Fogel began his career in Hollywood pursuing stand-up comedy and acting.[3] He had a small part in the 2009 Disney movie Race to Witch Mountain.[4]
Fogel has given keynote speeches to organizations around the world including the Oslo Freedom Forum in 2019 and 2020 - Human Rights Foundation and has appeared on ABC Nightline, Charlie Rose, Seth Meyers, Joe Rogan, CNN, ESPN, Meet The Press, The View, NPR, BBC and has been featured in publications around the globe including The Guardian.[5] Fogel currently resides in Los Angeles.
Fogel developed, co-wrote, and initially starred in the play Jewtopia, an off-Broadway comedy about the dating lives of two young men seeking Jewish women, which was made into a feature film. The play opened in Los Angeles in 2003 and ran for 300 performances.[6] It moved on in 2004 to the off-Broadway Westside Theater in New York, where it ran for more than three years and over a thousand performances before closing in April 2007. It is one of the longest-running and fastest-recouping productions in Off-Broadway history.[7]
Fogel co-authored the book Jewtopia: The Chosen Guide for the Chosen People, with Sam Wolfson.[8] The book was published by Hachette Book Group and Fogel appeared on ABC's The View in support of the book.
Fogel directed, co-wrote and produced the feature film adaptation of Jewtopia, which was released in 2012. The film had its U.S. premiere as the opening night gala of the 13th Newport Beach International Film Festival.[9][10]
Fogel, as a lifelong cyclist, had followed Lance Armstrong’s rise and fall, in particular, his ability to evade doping detection. Fogel later connected with Russian scientist Grigory Rodchenkov, eventually preparing evidence and setting-up an interview for Rodchenkov at The New York Times.[11][5] The Times story, published in 2016, presaged Russia's ban from the Olympic Games in 2018, 2020 and 2022.[12]
Icarus, a film documenting these investigations, was described by The New York Times as "Illuminating"[13] with Variety magazine calling it "A game changing documentary."[14]Icarus premiered at the Sundance Film Festival, where it won U.S. Documentary Special Jury Award "The Orwell Award" and the first ever "Audience Choice" Award of Sundance Film Festival London. The film was acquired in a $5 million sale by Netflix[15] and launched globally on August 4, 2017. The film won Netflix its first Feature Documentary Oscar.[16]
Despite generally positive reviews, the film struggled to find a distributor for eight months and was not able to run on a large streaming platform. Fogel believed this was due to those platforms' fear of offending the Saudi Arabian government and possibly losing subscribers.[19][20][21]
Fogel completed Icarus: The Aftermath in 2022, a follow-up to the Oscar-winning doc Icarus.[22] The film premiered that same year at the 49th Telluride Film Festival.[23]