Pigeon Chess

Someone is wrong on The Internet

Log in:

City Data Cosmoquest Forum Ed Brayton GNU Free Documentation License Science and Math Defeated RenewAmerica Zero Hedge Adam Ruins Everything Eric S. Raymond DCinside Revolution Muslim Tether v - t - e

"Pigeon chess" or "like playing chess with a pigeon"^{[note 1]} is a figure of speech originating from a comment made in March 2005 on Amazon by Scott D. Weitzenhoffer^[2] regarding Eugenie Scott's book Evolution vs. Creationism: An introduction:

As such "debating techniques" are not limited to creationists, the phrase has entered the general Internet lexicon,^[3] together with the source quotation, which is sometimes cited as an anonymous "Internet law". The reference to creationists is usually replaced with whatever group the user is arguing with.

Even the Bible advises against this sort of thing, in Proverbs 29:9: "If a wise man contendeth with a foolish man, whether he rage or laugh, there is no rest."

Andrew Schlafly was similarly described for his contributions to Usenet talk.origins in 2002:^[4] "I tried it for a while, but arguing with Andy is like playing chess with a small child who doesn't know the rules."

See also[edit]

• Not even wrong
• Fractal wrongness
• Dunning-Kruger effect
• Monkey typewriter theory — with enough pigeons and chess boards, we could find a grand master

External links[edit]

• Playing Chess With Pigeons - talk.origins veteran Troy Britain's blog

Notes[edit]

References[edit]