William Muldoon

American wrestler (1852–1933)

This article includes a list of general references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding inline citations. Please help to improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (April 2023) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

|

William Muldoon

Muldoon ca. 1885

Born| May 25, 1852
Caneadea, New York, U.S.
Died| June 3, 1933 (aged 81)
Purchase, New York, U.S.
Professional wrestling career
Ring name(s)| Bill Muldoon
Billed height| 5 ft 10 in (178 cm)
Billed weight| 192–212 lb (87–96 kg)
Debut| 1870 (amateur)
1876 (semi-pro)
1881 (pro)
Retired| March, 1890

William Muldoon (May 25, 1852 – June 3, 1933)[1] was an American Greco-Roman Wrestling champion, a physical culturist, and the first chairman of the New York State Athletic Commission. He once wrestled a match that lasted over seven hours.

Nicknamed "The Solid Man,"[2] Muldoon established himself as champion in Greco-Roman wrestling in the 1880s and over the years gained a remarkable measure of public influence that would continue through his days as a health farm proprietor in Westchester County and his service on NYSAC. Muldoon was a mainstay in New York sports for over 50 years.

## Early life

[edit]

Born in Allegany County, New York, Muldoon was the son of Irish immigrants Patrick Muldoon and Maria Donahoe.[3] His father was a farmer. Showing a knack for strength athletics at a young age, Muldoon gained a local reputation as a standout in caber-tossing, weightlifting, sprinting and amateur wrestling. His youth was otherwise characterized by a brutish, flash temper, and his desire to be treated with the respect of an adult despite being a child.

Muldoon journeyed to Paris to serve as a volunteer in the French Army in the Franco-Prussian War of 1870-71, where he met publisher James Gordon Bennett, Jr., who told Muldoon he had the potential to be the best Greco-Roman wrestler in the world if he concentrated on it.[4]

By 1876, Muldoon was living in New York City, where he accepted appointment to the New York Police Department at the behest of Senator John Morrissey, former bare-knuckle boxing champion. At the time of his resignation in 1881, Muldoon was a detective.

## The Solid Man

[edit]

In 1880, Muldoon gained recognition when he won the World Greco-Roman Heavyweight Championship with a win over title claimant Thiebaud Bauer. His rise to prominence brought challengers from across the globe, including Edwin Bibby and Tom Cannon of England, Donald Dinnie of Scotland, "Mat" Sorakichi of Japan, Carl Abs of Germany, William Miller of Australia, and John McMahon and Clarence Whistler, the latter being Muldoon's opponent in a titanic seven-hour match in 1881, where neither could gain a single fall.[5]

Following the celebrated match with Whistler, Muldoon assembled an athletic combination and toured the country promoting athletic events and defending his title against all comers. Muldoon became involved in theater around this time, stemming from his fame in athletics. In 1883 he shared the bill with Maurice Barrymore, a boxer turned actor, in Madame Modjeska's production of Shakespeare's As You Like It. Barrymore played Orlando and Muldoon was Charles the Wrestler. In 1887, he appeared on Broadway as "The Fighting Gaul" in Spartacus.

Muldoon was one of a party of gentlemen entertained by Robert Emmet Odlum, brother of women's rights activist Charlotte Odlum Smith, on the morning of May 19, 1885, the day he jumped from the Brooklyn Bridge and was killed. Muldoon assisted in unsuccessful resuscitation efforts and summoned an ambulance, which arrived too late to save Odlum.[6][7]

An 1887 "Allen & Ginter" tobacco card depicting Muldoon

In 1889 Muldoon trained John L. Sullivan for his famous 75-round fight against Jake Kilrain for the world heavyweight bare-knuckle boxing championship. He had done so on a friendly wager and offered to absorb expenses if Sullivan lost. Sullivan won and Muldoon gained national notice for restoring the boxing champion to fighting form. Muldoon's methods for accomplishing Sullivan's rejuvenation drew much public interest.

