal

* Reformed Egyptian
* List of plates (Latter Day Saint movement)

## Notes

[edit]

1. ^ Revelation of 17 January 1845, quoted from http://www.strangite.org/Plates.htm Archived 2012-09-17 at archive.today. Contains a reproduction of the plates.
2. ^ Gospel Herald, May 4, 1848. Quoted from http://www.strangite.org/Plates.htm Archived 2012-09-17 at archive.today.
3. ^ Some spell this "Manchore" instead of "Manchou".
4. ^ a b c d e f g h i j "The Voree Plates - Mormon scriptures - brass plates". strangite.org. Archived from the original on 2012-09-17. Retrieved 2011-03-12.
5. ^ Gospel Herald, 23 September 1847. Quoted in http://www.strangite.org/Plates.htm Archived 2012-09-17 at archive.today.
6. ^ Gospel Herald, 26 October 1848. Quoted in http://www.strangite.org/Plates.htm Archived 2012-09-17 at archive.today.
7. ^ "Book of Mormon witnesses:Strangite parallels. - FAIRMormon". fairmormon.org. Retrieved 2011-03-12.
8. ^ "The sides are not numbered, but when looking at the facsimile published on this site, it appears to be side five". strangite.org. Archived from the original on 2012-09-17. Retrieved 2011-03-12.
9. ^ "See note, above". strangite.org. Archived from the original on 2012-09-17. Retrieved 2011-03-12.
10. ^ Zion's Reveille, April 1, 1847. Quoted in http://www.strangite.org/Plates.htm Archived 2012-09-17 at archive.today.
11. ^ Facsimile of the Voree plates Archived 2012-09-17 at archive.today
12. ^ Doyle Fitzpatrick, The King Strang Story, A Vindication of James J. Strang, the Beaver Island Mormon King (National Heritage, 1970), p.36.
13. ^ a b The Saints' Herald 35 (December 29, 1888): 831–32.
14. ^ The Prophetic Controversy, No. 3; or the Even Balances by which Isaac Scott, Chancy Loomis, and the Founders of the Reorganization Are Weighted and Found Wanting. In Two Chapters (Boyne, Mich.[?]: n.p. 1889).
15. ^ Fitzpatrick, p. 259.
16. ^ Giants of Burlington: Voree Plate 1 Site also contains photos of the discovery site on the "Hill of Promise."
17. ^ "he served as General Church Historian for the Restoration Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. And has published twice before in The John Whitmer Historical Association Journal." ""Inspired Fiction" v. The Plates & The Witnesses", Mormon Dialog & Discussion Board. Comment posted October 5, 2017; retrieved April 27, 2024.

## External links

[edit]

* The Voree Plates, Strangite site containing a large reproduction of the Voree plates, with translation and other information.
* James Strang as Translator, Strangite site on the plates.
* Giants of Burlington, non-Strangite website seeking to link the Voree plates to the world of psychic and UFO phenomena.

* v
* t
* e

Latter Day Saint movement

Fundamental ideas|

* Mormonism
* Mormonism and Nicene Christianity
* Mormon fundamentalism
* Teachings of Joseph Smith

History|

* Church of Christ
* Extermination Order
* Succession crisis

* History of the LDS Church
* Mormon handcart pioneers
* Mormon Battalion
* Mormon Reformation
* Utah War

* Community of Christ history
* Amboy Conference
* Restoration branches

* Church of Jesus Christ (Bickertonite) history
* Rigdonite
* William Bickerton

Sacred texts|

* Bible
* Old Testament
* New Testament
* Book of Abraham
* Criticism
* Book of Mormon
* outline
* Criticism
* Book of Moses
* Criticism of Mormon sacred texts
* Doctrine and Covenants (Book of Commandments)
* Joseph Smith Translation of the Bible
* Pearl of Great Price
* Lectures on Faith
* Book of the Law of the Lord (Strangites only)
* The Word of the Lord (Fettingites and offshoots)

Founders and leaders|

* Joseph Smith
* outline
* Oliver Cowdery
* Sidney Rigdon
* Brigham Young
* Wilford Woodruff
* Joseph Smith III
* James Strang
* William Bickerton
* Granville Hedrick
* Alpheus Cutler

LDS denominations|

* The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
* outline
* Community of Christ
* Restoration branches
* Bickertonite
* Strangite
* Hedrickite
* Christian fellowships of "the Remnants" movement
* Mormon fundamentalism
* FLDS Church
* Apostolic United Brethren
* Latter Day Church of Christ
* Centennial Park group
* List of Reorganized Restorationist churches

Doctrines and practices|

* Adam–God doctrine
* Agency
* Articles of Faith
* Confirmation
* Cosmology
* Degrees of glory
* Early views on death
* Exaltation
* Gifts of the Spirit
* Views on God
* Heavenly Parents
* Heavenly Mother
* Islam and Mormonism
* Judaism and Mormonism
* Law of consecration
* Melchizedek priesthood
* Patriarchal blessing
* Plan of salvation
* Premortal life
* Priesthood
* Restoration
* Revelation
* Second anointing
* Spirit world
* Spectrums of orthodoxy and practice
* Son of perdition
* Temples
* Tithing
* Women and Mormonism
* Word of wisdom

Controversies|

* Polygamy
* current state
* origin
* Race
* Black people
* Black people and early Mormonism
* Civil rights
* Joseph Smith's views
* Native Americans
* Pacific Islanders
* Phrenology
* Slavery
* LGBT people
* Violence
* Historicity of the Book of Mormon
* archaeology
* origin
* Geographical setting
* List of prophecies of Joseph Smith
* Universalism

Culture|

* Ex-Mormon
* Jack Mormon
* Lost boys
* Mormon art
* Mormon blogosphere
* Mormon cinema
* Mormon folklore
* Cunning folk traditions and the Latter Day Saint movement
* Mormon foodways
* Mormon literature
* Mormon poetry
* Mormon fiction
* Association for Mormon Letters
* Mormon music
* Mormon folk music
* Placement marriage

The Mormon Image|

* Mormon studies
* Latter Day Saints in popular culture
* Portrayal of Mormons in comics
* Mormon pornography

Places|

* Cumorah
* Kirtland, Ohio
* Mormon corridor
* Nauvoo, Illinois
* Salt Lake City
* Sacred Grove
* Smith Family Farm

Related|

* Anti-Mormonism
* Angel Moroni
* Bibliography
* Bibliography of books critical of Mormonism
* Criticism of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
* First Vision
* Golden plates
* Joseph Smith Papyri
* Eyewitness accounts associated with the Joseph Smith Papyri
* Kirtland Egyptian papers
* Kolob
* Mormonism and history
* Reformed Egyptian
* Temple architecture (LDS Church)
* Theodemocracy
* Voree plates

* Latter Day Saints Portal

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template