Ashes to Ashes (David Bowie song)

"Ashes to Ashes"
One of the UK artwork variants
Single by David Bowie
from the album Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps)
B-side	"Move On"
Released	1 August 1980 (1980-08-01)
Recorded	February–April 1980
Studio	Power Station (New York City) Good Earth (London)
Genre	Art rock art pop new wave
Length	4:23 (album version) 3:35 (single version)
Label	RCA
Songwriter(s)	David Bowie
Producer(s)	David Bowie Tony Visconti
David Bowie singles chronology
"Crystal Japan" (1980) "Ashes to Ashes" (1980) "Fashion" (1980)
Music video
"Ashes to Ashes" on YouTube

"Ashes to Ashes" is a song by the English musician David Bowie from his 14th studio album, Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps) (1980). Co-produced by Bowie and Tony Visconti, it was recorded from February to April 1980 in New York and London and features guitar synthesiser played by Chuck Hammer. An art rock, art pop and new wave song led by a flanged piano riff, the lyrics act as a sequel to Bowie's 1969 hit "Space Oddity": the astronaut Major Tom has succumbed to drug addiction and floats isolated in space. Bowie partially based the lyrics on his own experiences with drug addiction throughout the 1970s.

Released as the album's lead single on 1 August 1980, "Ashes to Ashes" became Bowie's second No. 1 UK single and his fastest-selling single. The song's music video, co-directed by Bowie and David Mallet, was at the time the most expensive music video ever made.^[1] The solarised video features Bowie as a clown, an astronaut and an asylum inmate, each representing variations on the song's theme, and four members of London's Blitz club, including singer Steve Strange. Influential on the rising New Romantic movement, commentators have considered it one of Bowie's best videos and of all time.

Bowie performed the song only once during 1980 but frequently during his later concert tours. Initially viewed with mixed critical reactions, later reviewers and biographers have considered it one of Bowie's finest songs, particularly praising the unique musical structure. In subsequent decades, the song has appeared on compilation albums and other artists have covered, sampled or used its musical elements for their own songs. The song's namesake was also used for the 2008 BBC series of the same name.

The sessions for David Bowie's Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps) commenced at the Power Station in New York City in February 1980, with production handled by Bowie and longtime collaborator Tony Visconti. The backing tracks for "Ashes to Ashes" were recorded under the working title "People Are Turning to Gold".^[2][3][4] The band, as for Bowie's previous four albums, consisted of Carlos Alomar on guitar, George Murray on bass and Dennis Davis on drums. Roy Bittan, a member of Bruce Springsteen's E Street Band who were recording The River (1980) in the adjacent studio, contributed piano while session musician Chuck Hammer played guitar synthesiser.^[a][2][3] Hammer, who dubbed his work "guitarchitecture",^[4] formerly toured for Lou Reed and was hired by Bowie after he sent tapes of his work to him. Visconti stated that Hammer "would pick a note and out of his amplifier would come a symphonic string section".^[5]

For their parts, Alomar played "opaque reggae" and Murray played a funk bassline using a mixture of fingerstyle and slapping.^[3][6][7] Davis initially struggled with the ska drumbeat. Bowie played the beat he envisioned for the drummer on a chair and cardboard box, which Davis studied and learned, recording the final take the next day.^[5][3] Although desiring a Wurlitzer electronic piano to tape Bittan's piano part, Visconti ran a grand piano through an Eventide Instant Flanger to imitate the sound of one upon learning the real Wurlitzer would take too long to deliver.^[5][3] For his parts, Hammer layered four multi-track guitar textures, each given different treatments through the Eventide Harmonizer, which were recorded in the studio's back stairwell to add extra reverb. According to biographer Chris O'Leary, he played "various chord inversions for each chorus section", although Visconti said that "it's the warm string choir you hear on the part that goes, 'I've never done good things, I've never done bad things...'"^[5][3]

The backing tracks were recorded without lyrics or melodies pre-written. Unlike his recent Berlin Trilogy, wherein Bowie wrote lyrics almost immediately after the backing tracks were finished, he wanted to take time writing melodies and lyrics for the Scary Monsters songs.^[8] Feeling nostalgic, he had the idea of writing a sequel to his first hit "Space Oddity" (1969), a tale about a fictional astronaut named Major Tom, after re-recording the song in 1979 for The "Will Kenny Everett Make It to 1980?" Show.^[3][9] Bowie stated in 1980:^[10]

When I originally wrote about Major Tom, I was a very pragmatic and self-opinionated lad that thought he knew all about the great American dream and where it started and where it should stop. Here we had the great blast of American technological know-how shoving this guy up into space, but once he gets there he's not quite sure why he's there. And that's where I left him.