On May 28, Muldoon and Sullivan would have an exhibition wrestling bout contested under London Prize Ring Rules that ended on a 5-5 draw.[8] The two would later have a three-round bout where Muldoon would win two of three bouts[9][10]

Muldoon was never defeated for his Greco-Roman Championship. He wrestled in his final championship match in 1890, defeating Evan Lewis in Philadelphia. Despite being implored by promoters and challengers to come out of retirement, Muldoon never wrestled another finish match or claimed any active championship. He symbolically passed his World Greco-Roman Heavyweight Championship to protégé Ernest Roeber (whom Lewis later defeated). Muldoon would make his final public appearance as a wrestler in a charity exhibition match against Roeber at Madison Square Garden in 1894.

That same year Muldoon moved his health farm from Belfast, New York, to White Plains. As he tapered off direct involvement in professional athletics, he devoted more time to devising his system on restoring one's health. Muldoon continued to train boxers and wrestlers until boxing was banned in New York at the turn of the century.

## Later years

[edit]

In 1900, Muldoon opened what would become the work of his life, the well-known health institute The Olympia at Purchase, New York. In subsequent years through the success of the Olympia, Muldoon would again gain national notice as he treated such notables there as U.S. Ambassador to Great Britain Joseph Hodges Choate, publisher Ralph Pulitzer, Senator Chauncey Depew, Major General J. Franklin Bell, essayist Elbert Hubbard, novelist Theodore Dreiser and Secretary of State Elihu Root, who was sent to Muldoon by President Roosevelt. In 1907 there was talk that Muldoon would be appointed to the president's cabinet to oversee physical health. For his uncompromised methods at his health farm Muldoon was dubbed "the Professor". Journalist Nellie Bly was the first woman to complete Muldoon's course.

In the spring of 1909 Muldoon made a final return to the stage in a theatrical tour organized in benefit of The Lambs. Muldoon dedicated a Civil War monument to the town of Belfast, New York, listing the names of local veterans in 1915, including that of his older brother John.[11]

The mausoleum of William Muldoon in Kensico Cemetery

In 1921 Muldoon was personally tapped by Governor Nathan Lewis Miller as the inaugural Chairman of the New York State Athletic Commission, when professional boxing's status was legally restored in New York. While on NYSAC, Muldoon's czarish decrees characterized his inflexible sense of integrity to the press and sporting public. He was dubbed in the papers "the Iron Duke."

In 1927 Muldoon was profiled by The New Yorker magazine and in 1929 by The Saturday Evening Post.[12][13] A biography was published in 1928, with a foreword by Jack Dempsey.[14]

William Muldoon died at age 81 in Westchester County, New York, and was interred in a grandiose private mausoleum at Kensico Cemetery in Valhalla, New York. Sometime after the end of his wrestling career and before the turn of the century, Muldoon had claimed for years that he was born in 1845, and seven years older than his age verified in the Muldoon Family Bible, which documents his real birth year.

In 1996, Muldoon was inducted into the International Boxing Hall of Fame.

In 2004, he was inducted into the Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame and Museum under the "Pioneer Era" category.

## Personal

[edit]

Muldoon claimed to be a lifelong bachelor. However, he was married twice; the first marriage ended in divorce, the second in separation. His housekeeper of 30 years, Leonie Lutringer, left her entire estate to Muldoon in 1922. It was revealed later in his life that he had adopted his longtime secretary Margaret Farrell – she received his entire estate at his death. Muldoon was diagnosed with terminal cancer in 1931, though his doctors did not reveal the nature of his illness to him. Muldoon died two years later. Retired boxing champion Gene Tunney, a disciple of Muldoon, remarked to the New York Times at the time of Muldoon's death, "All I know about training I learned from him... His patience, intellectual courage and wisdom were inspirational."[15] William Muldoon was interred at Kensico Cemetery, Valhalla, NY.

Muldoon was a strong advocate of compulsory military service, equestrianism, physical culture and the Boy Scouts of America, citing the latter as the only organization left devoted to leadership-building for young men.

