Shad-darshana Darpana

Shad-darshana Darpana
Author	Nehemiah Goreh
Original title	षड्दर्शन दर्पण
Translator	Fitzedward Hall
Language	Hindi
Subject	Criticism of Hinduism
Genre	non-fiction
Publisher	Baptist Mission Press / Bishop's College Press
Publication date	1860
Publication place	British India
Published in English	1862
ISBN	9781377003047 reprint
OCLC	11919856

Shad-darshana Darpana (IAST: Ṣaḍ-darśana-darpaṇa, English titles: Mirror of the Six Schools and A Rational Refutation of the Hindu Philosophical Systems) is an 1860 Hindi-language book written in Varanasi by Nehemiah Goreh, a Hindu convert to Christianity. It is a critique of the six orthodox schools of the Hindu philosophy.

Background

The author Nehemiah Goreh, originally known as Nilakantha Gore, was a Hindu convert to Christianity. During 1844–1845, as a Hindu, he wrote the Sanskrit-language Hindu apologetic text Śāstra-tattva-vinirṇaya, which was critical of Christianity.^[1] In 1848, he converted to Christianity, and in 1860, wrote the Hindi-language Shad-darshana-darpana. The book was initially translated into English under the title Mirror of the Six Schools (a literal translation of the original title), but later the English title was changed to A Rational Refutation of the Hindu Philosophical Systems (1862).^[2]^[3]

Shad-darshana-darpana became Goreh's most influential work. Although its aim was to prove the superiority of Christianity over Hinduism, its English translation also served as the best introduction to the Hindu philosophy for English speakers for several decades,^[2] until Max Müller's Six Systems of Hindu Philosophy (1899).^[4]

In 1951, S.L. Katre prepared a critical edition of Goreh's earlier work Śāstra-tattva-vinirṇaya, intending to counteract the arguments outlined in the Shad-darshana-darpana.^[5]

Content

Shad-darshana-darpana is a critique of the six orthodox schools of the Hindu philosophy. Goreh is critical of several aspects of the Hindu philosophy, but also acknowledges many agreements between the Christian and the Hindu beliefs. He believed that the god had been preparing the Hindus to receive the Christian revelation, because of which certain Hindu teachings enabled the Hindus to appreciate Christianity.^[3]

Goreh uses the work of the 16th-century scholar Vijnanabhiksu to argue against the Vedanta epistemology and metaphysics. He elaborates the concepts of subtle and causal bodies to present Vedanta as incoherent.^[4] For example, Goreh states that the Advaita tradition denies the reality of the creation while stating that the creation is one with Brahman, who is real. He describes the Hindu views on sin, the human condition, and salvation as irrational.^[6]

Goreh presents the Christian doctrine as a rational alternative to the Hindu doctrine.^[6]

References

^ Richard Fox Young (2020). "Hindu–Christian debates in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries". In Chad M. Bauman; Michelle Voss Roberts (eds.). The Routledge Handbook of Hindu-Christian Relations. p. 134. ISBN 9781000328882.
^ ^a ^b J.P. Schouten (2008). "From False Prophet To Demonstrable Divinity". Jesus as Guru: The Image of Christ Among Hindus and Christians in India. Brill. pp. 44–45. doi:10.1163/9789401206198_004. ISBN 9789401206198.
^ ^a ^b Klaus K. Klostermaier (2010). A Survey of Hinduism (Third ed.). State University of New York Press. p. 586. ISBN 9780791480113.
^ ^a ^b Simon Cox (2021). The Subtle Body: A Genealogy. Oxford University Press. p. 83. ISBN 9780197581032.
^ Richard Fox Young (1981). Resistant Hinduism: Sanskrit Sources on Anti-Christian Apologetics in Early Nineteenth-century India. De Nobili Research Library. p. 108. ISBN 9783900271091.
^ ^a ^b Arun W. Jones (2004). "Indian Theology". In Hans J. Hillerbrand (ed.). The Encyclopedia of Protestantism. Taylor & Francis. pp. 816–817. ISBN 9781135960278.

External links

षड्दर्शन दर्पण (1860), original Hindi edition published by the Baptist Mission Press, Calcutta (Copy on archive.org)
A Rational Refutation of the Hindu Philosophical Systems (1862), English translation Fitz-Edward Hall, published by Bishop's College Press; 1897 edition published by The Christian Literature society for India, London

[1] Richard Fox Young (2020). "Hindu–Christian debates in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries". In Chad M. Bauman; Michelle Voss Roberts (eds.). The Routledge Handbook of Hindu-Christian Relations. p. 134. ISBN 9781000328882.

[JPS_2008-2] J.P. Schouten (2008). "From False Prophet To Demonstrable Divinity". Jesus as Guru: The Image of Christ Among Hindus and Christians in India. Brill. pp. 44–45. doi:10.1163/9789401206198_004. ISBN 9789401206198.

[KKK_2010-3] Klaus K. Klostermaier (2010). A Survey of Hinduism (Third ed.). State University of New York Press. p. 586. ISBN 9780791480113.

[SC_2021-4] Simon Cox (2021). The Subtle Body: A Genealogy. Oxford University Press. p. 83. ISBN 9780197581032.

[5] Richard Fox Young (1981). Resistant Hinduism: Sanskrit Sources on Anti-Christian Apologetics in Early Nineteenth-century India. De Nobili Research Library. p. 108. ISBN 9783900271091.

[AWJ_2004-6] Arun W. Jones (2004). "Indian Theology". In Hans J. Hillerbrand (ed.). The Encyclopedia of Protestantism. Taylor & Francis. pp. 816–817. ISBN 9781135960278.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]