Reconvening in April 1980 at Visconti's own Good Earth Studios in London, Bowie and Visconti recorded the vocal tracks and additional overdubs for the now-titled "Ashes to Ashes".^[2][3] Author Peter Doggett states that Bowie originally sang "ashes to ashes" as "ashes to ash" and "funk to funky" as "fun to funky" before settling on the final lines.^[11] For overdubs, Visconti added additional percussion and contributions from session keyboardist Andy Clark, who had been introduced to Visconti by Kenny Everett Show "Space Oddity" drummer Andy Duncan. According to biographer Nicholas Pegg, Clark "provided the symphonic sounds" that end the track,^[5] while O'Leary says his parts are "a high pitch in the chorus".^[3] Upon finishing the track, Visconti recalled: "We love[d] it immensely and knew it was one of the major tracks."^[4]

Characterised by commentators as art rock, art pop and new wave;^[12][13][14] Pegg describes "Ashes to Ashes" a culmination of Bowie's late 1970s experimental period.^[5] With a funk rhythm, a guitar synth-led sound and complex vocal layering,^[15][6] author James E. Perone considers it the most musically accessible song on Scary Monsters and on any Bowie album in several years. The author likens Murray's funky bass playing to the plastic soul of Young Americans (1975) and Station to Station (1976).^[16]

The song's musical structure is unique and unusual, which Perone argues made it stand out in pop music at the time.^[16] The piano riff appears to have a "missing bar". It is a three-bar loop, rather than the more common four-bar loop.

The vocal melody also matches the piano riff through its use of contrasting beats, such as "funk" on the downbeat and "fun-ky" on the off-beat.^[3] Visconti called the beat "a mind-bender".^[9] Additionally, the vocal melody features contrasting phrasing, meaning the verses consist of unrelated sections, singing through bars ("Major To-om's"), key changes, large vocal register changes and contrasting singing styles.^[3][16] O'Leary comments: "It's as if the conductor of an orchestra is also the lead tenor."^[3]

"Ashes to Ashes" takes melodic inspiration from "Inchworm" by Danny Kaye, who was one of Bowie's earliest influences. Originating from the 1952 musical film Hans Christian Andersen, Bowie stated in 2003 that the song's chords were some of the first he learned on guitar, calling them "remarkable" and "melancholic": "'Ashes to Ashes' is influenced by that. It's childlike and melancholic in that children's story way."^[5] Like "Inchworm", "Ashes to Ashes" contains moves from F to E-flat to close out verses. The song itself is in the key of A-flat major, with the intro and outro featuring "intrusions" of B-flat minor. O'Leary refers to the two bridges as a "series of arcs", as Bowie starts low in his register, rising to high and descending back to low in the same breath. The second verse features dead-pan backing vocals "delay-echoing" the lead vocal.^[3][6]

Melancholic and introspective,^[17] the song's lyrics act as a sequel to "Space Oddity", which ends with Major Tom alone floating out in space.^[9] Eleven years after liftoff,^[5] Ground Control receives a message from Major Tom, who has succumbed to drug addiction and increased paranoia following his abandonment to space: "Strung out in heaven's high / hitting an all-time low."^[9] Ground Control are not keen on the astronaut's reappearance – "Oh no, don't say it's true" – and pretend that he is fine, in Doggett's words mimicking "government agencies everywhere".^[15][11] The astronaut reflects on his life and hopes for the future and wishes he could break free from his "caged psyche".^[b][9] His pleas are disregarded by the public, leading him to proclaim that he has "never done good things", has "never done bad things" and "never did anything out of the blue".^[15] The song ends with the nursery rhyme lines "My mother said / to get things done / you'd better not mess with Major Tom".^[9][15]

Described by the artist as "a story of corruption",^[10] Bowie wanted to see where Major Tom ended up in the 1970s:^[3]

We come to him 10 years later and find the whole thing has soured, because there was no reason for putting him up there ... [So] the most disastrous thing I could think of is that he finds solace in some kind of heroin-type drug, actually cosmic space feeding him: an addiction. He wants to return to the womb from whence he came.