## Championships and accomplishments

[edit]

* Other titles

* World Greco-Roman Heavyweight Championship (2 times)[16]

* Hall of Fame Inductions

* International Boxing Hall of Fame, 1996 (Non-Participant)[17]
* Wrestling Observer Newsletter Hall of Fame (Class of 1997)
* Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame, 2004 (Pioneer Era)
* George Tragos/Lou Thesz Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame, 2001[18]
* International Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame (Class of 2021)[19]
* Bare Knuckle Boxing Hall of Fame (Class of 2009)[20]
* New York State Boxing Hall of Fame (Class of 2014)

## Notes and references

[edit]

1. ^ "Bill Muldoon Dies in Sleep at 88". New York Times, June 4 1933.
2. ^ "The Solid Man" nickname was referenced from a popular song of the time, "Muldoon, the Solid Man" by Edward ("Ned") Harrigan. The moniker may have also been a nod to the "Solid Muldoon", a P.T. Barnum exhibit claimed to be the petrified remains of an ancestral missing link between man and ape, later revealed as a hoax.
3. ^ 1860 United States Federal Census
4. ^ According to Ring Magazine publisher Nat Fleischer in his volume, "From Milo to Londos" (The Ring Athletic Library, Book No. 13, 1936)
5. ^ Whistler, who died young, was later eulogized by Muldoon as the toughest man he ever met on the mat. Their 1881 match ignited a professional and personal rivalry that punctuated wrestling's popularity in the early to mid-1880s.
6. ^ Odlum, Catherine (1885). The Life and Adventures of Prof. Robert Emmet Odlum, Containing an Account of his Splendid Natatorium at the National Capital. Gray and Clarkson.
7. ^ "Odlum's Leap to Death". The New York Times. May 20, 1885. p. 1. Retrieved 2011-06-25.
8. ^ "Sullivan as a wrestler". The Nebraska State Journal. May 29, 1889. p. 4. Retrieved 2019-11-03.
9. ^ "Threw John L. Twice". Evening Edition of The World. May 31, 1889. p. 4. Retrieved 2019-11-03.
10. ^ "Why the Baddest Man on the Planet's a Pro Wrestler". 27 June 2012.
11. ^ [1] www.usgennet.org.
12. ^ Walker, Stanley (9 July 1927). "Profiles: Spartacus in Westchester". The New Yorker. Retrieved 2013-06-04.
13. ^ "Contents Lists". Philsp.com. Retrieved 2013-06-04.
14. ^ Van Every, Edward (1928). Muldoon – The Solid Man of Sport. New York: Frederick A. Stokes Company.
15. ^ "William Muldoon: ' Iron Duke' of Athletics, Idol of Boxing World, Was John L. Sullivan's Trainer. Veteran of the Civil War As State Commissioner He Won Renown for Raising Standards of Pugilism". The New York Times. June 4, 1933.
16. ^ Hoops, Brian (January 19, 2019). "Pro wrestling history (01/19): Ric Flair wins WWF title in 1992 Royal Rumble". Wrestling Observer Figure Four Online. Retrieved January 18, 2019.
17. ^ Despite being inducted as a non-participant into the IBHOF, Muldoon did box semi-professionally in Gas House District smokers in the 1870s and had the occasional professional bout during his wrestling career. He continued to spar late into his life. http://www.boxrec.com/media/index.php/IBHOF:_1996_Induction
18. ^ "Ventura given Museum's top honour". Slam! Wrestling. Canadian Online Explorer. August 4, 2003. Archived from the original on July 31, 2018. Retrieved November 6, 2018.
19. ^ "Induction Weekend 2022 | Pro Wrestling Hall of Fame".
20. ^ "Bkbhof Inductees". Archived from the original on 2017-04-28.

## External links

[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to William Muldoon.

* portrait of Muldoon by Sarony(archived)

* v
* t
* e

Chairs of the New York State Athletic Commission

* James Edward Sullivan (1911)
* Frank S. O'Neil (1913–1915)
* Fred A. Wenck (1915–1917)
* William Muldoon (1921–1924)
* George E. Brower (1924–1925)
* James A. Farley (1925–1933)
* John J. Phelan (1933–1945)
* Eddie Eagan (1945–1951)
* Robert K. Christenberry (1951–1955)
* Julius Helfand (1955–1959)
* Melvin Krulewitch (1959–1966)
* Edwin B. Dooley (1966–1975)
* James A. Farley Jr. (1975–1977)
* John M. Prenderville (1978–1983)
* John R. Branca (1983–1984)
* José Torres (1984–1988)
* Randy Gordon (1988–1995)
* Floyd Patterson (1995–1998)
* Mel Southard (1998–2001)
* Raymond Kelly (2001–2002)
* Bernard Kerik (2002–2003)
* Ron Scott Stevens (2003–2008)
* Melvina Lathan (2008–2015)
* Thomas Hoover (2015–2016)
* Ndidi Massay (2016–2021)

