1994 - Martin Methodist College (now the University of Tennessee Southern) joined the TCAC, effective in the 1994-95 academic year.
1996 - The TCAC would cease operations as an athletic conference, effective after the 1995-96 academic year; as many schools left to join their respective new home primary conferences, effective beginning the 1996-97 academic year: Bethel (Tenn.), David Lipscomb, Freed–Hardeman, Martin Methodist, Trevecca Nazarene and Union (Tenn.) to the TranSouth Athletic Conference (TranSouth or TSAC); while Cumberland (Tenn.) and Lambuth to the Mid-South Conference (MSC); Belmont to the Division I ranks of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) as an NCAA D-I Independent (which would later join the Atlantic Sun Conference, effective beginning the 2001-02 academic year); and Christian Brothers to the NCAA Division II ranks and the Gulf South Conference (GSC).
The TCAC sponsored 9 sports for men and women including baseball, basketball, golf, tennis, softball, and volleyball. Bethel and Cumberland play football in the Mid-South Conference. Defunct Lambuth also played football.