Regarding the song's drug references, Bowie joked about getting the word "junkie" past the BBC's censors in an interview with NME in September 1980.^[10] Comparing "Space Oddity" with "Ashes to Ashes", NPR's Jason Heller evaluated the latter's technological undertones compared to the "psychedelically spacious" former.^[9] Writer Tom Ewing wrote that it was as if "Major Tom thought he was starring in an Arthur C. Clarke story and found himself in a Philip K. Dick one by mistake, and the result is oddly magnificent".^[3]

Reviewers have interpreted "Ashes to Ashes" as commentary on Bowie's own personal struggles with drug addiction throughout the 1970s.^[c] Several said the song represents Bowie's reflection and acknowledgement of the past, at the same time offering hopes for the future.^[11][16][18] Bowie himself said the Scary Monsters album was an attempt to "accommodate" his "pasts", as "you have to understand why you went through them".^[5] The lyrics describe Major Tom as a junkie who has hit "an all-time low". NME editors Roy Carr and Charles Shaar Murray interpreted the line as a play on the title of Bowie's 1977 album Low, which charted his withdrawal inwards following his drug excesses in the US a short time before, another reversal of Major Tom's original withdrawal "outwards" or towards space.^[17]

Biographer David Buckley argues that Bowie offered a comment on his entire career "using a rather sarcastic piece of self-deprecation" with the line "I've never done good things / I've never done bad things / I never did anything out of the blue."^[1] Bowie himself said that these three lines "represent a continuing, returning feeling of inadequacy over what I've done."^[10] On the artist's future, Buckley interprets the axe line ("Want an axe to break the ice / Wanna come down right now") as his desire to move into less experimental territory and more "normalised" ground.^[1] Years later, Bowie said, "I was wrapping up the seventies really for myself, and that seemed a good enough epitaph for it – that we've lost him, he's out there somewhere, we'll leave him be."^[5] Heller agreed, arguing that it provided closure for the artist's "most momentous decade".^[9]

"Ashes to Ashes" was released in edited form as the lead single from Scary Monsters on 1 August 1980,^[3][19] with the catalogue number RCA BOW 6 and the Lodger track "Move On" as the B-side.^[20] RCA emphasised the relationship of "Space Oddity" and "Ashes to Ashes" by releasing a nine-minute promo on 12" vinyl in the US titled "The Continuing Story of Major Tom", which segued the former into the latter.^[9][5][19] The British single came in three different picture sleeves, each packaged with four different sheets of adhesive stamps, all featuring Bowie in his Pierrot costume from the music video; Pegg says this was RCA adopting "the craze for limited-edition collectables" that pervaded the 7" single market at the time.^[5] On Scary Monsters, released on 12 September,^[3] "Ashes to Ashes" was sequenced in its full-length form as the fourth track on side one of the original LP, between the title track and "Fashion".^[2]

After years of dwindling commercial fortunes, "Ashes to Ashes" was a return to commercial form for Bowie.^[3] Debuting at No. 4 on the UK Singles Chart, the single secured the top spot from ABBA's "The Winner Takes It All" a week later following the music video's broadcast on Top of the Pops. It became Bowie's fastest-selling single up to that point and his second number one single following the 1975 reissue of "Space Oddity".^{[5][3][1][19]}