* v
* t
* e

Physical culture

Antecedents|

* Johann Christoph Friedrich GutsMuths
* Friedrich Ludwig Jahn
* Johann Baptist Krebs
* Pehr Henrik Ling
* Franz Nachtegall
* Francisco Amorós y Ondeano
* Adolf Spiess
* Thomas Topham

Systems|

| Western|

| European|

* Bert Assirati
* William Bankier
* Edward William Barton-Wright
* Zishe Breitbart
* Niels Bukh
* Victor Dane
* François Delsarte
* Edmond Desbonnet
* Launceston Elliot
* Tony Emmott
* Juan Ferrero
* Eileen Fowler
* Bob Fitzsimmons
* Gustav Frištenský
* Edith Margaret Garrud
* Hermann Görner
* George Hackenschmidt
* Georges Hébert
* Oscar Heidenstam
* F. A. Hornibrook
* Thomas Inch
* John Lees
* Dan McLeod
* Jørgen Peter Müller
* Hartvig Nissen
* Reg Park
* William Pullum
* Joan Rhodes
* Eugen Sandow
* Arthur Saxon
* Clara Schlaffhorst
* Sokol
* Mary Bagot Stack
* Lionel Strongfort
* Maxalding
* Maxick
* Monte Saldo
* Vulcana
* Ronald Walker
* Emily Diana Watts
* Freddie Welsh

|

New World|

* Marguerite Agniel
* Charles Atlas
* Clarence Bass
* Sanford Bennett
* Pierre Bernard
* Mark Berry
* Joe Bonomo
* George Brosius
* Drexel Biddle
* Marie Bjelke Petersen
* William Blaikie
* Paul Bragg
* Alan Calvert
* Edwin Checkley
* C. Ward Crampton
* Jack Delinger
* Ludwig Durlacher
* George Eiferman
* Carrica Le Favre
* Keene Fitzpatrick
* Mark Forest
* Ed Fury
* John B. Gagnon
* Vince Gironda
* Joe Greenstein
* John Grimek
* Milo Hastings
* Roy Hilligenn
* Bob Hoffman
* George F. Jowett
* Annette Kellerman
* Siegmund Klein
* Jack LaLanne
* W. R. C. Latson
* Diocletian Lewis
* Gilman Low
* Dan Lurie
* Bernarr Macfadden
* Artie McGovern
* William Muldoon
* Ralph Parcaut
* Kid Parker
* Harry Paschall
* Bill Pearl
* Steve Reeves
* Leo Robert
* Joe Rollino
* Tony Sansone
* Dudley Allen Sargent
* Larry Scott
* Amos Alonzo Stagg
* Genevieve Stebbins
* Alois P. Swoboda
* Armand Tanny
* Vic Tanny
* John Terpak
* Warren Lincoln Travis
* Al Treloar
* Turners

Indian|

| Bodybuilding|

* Manohar Aich
* Ramesh Balsekar
* The Great Gama
* B. C. Ghosh
* Ambika Charan Guha
* Jatindra Charan Guho
* Guru Hanuman
* K. V. Iyer
* Kodi Rammurthy Naidu
* Chandgi Ram
* Monotosh Roy

|

Yogic|

* Krishnamacharya
* Kuvalayananda
* Seetharaman Sundaram
* Shri Yogendra
* Tiruka
* Bhawanrao Shriniwasrao

Related|

* Battle of the Systems
* Fitness culture
* Gymnastics
* Muscular religion
* Yoga as exercise
* Natural hygiene
* Pilates

* Category

*[v]: View this template
*[t]: Discuss this template
*[e]: Edit this template