Compared to the single's strong UK performance, the US release fared worse. With "It's No Game (No. 1)" as the B-side, the US single reached No. 79 on the Cash Box Top 100 chart and No. 101 on the Billboard Bubbling Under the Hot 100 chart.^[21] Elsewhere, "Ashes to Ashes" charted at No. 3 in Australia and Norway,^[22][23] 4 in Ireland,^[24] 6 in Austria, New Zealand and Sweden,^[25][26][27] 9 in West Germany,^[28] 11 in the Netherlands' Dutch Top 40 and in Switzerland,^[29][30] 15 in Belgium Flanders and the Netherlands' Dutch Single Top 100,^[31][32] and 35 in Canada.^[33] The song also reached No. 14 in France in 2016.^[34]

"Ashes to Ashes" initially received mixed reviews from music critics. Amongst positive reviews, a writer for Billboard magazine said the song combines "rock and dance beats" with "tight rock rhythms lay[ing] the groundwork for the nuance-rich melody".^[35] In their reviews of the Scary Monsters album, Billboard and The Spokesman-Review's Tom Sowa highlighted "Ashes to Ashes" as one of its best tracks.^[36][37]

On the other hand, Deanne Pearson called the song a "strange choice for a single" in Smash Hits, one that was ultimately "not a hit" and should have been left as an album track.^[38] Rolling Stone's Debra Rae Cohen described the song as Bowie's "most explicit self-indictment", and one that mirrors "the malaise of the times". Although Cohen found the track's imagery "chilling", she ultimately felt it was hard to see it "as anything but perverse self-aggrandizement".^[39] Ronnie Gurr of Record Mirror was negative, finding the song "not in truth a great effort".^[40] The magazine ranked it the second best single of 1980, behind "Going Underground" by the Jam,^[41] while NME ranked the song the fifth best single of the year.^[42]

The music video for "Ashes to Ashes" was co-directed by Bowie and David Mallet,^[43] who had previously directed the videos for Lodger (1979).^[44] Filmed at a cost of £250,000,^[d][45] it was the most expensive music video ever made at the time and has remained one of the most expensive of all time.^[1] Shot in May 1980 over a period of three days,^[e] Bowie storyboarded the video himself, planning every shot and dictating the editing process.^[5][46] Mallet used the then new Quantel Paintbox to alter the colour palette, rendering the sky black and the ocean pink.^[5][9] Writer Michael Shore described Mallet's direction as "deliberately overloaded": "demented, horror-movie camera angles, heavy solarisations, neurotic cuts from supersaturated colour to black-and-white."^[44]

Filming locations included Beachy Head and Hastings.^[5] Shooting at the beach was Mallet's idea; he later said: "[It is] one of the very rare places you can get right down to the water and there's a cliff towering over you."^[46] The crew found an abandoned bulldozer on the beach and were able to contact its owners and employ the vehicle for the shoot.^[46] Meanwhile, the "padded cell" and "exploded kitchen" sets were developed from the Kenny Everett Show performance of "Space Oddity", also shot by Mallet, the year prior.^[5][47] Similar to Bowie's other music videos, "Ashes to Ashes" does not tell a story, instead being filled with strange images that Buckley compares to a "dreamlike mental state".^[44] Discussing the connections between the different locations, Shore states "the stunningly elegant self-referential video-within-video motif, wherein each new sequence is introduced by Bowie holding a postcard-sized video screen displaying the first shot of the next scene".^[44]

In the video, Bowie portrays three different characters – a clown, astronaut and asylum inmate – all of whom represent variations of the song's "outsider theme".^[f] The black clerical robes of his followers, inspired by The Sound of Music, were designed by Judi Frankland.^[46][48] They were worn by members of London's Blitz, a "Bowie-worshipping nightclub" that housed several up-and-coming artists of the New Romantic era, including Steve Strange, a member of Visage.^[g][5][44] Strange later told biographer Marc Spitz that his robe kept getting caught in the bulldozer: "That's why I kept doing that move where I pull my arm down. So I wouldn't be crushed."^[h][46] Strange's friend Richard Sharah did Bowie's make-up for both the video and the Scary Monsters photo shoot the previous month, while his Italian Pierrot costume was designed by Natasha Korniloff, whose affiliation with the singer dated back to his days as a mime with Lindsay Kemp in 1968.^[5][4] The elderly woman who appears at the video's end, acting as Bowie's mother, was not, contrary to popular belief, his actual mother.^[i][5][44]

In his book Strange Fascination, Buckley states that the video conveys an "Edwardian queasiness", depicting "a world of nostalgia, childhood reminiscence and distant memories".^[44] Pegg and Buckley interpret that Bowie's three characters, archetypes that had permeated his songwriting for a decade, act as an "exorcism of his past".^[5][44] Bowie himself described the shot of him and his followers walking up the shoreline while the bulldozer trails behind them as symbolising "oncoming violence".^[46][49] He also said the followers have religious undertones, "an ominous quality that's rooted quite deeply".^[5] Scenes of the singer in a space suit – which suggested a hospital life-support system – and others showing him locked in what appeared to be a padded room, referred to both Major Tom and to Bowie's new, rueful interpretation of him.^[5][44] The former scenes were "intentionally" derived from H. R. Giger's designs for the 1979 film Alien.^[5]

Bowie only performed "Ashes to Ashes" once in 1980, on 3 September for an appearance on NBC's The Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson. In subsequent decades, Bowie performed the song on the 1983 Serious Moonlight, 1990 Sound+Vision, 1999 Hours, 2002 Heathen, and 2003–2004 A Reality tours.^[5] A Serious Moonlight performance, recorded on 12 September 1983, was included on the live album Serious Moonlight (Live '83), released as part of the Loving the Alien (1983–1988) box set in 2018 and separately the following year.^[50] The filmed performance also appears on the concert video Serious Moonlight (1984).^[51] Bowie's 25 June 2000 performance of the song at the Glastonbury Festival was released in 2018 on Glastonbury 2000,^[52] while a recording from a special performance at the BBC Radio Theatre, London, on 27 June 2000 was released on the bonus disc of Bowie at the Beeb.^[53][54] Another live recording from the A Reality Tour, recorded in Dublin in November 2003, is included on the accompanying DVD and live album.^[55][56] Although O'Leary believes no live performances ever came close to matching the studio recording in quality,^[3] Pegg believes "Ashes to Ashes" made "successful transitions" to the stage.^[5]

In later decades, reviewers and biographers consider "Ashes to Ashes" one of Bowie's best songs.^[5] Praise is given to its musicality and unique structure;^[1][16][57] Biographer Paul Trynka, in particular, attributes the song's success to its "melodic inventiveness".^[4] Regarding its structure, O'Leary says the track "seems built by a surrealist watchmaker" due to the details present in the mix, deeming it one of Bowie's finest studio recordings.^[3] Writing for Consequence of Sound, Nina Corcoran stated the song "makes the most of Bowie's musical creativity" and overall represents "an ode to the '70s".^[57] American Songwriter's Jim Beviglia called the song a "dark masterpiece".^[15] Rhino Entertainment argued the song predicted the subsequent decade with its "ominous clash of synthesized guitars, hard funk bassline and dissonant guitars".^[58]

Some critics analysed the song against Bowie's entire career. O'Leary says that while his career was far from over when the song was released, "Ashes to Ashes" is "his last song" or "the closing chapter that comes midway through the book". He concludes: "Bowie sings himself onstage with a children's rhyme: eternally falling, eternally young."^[3] The Guardian's Alexis Petridis said the song represents a moment in his catalogue where "the correct response is to stand back and boggle in awe", because "everything about it – [its] lingering oddness of its sound, its constantly shifting melody and emotional tenor, its alternately self-mythologising and self-doubting lyrics – is perfect".^[59] Chris Gerard of PopMatters even considered the track one of Bowie's signature songs.^[60]

Artists who have covered "Ashes to Ashes" live or in-studio include Tears for Fears for the 1992 Ruby Trax charity album, Uwe Schmidt, Northern Kings, the Shins, the Mike Flowers Pops and John Wesley Harding.^[5] Songs that used musical elements or lyrics from "Ashes to Ashes" include Marilyn Manson's "Apple of Sodom" (1997), Landscape's "Einstein a Go-Go" (1981) and Keane's "Better Than This" (2008).^[5] Songs that directly sampled "Ashes to Ashes" include Samantha Mumba's UK top five hit "Body II Body" (2000) and James Murphy's remix of Bowie's 2013 single "Love Is Lost".^[61][5] The song was the namesake for the 2008 BBC sequel series to their time-travelling crime drama Life on Mars,^[5][62] which itself took its name from another Bowie song;^[63] an apparition of the clown from the video regularly appeared to the main character during the show's first series.^[64]

The music video has also received praise and recognition as a major influence on the then-rising New Romantic movement.^[5] Initially voted by Record Mirror's readers as the best music video of 1980, together with "Fashion",^[41] Rolling Stone placed it at number 44 in their list of the 100 best music videos of all time in 2021. Discussing the video's influence upon its release, Andy Greene wrote: "MTV came onto the airwaves exactly one year later, and it would give rise to a whole new generation of Bowie imitators, but none of them could compete with the real deal."^[45] Dig! website also included the visual in their list of 20 essential clips of the 1980s. Luke Edwards argued that the video "truly captured the spirit of the MTV age" before the channel's golden era.^[13]

Commentators hail the video as not only one of Bowie's finest, but one of the medium's high points.^[1][46] Considered "the defining early music video" by Buckley, and "one of the most significant and influential of the age" by Dave Thompson,^[44][19] its techniques and effects influenced videos of artists including Adam Ant, Duran Duran and the Cure.^[5] Pegg argues the visual "define[d] rock video for the early 1980s",^[5] while Heller contended it proved music videos were "viable promotional investments".^[9] Videos that later mimicked or took appropriation from the "Ashes to Ashes" video included Peter Gabriel's "Shock the Monkey" (1982), Erasure's "Chorus" (1991) and Marilyn Manson's "The Dope Show" (1998).^[5]

"Ashes to Ashes", in both its single edit and full-length forms, has made appearances on compilation albums. The single edit is included on Changestwobowie (1981),^[65] Best of Bowie (2002),^[66] The Platinum Collection (2006),^[67] Nothing Has Changed (2014) and Legacy (The Very Best of David Bowie) (2016),^[68][69] while the album version is included on the Sound + Vision box set (1989),^[70] Changesbowie (1990) and The Singles Collection (1993).^[71][72] The single edit was also included on Re:Call 3, part of the A New Career in a New Town (1977–1982) compilation, in 2017.^[73] An unreleased extended version, allegedly 13-minutes long and featuring additional verses, a longer fade-out and a synthesiser solo, is rumoured to exist, although a 12-minute version that appeared on bootlegs was fake, simply repeating and splicing the verses.^[5][19] In 2020, Visconti said that no additional verses were recorded nor is he aware of any other versions of the song existing.^[74]

Following Bowie's death in January 2016, Rolling Stone named "Ashes to Ashes" one of the 30 most essential songs of the artist's catalogue. The magazine wrote: "As offbeat as the song was, it's a testament to Bowie's art-pop genius that 'Ashes to Ashes' became a huge international hit."^[75] The song has appeared on lists of Bowie's greatest songs by The Telegraph,^[76] The Guardian (No. 2), behind "Sound and Vision" (1977),^[59] Digital Spy (No. 3),^[77] Far Out and Uncut (No. 6),^[78][79] Smooth Radio (No. 7),^[80] NME (No. 9),^[81] Mojo (No. 10) and Consequence of Sound (No. 30).^[57][82] In 2016, Ultimate Classic Rock placed the single at number 10 in a list ranking every Bowie single from worst to best.^[83] Two years later, NME readers voted it Bowie's third best track, behind "All the Young Dudes" (1972) and "Life on Mars?" (1971).^[84]

According to Chris O'Leary:^[3]

• David Bowie – lead and backing vocal
• Chuck Hammer – Roland GR-500 guitar synthesiser
• Carlos Alomar – rhythm guitar
• Andy Clark – Minimoog, Yamaha CS-80 synthesiser
• Roy Bittan – flanged piano
• George Murray – bass
• Dennis Davis – drums
• Tony Visconti – shaker, other percussion

Technical

• David Bowie – producer
• Tony Visconti – producer, engineer
• Larry Alexander – engineer
• Jeff Hendrickson – engineer